Coin Exchange

Scott provided excellent customer service and treated me very fairly.

My experience was very good, nice and respectful staff.

Very professional and friendly staff. Fair prices. I highly recommend.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had an excellent experience today (Wednesday 2/25) at Coin Exchange in Hartsdale. If you’re looking to sell gold or silver and want a fair, straightforward transaction with knowledgeable professionals, this is the place. The building itself is large, easy to find on Central Ave, and has convenient handicap access right in front. Inside, the showroom is surprisingly spacious and well organized. They carry an impressive variety of coins — rare pieces, international coins, special editions, full sets — in both silver and gold. They also have gold bars, a select collection of high-value Pokémon cards, and even a small but tasteful watch selection. It’s clearly a serious operation with real inventory — not just a counter and a scale. I worked with Mike today, and both he and Scott were easy to deal with, transparent, and professional. Most importantly, they gave me very fair pricing on my metals. If you’ve ever sold gold or silver before, you know that trust and pricing are everything — and I felt completely comfortable throughout the process. I originally learned about Coin Exchange through a long-time friend who owns a well-known jewelry store in Scarsdale and frequently uses them for customer gold and silver transactions. That referral alone spoke volumes, and after today’s experience, I understand why. Whether you’re a collector, an investor, or someone simply looking to sell old jewelry or bullion and get treated fairly, Coin Exchange is worth the visit. I’ll definitely be back — and next time I plan to spend more time exploring their collection. Highly recommended.

Great customer service. Fast and efficient. Great buy prices