Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Baby's First Christmas: 18 Sweet Keepsakes & Gifts for New Little Ones 👶
15
items There's nothing sweeter than a first Christmas — these are the keepsakes and gifts worth grabbing for the littlest one on your list. Heads up: some links may earn me a commission.
Sections
4
Â
Ornaments for the Tree
Â
Handprint & Footprint Keepsakes
Â
Stockings & First-Holiday Wear
Â
Books, Plush & Little Luxuries
Ornaments for the Tree
The annual must — one of these goes on the tree every December from now on.
Â
The tiny porcelain booties with custom text are the classic first-Christmas pick — personal, sweet, and it hangs on the tree every year after. Perfect for grandparents gifting the new parents.
Baby's First Christmas Booties Porcelain Personalized ...
Â
A dated 2026 rocking horse is the heirloom move — it marks the exact year, which makes it the ornament the kid reaches for decades later. Collectors grab the dated Keepsakes fast, so don't wait.
Baby's First Christmas Rocking Horse 2026 Porcelain ...
Â
Winnie the Pooh never misses for a baby's first tree — this one pairs the Disney sweetness with the 2026 date. Great choice if the nursery theme is already Pooh.
Disney Winnie the Pooh Baby's First Christmas 2026 ...
Â
A photo-frame ornament doubles the keepsake — the ornament itself plus whatever tiny face goes inside it. This is the one that makes grandparents tear up at the tree.
My Very First Christmas 2026 Photo Frame Ornament
Â
Birth stats printed on an ornament turn a decoration into a record — name, date, weight, all of it. Made-to-order from small shops, so order early for December delivery.
Baby's First Christmas Ornament 2026 | Newborn Birth Stats
Handprint & Footprint Keepsakes
Tiny hands, tiny feet, preserved forever — these kits make it easy and mess-free.
Â
The no-bake clay kit is the simplest way to capture that first tiny handprint or footprint in ornament form. Everything's included and it's 100% baby-safe — a can't-miss registry add.
Pearhead Babyprints Ornament - Baby's 1st Christmas
Â
The clean-touch ink pad means baby's skin never touches ink — press, peel, and you've got a perfect print. Photo on the front, print on the back: two keepsakes in one.
Pearhead Babyprints Double-Sided Christmas Photo
Â
Heart-shaped, glittered, and made with baby's own print — this one photographs beautifully and kids love the sparkle. A sweet weekend project with the new parents.
Lil Peach Baby Print Clay Heart Ornament Kit
Â
A frame version of the print keepsake works for parents who want it on the mantel, not the tree. Pearhead's frames are the best-reviewed in the category for a reason.
Pearhead Baby First Christmas 2025 Print
Stockings & First-Holiday Wear
The outfit and the stocking they'll dig out every single December.
Â
One soft little hat turns every December photo into a keeper. Sized for newborn heads, and it pairs perfectly with the onesie for the full look.
Baby My First Christmas Santa Hat - Red/White
Â
A stocking with the baby's name on it is non-negotiable for a first Christmas — it becomes the family's official baby stocking. Personalized ones sell out by mid-December every year.
Baby's First Christmas Stocking
Books, Plush & Little Luxuries
The gifts that get read, hugged, and saved for years.
Â
A recordable storybook lets a parent or grandparent record the story in their own voice — the keepsake value is off the charts. Kids replay these long after the pages wear in.
The Very First Christmas Recordable Storybook
Â
The child's name printed right in the story makes this feel custom-made — because it is. A keepsake book that gets re-read every Christmas, year after year.
Personalized Baby's First Christmas Book | Keepsake Story
Â
If there's one stuffed animal every baby should get, it's this buttery-soft bunny — it's the default luxury baby gift for a reason. Sized just right for tiny arms to grab.
Bashful Bunny Junior - Official Jellycat
Â
A guided memory book turns the chaos of the first years into something organized and beautiful. The perfect gift for the sentimental new parent who wants to write it all down.
Craft Baby First Years Memory Book