Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Brows & Lashes After 40: Products That Actually Make a Difference
41
items ✨ This list is all about high-performing brow and lash products that hold their own after 40.
Growth serums, smudge-proof mascaras, brow and lash prep these picks are backed by ingredients that work.
Clean, effective, and built to enhance your na...
Map
Sections
5
Brow + Lash Growth That Actually Works
Brow Shaping Tools for a Natural Lift
Mascaras That Don’t Smudge, Flake, or Fade
Anti-Aging Eye Products That Boost Your Brow/Lash Game
Brow + Lash Prep You Didn’t Know You Needed
Brow + Lash Growth That Actually Works
These are the serums and treatments that actually make a difference. They’re packed with ingredients like peptides, biotin, and plant-based extracts to help fill in sparse spots and support stronger, fuller growth over time. If your brows or lashes h...
✨ What it is:
A prestige lash growth serum backed by ophthalmologists and tons of loyal fans. Conditions lashes while promoting strength, length, and flexibility.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s the gold standard in lash growth serums — gentle, proven...
RevitaLash Advanced Eye Lash Serum
✨ What it is:
A brow-targeted growth serum formulated with vitamins, amino acids, and conditioning agents to help sparse brows look fuller.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
This one actually delivers results. Most users report fuller brows in just 6–8 weeks...
GrandeBROW Thickening Serum
✨ What it is:
A 2-in-1 formula that strengthens and improves the look of sparse, thinning brows. Great for reshaping the brow arch.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Derm-recommended and user-approved, especially for overplucked or mature brows.
✨ Why it wo...
neuLASH® neuBROW® Brow Enhancing Serum
✨ What it is:
A budget-friendly lash + brow serum that uses multiple peptide technologies to support thickness and volume.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
No fluff, no fragrance, no irritation. Just simple, science-backed ingredients that get the job done....
The Ordinary Multi-Peptide Lash & Brow Serum
✨ What it is:
A high-performance lash serum that delivers visible volume and length — without the luxury price tag.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
A TikTok-favorite that actually holds up. Clean formula, consistent results, and affordable enough for long-...
UKLASH Eyelash Growth Serum | Lash Serum, Longer Lashes | 10% Off
✨ What it is:
A cult-favorite lash serum that delivers longer, fuller-looking lashes with consistent use. Ophthalmologist-tested and prostaglandin-free.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s affordable, highly rated, and beginner-friendly — perfect for firs...
Essential Lash Serum
✨ What it is:
A clean, plant-based duo designed to boost both lash and brow density. Made with clinically tested phytoactives and free from prostaglandins or harsh ingredients.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s a top choice for women looking for clean b...
GRO Lash and Brow Kit | Vegan Serums
✨ What it is:
A minimalist French serum that supports lash + brow density with no fluff ingredients.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s lightweight, clean, and safe for sensitive skin — perfect for thinning lashes or sparse brows after 40.
✨ Why it work...
Eyebrow & Eyelash Serum with 2% Pea Peptides + Castor Oil
Brow Shaping Tools for a Natural Lift
These tools are all about giving your brows a subtle, lifted look without going overboard. Whether you’re filling in sparse areas, adding structure, or setting hairs in place, these picks make shaping easy. Precise pencils, clear-hold gels, everythin...
✨ What it is:
A fine-tip mechanical pencil for ultra-precise hair-like strokes. Comes with a built-in spoolie for blending.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s easy to control, especially for sparse or uneven brows. You can define the arch without making ...
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
✨ What it is:
A creamy matte highlighter pencil designed to go under the brow bone to visually lift the arch.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
One swipe instantly brightens your eye area and makes the brows look more lifted—no concealer needed.
✨ Why it wo...
High Brow Duo Pencil
✨ What it is:
A clear, extreme-hold styling wax that lifts, sets, and sculpts brows into place with a laminated look.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s the go-to product for that brushed-up, lifted brow trend — no flaking, no stiffness, just clean hold ...
Brow Freeze
✨ What it is:
A dual-ended brow tool with a flat spatula on one end and a spoolie on the other, designed to pair with brow waxes and gels.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It helps press brows into place for that lifted, laminated finish — perfect for sculp...
Brow Lift Applicator and Spoolie
✨ What it is:
A tinted brow gel that defines, fills, and lifts with natural pigments and plant-based conditioning ingredients.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s a clean, cruelty-free formula that’s perfect for sparse or graying brows. The tiny brush all...
Instant Brow Fix™ Semi-Permanent Eyebrow Gel
✨ What it is:
A multitasking brow product that delivers instant tint and shape while also supporting long-term growth with peptides and botanical extracts.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s ideal for thinning or aging brows — combining pigment + treatme...
GrandeBROW 2-In-1
✨ What it is:
An ultra-fine brow pencil that lets you draw natural-looking, hair-like strokes for precise shape and definition.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s one of the easiest ways to fake fuller brows without going too bold. Especially great for s...
Precisely, My Brow Pencil
It’s a clear, flexible brow-lifting gel it gives you that laminated look with zero stiffness.
It actually lifts and holds mature brows all day without flaking or crusting.
It’s a legit alternative to Brow Freeze and It’s affordable and you can fi...
Brow Lift - Clear Eyebrow Gel
Mascaras That Don’t Smudge, Flake, or Fade
These mascaras actually stay put. They’re heat-proof, sweat-proof, and built to last through long days. If you’re looking for extra curl, lift, or definition, every option here holds its shape No raccoon eyes. Just clean, dependable wear that works w...
✨ What it is:
A lifting, lengthening waterproof mascara with a curved wand that grabs every lash for clean, defined volume.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
The waterproof formula holds curl all day without weighing lashes down — even in humidity or sweat. ...
Lash Idôle 24H Waterproof Mascara Glossy Black – Lancôme
✨ What it is:
A volumizing waterproof version of the original cult classic — same drama, more staying power.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
The hourglass brush grabs and thickens lashes from root to tip, and the formula locks it all in without smearing.
...
Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara
✨ What it is:
A lengthening mascara with a heat- and humidity-resistant formula that lives up to the Double Wear name.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s designed to stay flawless in heat and humidity — ideal for Arizona summers or anyone dealing with sw...
Double Wear Zero-Smudge Lengthening Mascara
✨ What it is: A clean, dual-brush mascara that lengthens, lifts, and holds without irritation.
💡 Why it’s on the list: Great for sensitive, hooded, or aging eyes — and removes easily without tugging.
✨ Why it works: Holds curl, doesn’t smudge, and...
Limitless Lash Mascara - Best Clean Lengthening ...
✨ What it is: A tubing mascara that resists sweat, humidity, and transfer.
💡 Why it’s on the list: Ideal for mature eyes or contact lens wearers who want clean definition.
✨ Why it works: No flaking, no smudging — removes with warm water for lash-...
Lash Power™ Mascara Long-Wearing Formula
✨ What it is:
A dual-ended clear gel for lashes and brows — affordable, lightweight, and perfect for no-makeup days or a subtle lift.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Ideal for mature eyes that want hold without heaviness. It gives lashes a natural definiti...
Clear Brow & Lash Mascara
✨ What it is:
A best-selling tubing mascara that gives length, definition, and lift — without a trace of smudging or flaking.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It holds up in heat, sweat, and long days — perfect for hooded or mature eyes. It also removes eas...
Liquid Lash™ Extensions Tubing Mascara
✨ What it is:
A clean, vegan mascara that lifts, separates, and volumizes without flaking — even in heat or humidity.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s surprisingly reliable for a drugstore option. Smudge-resistant, easy to remove, and safe for sensitiv...
Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara
Anti-Aging Eye Products That Boost Your Brow/Lash Game
These picks go beyond eye cream. They hydrate, firm, and strengthen the delicate skin around your brows and lashes — which matters more than people think. Healthier skin in this area means better product absorption, stronger brow and lash growth, and...
✨ What it is:
A luxurious, fast-absorbing cream that visibly reduces fine lines while deeply hydrating and plumping.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Its ReNeura Technology™ + KOMBU-Bounce complex supports collagen production and elasticity in the eye area....
Benefiance Anti-Aging Eye Cream for Wrinkles
✨ What it is:
An anti-aging powerhouse with pure retinol and a mineral complex, designed to reduce crow’s feet, fine lines, and puffiness.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Clinically proven to visibly lift and firm the eye area — a trusted favorite for wome...
RETINOL CORREXION® Line Smoothing Eye Cream
💧 What it is: A lightweight serum with dual weight hyaluronic acid, caffeine, and niacinamide to plump, firm, and depuff.
💡 Why it’s on the list: Expert-loved for brightening mature skin. The cooling rollerball is perfect for relaxed eye area prep...
Hyalu B5 Eye Serum with Hyaluronic Acid + 10% Complex
✨ What it is: An ultra-slim brow pencil with rich pigment and great staying power.
💡 Why it’s on the list: Ideal for natural detail work and arch definition without looking overdone.
✨ Why it works: Sweat-proof, budge-proof, and smooth enough for ...
Precisely, My Brow Pencil
✨ What it is:
A lightweight, drugstore-favorite eye cream with hyaluronic acid designed to instantly hydrate and smooth the skin around the eyes.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Mature skin often loses hydration around the eyes and brows. This gel-cream he...
Neutrogena Hydro Boost Daily Hyaluronic Acid Gel Eye Cream, 0.5 fl. oz
✨ What it is:
A vitamin C–infused eye cream that brightens dark circles, improves firmness, and hydrates delicate under-eye skin — all while creating a smooth base for concealer.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
This is a cult-favorite for mature eyes deali...
Banana Bright+ Eye Crème - Vitamin C Eye Cream
✨ What it is:
A targeted eye cream with 5% stabilized vitamin C, peptides, and hyaluronic acid — designed to brighten, smooth, and firm the delicate eye area.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s great for women over 40 dealing with dullness, fine lines, o...
C5 Super Boost Eye Cream | Vitamin C ...
✨ What it is:
A lightweight under-eye cream formulated with caffeine and peptides to reduce puffiness and support smoother, firmer skin over time.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It’s affordable, effective, and ideal for women over 40 looking to target und...
The INKEY List USA Caffeine Eye Cream
✨ What it is:
A dermatologist-loved eye gel with peptides, hyaluronic acid, and caffeine that depuffs, hydrates, and smooths the under-eye and brow area.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
The cooling gel formula supports skin around the brows and lashes — gr...
EltaMD Renew Eye Gel, Serum for Dark Circles and Puffiness, Under ...
Brow + Lash Prep You Didn’t Know You Needed
These low-key essentials do the behind-the-scenes work that makes all the difference. From gentle makeup removers to nourishing oils, every product here helps create the ideal base for brow and lash growth. They keep the area clean, balanced, and con...
✨ What it is:
A gentle balm cleanser that melts off makeup while hydrating skin and lashes. It’s formulated with hyaluronic acid, ceramides, and peptides.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Traditional wipes can tug and pull — this balm removes everything smo...
Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm
✨ What it is:
A gentle, milky cleanser for sensitive skin that removes makeup without harsh rubbing — ideal for prepping the eye area and protecting fragile lashes.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Harsh foaming cleansers can dry out or irritate the eye are...
Toleriane Dermo Milky Cleanser
✨ What it is:
A conditioning primer infused with vegan collagen and plant-based ingredients that preps lashes for mascara while promoting softness and strength.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
It acts like a nourishing base coat for lashes, making mascara ...
Amazon.com: Pacifica Vegan Collagen Eye Lash Serum & Clear Mascara Primer
✨ This gentle balm-to-oil cleanser is a go-to for anyone 40+ who wants to melt away makeup without stripping the skin. It’s especially great around the eye area — it won’t weaken lashes or dry out sensitive skin. Squalane mimics the skin’s natural oi...
The Ordinary Squalane Cleanser
✨ What it is:
A gentle yet powerful oil-infused eye makeup remover that dissolves product without rubbing or drying out the delicate eye area.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Removing mascara or brow products without damaging hairs is essential — especiall...
Bi-Facil Double Action Eye Makeup Remover
✨ What it is:
A cult-favorite micellar water that removes makeup, sunscreen, and buildup without irritating your skin barrier.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Prepping your brows and lashes starts with clean, calm skin. This one’s gentle enough for sensiti...
Bioderma Micellar Water
✨ What it is:
A skin-loving micellar water with sugarcane-derived squalane that melts away eye makeup while hydrating and soothing.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Perfect for prepping lashes and brows without over-drying. It keeps your skin barrier strong...
Squalane Cleansers & Toners
✨ What it is:
Gentle, pre-soaked cleansing pads that sweep away mascara and brow products without irritating eyes.
💡 Why it’s on the list:
Perfect for quick, travel-friendly cleansing — especially if you’re using growth serums and need a clean base...
Almay Biodegradable Oil Free Micellar Eye Makeup Remover Pads, 120 count