Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Cookie Decorating Supplies That Turned Our Family Nights Into a Real Tradition
30
items Saturday nights used to be everyone staring at separate screens in different rooms. We needed something hands-on that worked for a five-year-old AND a teenager without anyone rolling their eyes. Once we started baking and decorating cookies together,...
Sections
5
Heart Cookie Cutters and Shapes We Actually Use
Sugar Cookie Mixes and Doughs That Don't Spread Into Blobs
Icing and Frosting for People Who Aren't Professional Decorators
Sprinkles and Toppings That Make Kids Actually Excited to Decorate
Baking Tools That Keep the Kitchen From Becoming a Disaster Zone
Heart Cookie Cutters and Shapes We Actually Use
We had a junk drawer full of random cutters that never stacked right or cut clean. These are the ones that survived the purge and get pulled out every single weekend now.
Grab this set first. We went through two plastic ones that cracked before landing here. The nested sizes mean my youngest can do small hearts while my oldest goes big. They store flat in a drawer without the usual cutter avalanche.
CIRCLE- New Wilton 4 Piece Heart Cookie Cutters
Use these when you want sharper edges for royal icing work. My husband kept complaining the dough stuck to our old plastic ones. Switched to these and the shapes pop right out clean every time.
Ateco Heart Pastry Cutter Set - Stainless steel
Perfect if your kids fight over who gets what shape. Stars AND hearts in one tin solved a weekly argument at our table. Durable enough that my six-year-old presses them without bending anything.
Wilton Nesting Hearts Cookie Cutter Set, 4-Piece
Keep this one around for Valentine's Day prep. The sizes range from tiny to palm-sized, so we make a whole gradient of hearts on one baking sheet. Friends thought we ordered from a bakery.
R&M International Love Birds 5 Piece Cookie Cutter Set
Snag this for anyone with hand pain or arthritis. My mom visits and she can press through chilled dough without wincing. The cushioned top makes a real difference during long baking sessions.
Wilton Large Heart Comfort-Grip Cookie Cutter
Try these if you want USA-made and food safe certified. They arrived sharp enough to cut through our thickest sugar cookie recipe on the first press. No wiggling, no tearing.
Customer reviews for Heart Cookie Cutters 5-Pc.
Sugar Cookie Mixes and Doughs That Don't Spread Into Blobs
Spent three batches watching perfect hearts puff into shapeless circles. These actually hold their form in the oven so decorating isn't pointless.
Toss this in your cart for weeknight baking when nobody wants to measure flour. Add one egg, some butter, and you're rolling in fifteen minutes. Cookies kept their shape and my kids didn't lose patience waiting.
13 Sugar Cookie Mix Hacks
For the nights when even mixing feels like too much. Slice, cut shapes, bake. My teenager handles this start to finish without asking me a single question, which honestly is the real win.
Pillsbury Ready to Bake Refrigerated Sugar Cookie Dough
Switch to this if you're trying to avoid artificial stuff but still want cookies that taste like actual cookies. My neighbor who's picky about ingredients ate four at our last family night. Enough said.
Miss Jones Baking Co. Gluten-Free Sugar Cookie Mix
Pair this with a cold rolling pin for the cleanest cuts you'll get from store-bought dough. It firms up nicely and doesn't stick to every surface in your kitchen. Found that out after ruining a batch with another brand.
Pillsbury Ready to Bake Refrigerated Sugar Cookie Dough
Use this when you want bakery-level results without a bakery-level skill set. The dough rolls out smooth and thick. Our hearts came out of the oven looking exactly like hearts, not puffy ovals.
Arthur
Bring this one out when the kids want a chewier cookie. Slightly different texture than the classic crunchy sugar cookie. My youngest calls these the soft ones and requests them by name now.
Duncan Hines Dolly Parton's Sugar Cookie Mix
Icing and Frosting for People Who Aren't Professional Decorators
Royal icing tutorials on the internet made me feel like a failure. These products let everyone at the table make something they're proud of without a pastry degree.
Grab a tub and thin it with a few drops of water for flooding. Took me embarrassingly long to figure out I didn't need to make royal icing from scratch. This works just as well and saves forty minutes.
Wilton, Royal Icing, 14oz, White Stiff Consistency Ready-To
Each tube has a built-in tip so there's zero cleanup of piping bags. My five-year-old holds it like a marker and draws squiggles. My teenager does actual lettering. Same product, wildly different skill levels, everyone's happy.
Betty Crocker Christmas Colors Decorating Cookie Icing, 3pk
Ditch the liquid food coloring that turns everything pastel. A toothpick dab of these gels gets you deep red, actual teal, real black. Our cookies finally look like the Pinterest photos instead of a sad watercolor.
Wilton Edible Gel Food Coloring Set, 12-pack of 0.5 Oz jars
Try the squeeze pouch if piping bags stress you out. It dries smooth and shiny without any special technique. Point, squeeze, done. Even my husband who refuses to follow instructions made decent-looking cookies.
Wilton White Icing Pouch with Tips, 8 oz.
Use this when you DO want that classic hard-shell finish. Just add water and whip. Dries firm overnight so you can stack cookies in gift bags without smearing. We learned that lesson the sticky way.
Satin Ice Royal Icing Mix, 14 oz
Swap these in when you need colors that won't thin out your icing. One tiny squeeze and you've got vibrant shades. Lasted us six months of weekly baking and we're barely halfway through the bottles.
AmeriColor, Food Color, Soft Gel Paste, 12 .75 oz Multicolor
Sprinkles and Toppings That Make Kids Actually Excited to Decorate
Plain frosted cookies sat on the counter untouched until I put out bowls of sprinkles. Now there's a line forming before the icing even dries.
Keep a jar of these on standby. They stick to wet icing perfectly and add that classic bakery look. My daughter dumps them on with zero restraint and honestly her cookies always look the most fun.
Wilton Rainbow Jumbo Nonpareil Sprinkles, 2.3 oz.
Use these when you want the long sprinkle look instead of tiny dots. They roll off the cookie less than nonpareils, which means less mess on the table. A small victory I celebrate quietly.
WILTON JIMMIES RAINBOW SHORT 6 CELL 72g
Snag the multi-pack so everyone picks their favorite color. We set them out in little bowls like a sprinkle bar. It sounds extra but it keeps the kids at the table for an hour, which is priceless.
(Pack Of 24) Betty Crocker Decor Chocolate 1.75 Oz
Toss these on heart-shaped cookies for maximum on-theme vibes. Tiny candy hearts, pink and red jimmies, all in one bottle. Valentine's Day cookies went from basic to gift-worthy with just this one addition.
Wilton Tall Bottle Sprinkles Mix, Open Heart - 4oz
Bring these out for writing names or drawing faces on cookies. The squeeze tubes give more control than icing bags for small details. My son writes everyone's name on their cookie now and it's become his thing.
Cake Mate Decorating Gel - Blue - .67 oz - Case of 6
Try sanding sugar if you want sparkle without bulk. Dust it over wet icing and the cookies literally shimmer under kitchen lights. My daughter called them fairy cookies and that name stuck permanently in our house.
Wilton Sparkling Sugar for Baking Decor
Baking Tools That Keep the Kitchen From Becoming a Disaster Zone
First family bake night ended with flour on the ceiling and dough cemented to the counter. These tools cut our cleanup time in half and saved my sanity.
Get this before your first batch. No more parchment paper tearing, no more cookies welded to the pan. Wash it, roll it up, done. Paid for itself in saved parchment paper within a month.
Customer reviews for Silpat Silicone Mat for Baking Non
Use a rolling pin with actual handles if you bake with small kids. My daughter can grip and roll without the pin shooting across the counter. Sounds minor until you've chased a rolling pin off the edge three times.
Farberware, Wood Rolling Pin with Classic Handles
Pair this with a silicone mat and nothing sticks, nothing burns. Even heating across the whole pan means the edge cookies don't crisp while the center ones stay raw. That used to drive me crazy.
Wilton, Recipe Right Cookie Sheet Set
Grab a rack that fits inside your sheet pan. Cookies cool evenly and you're not balancing them on random plates all over the counter. Freed up so much space that we could actually decorate while the next batch baked.
Kitchenaid Metal Nonstick Universal Cooling Rack
Ditch whatever flimsy spatula keeps bending under your cookies. This one slides under warm cookies without mangling them. Saved us from the heartbreak of a broken heart cookie more than once.
OXO Good Grips Silicone Cookie Spatula
Swap your old cookie tins for these. Airtight seal means decorated cookies stay fresh for days instead of going stale overnight. We make batches on Saturday and they still taste great by Wednesday lunch boxes.
Rubbermaid, Food Storage Container, 9.6 Cup