Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Creative Gift Card Holders I Made That Actually Got Bigger Laughs Than the Gift
49
items Handing someone a plain gift card envelope feels like giving up. You spent time picking the right amount, the right store, and then it just sits there in a boring little sleeve. These are the supplies I grabbed to turn gift cards into something peopl...
Sections
7
Candy Bar Wrapper Gift Card Holders
Funny Fake Packaging for Gift Cards
Balloon Pop Gift Card Reveals
DIY Gift Card Puzzle Boxes
Gift Card Origami and Paper Craft Supplies
Gift Card Scavenger Hunt Supplies
Candy Bar Wrapper Gift Card Holders
Started doing this after my sister said my gifts were ‘predictable.’ I wrapped a gift card around a candy bar, sealed it in the original wrapper, and watched her tear into it expecting chocolate. The confused laugh was worth everything.
Grab this because the wrapper is big enough to slide a standard gift card inside and reseal with a glue stick. My niece bit into the chocolate before she even noticed the card tucked behind it.
Hershey's Milk Chocolate XL Candy Bar, Extra Large
Use the orange wrapper to hide a gift card flat against the back of the package. Works perfectly for anyone who rips into candy without looking. My coworker almost threw away a $50 card doing this.
Reese's White Peanut Butter Cups King Size, 2.8 oz, 4 count
Stick these on the back of the gift card so it stays pressed against the candy inside the wrapper. No tape residue, peels clean, and the card slides right out when they finally find it.
Scotch Restickable Tabs Self Adhesive - Clear, 1 x 1 In
Dab this along the wrapper seam after you tuck the card in. Dries clear, holds just enough that it looks factory sealed. My dad had zero clue it had been opened.
Elmer's, Disappearing Purple School Glue Sticks
Try this one for longer gift cards like restaurant ones. The rectangular shape lines up almost perfectly. Wrap it back up and nobody suspects a thing until they snap a piece off.
Kit Kat Milk Chocolate Wafer King Size Candy, Bar 3 oz
Keep a sharp pair nearby because you need a clean cut along the wrapper seam, not a jagged tear. Learned that the hard way when my first attempt looked like a raccoon opened it.
Fiskars 8 Inch Original, Orange Handled Scissors for Adults
Pair this with a gas station gift card for a road trip gift. Tuck the card under the bar inside the wrapper. My friend found it three bites in and almost choked laughing.
Snickers Full Size Bulk Chocolate Candy Bars - 1.86 oz Bar
Funny Fake Packaging for Gift Cards
After the candy bar trick worked so well, I started putting gift cards inside fake product boxes. The more boring the fake product, the funnier the reaction. A gift card inside a box of ‘socks’ hits different.
Slide any gift card inside this ridiculous fake product box and watch them open it with the most confused face. My brother-in-law read the whole fake box before he found the real gift.
Prank Pack Roto Wipe Gift Box Gag Toys & Practical Joke
Use this when you want the person to genuinely question your judgment for about 30 seconds before they dig deeper. The relief on their face when they find the actual gift card is priceless.
Prank-O Earwax Candle Kit Prank Gift Box
Toss the prank item inside this so it looks legit from the outside. A nice box makes them think it is something serious, which makes the joke land harder.
Hallmark 3-Pack Gift Box Bundle (White Square)
Wrap the outer box neatly because sloppy wrapping tips people off that something is up. Clean corners and tight folds sell the whole bit.
Scotch Gift Wrap Tape Dispensers, Satin Finish, 3/4 in. x
Swap this in for anyone who actually needs socks. They will groan, then find the gift card, then forgive you. Tested on my dad at Christmas and he still talks about it.
Prank Pack Cargo Socks Gift Box
Stuff tissue around the gift card inside the prank box so they have to dig through layers. The longer the unwrapping takes, the better the payoff.
Hallmark Tissue Paper (Solid White) 8 Sheets
Write a fake note on the prank box lid like ‘Thought you could really use this!’ to sell the joke. My mom read it out loud and the whole room lost it before she even opened the box.
Sharpie Permanent Markers, Fine Point, Black, 5 Count
Balloon Pop Gift Card Reveals
Put a gift card inside a balloon, inflate it, and hand them a pin. Watching someone nervously pop a balloon not knowing what is inside never gets old. My cousin screamed and then screamed again when the card fell out.
Use the clear ones so they can almost see something inside but cannot quite tell what it is. The suspense drives people nuts. Roll the gift card tight and slide it in before inflating.
Happy New Year 11-Inch Qualatex Latex Balloons 25 Per
Try inflating a balloon with a card stuffed inside by mouth and you will pass out. This pump does it in four squeezes and saves your lungs for singing happy birthday.
Balloon Pump Hand Held Two-Way Dual Action
Tie a long piece to the balloon so it floats around the room looking all festive before they destroy it. My aunt batted it around for ten minutes before we told her to pop it.
Way To Celebrate Red Curling Ribbon, 350 yds
Wrap the gift card in a small ribbon bow before stuffing it in the balloon so it looks intentional when it falls out, not like litter. Small detail, big difference.
Offray Ribbon, Brown 5/8 inch Football Grosgrain
Anchor the balloon to the table so it does not float away before they get to it. Lost a $25 card to a ceiling fan once. Never again.
65-gram Cube Weight - Neon Assortment Balloon Weights
Hand these to little kids instead of a pin so they can pop their own balloon safely. Watching a six year old saw at a balloon with safety scissors is comedy gold.
Westcott 5-Inch Assorted Pointed Kids Scissors
Toss a handful of confetti in the balloon before inflating so when it pops there is a mini explosion. Messy? Yes. Worth the cleanup? Every single time.
Better Office Products: Multicolor Tissue Paper Confetti
DIY Gift Card Puzzle Boxes
My friend once told me gift cards feel impersonal. So I started hiding them inside puzzle boxes that take five minutes to open. Nothing says ‘I care’ like watching someone struggle with a wooden box while everyone else has already opened their gifts.
Tuck a gift card inside this and hand it over with zero instructions. My cousin spent 15 minutes at Thanksgiving working on it while everyone watched and offered terrible advice.
True Genius Aztec Sun Stone Wooden Spheric Brain
Use this for the person in your family who thinks they are smarter than everyone. Watching their confidence slowly crumble as they cannot open a wooden box is deeply satisfying.
True Genius - Pharoah's Tomb Puzzle Box
Swap this in for someone who likes a quick challenge. Not as hard as the full puzzle boxes but still takes a couple minutes of fumbling before the card falls out.
Professor Puzzles - Great Minds
Tape a gift card to the inside of the Rubik's cube box and wrap the whole thing. They think the cube IS the gift, then find the card underneath. Double gift energy.
Rubik's Cube, Retro 50th Anniversary Edition 3x3
Grab this for a kid's gift card reveal. They unlatch all six latches to find the card inside. Keeps little hands busy and buys you five minutes of quiet.
Melissa & Doug Wooden Latches Board
Seal the puzzle box inside a padded mailer if you are shipping it. Nothing worse than a puzzle box that arrives already cracked open and spoils the surprise.
Duck Brand Self-Seal Kraft Bubble Mailer, 8.5"x11", 12pk
Write clues on sticky notes and attach them to the puzzle box so the person knows there is something inside worth solving for. Otherwise they just set it on a shelf.
Post-it Super Sticky Full Stick Notes, 3x3, Yellow, 12 Pads
Gift Card Origami and Paper Craft Supplies
Folding a gift card into a paper shirt or hiding it inside a handmade envelope takes about four minutes and makes people think you spent an hour. Biggest effort-to-impression ratio of any gift hack I know.
Keep this stack around because you will burn through paper practicing folds before you get one right. Thick enough to hold shape but thin enough to crease cleanly.
Crayola, Construction Paper, 240 Pages
Use this instead of regular tape when sealing handmade envelopes. No visible tape lines, everything looks cleaner, and the card stays put when they shake it.
Scotch, Double Sided Tape Runner, .27 in x 26 ft, Red
Cut straight lines on your first try instead of your fifth. Crooked edges ruin the whole handmade look and make it seem like a last minute job, which it probably is, but they do not need to know.
Fiskars SureCut Supercut 12-Inch Paper Trimmer, Gray
Switch to cardstock when you want the holder to actually stand up on its own like a little card display. Regular paper flops over and looks sad.
Recollections Smooth Solid Cardstock Paper, 12" x 12"
Draw a goofy face or write a note directly on your handmade holder. Personal touches are what separate ‘creative gift’ from ‘weird folded paper with money in it.’
Are Crayola and Silly Putty products nontoxic even if
Bring these out if you want the holder to look polished. Blend colors, do some lettering, make it Instagram-worthy. My sister framed the holder and forgot to use the gift card for two months.
Tombow Dual Brush Pen Art Markers, Mermaids, 10-Pack
Dab a tiny bit on tricky folds that will not stay down. Dries invisible and holds strong. Learned this after a handmade wallet I made unfolded in someone's hands mid-reveal.
Gorilla, Hot Glue Sticks, 30 Count, Clear 4 inch Dual Temp
Gift Card Scavenger Hunt Supplies
Instead of handing over a card directly, I hide clues around the house that lead to it. Takes ten minutes to set up and turns a two-second gift into a twenty-minute adventure. Kids go absolutely feral for this.
Print your clues on these and stick them around the house. Way faster than handwriting ten clues, and they peel off walls and furniture without leaving marks.
Avery, Shipping Labels, 2" x 4", Glossy White, Pack of 250
Stick clue cards under chairs, behind picture frames, inside the fridge. These hold paper to any surface and come off clean, which matters when your landlord is strict.
Scotch Removable Poster Tape, Clear, 3/4 in x 150 in, 1 Roll
Hand these to kids so they can decode clues you wrote in matching crayon colors. ‘Find the blue clue’ sends a five year old sprinting through every room in the house.
Crayola Crayons Bulk, Classroom Supplies, 24 Pack
Seal each clue in a bag if you are hiding them outdoors. One gust of wind or morning dew and your whole scavenger hunt dissolves. Learned this at an Easter egg hunt gone wrong.
Ziploc® Sandwich Bags with EasyGuide™ 40 Count
Put the final gift card inside this little chest at the end of the hunt. Finding a tiny treasure box after following clues makes a $25 gift card feel like buried pirate gold.
Small Pirate Style Wooden Treasure Chest
Let little kids paint their own clue cards as part of the activity. Turns the setup into a craft project and kills an extra hour on a rainy Saturday. Parents, you are welcome.
Customer reviews for Cra-Z-Art Washable Tempera Paint
Mark a trail on the floor with colored tape arrows pointing to each clue station. Rip it up after and it peels clean off tile and hardwood. Do not try this on carpet though.
Color Duck Tape Brand Duct Tape, 1.88 in. x 20 yd., White
Gift Card Wrapping Finishing Touches
The difference between a gift card someone remembers and one they forget about is the presentation in the last ten seconds. A ribbon, a tag, a weird little bow made from magazine pages. These small details seal the whole thing.
Peel and stick a tag on your finished creation so they know who it is from. I once forgot a tag and my aunt thanked the wrong person for twenty minutes. Awkward.
Hallmark Gift Tag Stickers (Colorful For/From) 8 sheets
Curl a few strands and attach them to whatever holder you made. Takes three seconds with scissors and makes the whole thing look like you planned it weeks ago.
Berwick Splendorette Crimped Curling Ribbon
Wrap a strip of patterned tape around a plain envelope or box to add color without buying wrapping paper. Rips by hand, sticks to everything, and comes in wild patterns.
Scotch Expressions Washi Tape, Multi-Pack with Storage
Glue a pom pom on top of your gift card holder like a little hat. Sounds dumb but it makes people smile every time. My nephew kept the pom pom longer than he kept the card.
Darice Acrylic Pom Poms, Orange, 1 Inch, 40 ...
Paint a quick design on a plain box or card holder to personalize it. Even bad art is charming when it is clearly handmade. My stick-figure portrait of my mom made her cry laughing.
Apple Barrel Color Basics 2 fl oz Acrylic Craft Paint Set
Press one of these wherever you need something to stick without the mess of liquid glue. Clean, instant hold, no drying time. Perfect for last-minute assembly ten minutes before the party.
Elmer's Craft Bond Glue Spots, 300/pkg, Thin Mini
Slap some stickers on a plain holder and suddenly it looks like a craft project instead of a procrastination project. Kids love adding their own stickers too, which buys you more setup time.
12 Pack: Maker Sticker Book by Recollections