Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

I Finally Found Baking Tools That Fixed My Burnt Pie Crust Problem

Purple Star emoji 35 items
Every Thanksgiving I'd pull a pie out of the oven with edges that looked like charcoal while the center was still jiggly. Spent years doing the aluminum foil origami trick and it never worked right. If you're someone who actually bakes pies more than...
Sections
7
 
 
 
 
 
 

Pie Crust Shields and Edge Protectors

Burned edges ruined so many of my pies that I almost gave up on baking from scratch. These protectors sit right on the rim and let the center catch up without torching the outside.

 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Grab this if you've been wrapping foil around your pie like a tinfoil hat every holiday. Dropped it on a 9-inch pie and the edges came out golden for the first time in years. Perfect for anyone who bakes more than two pies a season.
Customer reviews for (4 pack) Mrs. Anderson's Baking Pie
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Switch to silicone if metal shields keep sliding off in your oven. This one grips the edge and stays put the entire bake. Washed it about thirty times now and it hasn't warped once.
Customer reviews for Norpro Silicone Mini Pie Crust Shields
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Keep this set around if you bake different sized pies. Fits standard and deep dish without fussing. Before I had these, my pecan pie edges were always dark brown while the filling was still liquid.
Wilton Adjustable Silicone Pie Crust Shield
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Use the adjustable ring if your pie dishes are all slightly different sizes. Slides to fit 8 to 10 inches. Saved me from buying three separate shields for my mismatched collection.
Pie Crust Shield
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Toss this on during the last 20 minutes when edges start browning too fast. Nonstick coating means zero sticking to your decorative crimps. For anyone whose pretty fluted edges always end up looking scorched.
Adjustable Silicone Pie Crust Shield Pie Protectors

Pie Pans That Bake Evenly

Half my crust problems turned out to be cheap pans that created hot spots. Swapping pans made a bigger difference than I expected.

 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Try glass if you've never baked a pie in it. You can actually see the bottom browning through the dish, so no more guessing. Pulled my first evenly browned apple pie out of this and almost cried.
Pyrex Basics 9.5 inch Round Glass Pie Plate
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Pair this with a crust shield and you'll wonder why you struggled for so long. The steel distributes heat so evenly that my crusts stopped having that one random burnt spot. Worth every penny.
USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pie Pan, 9-Inch
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Snag this if you want a pie dish that goes straight from oven to table without shame. Ceramic holds heat gently so the crust doesn't shock-cook. My blueberry pie finally set properly in this one.
Emile Henry 9 Inch Round Modern Classics Ceramic Pie
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Grab a couple of these for everyday baking without worrying about scratching something expensive. Cheap enough to own four, sturdy enough to last years. Great starter pan for someone just getting into pie baking.
WILTON INDUSTRIES Recipe Right 9-Inch Non-Stick Pie
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Use this if your dark nonstick pans keep burning the bottom crust before the top is done. Natural aluminum runs cooler and more even. Swapped to this last fall and haven't looked back.
Nordic Ware Naturals® 9 Inch Pie Pan

Pie Weights and Blind Baking Supplies

Soggy bottoms plagued me for years before I learned to blind bake properly. These tools finally gave me a crisp base layer.

 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Pour these into your crust before blind baking and say goodbye to bubbling and shrinking. Washed and reused mine probably fifty times. If you've been using dried beans, this is the real upgrade.
Mrs. Anderson's, Ceramic Pie Crust Weights
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Drape this chain across the bottom and it conforms to any shape. Way easier to remove than loose weights when the crust is hot. Saved me from burning my fingers fishing out individual beads.
R&M International Ceramic Pie Weights 1lb Pack
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Toss your dough in this bag to roll it out perfectly round every time. No more flour explosions on the counter. For anyone whose crusts always end up shaped like a map of Florida.
Mrs. Anderson s Baking, Pie Crust Maker Bag, 14-inch
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Use the straight edge to trim excess dough cleanly instead of hacking at it with a butter knife. Quick flick around the rim and done. Wish I'd grabbed this before I mangled my first dozen pie edges.
Ateco Fluted Pastry Wheel, 1 3/8 Inch Blade
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Press this into rolled dough and you get a perfect lattice in about ten seconds. Before this, my lattice attempts looked like a toddler wove them. Huge time saver during holiday crunch.
Fox Run Lattice Pie Top Cutter, White 9.75"

Rolling Pins and Dough Prep Tools

My crusts used to tear apart because I was overworking the dough with the wrong tools. Getting the right rolling pin honestly changed everything.

 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Switch to a tapered French pin if you want to actually feel the dough thickness under your hands. Went from uneven crusts to consistent quarter-inch thickness overnight. The maple is smooth and doesn't stick.
JK Adams Maple French Tapered Rolling Pin for Baking
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Grab this if you can never tell how thin your dough is. The removable rings set exact thickness so you stop guessing. Perfect for anyone who rolls one side paper thin and the other side like cardboard.
Joseph Joseph Duo Adjustable Rolling Pin
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Throw this on your counter before rolling and the measurements printed on it keep your circle the right diameter. No more rolling a crust that's too small for the pan. Peels right off without sticking.
Kitzini Silicone Baking Mat Set. Non-Stick
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Use this to cut butter into flour without warming it up with your hands. Cold butter equals flaky crust, period. My pie dough went from tough to shatteringly flaky once I stopped using my fingers.
OXO Good Grips Dough Blender With Blades
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Keep this next to your work surface to scoop and move dough without stretching it. Also scrapes dried flour off the counter in one swipe. Costs almost nothing and you'll use it constantly.
Amerteer Spring Chef Stainless Steel Pastry Scraper

Oven Thermometers and Temperature Control

Found out my oven was running 25 degrees hot, which explained years of burned crusts. Checking your actual oven temp is step one.

 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Hang this inside your oven and prepare to be annoyed at how wrong your dial has been. Mine was 25 degrees off for who knows how long. Under five bucks and it solved half my burning problems instantly.
Taylor Precision Products 1470N Oven Thermometer
placeholder
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Try this one if you want something that stays put on the rack without falling over. Sturdy base and clear numbers you can read through the oven window. Built for heavy use.
Rubbermaid Commercial FGTHO550 Stainless Steel Oven
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Snag this if you want a bigger display. The face is easy to read without squinting or opening the door. Opening the door drops your oven temp, which messes with bake times.
OXO Good Grips Chef's Precision Oven Thermometer
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Use this to check if your custard or pumpkin filling has actually set in the center. Stick it in, get a reading in seconds. No more cutting into a pie to see if it's done and ruining the presentation.
ThermoPro TP-02S Instant Read Meat Thermometer Digital
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Keep one on each rack if you bake multiple pies at once. Found out my top rack runs way hotter than the bottom. Knowing that saved my pecan pie from getting scorched on top last Thanksgiving.
CDN Oven Thermometer ProAccurate®

Pie Carriers and Storage Solutions

Spent all that effort baking a perfect pie and then destroyed it trying to transport it in a cardboard box. Never again.

 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Bring this to any potluck and your pie arrives looking exactly like it did on your counter. Locks shut so nothing slides around in the car. Collapses flat for storage, which matters if your kitchen is small.
Progressive Intl Collapsible Party Carrier
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Toss your pie in this after it cools and it stays fresh on the counter for days. The dome is tall enough for meringue without smashing it. Learned that lesson the hard way with plastic wrap.
Pie Keeper with Hinged Lid, Universal Storage Container
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Pair this with the Pyrex glass pie plate and the whole thing nests together perfectly. Insulated bag keeps it warm during the drive. For anyone who's tired of showing up with a lukewarm pie.
Pyrex 1087999 Portable Pie Plate, 9", Red
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Flip the base and it holds a standard pie plate snugly. Double duty since it also stores bundt cakes. Smart purchase if you don't want a separate carrier for every baked good you own.
Nordic Ware Bundt Cake Keeper - Single Pack
placeholder
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Get this if you want one dish that bakes and stores. Glass plate with a snap-on lid so you go from oven to fridge without transferring. Fewer dishes to wash, which honestly matters after a big baking day.
Anchor Hocking 11729 9.5 in. Deep Pie with Cover

Cookbooks and Recipe Resources for Better Pies

Watching random YouTube videos gave me conflicting advice for years. These books actually explained the science behind why my crusts kept failing.

 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Grab this if you want seasonal pie recipes that go beyond apple and pumpkin. The salted caramel apple pie recipe alone is worth the price. Written by people who clearly bake pies every single day.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds Pie Book: Uncommon Recipes
placeholder
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Read this before your next pie attempt. Kate explains dough handling in a way that finally clicked for me after years of tough crusts. For anyone who thinks they're just bad at pies. You're not, you just need better instructions.
Art of the Pie: A Practical Guide to Homemade Crusts
placeholder
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Dive into the science chapters first. Stella explains why butter temperature and flour type matter so much. My pie game completely changed once I understood what was actually happening in the dough.
Pre-Owned BraveTart: Iconic American Desserts by Stella
placeholder
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Try the toasted marshmallow butterscotch pie recipe and tell me it's not the best thing you've ever made. The book has a relaxed tone that makes baking feel less intimidating. Great for someone who gets stressed in the kitchen.
Lisa Ludwinski, Sister Pie Cookbook, 75 Recipes and Stories
 
Alessandra Laurent profile picture
Use this as your reference manual for every pie question you'll ever have. Covers 300+ recipes and every crust style imaginable. Picked this up two years ago and it's permanently flour-stained on my counter now.
Pie Academy: Master the Perfect Crust and 255 Amazing
placeholder