Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Nailed Candy Cane Meringues That Melt in Your Mouth
33
items Every December I'd attempt meringues and end up with sticky, cracked blobs that tasted like sweetened air. If you've rage-quit a baking sheet at 11pm on Christmas Eve, this list is the gear and ingredients that finally got me to crispy-outside, pillo...
Sections
11
Peppermint Extracts and Flavorings That Actually Taste Like Candy Canes
Food Coloring That Creates Real Candy Cane Stripes
Piping Bags and Tips for Perfect Swirled Meringues
Baking Sheets and Liners That Prevent Sticking
Stand Mixers and Hand Mixers That Whip Stiff Peaks Fast
Sugars and Sweeteners for Crispy Outside Chewy Inside
Peppermint Extracts and Flavorings That Actually Taste Like Candy Canes
Most peppermint extracts taste like toothpaste. I went through four bottles before landing on ones that gave me that real candy cane punch without a medicinal aftertaste.
Grab this one for a clean, sharp peppermint hit. Before I switched to pure extract, my meringues tasted like cough drops. A few drops go a long way, so one bottle covers multiple batches.
McCormick Kosher Pure Peppermint Extract, 1.0 fl oz Box
Use this if you want intense flavor without adding extra liquid to your batter. Meringues are finicky about moisture, and this concentrated oil solved the weepy-meringue problem I fought for two Christmases straight.
LorAnn Oils Super Strength Flavoring
Keep this around for when McCormick sells out in December, because it will. Slightly sweeter profile that works great if you're making meringues for kids who think regular peppermint is too strong.
Watkins Organic Pure Peppermint Extract 2 fl. oz.
Food Coloring That Creates Real Candy Cane Stripes
Getting those red swirls without turning the whole meringue pink took me embarrassingly long to figure out. Gel colors changed everything because they don't mess with the batter consistency.
Ditch the liquid food coloring right now. Seriously. Liquid coloring made my meringues weep every single time. This gel gives you deep red stripes and the batter stays stiff.
Customer reviews for Wilton Red-Red Food Coloring
Try this for an even brighter red than Wilton. Paint it in stripes inside your piping bag and the swirl pattern comes out looking like you went to pastry school. You didn't, but nobody needs to know.
AmeriColor, Soft Gel Paste Food Color, Super Red 4.5 oz
Perfect for the person who bakes once a year and wants options beyond red. Comes with multiple colors so next Easter you can make pastel meringues too. Paid for itself in two holidays.
Wilton Color Right Performance Food Coloring Set
Piping Bags and Tips for Perfect Swirled Meringues
My first attempt involved a ziplock bag with the corner cut off. The meringues looked like sad ghosts. Proper piping tips made the difference between Pinterest fail and actual compliments.
Swap whatever tip you're using for this one. The 1M gives you those classic rosette swirls that make meringues look fancy with zero skill. I pipe in a single motion and they come out looking professional.
Wilton 1M Stainless Steel Open Star Cake Decorating Tip
Get the bigger bags. Tiny bags mean you're refilling every six meringues and getting batter everywhere. These fit a full batch and your hands stay clean enough to keep sipping your wine.
Ateco Disposable Decorating Bags, 18-Inch, Pack of 100
Snag one of these if you want to switch tips mid-batch without emptying the bag. Saved me from washing and refilling when I wanted both stars and round kisses on the same tray.
Wilton, Decorating Coupler Set, 4-Count, Plastic, White
Baking Sheets and Liners That Prevent Sticking
Nothing kills the mood faster than meringues welded to a pan. I lost an entire batch to a greased cookie sheet before I learned that parchment and silicone are non-negotiable.
Use pre-cut sheets instead of fighting with a roll that curls up every time you turn around. Meringues slide right off after baking. No scraping, no broken bottoms, no tears.
Reynolds Kitchens Cookie Baking Sheets
Worth every penny if you bake more than once a year. My meringues release perfectly and the mat lays completely flat, which means even bottoms instead of lopsided little blobs.
Customer reviews for Silpat Silicone Mat for Baking Non
Toss your dark nonstick pans for meringues. Dark pans cook too hot on the bottom and you get browning before the inside dries out. This light aluminum solved the soggy-center problem overnight.
Nordic Ware, Half Sheet, 18"x13" Aluminum, Rectangular Baking Pan
Stand Mixers and Hand Mixers That Whip Stiff Peaks Fast
Whipping egg whites by hand is a workout nobody signed up for. The right mixer gets you glossy stiff peaks in minutes instead of a sore arm and sad floppy whites.
Pair this with the whisk attachment and walk away. Stiff peaks in about 7 minutes while you prep the piping bag. Before I had a stand mixer, I was hand-whisking for 20 minutes and still getting soft peaks.
KitchenAid Classic Series 4.5-Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer
Grab this if a stand mixer isn't in the budget. Lightweight, powerful enough for meringue, and it fits in a drawer. My sister uses this one and her meringues are just as good as mine.
Hamilton Beach Electric Hand Mixer, 6-Speed Corded
Switch to the 6-wire whisk if your mixer came with a different one. More wires means more air incorporation, which means fluffier meringues. Small upgrade, big difference in texture.
Stainless Steel Wire Whisk for KitchenAid
Sugars and Sweeteners for Crispy Outside Chewy Inside
Regular granulated sugar left my meringues gritty. Superfine sugar dissolves completely in the egg whites and that's how you get that smooth, crackly shell everyone fights over.
Use this run through a blender for 30 seconds to make your own superfine sugar. Saved me from hunting for specialty sugar at three different stores last December.
Domino Premium Pure Cane Granulated Sugar, 10 lb
Try this if you don't want to DIY your superfine sugar. Dissolves instantly in egg whites so you never get that grainy crunch. My meringues went from sandy to silky the first time I used it.
C&H, Baker's Sugar, 3.5 lb Tub, Ultrafine Granulated Cane
Keep this on hand for dusting finished meringues. A light snow of powdered sugar before serving makes them look bakery-level. Also great for rescuing meringues that cracked, just dust and nobody notices.
Great Value Confectioners Powdered Sugar, 32 oz
Cream of Tartar and Stabilizers That Prevent Flat Meringues
Egg whites are drama queens. One speck of grease or yolk and the whole batch falls flat. These stabilizers keep your peaks standing tall through piping and baking.
Toss a quarter teaspoon in with your egg whites before whipping. My meringues used to deflate the second I stopped the mixer. Cream of tartar fixed that completely. Non-negotiable ingredient.
McCormick All Natural Kosher Cream Of Tartar, 1.5 oz Bottle
Use a tiny splash to wipe down your mixing bowl before you start. Any grease residue kills meringue. This is the cheapest insurance policy for a successful batch.
Great Value Distilled White Vinegar, 64 fl oz
Fold a teaspoon into finished meringue for that marshmallow-soft center. Learned this trick from a Pavlova recipe and never went back. The contrast between crispy shell and chewy middle is unreal.
Great Value Corn Starch, 16 oz
Candy Canes and Crushed Peppermint for Topping
Sprinkling crushed candy canes on top before baking adds crunch and makes them look like they belong on a magazine cover. Timing matters though. Too early and they melt into red puddles.
Smash these in a ziplock bag with a rolling pin. Way cheaper than buying pre-crushed peppermint and oddly satisfying after a long day. Sprinkle on meringues right before they go in the oven.
Brach's Bobs Red and White Candy Canes Peppermint
Grab these as a backup when candy canes sell out. Same peppermint flavor, and they crush into more uniform pieces. Easier to get consistent sprinkles across a whole batch.
Brach's Star Brites, Individully Wrapped
Pair these with the crushed candy canes for a chocolate-peppermint version. Press a few chips into each meringue before baking. My neighbor literally asked me to make a second batch just for her.
Andes Peppermint Crunch Baking Chips 10oz - 2 Bags
Egg Separators and Prep Tools for Clean Whites
One tiny drop of yolk in your whites and the whole thing is ruined. Ask me how I know. These tools keep separation clean so you're not fishing out yolk with a spoon and praying.
Snap this onto the side of your bowl and crack eggs one-handed. Zero yolk contamination in five batches and counting. Before this, I was doing the shell-to-shell method and failing every third egg.
OXO Good Grips 3-in-1 Egg Separator
Keep a small whisk around for hand-checking your meringue texture. Sometimes you need to feel the peaks between your fingers to know they're ready. Sounds fussy but it prevents overbearing.
OXO International OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Balloon
Use a glass cup to separate eggs one at a time before adding to the main bowl. If you crack a yolk, you only lose one egg instead of the whole batch. This saved me on Christmas morning last year.
Pyrex -2 Prepware 2 Glass Measuring Cup
Oven Thermometers and Baking Precision Tools
Meringues bake low and slow, and if your oven runs hot you'll get browning and cracks. Found out my oven was 25 degrees off. That one discovery fixed years of frustration.
Stick this in your oven and prepare to be annoyed at how wrong your oven's built-in thermometer is. Mine was 25 degrees high. Adjusting down gave me perfectly white meringues for the first time ever.
Taylor Classic Oven Thermometer 5932 - Stainless Steel, Analog
Try this as an alternative that hangs from the rack instead of standing. Easier to read through the oven window without opening the door, which matters because cold air drafts crack meringues instantly.
Meat Probe Not Working - Commercial-Style Range
Wear these when rotating your sheet pan halfway through baking. Regular potholders are clumsy and I once bumped the rack and sent meringues flying. These grip the pan securely and go up past your wrist.
GORILLA GRIP, Silicone Oven Mitts, 12.5", Blue
Storage Containers That Keep Meringues Crispy for Days
Meringues absorb moisture from the air like little sponges. Leave them uncovered overnight and they turn chewy and sticky. Airtight storage is the only way they survive until the party.
Snap meringues into this with a sheet of parchment between layers. Kept mine crispy for five days during the holidays. Without airtight storage, they went soft in about six hours. Learned that one the hard way.
Rubbermaid Brilliance Pantry Food Storage Containers
Wrap the container lid with foil for extra moisture protection if you live somewhere humid. Florida bakers, this one's for you. Double sealing kept my meringues crunchy through a week of 80% humidity.
Reynolds Wrap Heavy Duty Aluminum Foil, 12 Inch Wide
Toss individual servings into bags for gifting. Way easier than finding tins, and people can see the pretty swirls through the plastic. Tied with ribbon, these look like you spent way more effort than you did.
Great Value, Double Zipper Sandwich Bags