Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Best New to Me Holy Grail Products

Purple Star emoji 42 items
Some of my favorite products that I swear by as a newer makeup loving girly!
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Literally so buttery and smooth and stays on for so long! Leaves my lips extremely hydrated! Vanilla Beige and Iced Coffee leave a nice subtle beautiful color and smell incredible! And the Sweet Mint leaves a slight cooling tingle which I love and al...
Lip Butter Balm, Vanilla | Summer Fridays
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
AMAZING! Feels so good on the lips, has a slight tint to make them pop, stays on for so long and leaves the lips looking juicy!
Glow Reviver Tinted Lip Oil | e.l.f. Cosmetics
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
One of the BEST skin tints I've ever used! I have horrible redness from rosacea all over my face and this skin tint covers it so well! It's also buildable to your liking and feels so good on the skin! Doesn't irritate my sensitive skin either.
Super Stay 24-Hour Skin Tint with Vitamin C - Maybelline
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Hydrates your lips INSANELY well! My lips were so dry and cracked and I used this overnight the first time and it was like magic for real. I have the cotton candy one and it's my favorite! I use it under my Summer Fridays or my Elf Lip Oil too! I use...
Lip Sleeping Mask Nourish & Hydrate - Laneige
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I am a vanilla perfume girly through and through and this is the BEST true vanilla one I have found so far! It's a clean brand and it also lasts ALL day. It genuinely smells just like pure vanilla extract which is what I have always looked for in a v...
Vanilla - 50ml - Solinotes
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I know SHEIN makeup products have been controversial, but this has been my favorite liquid blush I've found so far! It's so pigmented and lasts so so long!
Fashion Blush | SHEIN USA
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
LOVE this. I lost my hair when going through chemo and I was absolutely devastated about losing my hair and worried that it would take forever to grow. I use this daily and my hair is coming back quickly and thick! I finally have my chemo curls and m...
Rosemary Mint Scalp & Hair Strengthening Oil - Mielle Organics
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I have pretty severe rosacea and dry dry skin and I have used so so so many moisturizers looking for one that wouldn't irritate my sensitive skin and that would actually work and this has been the absolute best one for me so far. It is a bit pricy an...
Neutrogena ® Hydro Boost Water Gel with Hyaluronic Acid
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I was VERY hesitant to try this out because of the price, but I can say it is extremely worth it. It's so glowy and has just the right amount of pigmentation and it's just a gorgeous blush! Plus the applicator is just so cute and convenient! So easy ...
On-the-Glow Blush - Pixi Beauty
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I'm a huge red lipstick girly and I always struggled with having it transfer, but I found this one and it is AMAZING. It stays on forever and the colors are gorgeous! I even ended up buying my wedding lipstick shade from them and that lasted through ...
Super Stay 24® 2-Step Liquid Lipstick Makeup - Maybelline
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Such a good lip gloss! Makes my lips look so plump and juicy and it lasts on the lips for so long! I have the açaí one and it's so good! They also smell delicious!! I even recommended this one to my mom!
Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss | COVERGIRL®
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I had never known how to do my eyebrows and I bought this to try to do them like I saw on Tik Tok and holy this stuff works SO good! My eyebrows were locked in place from morning until night😂 for me it didn't flake at all either!
Brow Lift - Clear Eyebrow Gel | e.l.f. Cosmetics
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
This has been all the hype lately and I see why!! It's so convenient to keep in your purse and you don't have to deal with taking off any caps! Just spray and go! Plus the scents are sooo good!
Touchland Power Mist Hydrating Hand Sanitizer - Sephora
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I know what you're thinking, that much for chapstick? I thought the same thing, but I ended up caving and it was such a good idea! They are HUGE and it's going to last me forever! I got the lemon wedding cake one and it smells HEAVENLY. It's extremel...
Jumbo Organic Lip Balm - Treat Beauty
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I had never been a huge fan of EOS, but I picked this up on vacation one time when I forgot my lip balm and it surprised me! It works super well and feels so good on! Not sticky at all! I have the peppermint swirl one and it's very refreshing! My nex...
Super Balms by eos - Extra Hydrating Lip Balm Gloss and Lip ...
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I am a lotion snob, I only like specific thicker ones that don't leave a greasy feel and this one does not disappoint! I initially bought it as a travel one for vacation, but ended up buying a bottle to keep in my purse because it's so good! Keeps my...
Products - Dr Teal's
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
This has been my favorite shampoo and conditioner for a long time! With my new hair coming back in after chemo, I was worried about what to put on my hair and this one keeps it feeling so soft and healthy! Plus it smells great!
Elvive Total Repair 5 Shampoo for Damaged Hair - L'Oréal Paris
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I'll always be a vanilla girly, but I came across this body oil in my strawberry shortcake obsessed era and it is soooo good. It's like a strawberry cake scent and it's very hydrating too and makes my skin so soft! The scent lasts forever, even throu...
Strawberry Tears - Femmenina
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Love love love! Has that vanilla scent that I always look for, but with a little creamy musk added! Lasts so long too! Once it dries down it's a little more sweet which I love. I get compliments all the time when I wear this!
Milk Perfume Mist - Bath & Body Works
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I stumbled upon this when I was doing research for a good moisturizer for my rosacea and dry skin. I read review after review because I was tired of spending all this money trying different things that wouldn't work. I literally won't leave the house...
SOS Daily Skin Barrier Redness Recovery Moisturizer - Tower 28 ...
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Absolutely LOVE this cleansing balm. I used makeup wipes religiously and my skin was paying the price so I switched to this and it melts my makeup right off and leaves my skin feeling so smooth after. It also doesn't sting my eyes when taking off eye...
Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm - e.l.f. Cosmetics
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
If you're a gourmand perfume girly, this site is for you!! I have the powdered donut roll on and it literally is exactly like smelling a bag of donuts. It's AMAZING and people always ask what I'm wearing and they get a kick out of it when I tell them...
Powdered Donuts Perfume Oil - Sugar Milk Co.
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I got a free sample size of this when I went to Sephora one time and it was my go to special occasion perfume all the time after! I've never loved floral perfumes, but this one is sweet along with the floral scents, almost lilac-y which I absolutely ...
Gucci Flora Gorgeous Magnolia, 100ml, eau de parfum
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
The ONLY lip liner I will use! It goes on so smoothly and so nice and the colors are the perfect density! I have shade "Stockholm" for the more natural lip days and then I have the shade "Girl, Bye" which is my absolute favorite and I pair that with ...
Suede Matte Lip Liner Pencil | NYX Professional Makeup
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
The BEST concealer! I have never liked using it because I thought it never worked, but I got this as a sample from Sephora and tried it out and it turns out I never liked it because I never had a good quality one haha. I immediately ordered it. This ...
Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez Liquid Touch Brightening Concealer
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
So I fell into the fad of having this and at first I absolutely hated it because I was applying it like a regular lip color and it just kept separating and looked horrible on my lips. It was always great as a cheek stain though as long as you blend i...
Benetint Liquid Lip Blush & Cheek Tint - Benefit Cosmetics - Ulta Beauty
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I smelled this scent in store about a year ago, but wasn't able to get it at the time with the coupon I had, but I absolutely loved it and wrote down the name and I was finally able to get it last month! I've always been a vanilla girly through and t...
Dahlia Body Lotion
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I was never one to use any type of eyelash primer, I just always went in with mascara, but I got this as a free gift from Sephora and I absolutely love it. It works amazing and makes my lashes look so long and beautiful! I even wear it by itself on d...
Cils Booster XL Super-Enhancing Mascara Primer - Sephora
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I just got this set for Christmas and it works SO WELL for my new "chemo curls" that are coming in. I actually love this more than the Miss Jessie's line! I dont have to use a lot of product for this to make my curls look amazing, so it's lasting me ...
Mini Styling Set - Not Your Mother's
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I've never used lip plumpers before, my lips really don't need it, but I picked this one up at the store just to try and it's so good! It's not a huge plumping affect, it has a slight minty tingle, but it's really amazing! I have shade Velvet Mink an...
REVLON Kiss Plumping Lip Creme, Velvet Mink
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Just recently tried this cleanser and I really love it! It takes my face makeup off very nicely. It is a little tough to get the mascara off at first, but it does get it! It's a thicker consistency which I didn't expect, but it works very well!
Korean Cleanser
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I just discovered this perfume about a week ago and it smells AMAZING. It lasts so long on as well! I just turned 26 and am wanting to gradually start using more mature perfumes and this one was definitely the first step in that direction! It's just ...
Tru Fragrance Angel 444 Eau de Parfum 1.7oz
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
The PERFECT tropical summery scent! Just saw this at target a few days ago along with a few others and I sprayed them all on my arm to test and I just kept gravitating back towards this scent! You just can't get enough of it and you want to keep smel...
Good Chemistry® Body Mist Fragrance Spray - Coco Blush - 5.07 fl oz
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I know you probably see ads for this weighted hoodie all over social media and are sick of it, but I was in that same boat, until I finally googled the brand and this specific hoodie and read all of the reviews in depth. Almost all of them were great...
Weighted Hoodie
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Such a beautiful scent!! Gourmand, but grown up. Smells just like a slice of lemon meringue pie and the PERFECT summer scent. I've gotten so many compliments and I just got it a week ago!
Lemon Pie EDP
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Incredible foundation!! I'm a huge "just concealer" girly, but I just recently started getting back into foundation and wanted one that would make me look hydrated and wouldn't feel so heavy and this was the perfect one! Feels so good on my skin and ...
Lifter Plump & Glow Foundation
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I am VERY picky with lotions and need to use specific consistency ones and this is the ONLY every day lotion I can use. It's the perfect thickness and has such a nice light smell to it. It doesn't leave my hands feeling greasy and they instantly feel...
Curel Skin & Facial Care Lotions, Moisturizers and Creams
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
Love love love miscellar water for taking off my makeup. Specifically the rose one. I struggle with horrible rosacea and everything irritates my skin, but this rose one is incredible. It removes makeup so easily, but it also leaves my skin feeling so...
Garnier Micellar Cleansing Water Skin Care Products
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I just started getting back into using contour and this one is PERFECT. It blends SO easily and gives a nice soft contour look. The applicator is amazing too and feels very nice on the skin. This is the only contour I use now and it's the perfect dup...
Halo Glow Liquid Contour Wand
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I had searched for soooo long for a faux brow pen with the precise tip like this and I finally discovered this one!! It is AMAZING for replicating hair like strokes and the colors are perfect. I have red hair and use the mahogany-ish one and it's per...
L'Oreal Paris Faux Brow Hair-Like Eyebrow Pen
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
This specific scent of this brand is INCREDIBLE. It's like a sophisticated smell, almost like a more adult version of Cloud by Ariana. My dad normally HATES body sprays and perfume and is super sensitive to them, but I wore this the day I bought it a...
ParfumsBelcam Kinda Warm & Sweet Hair & Body Mist for Women ...
 
Allie Fagan profile picture
I have alwaysss loved the rose scent conditioner of this brand and I had gone to Walmart one day and saw the hair perfume and immediately bought it. This is something I will ALWAYS use, every single day. It smells DELICIOUS and it adds a little fresh...
Rose Fragrance Hair Mist - Herbal Essences