Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
How I Potty Trained My Stubborn Puppy Without Losing My Sanity
36
items Carpet stains at 6 AM, accidents behind the couch you don't find for three days, that helpless look your puppy gives you after peeing on your shoe — yeah, I lived that for weeks. This is the exact lineup of products that finally got my stubborn terri...
Sections
9
Potty Training Bells That Actually Get Used
Indoor Accident Cleanup Without the Lingering Smell
Puppy Pads for the Transition Phase
Treats That Make Training Stick
Crate Training Gear That Speeds Everything Up
Leashes and Harnesses for Quick Potty Trips
Potty Training Bells That Actually Get Used
Spent the first week pointing at the door like a mime before I realized the bell setup matters more than the training method. Once I switched to the right bells and placement, my puppy figured it out in four days flat.
Grab these first — they hang right on the doorknob and my puppy went from scratching the door to ringing these in under a week. Perfect for anyone whose door is getting wrecked by tiny claws.
Mighty Paw Tinkle Bells Dog Doorbells Housetraining
Keep a backup set on the back door if you have two exits. My neighbor's golden retriever learned on these in three days, which made me jealous enough to buy a second set for our sliding door.
Potty Bells - Caldwell's Pet Supply Co.
Switch to this if your puppy figured out bells but rings them too quietly for you to hear from the kitchen. The wireless chime reaches every room — no more missed signals while I'm cooking dinner.
Wireless Dog Door Bell, Doggie Doorbells for Potty
Toss these on the floor near the door if your puppy ignores hanging bells. My friend's dachshund had short legs and couldn't reach the doorknob ones, so these tap bells on the ground worked way better for small breeds.
Comsmart Dog Training Bell, Set of 2 Dog Puppy Pet Potty
Indoor Accident Cleanup Without the Lingering Smell
Nothing haunts you like thinking you cleaned a spot and then guests walk in and wrinkle their nose. I went through four different sprays before finding ones that actually kill the scent instead of just covering it with lavender.
Ditch whatever grocery store spray you're using — this enzyme formula actually breaks down the urine instead of masking it. Poured it on a two-day-old carpet stain I didn't know about and the smell was gone by morning.
Nature's Miracle Advanced Dog Stain & Odor
Use this on hardwood or tile where other cleaners leave a sticky residue. Found a puddle behind the bathroom door that had been there who knows how long, and one spray plus a paper towel handled it completely.
Rocco Roxie Stain Odor Elim Spray 24oz
Snag this if your carpet has taken repeated hits in the same spot. The scrubbing brush head pulls stains out of carpet fibers in a way that spraying and blotting never could — wish I had this from day one.
BISSELL® Pet Stain Eraser™ PowerBrush
Try the gallon size because you will go through it faster than you think during weeks two and three. For anyone potty training in winter when the puppy refuses to go outside in the cold, stock up now.
Simple Solution Extreme Pet Stain & Odour Remover
Puppy Pads for the Transition Phase
Hated the idea of pads at first because I thought they'd teach my dog to pee inside forever. Turns out they're the bridge between chaos and a fully trained dog — you just have to phase them out strategically.
Pair these with a pad holder so your puppy stops dragging them across the room like a chew toy. The extra large size saved me because my puppy's aim was terrible for the first two weeks.
American Kennel Club, Dog Training Pads
Grab the 100-pack and don't feel guilty about going through ten a day at the start. For anyone in an apartment without quick yard access, these are the difference between sanity and soggy socks at 3 AM.
Amazon Basics Leak-Proof Dog Puppy Potty
Switch to these if regular pads leave your apartment smelling like a kennel. The carbon layer actually traps odor — I noticed the difference the first morning I woke up and my living room didn't smell like a pet store.
Glad Activated Charcoal Training Pads, 23in x 23in
Use this tray underneath whatever pad you pick. My puppy kept bunching pads up and peeing on the bare floor next to them, and this holder fixed that problem overnight. Flat floors, no more pad surfing.
Pee Pad Holder for Dogs 51''x25.6'' Silicone Puppy
Treats That Make Training Stick
Tried using her regular kibble as a reward and she looked at me like I insulted her. The second I pulled out high-value treats, she started racing to the door before I even said the word outside.
Keep a bag by every door in your house. These are tiny enough that you can give twenty a day without worrying about overfeeding, and my puppy will do literally anything for the peanut butter flavor.
(4 pack) Zuke's Mini Naturals Soft Dog Training Treats
Swap to these if your puppy gets bored of the same treat after a week — mine did. The soft texture means she eats them fast and refocuses on what I'm asking instead of spending thirty seconds chewing.
Blue Buffalo Bits Soft Dog Treats for Training
Try these for puppies under six months whose teeth are still coming in. My girl was teething and ignored hard treats completely, but these soft bites got her attention every single time at the door.
Wellness Grain Free Soft Puppy Bites for Small Dogs
Snag the bacon flavor specifically — I tested four flavors and bacon got the fastest response by far. For anyone whose puppy is food-motivated but picky, these are the ones that finally broke through the stubbornness.
Pet Botanics Train-Me Training Rewards Bacon Dog Treats
Crate Training Gear That Speeds Everything Up
Resisted crate training because it felt mean until my vet explained that dogs actually want a den. Once I set up the crate correctly, nighttime accidents dropped from every single night to zero in about five days.
Get the divider panel version so you can adjust the space as your puppy grows. Too much room and they pee in the corner — I learned that the hard way with a crate that was two sizes too big.
MidWest iCrate Double-Door Folding Dog Crate
Toss this in the crate instead of old towels. Towels bunch up and get soaked, but this pad stays flat and washes easily. My puppy stopped trying to dig at the crate floor once she had something actually comfortable.
MidWest Homes For Pets, Pet Bed & Dog Crate Mat
Drape this over the crate at night and suddenly your puppy thinks it's a cozy cave instead of a cage. Mine went from whining for forty-five minutes to settling down in under five. The darkness really does the trick.
Customer reviews for MidWest Homes for Pets Dog Crate
Bring this home before the first night. The heartbeat mimics another dog sleeping next to them, and my puppy's first-night crying went from two hours to maybe ten minutes. Worth every penny for your sleep alone.
Customer reviews for Original Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat
Leashes and Harnesses for Quick Potty Trips
Realized I was wasting five minutes fumbling with gear every time my puppy signaled, and by then she'd already had an accident by the door. Speed matters — you need a grab-and-go setup that takes under ten seconds.
Keep this hanging right on the doorknob next to the bells. No buckles, no clips — just slip it over her head and you're outside in three seconds. Saved me from at least a dozen near-misses at the front door.
Mendota Pet Slip Leash - Dog Lead and Collar Combo
Use this for daytime walks when you have more time to gear up. Clips in the front so pulling puppies can't drag you across the yard, which matters when you're in pajamas at 6 AM and the grass is wet.
PetSafe Easy Walk Dog Harness, No Pull Leash
Grab a short four-foot version for potty-only trips so your puppy doesn't wander and sniff everything instead of doing her business. Long leashes turn a two-minute potty break into a fifteen-minute adventure.
Blueberry Pet Essentials 21 Colors Durable Classic Dog
Pair this with late-night potty runs — the reflective stitching means cars can see you when you're standing in the driveway at midnight in dark clothes. Didn't think I needed it until I almost got clipped by a neighbor backing out.
FRISCO Outdoor Nylon Reflective Comfort Padded Dual
Outdoor Potty Spot Training Aids
My puppy treated the entire yard like a buffet of smells and forgot why we were out there. Designating one specific potty spot with attractant spray cut our outdoor waiting time from fifteen minutes to about two.
Spray this in the exact spot you want your puppy to go and watch them beeline straight to it. Before this, my girl would wander the whole yard for ten minutes. Now she hits her spot in under sixty seconds.
NaturVet Potty Here Training Spray for Dogs, 8 fl oz
Try this one if the first spray doesn't click with your dog — different attractant formulas work for different breeds. My neighbor's lab ignored one brand completely but responded to this one immediately.
Four Paws Wee-Wee Puppy Housebreaking Aid, 8 fl oz
Use this on your balcony or patio if you're in an apartment and can't get outside fast enough. Feels like real grass under their paws, and my friend's French bulldog in a third-floor walkup was fully trained on this setup alone.
PETMAKER 35.5x23.5 Artificial Grass Pee Pads
Toss this under the artificial grass pad to catch anything that drains through. Without it, your balcony becomes a biohazard. Learned this lesson the gross way after one rainy weekend when everything pooled underneath.
IRIS USA, Puppy Pee Pad Holder, 23" L x 22.75" W, Blue
Nighttime Potty Training Survival Kit
Nobody warns you that you'll be setting alarms every three hours like you have a newborn baby. These products helped me stretch my puppy's nighttime bladder from two hours to a full eight over about three weeks.
Swap out the regular water bowl for this two hours before bedtime and then take it away. Controlled water intake at night was the single biggest factor in stopping 2 AM accidents — more than any training trick I tried.
Veken Replacement Pump For Pet Fountain Cat Water
Keep this by your bed for midnight potty trips so you're not fumbling for light switches while your puppy dances at the door. Bright enough to see the yard but not so bright it wakes up the whole house.
Halo Bolt Mwh Portable Phone Laptop Charger Car Jump
Clip this to the crate so you can do a quick visual check without turning on overhead lights. Caught a couple early-warning signs of restlessness that saved me from full accidents just by glancing over.
Victsing Rechargeable Book Light, 80H, 3 Brightness
Throw this on your bed if your puppy sleeps with you during the transition phase. One accident on an unprotected mattress costs way more than this protector, and trust me, it will happen when you least expect it.
GORILLA GRIP Washable Mattress Incontinence Pads
Books and Guides That Saved Me from Bad Advice
YouTube university taught me three contradictory methods and I confused my puppy so badly she started peeing more. These actual trainer-written resources gave me one clear plan that worked from start to finish.
Grab this before you watch a single YouTube video. Zak breaks down exactly when to reward, when to redirect, and when to just wait — cleared up every confusing piece of advice I'd gotten from random internet strangers.
Zak George's Dog Training Revolution
Read the housetraining chapter specifically if your puppy is under four months. Their schedule template gave me exact timing for meals, water, and outdoor trips that I followed like a recipe, and it actually worked.
The Art of Raising a Puppy: New Skete Monks
Try this if you want a no-nonsense approach without all the theory. Brandon's seven commands method builds a communication foundation that makes potty training click faster because your puppy actually listens to you.
Lucky Dog Lessons Audiobook by Brandon McMillan
Use this if you're on a deadline — like I was when family was visiting in two weeks and I couldn't have accidents happening during Thanksgiving dinner. The structured daily plan is aggressive but it genuinely works fast.
Perfect Puppy in 7 Days: Start Right