Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Slow Cooker Chicken Tortilla Soup That Made Me Stop Eating Out
45
items Every weeknight used to end the same way. Too tired to cook, too guilty to order delivery again, wallet getting thinner while my waistline wasn't. Then I nailed a chicken tortilla soup in my slow cooker that genuinely smells better than the Mexican p...
Sections
9
Slow Cookers That Actually Hold Up
Chicken That Doesn't Fall Apart Into Mush
Canned Goods That Build the Base
Spices That Make It Smell Like a Restaurant
Toppings That Actually Make the Bowl
Fresh Ingredients Worth the Extra Minute
Slow Cookers That Actually Hold Up
Went through two cheap ones that cracked before I landed on something reliable. These are the ones that survived years of weekly soup batches without the lid chipping or the heating element dying.
Grab this if you cook for more than two people. I fill it Sunday morning and we eat soup for three days straight. No digital nonsense, just a dial that works.
Crock-Pot Manual 7-Quart Slow Cooker, Black
Bring this to potlucks without wearing the soup on your car seat. That locking lid is the reason I still have clean upholstery. Perfect for anyone who hauls food to work.
Hamilton Beach 6 Qt Slow Cooker, Stoneware Crock
Switch to this when you forgot to start the soup at 8am. Pressure cook mode saves a forgetful person in 40 minutes flat. Wish I'd bought it before I missed dinner twice.
Customer reviews for Instant Pot 6Qt Duo Plus
Keep this around for smaller batches or side dishes. My partner and I use it when we don't want a week's worth of leftovers staring at us from the fridge.
Crockpot™ Design Series 3-Quart Manual Slow Cooker
Use the timer function so it switches to warm while you're stuck in traffic. Came home at 7pm once and it was still perfect temp. Saved me from reheating sadness.
Hamilton Beach FlexCook 6 Quart Slow Cooker
Chicken That Doesn't Fall Apart Into Mush
First few batches turned into shredded mystery fiber because I used the wrong cuts. Getting the right chicken is honestly half the battle with this soup.
Toss these in instead of breast meat and thank me later. Thighs stay juicy after 8 hours on low. Breast turns into cardboard. Learned that lesson so you don't have to.
Freshness Guaranteed Boneless Skinless Chicken Thighs
Pour in two cartons as your base. It's cheap, it's consistent, and honestly nobody can tell the difference in a soup loaded with spices. Save the fancy broth for risotto.
Great Value, Gluten-Free Chicken Broth, 32 oz Carton
Grab these if you really prefer white meat. The trick is adding them halfway through so they don't disintegrate. Set a phone alarm, future you will appreciate it.
Perdue Harvestland, Free Range, Fresh Boneless Chicken
Keep a few cans in the pantry for emergency soup nights when you forgot to thaw anything. Drain, dump, done. Nobody at the table has ever noticed.
Great Value Canned Chunk Chicken Breast 12.5 oz Pack
Swap this in if you're watching sodium. I started using it after my doctor gave me that look. Still tastes rich because the spices do all the heavy lifting anyway.
Customer reviews for Swanson Unsalted Chicken Broth
Canned Goods That Build the Base
Opening six cans feels like cheating, but that's exactly why this soup works on a Tuesday. No chopping tomatoes, no soaking beans overnight, just pop and pour.
Dump two cans in and you've got heat plus acidity handled in ten seconds. This is the ingredient that makes people ask for the recipe every single time.
ROTEL Original Diced Tomatoes and Green Chilies, 10 oz
Toss in a drained can for texture and protein. My kids pick around them but at least they're eating the broth, so I count it as a win.
BUSH'S, Seasoned Recipe Black Beans
Throw a can in for sweetness that balances the chili. Frozen works too but canned means I never have to remember to buy it fresh. Lazy cooking is sustainable cooking.
(8 pack) Great Value Golden Sweet Whole Kernel Corn
Pour half a can in to thicken things up without using flour or cream. Gives the broth that restaurant depth. The other half goes in a freezer bag for next week.
Hunt's Tomato Sauce, Perfect for Chili & Soups, 8 oz. Can
Snag a jar and add a few spoonfuls right into the pot. Sounds weird, works brilliantly. All those flavors are already balanced so you skip five ingredients.
Green Mountain Gringo Medium Salsa 16oz
Spices That Make It Smell Like a Restaurant
The moment I stopped using pre-mixed taco seasoning packets and measured my own spices, the soup went from fine to genuinely incredible. This is where the magic actually lives.
Use a full tablespoon, not the timid half teaspoon the internet suggests. Cumin is the backbone of this soup. Your kitchen will smell like your favorite taqueria by hour three.
McCormick Kosher Ground Cumin, 1.5 oz Bottle
Pair this with the cumin at about two teaspoons. It adds warmth without actual heat, so even spice-averse family members eat it without complaint. Took me four batches to get the ratio right.
McCormick Chili Seasoning Mix, 1.25 oz Packet
Try half a teaspoon for smokiness that makes people think you spent hours over a stove. This is the secret ingredient nobody guesses. Stock up, it goes fast.
Badia, Smoked Paprika, Organic, 16 oz, Ground Spice
Keep this next to the slow cooker permanently. A solid teaspoon goes in every batch. Fresh garlic burns in a slow cooker, but powder distributes evenly and never gets bitter.
McCormick spices impossible to open. Apparently, it's the glue
Sprinkle this on top of each bowl right before serving. The lime and chili hit wakes everything up. My neighbor tried it once and now she buys it by the three-pack.
Recipe Finder - TAJIN a unique blend of mild chile peppers
Toppings That Actually Make the Bowl
Honestly the toppings are 40% of why this soup slaps. A naked bowl of tortilla soup is just spicy chicken broth. Load it up or what's the point.
Grab a bag and crush them right into the bowl. They soften just enough in the hot broth without going completely soggy. Way easier than frying your own on a weeknight.
Mission Tortilla Strips Nutrition Facts
Peel one open and drop a spoonful on top. Individual packs mean no browning in the fridge. Perfect for the person who eats soup for lunch three days in a row like I do.
WHOLLY Guacamole Minis Paste Classic 12oz 6 pack
Swirl a big spoon into the broth right before eating. It cools the heat and makes the soup creamy without actually adding cream to the pot. Non-negotiable in my house.
Daisy Pure & Natural Sour Cream, 8.0 oz
Toss a handful on while the soup is still screaming hot. It melts into these stretchy little ribbons. My kids eat the cheese strings first and then accidentally eat the soup.
Kraft Cheese, 4 Cheese Mexican Style Blend
Slice one thin and fan it across the top. Sounds fancy but takes 30 seconds. The cool creaminess against the hot spicy broth is the contrast that keeps me making this every week.
How much and how often to water avocado trees in California
Fresh Ingredients Worth the Extra Minute
Most of this recipe is dump and forget, but three minutes of chopping fresh stuff takes it from good to the thing your coworkers ask you to bring to every potluck.
Dice one roughly and toss it in at the start. It practically dissolves after 8 hours. Don't bother being precise, nobody will see the pieces. Just get it in the pot.
Fresh Whole Yellow Onion, Each
Tear off a big handful and throw it on each bowl right before eating. Cooking it kills the flavor. If you're a cilantro hater, flat leaf parsley works in a pinch.
Fresh Whole Green Cilantro Bunch, 1 Bunch, Fresh Produce
Squeeze half a lime into each bowl at the table. This single step is the difference between homemade and restaurant-quality. I go through a bag a week during soup season.
Cat Lime Wash Murah & Terbaik
Slice thin and drop a few rings into your bowl for fresh heat. The slow cooker mellows everything, so raw jalapeno on top brings the kick back. Wear gloves if you wear contacts.
Marketside Classic Iceberg Salad, 24 oz Bag (Fresh)
Dice a couple and add them in the last hour of cooking. They keep a little crunch and add sweetness. Great for anyone who finds the soup too smoky on its own.
Customer reviews for Marketside Mini Sweet Peppers, 16 oz
Sides That Round Out the Meal
Sometimes soup alone doesn't cut it, especially if you've got teenagers who eat like they're training for the Olympics. These sides turn soup night into a full spread.
Warm two in a dry skillet for 30 seconds each side. Tear off pieces and dunk them. This is how my grandmother ate every soup and I will not be changing the tradition.
Mission Carb Balance Flour Tortillas, Soft Taco Size, 8 Count
Whip up a batch while the soup does its thing. Takes 20 minutes and fills the house with a second layer of incredible smell. Cornbread plus tortilla soup is an undefeated combo.
Jiffy Cornbread Waffles -- so EASY!
Grab this from the deli section when you're too tired to make a side from scratch. The elote flavors go perfectly with the soup. Zero prep, maximum complement.
Taylor Farms Mexican Style Street Corn Salad Kit
Pour some into a bowl for scooping and dipping. Cheaper than restaurant chips and honestly crunchier. My family goes through a bag per soup night, no exaggeration.
Calidad Yellow Corn Tortilla Chips, 11 Ounce Bag
Microwave one and dump it into the bottom of the bowl before ladling soup over it. Makes it hearty enough that even my husband stops asking what else is for dinner.
Customer reviews for (8 pack) Minute White Rice
Storage for Leftovers and Meal Prep
This recipe makes a mountain of soup. Without proper storage, you're either wasting food or playing Tetris with mismatched lids every Sunday. Ask me how I know.
Use these for fridge leftovers. They seal tight enough that the cumin smell doesn't take over everything else in there. Learned the hard way with cheap containers and a traumatized cheesecake.
Rubbermaid Brilliance Plastic Food Storage Container
Fill these with soup, leave an inch of headspace, and freeze them. They stack neatly and you can see exactly what's inside. I prep four jars every Sunday for work lunches.
Ball, Glass Mason Jar, 32 Oz. Quart, Regular Mouth 12-Count
Line the pot before you start cooking. When the soup is done, lift and toss. No scrubbing baked-on tomato at 9pm. This alone made me a weekly slow cooker person.
Reynolds Kitchens, Slow Cooker Liners, Fits 3-8 Qt, 21" Clear
Stretch this over bowls when you don't feel like dirtying a container. It grips better than regular plastic wrap, which used to slide off and leave my soup exposed to fridge air.
Glad Press'N Seal Multipurpose Food Wrap, Clear
Pour soup in, freeze it into perfect blocks, then pop them out and bag them. Each cube is exactly one lunch portion. Whoever invented these understands meal prep on a spiritual level.
Customer reviews for Souper Cubes 1/2 Cup Silicone
Drinks That Go With Tortilla Soup
Spent a weird amount of time figuring out what to drink alongside this soup. Water is fine but the right pairing turns Tuesday dinner into something you actually look forward to all day.
Pour a cold glass alongside a hot bowl of soup. The fizz cuts through the richness and the mineral bite pairs weirdly well with cumin. Way better than flat water here.
Topo Chico, Sparkling Mineral Water, 12 fl oz Glass Bottles
Crack one open if you want something sweet to contrast the spice. The lime flavor echoes the squeeze you already put in the soup. My go-to when I want to treat myself on a weeknight.
(6 pack) Jarritos Lime Soda, 12.5 fl oz (370 ml) Glass Bottle
Keep a bottle in the fridge for soup nights. Sweet tea with spicy soup is a Southern move that just works. If you haven't tried it, this is your sign.
Gold Peak Black Sweet Tea Bottle, 52 fl oz
Pour a glass if you're making this for date night at home. The acidity matches the tomato base perfectly. Sounds fancy but it's boxed wine and slow cooker soup, let's be real.
Bota Box Sauvignon Blanc Wine, 3.0 L
Grab a six-pack for the weekend version of soup night. A cold lager with hot tortilla soup is the Friday evening reset I didn't know I needed until last winter.
Modelo Especial Mexican Lager Beer, 12pk 12 fl. oz.