Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Slow Cooker Mac and Cheese That Made Me the Potluck Hero
48
items Every potluck used to stress me out. I'd show up with something forgettable, watch it sit untouched, and drive home with a full dish. Then I nailed slow cooker mac and cheese and suddenly every parent wanted my recipe. This list covers everything fro...
Sections
12
Slow Cookers Built for Creamy Mac and Cheese
Pasta Shapes That Hold Cheese in Every Bite
Cheeses That Actually Melt Smooth
Dairy That Makes the Sauce Silky
Seasonings That Take It Past Basic
Mix-Ins That Kids Actually Eat
Slow Cookers Built for Creamy Mac and Cheese
Not all slow cookers heat evenly, and hot spots will scorch your cheese sauce faster than you think. Learned that the hard way with a $15 cooker that left me scraping burnt pasta off the bottom.
Grab this if you're feeding more than six people. The oval shape fits elbow macaroni without cramming, and the removable stoneware means cleanup takes about two minutes. I brought this to a block party and came home with an empty pot for the first ti...
Crock-Pot Manual 7-Quart Slow Cooker, Black
Use the locking lid for transport. Before I had this, I lost half my cheese sauce on the backseat of my car driving to a school fundraiser. The clip-tight lid solved that problem permanently and I haven't cleaned a cheese spill since.
Hamilton Beach 6 Qt Slow Cooker, Stoneware Crock
Switch to this if you need the timer function. Set it before work, come home, stir in your cheese, and you're out the door to the potluck. Saved me on a Wednesday night when I forgot about a church supper until 3 PM.
Crock-Pot® Design Series 7-Quart Cook-and-Carry
Keep this around for the nights you forgot to start the slow cooker. Pressure cook the pasta in 4 minutes, stir in cheese, switch to slow cook to keep warm. Pulled off mac and cheese in 20 minutes flat for my kid's birthday.
Instant Pot, Pressure Cooker, 6 Qt
Pasta Shapes That Hold Cheese in Every Bite
Spaghetti noodles in mac and cheese is a crime. The right shape catches sauce in every curve, and kids actually eat faster because every bite tastes loaded.
Toss these in and they hold up in the slow cooker for hours without turning to mush. I've tried fancy shapes but my 7-year-old literally picks out anything that isn't an elbow, so here we are.
Barilla Classic Elbows Pasta, Non-GMO
Snag this for a budget batch. Bigger tubes mean more cheese trapped inside each noodle. When I made a double batch for my daughter's soccer team, 22 kids cleared the entire crockpot in under 15 minutes.
Great Value Elbows, 16 oz
Try these corkscrew shapes if you want adults to actually be impressed. The spirals grab cheese sauce like nothing else. Brought this version to a work potluck and three coworkers texted me for the recipe the next morning.
(12 pack) Barilla Gluten Free Spaghetti Pasta, 12 oz
Swap in these thick tubes when you want something between elbows and corkscrews. They're sturdy enough to survive 4 hours on low without falling apart, which is exactly what happened at my Thanksgiving side dish attempt.
Great Value Penne Pasta, 16 oz
Cheeses That Actually Melt Smooth
Pre-shredded cheese has anti-caking powder that makes sauces grainy. Took me three failed batches to figure that out. Block cheese, freshly shredded, is the whole secret.
Use a chunk of this as your base layer. It melts into liquid gold and gives you that smooth, diner-style texture kids go crazy for. My nephew once told me my mac and cheese tastes better than the box kind, and this is why.
Velveeta, Cheese Product, 32 oz Block
Shred this yourself. The sharp flavor cuts through the richness so it doesn't taste flat. Before I added sharp cheddar, every batch was just bland and gooey. Now adults actually go back for seconds too.
Cracker Barrel Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese
Grab the big block if you're making a double batch. Mild cheddar keeps picky eaters happy because there's no bite. For a classroom party where 25 kids need to approve, this is your safest bet.
Great Value Mild Cheddar Block Cheese, 32 oz Chunk
Toss this in during the last 30 minutes for a flavor twist. Yes I know I just said don't use pre-shredded, but Colby Jack is the one exception where the convenience wins. Adds a slight tang that makes people ask what your secret ingredient is.
Sargento® Colby-Jack Sliced Cheese, 11 slices
Dairy That Makes the Sauce Silky
Water plus cheese equals a clumpy mess. You need fat to carry the flavor and keep everything creamy. Learned this after watching my first attempt separate into greasy orange soup.
Use unsalted so you control the salt level. Two tablespoons melted into the bottom of the crockpot before anything else goes in. Switched from salted to unsalted after one batch came out so salty my husband couldn't finish a bowl.
Land O'Lakes Unsalted Butter, 8 Half Sticks, 1 lb Pack
Pour in whole milk, not skim. The fat content is what keeps your sauce from breaking. Tried 2% once and the sauce was thin and sad. Whole milk gives you that thick, coat-the-spoon consistency every time.
Great Value Milk Whole Vitamin D, Half Gallon, 64 fl oz
Stir in half a cup right before serving. This is the trick that makes people think you added something fancy. A neighbor literally guessed truffle oil. Nope, just sour cream. Adds tang and makes the texture almost restaurant quality.
Daisy Pure and Natural Sour Cream, 16 oz Tub, ...
Drop a brick of this in while the pasta cooks. It melts down and thickens everything without making it heavy. Discovered this by accident when I ran out of Velveeta and had to improvise. Turned out even better.
Philadelphia, Whipped Cream Cheese Spread, 8 oz tub
Seasonings That Take It Past Basic
Plain mac and cheese tastes like cafeteria food. A few shakes of the right spices and suddenly it tastes like something you'd order at a restaurant, not scrape off a school lunch tray.
Shake in half a teaspoon. You won't taste mustard, but you'll notice the cheese flavor gets sharper and more complex. My sister couldn't figure out why hers always tasted flat until I told her this one trick.
McCormick Kosher Ground Mustard, 1.75 oz Bottle
Toss in a full teaspoon. Garlic powder dissolves right into the sauce and adds depth without chunks. Started adding this after eating mac and cheese at a BBQ joint in Texas and realizing mine was missing something obvious.
McCormick Kosher Garlic Powder, 3.12 oz Bottle
Sprinkle this on top before serving for color and a tiny bit of smokiness. People eat with their eyes first, and a dusting of paprika makes your crockpot mac look like it came from a food blog instead of your minivan.
McCormick Kosher Paprika, 2.12 oz Bottle
Season in layers, not all at once. Add a pinch when the pasta goes in, another when the cheese melts, and taste before serving. Over-salted one batch for a baby shower and learned that lesson publicly.
Morton All-Purpose Iodized Sea Salt, Fine Sea Salt, 26 oz
Mix-Ins That Kids Actually Eat
Tried adding truffle oil once. My kids looked at me like I'd betrayed them. These mix-ins are parent-tested and approved by the pickiest eaters at three different elementary schools.
Stir these in during the last 20 minutes. Bacon plus mac and cheese is the combo that got my 5-year-old to stop asking for chicken nuggets at every single gathering. The crunch holds up even in a slow cooker.
Hormel, Real Bacon Bits, 3 oz Plastic Jar, Salad Topping
Pile these on top right before you serve. They add crunch that contrasts with all that creamy cheese. Brought this version to Thanksgiving and my father-in-law, who hates everything, asked me to make it again for Christmas.
French's Kosher Original Crispy Fried Onions, 6.0 oz Can
Crush a sleeve and scatter on top for a buttery crumb layer. Way easier than making breadcrumbs from scratch and kids think it's fun. My daughter now insists on crushing them herself, which honestly keeps her busy while I finish cooking.
RITZ, Crackers, Original, 14 oz, Tasty Snack for Kids
Sprinkle a thick layer on top and prop the lid open for the last 30 minutes so they crisp up. Figured this out after watching a YouTube video at midnight before a potluck. Woke up feeling like a genius and it actually worked.
Great Value Plain Bread Crumbs, 15 oz
Serving Tools That Survive a Potluck
Flimsy plastic spoons snap the second you hit thick mac and cheese. Showed up to a cookout once with no serving spoon at all and had to use a coffee mug. Never again.
Keep this in your potluck bag. The bamboo won't scratch your crockpot insert and the slots let excess liquid drain so each scoop is thick and cheesy, not soupy. Replaced my old metal spoon after it scratched up two stoneware inserts.
Kitchenaid Bamboo 2-Piece Spoon and Short Turner
Grab this if you prefer something lighter. The nylon is heat resistant so it won't melt if you leave it sitting in the pot, which I definitely did at a Fourth of July party while chasing my toddler around the yard.
OXO Good Grips Nylon Slotted Spoon,Black
Transfer a portion into this for oven browning if you want that crispy top. Also works as a backup serving dish when the crockpot is too heavy to carry. Saved me at a Super Bowl party when the host ran out of table space.
Pyrex® Easy Grab® 3-quart Glass Baking Dish with Red Lid
Bring extras of these because people will ask for leftovers. Seriously. Pack four or five in your bag. A coworker once brought me her own Tupperware the next day and asked me to fill it. These are cheap enough to not worry about getting them back.
Rubbermaid, Food Storage Container, 1 Gallon
Transport Gear So Nothing Spills
Hot mac and cheese in the backseat of a car is a disaster waiting to happen. After one catastrophic spill on leather seats, I invested in proper transport gear and haven't lost a drop since.
Zip the whole crockpot inside this and carry it like a duffel bag. Insulated walls keep everything hot for over an hour. Walked into a potluck with this and someone asked if I was carrying a bowling ball. Worth the weird looks.
Hamilton Beach Crock Caddy, Insulated Slow Cooker Bag
Use this if you have a Crock-Pot brand cooker. Fits snug and has a strap so your hands stay free. Carried it through a parking lot in the rain once and the mac and cheese arrived perfect while I arrived soaked.
Hamilton Beach Crock Caddy, Insulated Slow Cooker Bag
Lay this in your trunk so the crockpot doesn't slide around on turns. Before I had this, every right turn was a prayer. Now the pot stays put even when I brake hard because someone cut me off.
Customer reviews for GORILLA GRIP Patented Bath Tub
Press a sheet tight over the top before putting the lid on. Double barrier against splashes. Learned this from my grandmother who transported potato salad to every family reunion for 30 years without a single spill.
Great Value Heavy Duty Aluminum Foil, 75 sq ft
Cleanup Supplies for After the Potluck
Burnt cheese on stoneware is brutal. Spent 45 minutes scrubbing after my first slow cooker mac attempt and almost gave up the hobby entirely. These make it painless.
Drop one of these in before you start cooking and cleanup is literally lifting out a bag and tossing it. No scrubbing, no soaking overnight. Wish someone had told me about these before I destroyed a sponge trying to scrub cheddar cement off my pot.
Reynolds Kitchens Slow Cooker Liners
Keep these under the sink for the times you forget a liner. They're tough enough for baked-on cheese but won't scratch the stoneware surface. Went through three generic sponges before finding one that didn't fall apart mid-scrub.
Scotch-Brite, Cleaning Sponges, Blue
Squirt this directly on the burnt spots and let it sit for 10 minutes before you even touch a sponge. Cuts through cheese grease faster than anything else I've tried, and I've tried at least six different dish soaps.
Dawn Platinum Dish Soap and Powerwash
Pull this out for the really stubborn rings that Dawn can't handle. A coworker recommended it after I complained about a cheese stain that survived three wash cycles. One application and the stoneware looked brand new.
Bar Keepers Friend Soft Cleanser, Citrus, 26 oz
Side Dishes That Pair With Mac and Cheese
Showing up with mac and cheese AND a side makes you look like you planned ahead, even if you threw the side together in five minutes in the car. Perception is everything at potlucks.
Bring this with a bag of baby carrots and suddenly you're the person who brought a balanced meal. Takes zero effort and parents at school events will actually thank you for including something green alongside the cheese.
Marzetti Ranch Veggie Dip, 12 oz.
Set this next to the mac and cheese for people who like a drizzle of BBQ on top. Sounds weird but try it once. A friend did this at a cookout and now half the group does it every time. Sweet and smoky with cheesy pasta just works.
Sweet Baby Ray's® Original Barbecue Sauce 18 oz
Toss this together in the bag while the mac heats. Dump it in a bowl and nobody knows it took 90 seconds. Brought this to a work lunch and someone complimented my homemade Caesar dressing. Smiled and said thank you.
Marketside Caesar Salad Kit, 14.55 oz Bag (Fresh)
Tear these open and pile them in a basket next to your crockpot. Soft sweet bread with salty cheese is the combo that disappears first at every potluck. Bought three packs for a neighborhood cookout and still ran out.
King's Hawaiian Original Hawaiian Sweet Rolls 12 Count
Drinks That Go With a Cheesy Potluck Spread
Nobody thinks about what to drink with mac and cheese, but the right pairing makes a difference. Brought lemonade to a summer potluck on a whim and people kept refilling their cups between bites.
Pour this over ice next to your mac station. The tartness cuts through all that cheese and resets your palate between bites. My kids drink this stuff like water anyway, so it doubles as crowd control while I set up the food.
Simply Lemonade Raspberry All Natural 52oz
Bring this for the Southern crowd or anyone who thinks sweet tea goes with everything. Spoiler: it does. Set out a jug at a family reunion in July and it was gone before the mac and cheese was.
Gold Peak Black Sweet Tea Bottle, 52 fl oz
Crack this open for holiday potlucks when you want something festive without alcohol. Kids love the fancy bottle and adults appreciate not having to explain why they're not drinking. Win-win at Thanksgiving gatherings.
Martinelli's Sparkling Apple Cider, 25.4 fl oz, Glass Bottle
Grab a four-pack for the adults who want something fizzy without sugar. The bubbles cleanse your palate between cheesy bites better than flat water. Started bringing these after a coworker introduced me to them at a taco night.
Topo Chico, Sparkling Mineral Water, 12 fl oz Glass Bottles
Containers for Sending Leftovers Home
When people ask for your recipe, hand them leftovers instead. They'll remember you forever. Having containers ready means you don't lose your good Tupperware to people who never return things.
Toss a stack of these in your potluck bag. They're cheap enough that you won't chase anyone down for them. Sent leftover mac home with five families after a school event and got zero containers back. Didn't even care.
Gladware Family Variety Pack Containers 12ct
Use these when you run out of containers. Scoop mac into a bag, squeeze out the air, and hand it over. A dad at soccer practice looked confused when I handed him a Ziploc of mac and cheese, but he texted me later saying his kids loved it.
Hefty Press to Close Gallon Freezer Bags, 40 Count
Keep a few of these in the car for overflow. When the crockpot is almost empty, scrape the rest into a foil pan and cover with foil. Gave one to my neighbor after a block party and she reheated it the next day for her kids' lunch.
Great Value Aluminum Pans with Board Lids, 8 in x 8
Portion individual servings into these for a cute presentation. Brought jarred mac and cheese to a bake sale as a savory option and sold out before the brownies. People kept the jars too, which honestly made me happier than the sales.
Mainstays Mason Jars 16 oz Regular Mouth 12 Pack