Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

The Eyeliner to put on my corpse

Purple Star emoji 12 items
My list of recommended eyeliners. From liquid to gel, pencil, etc.
Sections
5
 
 
 
 
 

Liquid

Liquids tend to be more pigmented, but it does take a little skill. Practice makes perfect.

 
Boheemse bo profile picture
Pretty good. Still there after waking up from a hangover. Brush on the thinner side. On the pricey side.
Stay All Day ® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
 
Boheemse bo profile picture
Very accessible. Something you can find at your local beauty supply. That cap may break off and cause it to dry up though. Luck of the draw there.
Breakup Proof Collection
 
Boheemse bo profile picture
Excellent formula. Thin brush, A steady hand is mandatory. It will last, don't rub your eye though.
Eye Booster Waterproof Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner | Blackest Black
 
Boheemse bo profile picture
This one will last a while. I've had a hard time getting it off. A few friends complained that it smudges (like how an old tattoo looks). Full disclosure I have dry skin, so oils can be playing a part here.
Brush Tip Illustrative Eyeliner
 
Boheemse bo profile picture
Very fine and precise tip. Steady hand needed. May not be as easily accessible as it is an Asian beauty product.
Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner Super Keep

Creamy

For someone who prefers applying eyeliner with an angle brush

 
Boheemse bo profile picture
Even though Gel is in the name, I'd say the texture is relatively creamy. I use my pinkie and apply this to my bottom waterline. Very pigmented. be mindful of how much product your brush picks up.
AMC Eyeliner Gel 77

Pencil

hell if you've been using a pencil all your life. Don't fix whats not broken

 
Boheemse bo profile picture
I use most of my pencil eyeliner on my bottom waterline, this one included. Good formula, doesn't irritate the eyes. I'll say it last most of the night
Stay Put® Eyeliner
 
Boheemse bo profile picture
Probably the cheapest one on this list. Me in the mirror: I love this eyeliner. it glides on so nicely, its pigmented, the color is cute-…..did it just break.
Ultimate Intense Stay Auto Eyeliner
 
Boheemse bo profile picture
Get your sharpener ladies! They have a good line of neutral colors and is a very versatile pencil. Can be used for brows, eyes, or lips. As any other pencil eyeliner I used this on my waterline, but also have the rose nude for lip combos.
ARTIST COLOR PENCIL Brow, Eye & Lip Liner

Powder

For those who want to use an eyeshadow pallet 

 
Boheemse bo profile picture
If you prefer powdered makeup and a more matte look then you can take any black eyeshadow and apply it as eyeliner with an angle brush. This is just the one I so happen to have and use sometimes.
My Dream Eyeshadow Palette
placeholder

Color

 
Boheemse bo profile picture
Their pastels are so cute! This is a fun one.
JOAH Line Up Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen
 
Boheemse bo profile picture
The name says it all. Colour definitely does *pop*. This stuff is pigmented. Easy to glide on and amazing if you want your lower line to stick out.
Colourpop Gel Liner Punch - Canary Yellow