Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

The Creamiest + Dreamiest Lip Liners for that “Who is She?” Energy

Purple Star emoji 16 items
If you’re hunting for the perfect lip liner that glides on like a dream and instantly levels up your whole look, you’re in the right place. These are my absolute favorite lip liners — creamy, flattering, and guaranteed to have strangers doing a doubl...
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
This is, and will FOREVER, be my absolutely favorite lip liner of ALL time, for a natural looking overline. Something about the shade is so natural and it blends in beautifully. And idk if it’s meant to be but it is waterproof in my experience. And y...
Pillow Talk - Lip Cheat - Nude Pink Lip Liner Pencil
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
MCO beauty has a rendition of the CT pillow talk and just like all of mco beauty’s other products, it is very comparable to the original. This brand blows me away more with each product release
Lip Liner
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
These are the creamiest and most affordable lip liners to ever exist I think they’re $2 EACH?! Mine are down to little nubs I love the nude pink and dark mocha brown shades
Lips - elf : Lip Liners & Pencils
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
These are SO cool. Literally they’re cooling to the lips and slightly plumping. For a your lips but even better vibe
Lippie Pencil
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
THESE have been the lip liners I reach for for over two years now. I stumbled upon them at Ulta one day and it was over for every other lip liner out there I have all the shades and they’re all soooo good by themselves or under a nice juicy lip oil O...
Soulmatte Filling Gel Lip Liner - My Boo
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
These have totally killed it the shade range is massive I am obsessed with all the nude pinks and they’ve helped me explore darker shades than ever before because they’re so flattering. Excellent for over lining and they are super highly pigmented. D...
Maybelline Lifter Liner Lip Liner Pencil With Hyaluronic Acid - 0.04oz
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
These have been a go to of mine for a while now. They aren’t THE creamiest option, however, they do have good shades and they’re do have good staying power. Great for lining not necessarily for filling in your entire lips
Nyx Professional Makeup Suede Matte Velvet Smooth Lip Liner - Vegan Formula
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
Shades 03 and 04 in the PENCILS I have been using for longer than I can remember..the formula has never changed and I am so thankful for that!
Lip Liners & Lip Pencils
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
THESE. I’m sorry, if you haven’t tried them WHAT are you doing? I don’t mean to be rude but they’re GORGEOUS, they last forever, and they’re funsies!! They’re only $12 each regular price but tiktokshop runs deals on them alllll the time! If you want ...
Lip Liner STAY-N® - Peel-off Lip Liner Stain
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
These are just like the sacheau beauty lip liner stains. These are my second favorite, but it might be because I like the shades in the sacheau version better. This option does last just as long and they have a lot of shades to try that are bright an...
WONDER BLADING Peel & Reveal Lip Stain Kit - WONDERSKIN
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
Yep, these are the ones tswift put on the map. I love everything pat McGrath labs I think she’s a genius in makeup
PermaGel Ultra Lip Pencil
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
Creamy, dreamy, smooth-and mature skin approved! (Like ALL merit products)
Lip Liner - Makeup
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
This one’s on the pricier end for what I like to spend, but it really does sculpt you a new pair of kissers!
REFY Lip Sculpt | Transfer-Proof Lip Liner For All Day Wear
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
The OG! I love these for a cute 90’s inspired lip combo with a dark lip line and a super light lipstick
MAC Lip Pencil | Whirl, Nightmoth, Cork, Chestnut & Spice Lip Liners
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
Shade range is impressive and formula and quality are pristine as always with miss ABH. These are forever a go to I love what she does with nude pinks!
Lip Liner
 
Caitlin Thompson profile picture
NARS is often slept on but their products are bomb. This is creamy and highly pigmented thank me later!
Highly Pigmented Precision Lip Liner Pencil