Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found Colored Eyeliners That Fixed My Boring Everyday Makeup
30
items Same brown eyeshadow, same black wing, same face staring back at me every morning. If your makeup routine has been on autopilot for months and you keep scrolling past colorful eye looks thinking “I could never pull that off,” this list is the reality...
Sections
5
Colored Eyeliners That Actually Show Up on Darker Skin
Liquid Liners for Sharp Colorful Wings
Smudge-Friendly Colors for a Smoky Eye Without Black
Glitter and Metallic Liners for Nights Out
Setting Products That Keep Colored Liner From Fading
Colored Eyeliners That Actually Show Up on Darker Skin
I wasted so much money on liners that looked bold in the tube and then vanished on my eyelid. These are the ones that showed up on the first swipe and stayed put through a full workday.
Grab this purple if you've been stuck in a black liner rut for years. I wore it to a Monday morning meeting and got three compliments before lunch. The creamy formula doesn't tug at all.
Psychedelic Sister 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Use this forest green along your lower lash line for a subtle pop that doesn't scream “I'm trying too hard.” Perfect for anyone who wants color but works in a conservative office. It survived a rainy commute without budging.
AQUA RESIST COLOR PENCIL 24HR waterproof eyeliner
Switch to this navy if true blue feels too intense for you. I layered it over black shadow and my eyes looked like they had actual depth for once. For anyone who photographs a lot, this one pops on camera.
Nars High Pigment Longwear Eyeliner
Try this electric cobalt on a Saturday when you want your eyes to do all the talking. I paired it with bare lips and simple gold hoops. The pigment is so rich it almost looks wet on the lid.
PAT McGRATH LABS PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil
Keep this in your bag for after-work plans. One line on the upper lid and suddenly you look like you went home and redid your whole face. The twist-up saves you from carrying a sharpener everywhere.
Too Faced Killer Liner 36 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
Snag this if you're testing the colored liner waters but don't want to spend $30 on something you might hate. I used it as a base color under darker shades and it held everything in place all day.
12HR Colorful Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner - Sephora
Liquid Liners for Sharp Colorful Wings
Pencils are great for smudgy looks, but when I wanted a clean colored wing, I needed liquid formulas that didn't skip or feather. These are the ones that let me draw a wing on the first try.
Pair this with a simple nude eye and watch people lose it. The felt tip is firm enough to get a sharp point but flexible enough that shaky hands won't ruin everything. I did a green wing for St. Patrick's Day and then just never stopped wearing it.
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liners-Emerald
Toss your fear of pink liner in the trash. This hot pink looked surprisingly wearable when I kept the wing thin and tight to the lash line. For anyone who thinks pink is “too much,” a thin line changes everything.
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Wear Liner Stick in Fucsia
Use this if you want a wing that leans more burgundy than purple. I wore it on a first date and it gave my whole face a warm, interesting vibe without any effort beyond the liner itself.
Plum Luxury Liner Eye Pencil eyeliner Mary Kay Waterproof Long-lasting Glides on smoothly Full size 5" long Twist-up slowly InonasCosmetics
Swap your black liquid liner for this warm brown and see how much softer your whole face looks. I started doing this on low-key days and honestly might never go back to black for daytime. The brush tip is incredibly precise.
Brown Perfect Strokes Matte Liquid Liner - Rare Beauty
Get this tangerine orange if you want the one color nobody else at brunch will be wearing. I was skeptical but it made my brown eyes look almost golden. Sharpen it to a fine point for a thin, clean line.
Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Flypencil Longwear Pencil
Try this deep olive when you want color that reads as “chic” not “costume.” My mom, who wears nothing but neutrals, borrowed this and immediately bought her own. It lasts through watery eyes and long days.
Lancôme Le Stylo Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil
Smudge-Friendly Colors for a Smoky Eye Without Black
Black smoky eyes started looking harsh on me somewhere around age 30. Colored smudgy liners gave me that same sultry vibe without aging me or looking like I was headed to a concert.
Grab this dusty pink-brown and smudge it along both lash lines. It gives you that “I woke up like this but hotter” energy. For anyone who wants a smoky eye at the office without getting side-eyed by HR, this is your answer.
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Eyeliner Pencil (Women)
Use the built-in smudger on this deep wine shade and you'll get the moodiest, prettiest eye in about 45 seconds. I did this look for a dinner party and someone asked if I'd gotten my makeup done professionally.
25+ Marc Jacobs Products Eyeliners for sale
Keep this rich reddish brown in rotation for fall and winter. Smudge it out with your finger (yes, really) and it blends like a cream shadow. Looks incredible on anyone with warm undertones who's tired of the same taupe.
Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil MAHOGANY 2 **read
Swipe this chunky crayon across your lid, blend with a fingertip, done. The whole look takes under two minutes and I've gotten more compliments from this lazy method than from any tutorial I've ever followed.
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Shade Plum Full Size New
Try this deep aubergine when you want drama without commitment. It starts creamy so you have about 30 seconds to smudge before it sets, which is plenty of time even if you're doing this in a car mirror.
Nars High Pigment Longwear Eyeliner MAMBO
Swap your standard dark brown for this richer, more saturated version. The twist-up design means no sharpening, and the built-in sponge tip makes blending foolproof. Perfect for rushed mornings when you want to look polished in under a minute.
Makeup | Clinique 3 Intense Chocolate Quickliner For Eyes
Glitter and Metallic Liners for Nights Out
Sometimes a matte colored line isn't enough and you want your eyelids to catch light from across the room. These metallic and glitter liners are the ones that survived dancing, sweating, and questionable late-night food runs.
Bring this champagne glitter pencil to any holiday party. I lined my waterline and inner corners with it and looked instantly awake after a 10-hour workday. The glitter doesn't migrate under your eyes, which is rare.
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Ditch the idea that glitter is just for teenagers. I'm 34 and I line my upper lash line with this silver and it looks sophisticated, not juvenile. One coat, no fallout, lasts until 2 AM.
Stila Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow Diamond Dust
Peel-off glitter liner sounds gimmicky but it actually works. No flaking onto your cheeks, no scrubbing with remover at midnight. For anyone who loves glitter but hates the cleanup, this solves that exact problem.
Too Faced Glitter POP! Glitter Peel-Off Eyeliner
Try this shimmery bronze for a New Year's Eve look that doesn't require an art degree. I drew a thick line, skipped eyeshadow entirely, and it was enough. The metallic finish catches light without being over the top.
NARS High-Pigment Longwear Eyeliner - Park Avenue
Get this rose gold pencil for wedding guest makeup or date nights. It's warm enough to complement most skin tones and the shimmer is fine, not chunky. I wore it to three weddings last summer and it held up through every single one.
Fenty Beauty Cute Ting Flypencil Longwear Eyeliner
Use this black with gold glitter flecks when you want to feel like you're starring in a music video. The sparkle is visible but controlled. I wore it to a concert and it looked exactly the same in the bathroom mirror six hours later.
PAT McGRATH LABS PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil
Setting Products That Keep Colored Liner From Fading
Nothing is more frustrating than spending time on a colorful eye look and watching it disappear by noon. I learned the hard way that colored liners need a little extra help staying vibrant, and these products are what finally made them last.
Spray this over your finished eye look and close your eyes for ten seconds. The difference is noticeable by hour four when your liner still looks freshly applied. Stock up before summer because humidity will test every product you own.
All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray
Swipe this on your lids before any colored liner and watch the pigment intensity double. I skipped it once thinking it didn't matter and my teal liner turned into a sad gray-green by lunchtime. Never again.
NARS Pro-Prime Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base
Use this under pencil liners especially. It gives them something to grip onto so they don't slide into your crease. For anyone with oily lids who's given up on liner lasting past 3 PM, this is the missing step.
Too Faced Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eyeshadow Primer
Try this if other primers feel too drying on your lids. It has a tacky finish that locks liner in place without making your skin feel tight or flaky. I switched from a matte primer and my liner looked better AND my lids felt better.
Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Eye Primer w/ Hyaluronic Acid
Keep this on your vanity for a final mist over everything. It doesn't disturb your liner or make shimmer move around. The mist is super fine so it won't drench your face or make you feel sticky.
Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray: Long-lasting
Grab this for outdoor events where you know you'll be sweating. I wore a cobalt wing to an outdoor wedding in July and it looked perfect in every photo. The spray dries down matte so it won't add unwanted shine to your lids.
Secure the Blur Makeup Magnet Primer Travel-Sized