16
items 
Last year a cheap inflatable ghost deflated by October 3rd and my six-year-old cried about it for two days. These are the outdoor pieces that held up through rain, wind, and a toddler who body-slammed everything in the yard.













My kids want to touch everything. Breakable decorations lasted exactly one afternoon before I gave up. These are the pieces that sit on shelves, tables, and mantels without me hovering like a nervous wreck.













Finding the sweet spot between creepy and toddler-friendly took me three Halloweens. Too scary and my youngest wouldn't go upstairs. Too tame and my oldest rolled his eyes. These hit right in the middle.













Bought a costume online once that my daughter refused to put on because it was itchy. Forty bucks gone. Now I only pick things they've tested or that come in soft fabrics, and I always grab accessories they can reuse for dress-up year round.










