Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Sign up for free
Discover
Login
Baseball Stocking Stuffers
56 items
By
CatchersMomsRDifferent
It is so hard to find the right mix of cute stuff that doesn’t just become clutter after Christmas. Here are some ideas for baseball players.
Sections
9
Baseball Cards
Hygiene
Snacks
Toys
Gear
Books
Baseball Cards
Christmas collectors sets
Buy them early they go quick here are 2025 ones at Target. Make sure not to get the 2024 ones.
2025 Topps MLB Holiday Baseball Trading Card Tin
Not quite in the stocking unless you have big ones but great all the same
2025 Topps MLB Holiday Baseball Trading Card Mega Box
Dicks stores have them if out online elsewhere
2025 Topps Holiday Baseball Collectors Tin
Full set
2025 Topps Holiday Baseball Collector Tins 3-Pack
Hygiene
Elves need to stay clean too
ELF Ninny Scrubbins 3-Pack
Holiday hygiene
LIMITED EDITION Ballboyz Christmas Pack
Love these kits as an intro to products
Squatch Stocking Stuffers
My oldest loves this brand
Premier Face & Body Kit for Tweens and Teens
I love these for trips
Travel-Size Face & Body Set for Tweens and Teens
CatchersMomsRDifferent
2Toms SportShield, Anti-Chafe Stick for Chafing Prevention, 1.5 Ounce Bottle HSA/FSA Eligible - Walmart.com
Great for hotels for travel players
Hanging Travel Toiletry Bag Baseball Pattern
CatchersMomsRDifferent
Personalized Embroidered Toiletry Bag for Men
Good starter tween/teen boy set
Viking Revolution Hair Styling Kit for Men
CatchersMomsRDifferent
Every Man Jack Spider-Man Body Set - Marvel Gift
Good intro to face care
JB SKRUB Face Kit – Pimple Patches & Wash
CatchersMomsRDifferent
Fresh Kidz Hair & Body Wash 16.9oz + 2 Roll On Deodorants Boys Red
CatchersMomsRDifferent
Hair Styling Powder - Buy 6 Get 10 - Black Friday Exclusive Deal
For when they wear a cup
Happy Nuts Comfort Powder
Snacks
Baseball theme snacks
Classic in holiday colors
Dubble Bubble Christmas Home Run Bat Gum - 4.5oz
Not sugary and a great on trend snack
Jack Link’s MrBeast Turkey Mini Sticks 12ct
Minty Christmas Freshness
Big League Chew - Pickoff Peppermint
Stocking stuffer ready
Big League Chew Christmas Bubble Gum & Activity Gift
For the sour fans
Big League Chew Sour Gumballs – 3 oz.
Toys
Busy minds and fast handed players love these mind games
Rubik's Cube Original 3x3 Brain Teaser
Same great ball just easier not to lose
Bounceback x Moon Ball
My kids loved this
Atlanta Braves Truist Park Mini BRXLZ Stadium
Fun collection of graphics
Junk Ball Wild Pitch Collectible Balls
CatchersMomsRDifferent
Foosbots Single Series 3 - Best Active Play for Ages 6 to 12
CatchersMomsRDifferent
Atomix Game
CatchersMomsRDifferent
Hasbro Gaming Rebounce Board Games
Stress ball type toy
Dippin’ Dots Scented Squishi Squeeze Toy
Gear
Cute set for the holidays
Nike Boys' Holiday Poly Boxer Briefs - 5 Pack
A gift for mom disguised for them…
Sneaker Balls Odor-Fighting Shoe Fresheners, 2 Pack
Especially if they get a new glove
Glove Break-In Kit
Great for the seeds lover
Seed Sack for Sunflower Seeds - The Classic
So their necklaces aren’t all over the house
VITASY Wooden Baseball Softball Ring Display
Grinchy sliding mitt
Rawlings Youth Happy Holidays Sliding Mitt
Awesome selection of junk bands in all the right colors
Junk Bands Headbands - Baseball Essentials Bundle
CatchersMomsRDifferent
THE FENCE BUDDY CUP HOLDER
Tri color to match team colors
Franklin Sports Premium Baseball Eye Black - Black/Gold
Santa would be jealous
BRUCE BOLT Men's Big League Chew Short Cuff Batting Gloves
Get those hands clean and clipped
Manicure Set 8-Piece Stainless Steel Kit
Grip work levels up every aspect of baseball
Great Ape Grips Grip Bag for building hand strength without the rice bucket mess - HAWAIIAN MINT
Mint is the IT Color and Bolts now let you personalize
Personalized Graduated Compression Premium Arm Sleeve - Mint Green
Books
Great light reading for young ball players who love these game
Baseball Book for Kids 9-12: Legends & Trivia
Fun holiday read
The Baseball Game Before Christmas - Children's Book
Socks
Banana socks in youth sizes
Banana Ball Socks in Youth Sizes
a little 6 7 santa will never disappoint a baseball player
Six Seven Santa Socks
Basketballs on them but perfect sports socks for holiday tournaments
Nike Youth Holiday Elite Crew Socks
Baseball themed ones near end of list
DICK's Sporting Goods Cozy Holiday Double Layer Socks
Three colors
Nike Elite 2.0 X-MAS Socks
Decorations
Several designs
Baseball Christmas Stocking
Such cute ribbon with baseball seams perfect for wrapping little things or hanging stockings
Baseball Stitch Christmas Ribbon, Red and White, 2.5" x 25', by Holiday Time
These can be used for little trees in their rooms and for everyday lighting and decoration around their bed or desk.
Yayfazy Baseball String Lights 6.5ft 10LED
Very sportsman feel
Carhartt Christmas Stocking
Gadgets
Games, devices, etc
Anker Nano 10,000mAh Power Bank 30W USB-C
