Anyone who loves true crime, and especially fans of the true crime podcast "My Favorite Murder" will get a kick out of these gift ideas.
Sections
2
My Favorite Murder Podcast
True Crime Fans
My Favorite Murder Podcast
I am 100% ordering this for myself! It will go nicely with my bracelet! #ssdgm
MFM Silicone Apple Compatible Watch Band. My favorite murder, murderino watch band. SSDGM.
Extra pluses for this mug looking like it has the big handle I love so much - and I can't wait to see if there are any quotes I DON'T recognize. Perfect for a “Day One Listener”!
My Favorite Murder Mug - MFM Mug - Murderino Mugs - MFM Quotes - Microwave and Dishwasher Safe Mugs
Perfect for a home office or library. Love this MFM fan art
My Favorite Murder, True Crime Therapy, MFM, SSDGM
I bought this at the Chicago show in November 2025, and it is one of my favorite sweatshirts! Super comfy and nicely understated!
Murderino Script Crewneck
One of my favorite lines they've ever said - I have this quote on an older tank they don't have anymore, but a mug would work nicely too!
Keep Going Mug
#SSDGM
SSDGM MFM Vinyl Sticker
I mean, I want ALL of these buttons! #mfm #ssgdm #callyourdad
My Favorite Murder Button Pins Choose Any One!
Funny sticker - I say this stuff to my husband (jokingly!) all the time!! 😂
MFM Murderino and True Crime Laptop/Water Bottle Decal Roses are Red, Violets are Blue, I Watch Enough Murder Shows
I HAVE to get this MFM advent calendar for next Christmas!
My Favorite Murder Advent Calendar
Take your true crime loving self on the road, listen to MFM in the car and sip Karen's favorite (Diet Coke) from this tumbler!
My Favorite Murder MFM podcast tumbler - multiple sayings from show, 20 oz skinny travel tumbler - hot or cold drinks
This is such a cute and subtle way to show your Murderino-ness on your Christmas tree!!
Murderino Book Ornament, glow in the dark skull, noose, & cleaver
Day One Listeners deserve to own it!
My Favorite Murder Sticker, Day One Listener, True Crime, Weatherproof Vinyl
Let your guests know the house rules with these MFM coasters
My Favorite Murder set of 4 slate coasters
This is a very unique gift idea for fans of My Favorite Murder!
My Favorite Murder Podcast
When you're the RIGHT kind of Karen, it's ok to flaunt it! 😉
I'm a Karen - My Favorite Murder
Good advice from the first year of MFM, now embroidered!
My Favorite Murder - Stay out of the forest - hand embroidery
Love that this is a kit, so you can DIY your own MFM decor!
Hand Embroidery Sampler Kit for Beginners, My Favorite Murder DIY Embroidery Kit, Needle Point Do it Yourself kit for beginners
I LOVE it when you can wear your fandom so subtly - this beautiful necklace is discreet, spelling out the golden rule of MFM in MORSE CODE! Safe to wear around your elders, lol.
