Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Eyeshadow Primers That Finally Stopped My Lids From Creasing By Noon
36
items Spent years watching my carefully blended eyeshadow migrate into my crease by lunchtime — oily lids, humidity, you name it. If you're the person reapplying shadow in the office bathroom mirror wondering what went wrong, I tested dozens of eyeshadow p...
Sections
12
Eyeshadow Primers for Oily Lids
Long-Wear Eye Primers for Hot Weather
Color-Correcting Eyeshadow Primers
Primers That Make Eyeshadow Colors Pop
Eyeshadow Primers for Mature Skin
Waterproof Eye Primers for Watery Eyes
Eyeshadow Primers for Oily Lids
My lids produce oil like a deep fryer. Foundation on the lids? Gone in an hour. These three are the only ones that survived my greasy eyelids through a full workday.
Grab this if your shadow disappears before your morning coffee gets cold — I wore it through a 14-hour wedding day and my smoky eye looked the same in every photo from start to finish.
Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion Original FULL
Switch to this if you've been using concealer as primer and wondering why it's not working. My oily lids used to eat through everything, but this stuff locks shadow down like cement. Stock up because it runs out fast.
Too Faced Shadow Insurance 24+ Hour Anti-Crease Eyeshadow Primer
For anyone on a budget who thinks you need to spend $25 to stop creasing — this $9 tube outperformed three luxury primers I tried. Wish I'd found it before wasting money on the others.
Milani Eyeshadow Primer
Long-Wear Eye Primers for Hot Weather
Moved to Texas and immediately learned that every primer I owned was useless in 100-degree heat. These survived summer without sliding off my face.
Toss this in your bag if you live anywhere with humidity — I wore it to an outdoor July barbecue and came home with my shadow still blended exactly where I put it. Zero transfer on my sunglasses either.
Nars Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base - Clear
Use this when you know you'll be sweating — gym classes, summer festivals, nervous first dates. Applied it before a beach vacation and my sunset look stayed put through sand, salt water, and sunscreen reapplication.
Smashbox Photo Finish 24H Eyeshadow Primer
Keep this around for days when you want a primer that doubles as a neutral base. Layered shadow over it during a Florida trip and nothing budged, even when my face was basically melting off.
MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Cream Eyeshadow
Color-Correcting Eyeshadow Primers
Dark veins and redness on my lids were showing through every light shimmer shade I owned. These neutralized everything underneath so colors finally looked true.
Try this if purple veins on your lids make every pastel shade look muddy — one swipe and suddenly my pink shimmer actually looked pink instead of grayish. The difference shocked me.
Ultimate Shadow & Liner Primer | NYX Professional Makeup
Snag this for a primer that cancels out redness without feeling thick. My eyelids run red and splotchy, and this evened everything out so my champagne shadows stopped looking patchy for the first time in years.
Rare Beauty Always An Optimist Weightless Eye Primer • 3ml
Pair this with any light-colored shadow if your lid discoloration keeps ruining your look. Took me three returns of other products before landing here — finally my white and silver shadows actually show up bright.
Lancôme Aquatique Waterproof Eye Color Base
Primers That Make Eyeshadow Colors Pop
Was spending $40 on palettes and the pigment looked washed out on my lids every single time. Turns out the problem wasn't the shadow — it was what I was putting under it.
Ditch whatever you're using if your shadows look dull — this white base made my neon palette actually look neon. Friends kept asking if I bought new eyeshadow when really I just changed my primer.
Rumour Eyeshadow Base & Primer
Use this under shimmers if you want that wet, foil-like finish without glitter fallout. My New Year's Eve look went from flat to blinding, and people asked if I used actual loose glitter.
Colorfix Eye, Cheek & Lip Cream Pigment
Grab this when your matte shadows keep applying patchy — something about the tacky finish makes powder grip perfectly. Went from needing four layers of shadow to one smooth swipe.
ONE/SIZE BY PATRICK STARRR Visionary Eyeshadow
Eyeshadow Primers for Mature Skin
Started noticing my shadow collecting in fine lines around 35. Regular primers made it worse by caking up. These sit smooth without emphasizing texture.
Try this if your primer settles into every tiny line on your lid — the texture is almost silky and it fills in creases instead of highlighting them. My mom borrowed it once and immediately ordered her own.
Laura Mercier Eye Basics Primer, 0.18 Oz
Swap to this if heavier primers make your lids look crepey. The formula is thin enough to smooth over fine lines but grippy enough to hold shadow all day. Wore it to my high school reunion and looked ten years younger.
[Ready] Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Flawless Eye Filter
Keep this in rotation if you want something lightweight that won't budge. Feels like nothing on the lid but held my shadow through a cross-country flight without a single crease line showing up.
Hourglass Veil Eye Primer
Waterproof Eye Primers for Watery Eyes
Allergies, contacts, random crying at commercials — my eyes water constantly and it destroys my shadow. These primers didn't flinch.
Bring this into your routine if allergy season turns your eye look into a smudgy mess. Wore it through the worst pollen week of spring and my shadow stayed cleaner than my car windshield.
Benefit Cosmetics Stay Don't Stray Stay-put Primer
Use a tiny dot on each lid if your eyes water from contacts — I spent years thinking waterproof shadow was the answer when really I just needed a waterproof base. Completely different results.
Fenty Beauty Instant Retouch Primer 4 Ml Original Produk
Try this if redness and watering go hand in hand for you — the green tint neutralizes irritation while keeping everything locked. Survived a full day of chopping onions in cooking class, not even joking.
Clarins SOS Primer 04-Green 1 oz Diminishes Redness
Budget-Friendly Eyeshadow Primers Under $15
Went through a phase of thinking expensive primers were automatically better. Wasted so much money before realizing some of the cheapest options outperform the luxury ones.
Snag this before your next drugstore run — it held my shadow through a double shift at work and costs less than my lunch. Honestly embarrassing how long I ignored it because of the price tag.
nyx proof it ! waterproof eyeshadow primer
Toss this in your cart if you're skeptical that a $3 primer works — I was too until I wore it side by side with a $28 one and couldn't tell the difference after eight hours. My wallet thanked me.
➩ Elf Shadow Lock Eyelid Primer (eyeshadow primer)
Get this for anyone just starting with eye primer who doesn't want to commit to a big purchase. Performs like something three times its price and the tube lasts forever because you need barely anything.
Wet n Wild Photo Focus Eyeshadow Primer
Shimmer-Specific Eye Primers
Kept losing my shimmer shadows to fallout and fading by mid-afternoon. Regular primers helped with creasing but didn't do anything for keeping glitter in place.
Use this under any glitter or pressed shimmer — before I found it, I had sparkle on my cheeks, nose, and shirt by noon. Now everything stays exactly where I tap it. Zero migration.
Makeup | Too Faced Glitter Glue Glitter Eyeshadow Too
Wear this alone as a one-and-done shimmer or layer it under other shimmers for insane foil payoff. Threw it on five minutes before a dinner date and got three compliments before appetizers arrived.
Stila Shimmer & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow - Kitten
Press these over a tacky primer for a metallic finish that photographs like actual metal. Showed up to a party looking like my eyelids were dipped in molten gold and nobody believed it took two minutes.
Danessa Myricks Beauty Infinite Chrome Flakes - Pride
Matte Eyeshadow Primers for a Smooth Canvas
Needed something that would keep matte shadows blended without turning them patchy or cakey halfway through the day. These gave me the smoothest base.
Dab a tiny bit on lids if your matte shadows apply streaky — the blurring effect smooths everything out so powder sits evenly. Stopped looking like I finger-painted my eyes and started looking intentional.
Smashbox The Original Photo Finish Smooth & Blur Oil
Try this for a completely invisible primer that doesn't change how your shadows feel or blend. Put it on, forget about it, and just know your look will still be there at dinner. Simple and reliable.
Beli bareMinerals Prime Time Eyeshadow Extender
Swap to this if you do a lot of intricate blending — it gives you enough slip to work with your brushes but enough grip that colors don't muddy together. Cut-crease looks finally stopped being a disaster.
Eye Primers & Correctors
Eye Primers That Double as Concealer
Hate adding extra steps to my routine, so finding primers that also cover dark circles and lid discoloration saved me five minutes every morning.
Keep this on your vanity if you want one product doing two jobs — covers my dark under-eye circles AND primes my lids. Morning routine went from 12 steps to 10, which honestly felt revolutionary on Monday mornings.
MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Soft Ochre
Swipe this on bare lids when you want coverage and a subtle wash of color without pulling out an entire palette. Perfect for anyone running late who still wants their eyes to look polished and put-together.
Bobbi Brown Long Wear Cream Shadow Stick Vanilla
Grab the lightest matte shade from this palette and use it as a setting layer over concealer on your lids — sounds weird but it locks everything in and gives the smoothest base I've ever blended shadow onto.
MAKEUP BY MARIO Master Mattes Eyeshadow Palette
Sensitive Skin Eye Primers
Dealt with itchy, flaky eyelids for years because most primers irritated my skin. These are the only ones that didn't make me want to claw my eyes out by 3pm.
Try a tiny amount on lids if every primer you've used makes your eyes itch — the coconut oil base is gentle enough for reactive skin but still keeps shadow in place. My dermatologist actually approved this one.
first aid beauty hello fab coconut skin smoothie priming moisturizer
Dab this on lids for light coverage and sun protection if traditional primers burn or sting. Figured out my lids were reacting to silicone in most primers, and this silicone-free formula was the fix I needed.
SunnyDays SPF30 Tinted Sunscreen Foundation - Sephora.me
Use a dot on each lid if you want something hydrating that won't trigger eczema flare-ups. Spent two years with angry red eyelids before switching to gentle tinted moisturizers as primer — wish someone had told me sooner.
READY STOCK Saie Slip Tint Dewy Tinted Moisturizer SPF
Setting Sprays That Lock Eyeshadow in Place
Learned that even the best primer needs backup sometimes. Adding a setting spray over finished eye looks was the final piece that took me from 8-hour wear to genuinely all-day.
Spritz this over your finished eye look from arm's length — the difference between spraying and not spraying is about four extra hours of wear. Tested it at a music festival and came home with my cut crease still intact.
Urban Decay All Nighter Long Lasting MakeUp Setting Spray
Mist this on if you want your shadow to look freshly applied at hour ten. Brought it to a wedding, did touchups exactly zero times, and danced until 1am with my eyes still looking sharp in every candid photo.
CHARLOTTE TILBURY - Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
Keep this in your desk drawer for midday refreshes — a quick spray revives shadow that's starting to fade without disturbing your blend. Costs less than lunch and the bottle lasts about three months with daily use.
Supercharged Continuous Prep & Set Mist Setting Spray