I love this liquid eyeliner. A little more expensive but not crazy expensive.
But this eyeliner had a learning curve because it had an odd tip but one you have it down your eyeline will be sharp and thin
Black Magic Flik Eyeliner - HALF MAGIC | Ulta Beauty
I have been using this since high school it’s definitely one of my drug store favorites. Can’t go wrong with this
Blackest Black Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara - Maybelline | Ulta Beauty