Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
How I Finally Got Perfect Spritz Cookies After Years of Lumpy Disasters
45
items Every December I'd haul out a cookie press, fight with the dough for an hour, and end up with blobs that looked nothing like the pretty shapes on the box. If you've ever rage-quit a batch of spritz cookies at 11 PM on a Tuesday — this is the gear, th...
Sections
9
Cookie Presses That Actually Work
Baking Sheets That Give You Even Browning
Parchment and Silicone Mats for Clean Release
Butter and Vanilla Worth Splurging On
Sprinkles and Decorating Sugars
Food Coloring for Tinted Dough
Cookie Presses That Actually Work
After wrestling with three different presses that jammed, cracked, or spit out shapeless lumps, these are the ones that finally cooperated with real dough on real baking nights.
Switch to this if your old press makes your hand cramp after six cookies — the ratchet mechanism is smooth and my 70-year-old mom used it for two hours straight without complaining.
OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with 12 Stainless Steel
Grab this for anyone just starting out with spritz cookies — it's straightforward, the discs pop in fast, and I got clean releases on the first try without chilling the dough.
Wilton Comfort Grip Cookie Press, White, Large Barrel
Use this when you want bakery-level detail on every single cookie — the metal construction means zero flex, and my shapes came out so crisp my sister thought I bought them.
Marcato Design Series Biscuit Maker Press
Snag this if you want variety without buying extra disc sets — eighteen shapes kept my kids entertained for an entire afternoon and the tree design is honestly stunning on a platter.
Cuisinart Not Powered Cookie Press Kit, 18 Disks 6 Tips
Keep this one around for thick Scandinavian-style dough that clogs cheaper presses — it handled my grandmother's buttery recipe without a single jam, which is more than I can say for my last three attempts.
Nordic Ware Deluxe Spritz Maker & Treat Decorating Set
Baking Sheets That Give You Even Browning
Half my spritz disasters were actually the pan's fault — dark bottoms, raw centers, cookies welded to the surface. Swapping sheets fixed more problems than I expected.
Try this if you keep getting dark bottoms on your cookies while the tops stay pale — the aluminized steel distributes heat so evenly I stopped rotating pans halfway through.
USA Pan Bakeware Half Baking Sheet with Baking
Pair this with parchment and your spritz cookies slide right off — I used to lose every third cookie to sticking before I ditched my old dark nonstick pans.
Nordic Ware, Half Sheet, 18"x13" Aluminum
Get this for quick weeknight batches when you don't feel like dealing with parchment — cookies released clean and it fits perfectly in my narrow apartment oven.
Wilton, Recipe Right Cookie Sheet Set
Toss these in your cart if you're baking six dozen cookies and need backup sheets in rotation — they're cheap enough that I don't panic when my teenager scrubs them with steel wool.
Mainstays 11.2 in x 17.2 in Nonstick Cookie & Baking Sheet
Use this specifically for spritz cookies that keep browning too fast — the air layer inside slows everything down, and my sugar-heavy dough finally stopped turning into caramel on the bottom.
Farberware Jumbo Nonstick Cookie Sheet, 15.5 in x 20
Parchment and Silicone Mats for Clean Release
Nothing ruins a batch faster than peeling a perfect cookie off the sheet and watching it tear in half. These liners ended that heartbreak for me.
Keep a roll in your drawer at all times — I ran out mid-batch once and tried wax paper instead, which melted and ruined forty cookies. Never again.
Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment Paper Roll
Swap this in when your spritz shapes keep spreading on parchment — the slight grip holds the dough in place and my wreaths actually looked like wreaths for the first time.
Customer reviews for Silpat Silicone Mat for Baking Non
Grab the pre-cut version if you're tired of fighting with a curling roll while your dough warms up — flat sheets save at least five minutes of frustration per batch.
Glad Pre-Cut Parchment Paper Sheets, 125 ct.
Try doubling up mats on a thin cookie sheet for extra insulation — sounds weird but it saved a batch when my oven was running hot last Christmas Eve.
Amazon Basics Silicone Rectangular Baking Mat
Use these if the chemical smell from bleached parchment bothers you — zero odor, cookies tasted cleaner, and they held up through 375 degrees without curling or browning.
If You Care, Parchment Baking Sheets
Butter and Vanilla Worth Splurging On
Spritz cookies have like four ingredients, so every single one matters. Cheap butter and imitation vanilla nearly cost me a cookie exchange trophy — yes, that's a real thing in my neighborhood.
Use this for your spritz dough and you'll taste the difference immediately — my cookies went from flat and bland to rich and almost shortbread-like, and people actually asked for the recipe.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Salted Pure Irish Butter, 8 oz
Ditch the imitation stuff — I did a side-by-side test and the batch with real vanilla had a warm depth that the fake version just couldn't touch. Worth every penny for holiday baking.
McCormick, Vanilla Extract, 2 fl oz, Non-GMO, Pure
Grab this when Kerrygold is sold out — consistent fat content means your dough behaves the same every time, which matters when you're pressing sixty cookies and can't afford a mushy batch.
Land O Lakes® Unsalted Butter
Snag a bottle before the holidays because it sells out fast — one teaspoon in spritz dough makes the whole kitchen smell like a bakery and the flavor lingers in every bite.
Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract
Try this West Coast butter if your dough keeps coming out too soft — it's slightly firmer than some brands and held its shape through the press better on a warm December afternoon in my kitchen.
Challenge Dairy, Unsalted Butter, 16 oz, 4 Sticks
Sprinkles and Decorating Sugars
Plain spritz cookies are fine, but a little color turns a good platter into the one everyone photographs. These are what I reach for when I want that festive sparkle without spending all night decorating.
Toss a pinch of these on each cookie right after pressing, before they hit the oven — the colors bake in and stay vibrant instead of looking dusty like some cheaper brands.
Wilton Christmas Sprinkles for Holiday Baking
Keep these around for kids who want to go wild — they're inexpensive enough that I don't flinch when my four-year-old dumps half the bottle on three cookies.
Betty Crocker Rainbow Sprinkles - 1.75 oz
Use this on Christmas tree shapes for a sparkly effect that catches the light on a platter — my neighbor literally thought I'd bought the cookies from a professional bakery.
Wilton Red Sanding Decorating Sugar, 2.5 oz.
Pair this with a simple round disc shape when you don't want to fuss with intricate designs — the mix does all the visual work and every cookie looks different.
Party in the USA Sprinkle Medley
Grab green jimmies specifically for wreath-shaped spritz — press the cookie, add sprinkles, then dot a red candy on top. Five seconds of effort and it looks like you spent an hour.
Celebakes By CK Products Jimmies Decorating Sprinkles
Food Coloring for Tinted Dough
Figured out that coloring the dough before pressing gives way more even results than painting finished cookies. One discovery that saved me hours of cleanup.
Use gel colors instead of liquid — I learned the hard way that liquid food coloring makes spritz dough too wet and it won't hold shape in the press. Gel fixes that completely.
Wilton Icing Colours Set
Try this for subtle pastel shades when you don't need intense color — a single drop in a full batch gives a soft pink or green that looks elegant on a white platter.
Customer reviews for McCormick Assorted Food Color
Grab this specific red if you want true crimson dough without adding ten drops — one tiny squeeze and my dough turned the perfect shade of holiday red on the first try.
AmeriColor, Soft Gel Paste Food Color, Super Red 4.5 oz
Switch to this if you're doing multiple dough colors in one session — the dropper bottles let you measure precisely so your green batch matches your green batch from last year.
Wilton Color Right Performance Food Coloring Set
Snag this set for anyone who bakes year-round — the colors are concentrated enough that one set lasted me two full holiday seasons plus Easter and birthdays in between.
Chefmaster Liqua-Gel Food Coloring Set
Cooling Racks That Handle Big Batches
When you're pressing out a hundred cookies, counter space disappears fast. Stackable racks saved my sanity and kept cookies from getting soggy on the bottom.
Get this if your counter is already covered in flour and you have nowhere to put finished cookies — three tiers in one footprint, and my spritz cookies cooled without getting soft underneath.
Wilton Perfect Results Cooling Rack, 3 Tier, Non-Stick
Use this rack inside the oven to bake and then just slide it out to cool — one less transfer step means fewer broken cookies, which matters when you've pressed perfect little stars.
Nordic Ware, Baking and Cooling Grid, Large, Gray, Steel
Toss both racks out at once when you're running two sheet pans back to back — the tight grid means even tiny spritz shapes don't fall through, which was a problem with my old wide-gap rack.
Baker's Secret Non-stick Set of 3 Cooling Rack Set 15.7"x9.
Pair this with a sheet pan underneath to catch crumbs — dishwasher safe too, which I didn't appreciate until I was elbow-deep in dishes at midnight after a baking marathon.
Checkered Chef Cooling Rack Set of 2 Stainless Steel Oven
Grab the nonstick version if your cookies have any chocolate or jam on them — regular racks left sticky residue that took forever to scrub, but these wipe clean in seconds.
Wilton W2105948 Recipe Right Non-Stick Cooling Grids
Cookie Tins and Packaging for Gifting
Spent all that time making perfect spritz cookies and then threw them in a ziplock bag exactly once. Never again — proper tins keep them fresh and make you look like you have your life together.
Use these for cookie exchange parties — they stack neatly, the lids actually seal, and three people asked where I got them last year because they looked so put together.
Wilton Metal Holiday Cookie Cutters, 12-Piece Set
Grab a few of these in early November before the good designs sell out — I waited until December 20th once and was stuck with a generic snowflake that looked like clip art.
Christmas Cookie Tins With Cookies
Try these for coworker gifts when you're distributing to twenty people and tins aren't practical — a dozen spritz cookies in a clear bag with a ribbon looks thoughtful without the expense.
Twist Ties Treat Bags for Parties & Gifts
Keep a box of these on hand all season — I filled them with four or five spritz cookies each for my kids' teachers and bus driver, tied with ribbon, done in ten minutes.
Wilton, Clear Treat Bags, 150-Count, Food Grade, 4 x 9.5 in.
Swap to airtight containers if you're storing cookies more than two days — my spritz stayed crispy for a full week in these while the ones in a regular tin went soft after three days.
Rubbermaid, Food Storage Container, 9.6 Cup
Recipe Books and Baking Guides
Took me years to realize my spritz dough recipe was the real problem, not the press. These books fixed my ratios and gave me flavor ideas I never would have tried on my own.
Use this as your starting point — the classic spritz recipe on page 18 is the one my grandmother used, and it works with every press I've tried without any modifications.
Betty Crocker, Cooky Book, 450+ Recipes, Hardcover
Grab this if you want to understand why your dough fails — the troubleshooting section explained that my butter was too warm, which is why my cookies kept spreading for three years straight.
King Arthur Baking Company, All-Purpose Baker's Companion
Try the chocolate spritz variation in here — I was skeptical but added cocoa to the dough and those cookies disappeared from the platter before anything else at my holiday party.
Sally McKenney, Cookie Bars, 3rd Edition
Keep this on your shelf for the science behind butter cookies — understanding gluten development changed how I mix my dough and my cookies went from tough to melt-in-your-mouth tender.
Pre-Owned Joy of Cooking
Snag this for inspiration beyond basic spritz — the dipped and drizzled variations gave me six new platter ideas and my cookie exchange contribution finally stood out instead of blending in.
Trusted Media Brands Christmas Cookies Cookbook