Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
How I Finally Stopped Making Dense Pie Crusts That Tasted Like Cardboard
60
items Spent years wondering why my pie crust came out tough and chewy while my grandmother's shattered into perfect flaky layers. Turns out it wasn't talent — it was tools and technique. If you're the person who dreads Thanksgiving pie duty or quietly buys...
Sections
12
Pastry Blenders That Actually Cut Butter Fast
Pie Dishes That Bake Evenly Without Burnt Bottoms
Rolling Pins That Don't Stick to Dough
Pastry Mats and Boards That Keep Dough in Place
Bench Scrapers and Dough Cutters for Clean Work
Butter and Shortening That Makes Flaky Layers
Pastry Blenders That Actually Cut Butter Fast
My old method was two forks and fifteen minutes of hand cramps. The first time I used a real pastry blender and watched cold butter turn into pea-sized pieces in under a minute, I genuinely felt betrayed that nobody told me sooner.
Grab this if your hands cramp up using two forks — the soft grip handle let me cut through a full stick of frozen butter without my wrist screaming at me afterward.
OXO SoftWorks Dough Blender with Stainless Steel Blades
Switched to this after my old wire blender snapped mid-pie. The blades are thick stainless steel and I've gone through dozens of batches without any bending. Perfect for anyone who bakes more than twice a year.
Spring Chef Dough Blender, Top Professional Pastry
Toss this in the dishwasher and forget about it — I used to hand-wash my old one and butter residue would hide in the wires for days. This one cleans up in seconds.
Zulay Kitchen Dough Blender & Pastry Cutter
Use this for softer butter that's been sitting out a bit too long. The thin wires grab and cut through it faster than rigid blades, and it saved a batch I almost threw away last Thanksgiving.
(5 pack) Mrs. Anderson's Baking 6-Wire Pastry Cutter
Keep this one in your drawer if you already own KitchenAid stuff — it matches everything and the curved shape fits right into a mixing bowl without scraping the sides. Feels solid, not flimsy.
Kitchenaid Gourmet Pastry Blender in Black with Stainless
Pie Dishes That Bake Evenly Without Burnt Bottoms
Nothing worse than pulling out a beautiful golden pie and flipping it to find a soggy, pale bottom. I cycled through three different dishes before landing on ones that actually conduct heat properly.
Swap out that cheap tin pan — glass lets you actually see the bottom crust browning in real time so you're not guessing. My soggy-bottom days ended the day I started using this.
Glass Pie Plate 9.5", Pyrex®, Easy Grab, 1 Piece
Bring this straight to the table and people think you're a professional. The ceramic holds heat so well that my filling stayed warm through second helpings at Christmas dinner.
Emile Henry Modern Classics 9" Deep Pie Dish
Try this if you've been using metal pans and getting uneven browning. The white ceramic distributes heat gently so the edges don't burn while the center catches up.
CorningWare FW111 French White 9 in Pie Plate
For anyone who wants that diner-style golden crust — the aluminized steel on this thing browns the bottom perfectly. I stopped second-guessing my oven temperature once I switched.
USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pie Pan, 9-Inch
Snag this if you're on a budget but still want glass. Works nearly identical to the Pyrex and I've dropped it on my counter without a crack. Sturdy for the price.
Anchor Hocking Deep Pie Plate
Rolling Pins That Don't Stick to Dough
Used to fight with a wooden pin that grabbed my dough and ripped it apart every single time. Flour everywhere, dough sticking, me swearing — the whole scene. These actually roll smooth.
Use the removable rings to set your exact dough thickness — I went from rolling lopsided crusts to perfectly even ones overnight. Wish someone had shown me this trick five years ago.
Joseph Joseph 20036 Adjustable Rolling Pin
Ditch the old wooden one your mom gave you (sorry, Mom). This non-stick surface means I use half the flour I used to, and less flour means flakier, more tender crust.
OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Steel Rolling Pin
Try this if you want more control — no handles means your palms feel exactly how thick the dough is. Took me one batch to get used to it and now I can't go back.
Berard Beechwood French Tapered Rolling Pin, 20 Inch
Keep this around as your workhorse. It's heavy enough that the weight does most of the work so you're not pressing down and overworking the dough into a tough mess.
Farberware, Wood Rolling Pin with Classic Handles
Stick this in the freezer for 20 minutes before rolling — the cold marble keeps butter from melting into the dough. Discovered this trick the summer I tried making pie in a kitchen with no AC.
Fox Run 48760 White Marble French Rolling Pin, 2 x 12
Pastry Mats and Boards That Keep Dough in Place
Rolling dough directly on my countertop meant it slid everywhere and I'd end up with a misshapen oval instead of a circle. A proper mat changed everything about my rolling technique.
Throw this on any counter surface and your dough stays put while you roll. No more chasing it across the kitchen. Plus the measurement guides printed on it keep my circles actually circular.
Customer reviews for Silpat Silicone Mat for Baking Non
Grab this if your counter is small — it's big enough to roll out a full double-crust pie and the non-slip backing grips granite, wood, whatever you've got.
Pastry and Danish
For anyone who bakes weekly, a dedicated board beats a mat. Wipe it down, hang it up, done. The printed circles saved me from rolling crusts that were too big or too small every time.
Brown Wooden Reversible Pastry Kneading Board 24'' x
Use this for cookie dough too — it's not just pie. The thickness guides on the side helped me finally figure out why my sugar cookies were always inconsistent.
Wilton Roll-N-Cut Mat
Pair this with a cold marble counter and it's basically cheating. The silicone grips the surface underneath while the dough releases cleanly on top. No flour dust explosion required.
Non-slip Silicone Pastry Mat Extra Large
Bench Scrapers and Dough Cutters for Clean Work
Before I owned a bench scraper, I'd peel stuck dough off my counter with a spatula and my fingernails. Embarrassing in hindsight. These make cleanup and portioning so much faster.
Keep this next to your workspace at all times. One swipe lifts stuck dough off the counter, and the flat edge portions dough into equal halves better than any knife I've tried.
Dexter-Russell Sani-Safe 6 x 3 Dough Cutter/Scraper
Grab this if you want one tool that scrapes dough, transfers chopped vegetables, and cleans your board. The ruler etched into the blade is surprisingly useful for eyeballing dough width.
OXO Good Grips Multi-purpose Stainless Steel Scraper & Chopper
Switched to stainless after my plastic one cracked in half during a cold-butter session. This feels indestructible and the grip doesn't slip even with floury hands.
LNGOOR Spring Chef Stainless Steel Pastry Scraper
Try this thinner blade if you do a lot of laminated dough — it slides under layers without dragging. Pastry school students use these for a reason.
Ateco Stainless Steel Bench Scraper 4'' Wide Blade
For anyone whose hands get slippery while baking — the rubber grip on this is aggressive in the best way. Dropped it in soapy water, picked it up, still had full control.
Norpro Grip-Ez Chopper/Scraper
Butter and Shortening That Makes Flaky Layers
Learned the hard way that not all butter is created equal. The cheap stuff has more water, which means steam, which means tough crust. Switched brands and immediately noticed a difference.
Use this for any pie crust recipe that calls for butter — the higher fat content means less water and more flavor. First time I used it, my husband asked if I followed a different recipe. Nope, just better butter.
Kerrygold Irish Grass-fed Salted Butter Sticks, 16oz, 4x4oz
Stick with unsalted so you control the salt level yourself. This is my everyday baking butter — consistent quality every time and it goes on sale often enough to stock up.
Land O Lakes Unsalted Butter, 4 Sticks, 1 lb Pack
Splurge on this for special occasion pies — the 82% butterfat makes layers so flaky they practically shatter when you cut into them. Worth every extra cent at Thanksgiving.
Plugra Premium European Style Unsalted Butter, 8 oz Solid
Swap half the butter for this if you want a crust that holds its shape better. Pure butter crusts taste amazing but can slump — a butter-shortening combo gives you the best of both.
Crisco All-Vegetable Shortening 48 oz for Baking and Frying
Try this if you want a cleaner ingredient list than traditional shortening. Works identically in pie crust and I couldn't taste a difference in a side-by-side test with my sister.
Crisco All-Vegetable Shortening, Whole, 16 oz Can
Flour Picks That Actually Affect Your Crust Texture
Thought flour was flour until I accidentally used bread flour in a pie crust and produced something you could sole a shoe with. The protein content matters more than I ever realized.
Stick with this as your go-to — the protein level is consistent bag to bag, which means my crust comes out the same every time instead of being a guessing game.
The Best Waffles Ever Recipe
Try this Southern staple if your crusts are coming out too tough. Lower protein means more tender results, and it's what every award-winning pie baker I've met swears by.
Where to Buy - White Lily Flour
Grab this if you prefer unbleached — slightly more protein gives the crust a bit more structure, which is great when you're making a pie with heavy filling that needs support.
Bob's Red Mill, Organic Unbleached White All-Purpose
Keep a bag of this around as your reliable backup. Nothing fancy, but it's been making good pie crusts since before I was born and there's something to be said for that.
White All Purpose Flour - Bread Flours
For anyone avoiding gluten who's given up on homemade pie crust — this is the closest I've found to regular flour behavior. My celiac friend cried actual tears over the crust I made with this.
Cup4Cup Multipurpose Flour, 3 Pounds
Pastry Tools for Crimping and Decorating Edges
My pie edges used to look like a toddler pinched them. Not in a charming rustic way — in a ‘did you make this blindfolded’ way. These tools gave me edges worth photographing.
Use this ring to stop your edges from burning dark brown while the center finishes baking. Saved every single pie I've made since buying it — no more aluminum foil origami.
Norpro Reusable 10" Pie Crust Shield, Inch, As Shown
Pair the straight and fluted wheels for lattice tops that look like they came from a bakery. Took me one YouTube video and this set to finally nail a lattice I wasn't embarrassed by.
Ateco Rectangular Pastry Cutter Set - Stainless steel
Snag this if you want to try leaf cutouts and braided edges without buying fifteen separate tools. The mini plunger cutters make autumn leaves that look way harder than they actually are.
Wilton Cake Decorating Set, 10-Piece
Press this onto rolled dough and it cuts a perfect lattice pattern in seconds. I spent 45 minutes weaving strips by hand once — never again. This does it in under a minute.
Fox Run Lattice Pie Top Cutter, White 9.75"
Try the different pattern attachments for edges that don't all look the same. Brought three pies to a potluck with different edge designs and people thought three different people made them.
Talisman Designs Pastry Wheels Decorator & Cutter Set
Mixing Bowls That Make Dough Prep Easier
Tried making pie dough in a bowl so small that flour went everywhere when I used the pastry blender. Having the right size bowl with enough room to actually work in made a real difference.
Grab the large one for pie dough — you need room to swing a pastry blender without flour erupting over the sides like a volcano. The pour spout helps when adding ice water too.
Pyrex Smart Essentials 8-Piece Mixing Bowl Set
Keep these in the freezer before making dough — cold metal bowls help keep the butter chilled while you work. Discovered this on a baking forum and it genuinely improved my crust.
FineDine Stainless Steel Mixing Bowl Set 8 Pieces
Use the non-slip base version so the bowl doesn't spin while you're cutting in butter. Freed up one hand and made the whole process less like wrestling and more like actual baking.
OXO Good Grips 3-Piece Mixing Bowl Set – Blueberry
Toss the lid on and refrigerate your dough right in the mixing bowl — one less dish to wash. For anyone who hates cleanup as much as I do, this tiny convenience adds up fast.
Cuisinart, Stainless Steel Mixing Bowls, 1.5 qt size
Bring this out when you want something that looks good sitting on the counter. Heavy ceramic stays put while you work and it doubles as a serving bowl for tossed salads between baking days.
Mason Cash In The Forest Mixing Bowls | Set of 4
Measuring Tools for Precise Pie Crust Ratios
Eyeballed my flour once and ended up with dough so dry it crumbled into dust. Pie crust is one of those recipes where a tablespoon too much flour ruins everything. Precision actually matters here.
Ditch the plastic ones that warp in the dishwasher — these hold their shape and the flat edges let you level off flour properly. Warped cups were adding extra flour to every batch without me knowing.
KitchenAid Gourmet Stainless Steel Measuring Cups
Use these for salt and baking powder — the narrow shape fits into spice jars without getting your fingers dirty. Sounds minor until you've fumbled with wide spoons for the hundredth time.
OXO Stainless Steel Measuring Spoons with Magnetic
Switch to weighing your flour instead of scooping and your crust will be consistent every single time. One cup of flour can vary by 30 grams depending on how you scoop — a scale eliminates the guesswork.
Customer reviews for Escali Primo Digital Food Scale Multi
Pour ice water into this and read the measurement from above without bending down. Adding water to pie dough is the most critical step and even a tablespoon too much makes it tough.
OXO Good Grips Angled Measuring Cup
Snap these together so they stop rattling around your drawer. Found my old set scattered across three different drawers — these magnets keep the whole set in one spot.
Spring Chef Magnetic Measuring Spoons Set
Chilling and Resting Gear for Better Dough
Skipped the resting step exactly once because I was impatient. The dough shrank in the oven, my filling leaked everywhere, and I ordered pizza. Now I never skip chilling — and these make it painless.
Wrap your dough disc, drop it in this container, and refrigerate for an hour. The airtight seal means no fridge smells get absorbed — learned that lesson after my crust tasted faintly like leftover garlic bread.
Rubbermaid, Food Storage Container, 9.6 Cup
Wrap dough tightly before chilling so it doesn't dry out on the edges. This brand actually clings without fighting you — switched after years of wrestling with cheap wrap that stuck to itself and nothing else.
Reynolds Kitchens, Plastic Wrap, Quick Cut, 200 sq ft
Slide your rolled crust onto this and freeze it flat for 15 minutes before transferring to the pie dish. Cold dough handles better and doesn't tear — this pan fits perfectly in a standard freezer.
43172AMZM Nordic Ware Half Sheet with Oven Safe
Try these if you're cutting back on plastic — they mold around dough discs with the warmth of your hands and keep everything sealed. Wash and reuse for months.
Bee's Wrap Reusable Eco-Friendly Beeswax Food Storage
Keep a flat glass dish in the fridge dedicated to chilling dough. Glass stays cold longer than plastic and the low sides make it easy to slide dough in and out without mangling it.
Pyrex Easy Grab 4-piece Rectangular Glass Bakeware Set
Books and Resources That Taught Me Actual Technique
Watched a dozen random videos and got a dozen conflicting tips. These resources finally gave me a consistent method I could repeat without second-guessing every step.
Read the butter temperature chapter alone and it'll change how you approach every crust. She explains the science behind flaky layers in a way that finally made it click for me after years of guessing.
The Pie and Pastry Bible - Rose Levy Beranbaum
Grab this if you want creative flavor combinations beyond basic apple. Her salted maple pie recipe became my signature dish and people request it by name now — that never happened with my old recipes.
Lisa Ludwinski, Sister Pie Cookbook, 75 Recipes and Stories
Use her all-butter crust recipe as your baseline — it's foolproof and she troubleshoots every possible mistake. Failed pie makers, this book was written specifically for us.
Pre-Owned BraveTart: Iconic American Desserts by Stella
Try her hand method if you hate using a food processor. She taught me how to feel when the dough is right, which matters more than any timer or measurement once you get the basics down.
Art of the Pie: A Practical Guide to Homemade Crusts
Keep this on your shelf as the reference book that covers every type of pastry, not just pie. When I wanted to branch out into galettes and tarts, this was the first place I looked.
How to Cook Everything: The Basics: All You Need to Make