Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found the Candy Thermometer That Makes My Fudge Set Every Time
36
items If you've ever dumped another batch of grainy, soupy fudge down the drain on December 23rd, I feel your pain. I ruined five batches in one holiday season before I figured out it wasn't my recipe. It was my tools. This list is for the home candy maker...
Sections
6
Candy Thermometers That Actually Read Accurately
Heavy Bottom Pots That Stop Scorching
Silicone Spatulas and Wooden Spoons for Stirring
Baking Pans and Molds for Setting Candy
Chocolate, Sugars, and Ingredients That Make a Difference
Packaging and Gift Boxes for Holiday Candy
Candy Thermometers That Actually Read Accurately
I used to blame my stove, my altitude, even my grandmother's recipe. Turns out my old thermometer was off by 8 degrees. That's the difference between perfect fudge and chocolate soup.
Grab this if you want a no-fuss analog thermometer that clips to the pot. Mine has survived four holiday seasons and still reads dead accurate. For anyone who doesn't trust digital screens near a pot of boiling sugar.
Taylor Kitchen Digital Deep Fry Candy Thermometer
Use this one if you like a big, easy-to-read dial while you're stirring. I switched from a tiny glass tube thermometer and immediately stopped second-guessing my soft ball stage. Stock up before November when they sell out.
KitchenAid Curved Candy and Deep Fry Thermometer
Keep this in your drawer for spot-checking temps fast. My sister borrowed it for her caramel batch and refused to give it back. Works great for anyone who needs a reading in under 3 seconds.
TempPro TempDip 1 Sec Digital Candy Thermometer
Try this if you want a thermometer with candy stage markings printed right on it. Saved me from Googling ‘what temp is hard crack’ with sticky hands at 11 PM on Christmas Eve.
Polder THM-515 Stainless Steel Candy/Jelly/Deep Fry
Snag this for its extra long probe. Keeps your hand farther from the boiling sugar, which matters a lot when you're making toffee. Wish I'd had this before I burned my wrist two years ago.
CDN TCG400 - Candy & Deep Fry Ruler Thermometer
Toss this in your apron pocket as a backup digital reader. It's cheap enough that I keep two around. Perfect for the person who panics when their main thermometer fogs up mid-batch.
Habor 022 Meat Thermometer, Instant Read
Heavy Bottom Pots That Stop Scorching
Fudge scorches in thin pots. I learned this the hard way when I scraped burnt sugar off my old saucepan for 45 minutes on Christmas morning. Never again.
Use this for small batches of fudge or pralines. The heavy bottom distributes heat evenly so you're not stirring like a maniac to prevent hot spots. Paid for itself after one batch.
Cuisinart 7193-20P Chef's Classic 3-Quart Cook
Grab this if cleanup is your least favorite part. Caramel slides right out. I used to soak my old pot overnight. Now I wipe and I'm done in two minutes.
T-fal Cook & Strain Non-stick, 3 Quart Saucepan with Lid
Try this bigger pot if your recipe bubbles up and overflows. My peanut brittle used to volcano everywhere in a 2 quart pot. This gave me the room I needed without switching to a full stockpot.
Farberware 1-Quart Classic Stainless Steel Saucepan
Pair this with a good thermometer and you're set for years. The tri-ply bottom holds steady temps, which is everything when you're trying to hit 238 degrees exactly. Worth every penny.
Customer reviews for Tramontina PrimaWare 3 Quart Non
Keep this one for your candy-only pot. I stopped sharing mine with pasta duties and my fudge improved immediately. Something about garlic residue and chocolate just doesn't mix.
Rachael Ray Cucina Hard Anodized Nonstick Saucepan
Swap this in if you're on a budget but still want thick walls. Held up through my entire holiday candy marathon last year. For anyone who needs a reliable pot without spending $60.
Mainstays Stainless Steel 3 qt Induction Compatible
Silicone Spatulas and Wooden Spoons for Stirring
Metal spoons scratch pots and plastic ones melt in hot sugar. I melted a spatula into a batch of toffee once and had to throw the whole thing away. These actually survive.
Use the medium one for fudge stirring. It scrapes every bit of mixture from the sides, which prevents those gross crystallized chunks. My old wooden spoon left behind so much wasted candy.
OXO Good Grips 3 Piece Silicone Spatula Set
Grab these for the traditional feel if you grew up watching your grandma stir with wood. They don't conduct heat so your hand stays comfortable during long stirs. Dedicated one spoon to candy only.
Farberware Professional 2-Piece Rubberwood Spoon
Try this if you want one spatula that handles everything from folding nuts into brittle to scraping fudge into the pan. It's rated to 550 degrees so hot sugar doesn't faze it at all.
GIR Get It Right 10 Piece Ultimate Silicone Cooking
Snag this hybrid spoon-spatula combo. Scoops like a spoon, scrapes like a spatula. I use it when I'm pouring caramel and need to get every last drop out of the pot.
Wilton Versa-Tools Measure and Mix Spoon, Silicone
Keep a set of these for candy making and nothing else. Bamboo doesn't absorb flavors the way soft wood does. Learned that after my caramel tasted faintly like tomato sauce.
KitchenAid
Toss this in your cart as a backup. Under two dollars and surprisingly sturdy. For anyone who keeps losing spatulas to the dishwasher abyss and needs replacements fast.
Mainstays Blue Silicone Kitchen Spatula, 10.55 in
Baking Pans and Molds for Setting Candy
Pouring hot fudge into the wrong pan is how you get pieces that are too thick in the middle and paper thin on the edges. Took me years to figure out pan size actually matters this much.
Use this for a standard fudge batch. Gets you that perfect thickness where each piece is dense and chewy without being a brick. I poured into a 13x9 once and got fudge so thin it crumbled.
Wilton Non-Stick Steel Square Baking Pan 9x9 Inch
Grab this for smaller batches or thicker slabs. When I want gift-box sized fudge pieces that look impressive, this is the pan. Lines up perfectly with a 2-cup recipe.
Baker's Secret Nonstick 9-Inch Carbon Steel Square Cake
Try this for large batches when you're making candy for the whole office. Spreads toffee thin and even, which is exactly what you want for a clean snap. Doubled my yield last December.
Wilton 13 x 9 Inch Aluminum Rectangular Cake Pan
Swap these in for individual pieces that pop right out. No cutting, no crumbling edges. My peanut butter cups came out looking store-bought and my kids thought I was a wizard.
15-Cavity Silicone Chocolate Candy Molds
Line your pan with this before pouring. Lift the whole slab out when it sets, flip it, peel the foil off. Zero sticking. Wish someone had told me this trick five years ago.
The Complete Guide on How to Use Reynolds Aluminum Foil
Use this under your brittle and toffee. Peels off clean every time. I used to butter the pan directly and still ended up chiseling candy off with a knife. Those days are over.
Reynolds Kitchens Stay Flat Parchment Paper Roll
Chocolate, Sugars, and Ingredients That Make a Difference
Cheap chocolate chips and old brown sugar wrecked more batches than I want to admit. Once I upgraded my base ingredients, my fudge tasted like it came from a candy shop.
Grab these for fudge that actually tastes like chocolate and not just sugar. The difference between these and generic chips is night and day. My neighbor asked if I took a candy making class.
Ghirardelli, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Chips
Use fresh brown sugar, not that rock-hard bag from the back of your pantry. Soft brown sugar dissolves evenly and prevents grainy texture. Replaced my old bag and my caramels improved instantly.
Domino Premium Pure Cane Dark Brown Sugar 2 lb
Keep a jar on hand for foolproof fantasy fudge. This is the secret weapon in my grandmother's recipe. Stir it in at the right moment and it gives fudge that smooth, creamy consistency.
RM Palmer Choco Fluff Marshmallow Filled Chocolate
Pair this with your sugar and butter for the creamiest base. Regular milk curdles at high temps. Switched to evaporated milk after one disastrous batch that looked like cottage cheese.
Nestlé Carnation Topping Evaporated Milk
Toss these into your fudge or pralines in the last minute of cooking. Fresh pecans make a huge difference over those stale bags. Check the expiration date, learned that lesson the expensive way.
(12 pack) Diamond of California Chopped Pecans 8 oz
Ditch the imitation stuff. Real vanilla comes through in candy because there's nowhere for it to hide. One teaspoon in a fudge batch and you can actually smell the difference across the kitchen.
McCormick All Natural Pure Vanilla Extract
Packaging and Gift Boxes for Holiday Candy
Spent three Christmases wrapping fudge in plastic wrap like leftovers before I figured out presentation. Now people think I run a small candy business. I definitely do not.
Grab a few packs of these for gifting fudge to teachers and neighbors. They look polished without trying too hard. Last year a teacher sent me a thank you card specifically mentioning the box.
Customer reviews for Wilton Small Treat Boxes, White, 3 Ct
Use these for brittle and bark pieces. Tie them up with the included ribbons and drop them in stockings. Way cheaper than buying pre-made candy gifts and people appreciate homemade so much more.
Way To Celebrate, Clear Treat Bags, Twist Ties, ...
Layer this between fudge pieces so they don't stick together. Stacked fudge without wax paper once and pulled out one giant chocolate brick. Not the look I was going for.
Reynolds Cut-Rite Wax Paper, 75 Square Feet
Try laminating your recipe cards and tucking them into gift boxes. My aunt cried when I included grandma's fudge recipe with her candy. Takes two minutes and makes the gift personal.
Scotch, Thermal Laminating Pouches, 50ct, 8.5x11in 3mil
Write little tags for each candy box. ‘Peanut Brittle, made Dec 22, keep cool.’ Sounds small but people remember the handwritten touch. Bought a holiday color pack and used them on everything.
Paper Mate Flair Felt Tip Pens Black 0.7mm Medium Point
Wrap your pans tight before storing in the fridge. Keeps fudge from drying out or absorbing fridge smells. Nobody wants garlic-scented caramel. Double wrap if you have leftovers past New Year's.
Kirkland Signature Stretch-Tite 12" X 3000' Food Wrap