Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found the Bitters and Bar Tools That Made My Home Old Fashioned Legit
48
items You follow the recipe exactly, use decent bourbon, and somehow your Old Fashioned still tastes like a sad glass of whiskey with sugar in it. Meanwhile the bartender down the street makes it in 30 seconds and it tastes like a revelation. I spent a yea...
Sections
7
Bitters That Actually Change the Drink
Bourbon and Whiskey Worth Mixing
Sweeteners Beyond the Sugar Cube
Ice That Doesn't Ruin Everything
Bar Tools That Replaced My Kitchen Drawer Improvising
Glassware That Makes It Feel Like a Real Drink
Bitters That Actually Change the Drink
I used to think bitters were decorative. A couple dashes of the same bottle for everything. Then I tried swapping flavors per cocktail and realized they're doing about 60% of the heavy lifting in an Old Fashioned.
Keep this as your baseline. Every Old Fashioned starts here, and if you've been eyeballing your dashes instead of counting them, that's probably why your drink tastes off. Three dashes, not five.
Angostura Aromatic Bitters, 4 fl oz, Liquid Cocktail Mixers
Try splitting your dashes between this and the aromatic. Two of each changed my Old Fashioned more than switching to a nicer bourbon did. Seriously wish someone told me this sooner.
Angostura Orange Liquid Cocktail Bitters, 4 fl oz
Grab this for when you're using a higher-rye bourbon. It rounds out the spice in a way that makes people stop mid-sip and ask what you did differently. Works in a Manhattan too.
Fee Brothers, Cocktail Bitters, Chocolate Aztec, 5 fl oz
Use this when you want something a little more complex than Angostura but don't want to reinvent the wheel. It leans slightly more herbal, which plays well with sweeter bourbons like Maker's Mark.
Fee Brothers Old Fashioned Aromatic Bitters
For anyone who thinks regular bitters are too sharp. The barrel aging mellows everything out. I started using this on weeknights when I want something smoother without fussing over ratios.
MULMEHË Exclusive Fee Brothers Whiskey Barrel-Aged
Toss a couple dashes in when you're grilling steaks and want your drink to match the vibe. Not for every night, but when it hits, it really hits. My brother-in-law now requests this specifically.
Hella Cocktail Co. Smoked Chili Bitters
Swap this in during fall when you're tired of the same profile. It's subtle enough that it doesn't turn your Old Fashioned into a fruit cocktail, just adds a little depth that feels seasonal.
Fee Brothers Plum Bitters 5oz
Bourbon and Whiskey Worth Mixing
I wasted money on bottom-shelf stuff thinking bitters would cover it, then wasted money on top-shelf stuff that was too good to mix. This is the sweet spot I landed on.
Get this if you want one bottle that works in literally every whiskey cocktail. It's $25 and bartenders use it all the time. No point spending more for a mixed drink.
Buffalo Trace, Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 750 ml
Pair this with the chocolate bitters from the first section. The high rye content gives your Old Fashioned a little spice and backbone. It's what finally made mine taste like a bar made it.
Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey, 750 mL, 45% ABV
Use this when you're making one drink and actually sitting down to enjoy it. Slightly more vanilla and caramel notes. Overkill for a party batch, perfect for a Tuesday night on the porch.
Bulleit Bourbon vs Woodford Reserve - Comparison Review
For anyone who likes their Old Fashioned with a little more punch. The higher proof means the flavors don't get buried under the ice as it dilutes. Holds up better than anything at this price.
Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon, 750 ml Bottle, 50.5% ABV
Grab this if you're newer to whiskey cocktails. It's softer and sweeter, so even if your ratios are slightly off, the drink still comes out smooth. Very forgiving to work with.
Maker's Mark Bourbon Whisky Review
This runs about $28 and punches way above its weight. I blind-tested it against bottles twice the price and kept picking it. Stock up because it rotates vintages.
Evan Williams
Switch to this when you want an Old Fashioned that feels like a cold-weather drink. Fuller body, more oak. It stands up to a big orange peel expression without getting lost.
Knob Creek 9-Year Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Sweeteners Beyond the Sugar Cube
Muddling a sugar cube for five minutes while your ice melts was my biggest mistake for the longest time. The right sweetener dissolves properly and actually adds flavor instead of just sweetness.
Try a tiny splash of this instead of simple syrup when you want something slightly different. It's made from real pomegranate, not corn syrup. Adds color and a tartness that wakes the drink up.
Liber & Co., Real Grenadine, 12.7 oz, premium cocktail syrup
Ditch the sugar cube completely. A quarter ounce of this dissolves instantly and gives you consistent sweetness every time. My drinks stopped being randomly too sweet or not sweet enough.
Monin Syrup - Pure Cane Sugar - 750 ml
Use a bar spoon of this if you're making an Old Fashioned with rye instead of bourbon. Agave plays nicer with rye's spiciness than regular simple syrup does. Game over for sugar cubes.
Wholesome Sweeteners Organic Raw Blue Agave, 176 oz
Bring this out in December. A small pour turns your Old Fashioned into something that tastes like the holidays without being gimmicky. People will think you spent 20 minutes on it.
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Latte Recipe
Swap this for white simple syrup and you'll never go back. Demerara has a deeper, almost molasses-like sweetness that makes your Old Fashioned taste richer. This is what most good bars actually use.
BG REYNOLDS Rich Demerara Cocktail Syrup - 12.7 Fl Oz
For anyone who wants to try a honey Old Fashioned. Mix equal parts honey and warm water to thin it out, then use it like simple syrup. Pairs ridiculously well with Bulleit.
Nature Nate's
Get this if you're cutting sugar but still want to make cocktails that don't taste like punishment. It dissolves cleanly and the maple note works surprisingly well with bourbon.
Lakanto, Sugar-Free Keto Maple Flavored Syrup, 13 fl oz
Ice That Doesn't Ruin Everything
Regular ice cubes from your freezer tray melt in about 90 seconds and water down your drink before you're halfway through. I didn't believe ice mattered until I tried making one big cube.
Use these 2-inch cubes and your drink stays cold without turning into bourbon-flavored water by the bottom of the glass. One cube per rocks glass, that's it. Took me embarrassingly long to figure this out.
Customer reviews for Tovolo King Cube Ice Tray, 6 Large 2
Grab these if you want the round ice ball look. They melt even slower than cubes because of the surface area thing. Plus they look impressive and people always comment on them.
Customer reviews for Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds, Set of 4
For anyone who's ever wondered why bar ice is crystal clear and yours looks cloudy. This tray uses directional freezing to push out air bubbles. Takes 24 hours but the results are worth it.
BPA-free Silicone Crystal Clear Ice Cube Tray for Freezer
Switch to this if you're serious about presentation. It makes perfectly clear spheres using insulated silicone. They melt so slowly your second Old Fashioned tastes as good as the first.
TINANA Crystal Clear Ice Maker, Silicone Ice Ball Tray
Pair this with the big ice cubes if you're drinking outside. It's insulated so your ice lasts even longer. I use mine on the deck all summer and the drink barely dilutes.
Hydro Flask Wide Mouth with Flex Sip Lid
Keep this around for when you need regular-sized cubes for shaking or stirring other cocktails. Silicone bottom pops them out clean. No more wrestling with plastic trays over the sink.
Peak Silicone Everyday Ice Tray w/ Protective Lid
Toss your old mini trays and get a couple of these. They're cheap, they stack in the freezer, and six big cubes is enough for a night of making drinks for friends. Simple upgrade, big difference.
Samuelworld Large Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin
Bar Tools That Replaced My Kitchen Drawer Improvising
I used to stir with a butter knife and strain through a fork. It technically worked but the drink never came out right. Proper tools cost less than one bar tab and last forever.
Get this if you're starting from zero. Shaker, strainer, jigger, muddler, bar spoon, the whole setup. I bought mine two years ago and everything still works perfectly. Way cheaper than buying pieces separately.
Mixology Bartender Kit: 10-Piece Bar Tool Set with Stylish
Use this instead of free-pouring. I thought I was eyeballing accurately until I actually measured and realized I was over-pouring by almost half an ounce every time. That's why my drinks were so boozy.
OXO SteeL Angled Measuring Jigger
Stir your Old Fashioned with this for about 30 seconds with ice. The long handle reaches the bottom of any mixing glass. Butter knives chip the ice and look ridiculous, trust me.
Hiware 2-Pack 12 Inches Stainless Steel Mixing Spoons
Grab this if you're mixing in a pint glass and need a clean pour. The spring catches any ice chips or muddled bits. My drinks went from chunky to smooth overnight.
Viski Antique Style Hawthorne Strainer
For anyone who's been hacking at oranges with a paring knife and getting mostly pith. This gives you a clean strip of zest every time. Express it over the drink and drop it in.
Chef Craft Select Plastic Orange Peeler, 2.25 inches
Keep this next to your setup for cutting garnishes. It's small enough that it doesn't take over the counter and thick enough that it won't slide around while you're peeling oranges.
Catskill Craftsmen Butcher Block Kitchen Cart in White
Ditch the back of a wooden spoon. A real muddler presses the oils out of your orange peel and sugar without shredding everything into pulp. Flat bottom works better than the textured kind.
Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler, Durable Ice Crusher Fruit
Glassware That Makes It Feel Like a Real Drink
Drinking a proper Old Fashioned out of a regular water glass is like eating a steak off a paper plate. It works, but something feels wrong. Good rocks glasses changed the whole experience for me.
Get these as your everyday set. They're heavy enough to feel substantial but not so fancy you're afraid to use them. Dishwasher safe, which matters more than people admit.
Libbey Craft Spirits Assorted Liquor Glasses (Set of 6)
Bring these out when company comes over. The cut crystal catches light and makes your drink look like it costs $18. They're around $30 for a set and feel way more expensive.
Godinger 25722 Dublin Crystal Whiskey Glass 11oz, Set of 4
Try these if you like a wider rim. The shape lets you nose the bourbon before you sip, which sounds pretentious but actually helps you taste more. My wife bought them as a joke gift and now I use them daily.
JoyJolt Aqua Vitae Triangle Whiskey Glasses, Set of 2 Off
Swap in these if you want something classic and understated. Straight sides, no pattern, just a solid rocks glass. Sometimes simple is better, especially when the drink itself is the star.
Libbey Province 16-Piece Tumbler and Rocks Glass Set
Keep these for special occasions. They're hefty, the cut pattern is traditional without being fussy, and they make even a Tuesday night drink feel like a celebration. Handle with care though.
Paksh Novelty 7-Piece Italian Glass Decanter & Whisky
Snag this one if you're the type who likes drinking alone with a book. The angled design sits nicely in your hand, and the crystal is thin enough that you can feel the cold of the drink through it.
Viski Raye Vintage Coupe Glasses
Garnishes and Finishing Touches
I used to skip the garnish entirely because it felt unnecessary. Turns out the orange peel isn't decoration. The oils change the aroma and the cherry adds a little sweetness at the end that ties everything together.
Throw away whatever neon red cherries are in your fridge right now. These taste like actual fruit, not candy. One at the bottom of your Old Fashioned and suddenly the last sip is the best one.
LUXARDO The Original Maraschino Cherries - 105.8 oz
Grab these if Luxardo is sold out or you want to spend a little less. They're darker, slightly more tart, and hold up well in a cocktail. I keep a jar in the fridge at all times.
Tillen Farms Bada Bing Cherries, 13.5 Oz.
Use these when you want the cherry to taste boozy. They're soaked in bourbon and vanilla, so they complement an Old Fashioned instead of competing with it. Worth the splurge for a party.
Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. Bourbon Cocktail Cherries 16 oz Jars
Peel a strip of zest, express the oils over the drink by squeezing it skin-side down, then drop it in. Fresh orange peel smells incredible and changes the whole experience. Don't skip this step.
Weee
Keep these in your pantry for when you're out of fresh oranges. They float on top of the drink and look like something from a cocktail bar. Guests always ask where I got them.
150 Dehydrated Orange, Lemon & Lime Citrus Slices
Pair these with Woodford bourbon for a matchy thing that actually works flavor-wise. They're plump, sweet without being cloying, and come in a nice jar you can leave out on your bar cart.
Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries
Wet the rim of your glass and dip it in this for a sugar rim variation. It's not traditional, but for a sweeter Old Fashioned on a special night, it adds a nice touch that surprises people.
365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Cane Sugar