Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Replaced My Terrible Toaster and Every Slice Comes Out Perfect
55
items You know that thing where one side of your toast is golden brown and the other side is barely warm? I lived with that for years. Tried flipping bread halfway through like some kind of breakfast line cook. If you're tired of babysitting your toaster e...
Sections
11
Toasters That Actually Toast Both Sides Evenly
Toaster Ovens for People Who Outgrew a Pop-Up Toaster
Bread That's Worth Toasting Right
Butter and Spreads That Hit Different on Warm Toast
Kitchen Timers and Gadgets for Precise Toasting
Crumb Catchers and Cleaning Supplies for Toaster Maintenance
Toasters That Actually Toast Both Sides Evenly
This was the whole reason I started this rabbit hole. My old toaster had one glowing element and one that seemed decorative. These all passed my side-by-side bread test on the first try.
Grab this if you make breakfast for more than just yourself. Four slots, and every single one toasted my sourdough evenly. My old 2-slice toaster couldn't even handle one slot properly.
Cuisinart 4 Slice Metal Classic Toaster
Perfect for anyone on a budget who just wants toast that looks the same on both sides. Paid under $25 and it outperformed the $80 toaster I had before. Wild.
Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster
Toss in a thick bagel and it actually fits without getting stuck. My last toaster practically held bagels hostage. This one has a lift lever that actually works, which apparently is a lot to ask.
BLACK+DECKER, Toaster, 2-Slice, Extra Wide Slots
Use this if you're particular about shade consistency. I ran six slices through it back to back and every one came out the same golden brown. No more toast roulette.
Oster 2 Slice Toaster Stainless Steel
Swap to this from whatever cheap toaster you got in college. The build quality is noticeably heavier, and the even heating made me realize I'd been eating half-raw toast for a decade.
KitchenAid 2-Slice Toaster with Manual Lift Lever, Onyx Black
Toaster Ovens for People Who Outgrew a Pop-Up Toaster
Once I started caring about even toasting, I realized a toaster oven opens up a whole new world. Reheating pizza alone justified the counter space.
Keep this on your counter if you hate preheating a full oven for one piece of garlic bread. It toasts evenly, broils, bakes, and takes up less space than my coffee maker.
Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Toaster Oven Review
Try this if you want a toaster oven and air fryer without buying two appliances. Reheated day-old fries came out crispy, not soggy. That alone sold me.
Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Get this if you regularly cook for four or more people. Fit a whole frozen pizza inside and the cheese melted evenly across every inch. My regular oven couldn't even do that.
Oster® Extra Large Digital Countertop Oven
For anyone in a small apartment who needs one appliance to do everything. Toasts, bakes, broils. I made toast and then roasted vegetables in the same hour without breaking a sweat.
BLACK+DECKER, Toaster Oven, 4 Slices ...
Pair this with a good sheet pan and you might stop using your regular oven entirely. I baked cookies in it last Tuesday just to see if I could. They came out perfect.
Cuisinart Custom Classic Toaster Oven Broiler, TOB-40NNAS
Bread That's Worth Toasting Right
After I got a toaster that actually worked, I realized my bread choices were lazy. Good bread in a good toaster is a completely different breakfast.
Snag a loaf if you want toast that actually fills you up until lunch. Thick slices, nutty flavor, and it toasts beautifully without drying out. Changed my whole morning.
Dave's Killer Bread 21 Whole Grains and Seeds Organic
Try this for anyone who grew up on white bread and wants something that still feels nostalgic but has more substance. Toasts to a perfect crunch without going stale in two days.
Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Hearty White Bread, 24 oz Loaf
Keep a loaf around for the person in your house who says they don't like wheat bread. The honey makes it just sweet enough that my picky kid eats it without complaining.
Nature's Own 100% Whole Wheat Bread
Use a toaster with wide slots for these. When they're toasted right, all those nooks and crannies hold butter like tiny delicious pools. I go through a pack a week now.
Customer reviews for Thomas' Original English Muffins
Grab this if you want sandwich bread that also toasts well. Soft enough for PB&J but sturdy enough to hold up under a toaster's heat without collapsing. Solid all-rounder.
Sara Lee Artesano Brioche Bakery Bread
Butter and Spreads That Hit Different on Warm Toast
I never understood fancy butter people until I had properly toasted bread. Now I get it. The right spread on warm, evenly toasted bread is an actual experience.
Spread this on hot toast and watch it melt into every pore of the bread. I used to buy store brand butter and thought it was fine. It was not fine. This ruined me in the best way.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Salted Pure Irish Butter, 8 oz.
For anyone with a sweet tooth who wants breakfast to feel like a reward. Warm toast plus Nutella is the reason I get out of bed some mornings. Not exaggerating.
The One Nutella Alternative We Didn't Want To Stop Eating
Toss your old jar of overly processed peanut butter. This one is just peanuts and salt, and on warm toast it gets melty and rich. Took me 30 years to try the natural stuff.
Laura Scudder's All Natural Nutty Peanut Butter, 26 oz Jar
Use this on a toasted bagel or English muffin and you'll wonder why you ever ate cream cheese on cold bread. The warmth softens it perfectly. No more tearing your bagel apart.
Philadelphia Original Brick Cream Cheese
Pair this with the Kerrygold butter on sourdough toast. I'm not being dramatic when I say this combination made me late for work because I stood in my kitchen savoring it.
Customer reviews for Smucker's Strawberry Jelly
Kitchen Timers and Gadgets for Precise Toasting
Some mornings I'd put bread in the toaster and then wander off to find my keys. Burned toast smell greeted me at the door more than once. These fixed my attention span problem.
Keep this on your counter if you're the type who starts toasting bread then checks your phone and forgets. Loud beep, magnetic back, dead simple. Saved me from smoke detector drama.
ThermoPro TM01 Digital Kitchen Timer with Touch Backlit
Get this if you're cooking multiple things at once. Three separate timers means I can track my toast, my eggs, and my coffee all without losing my mind.
OXO Good Grips Digital Triple Kitchen Timer - Black
Try this when you're baking bread at home and want to know if it's actually done inside. Took the guesswork out completely. Bread that looks done isn't always done.
KitchenAid Digital Instant Read Thermometer
Weigh your bread ingredients if you bake at home. I switched from measuring cups to a scale and my homemade loaves went from dense bricks to actual bread. Night and day difference.
Customer reviews for Escali Primo Digital Food Scale Multi
Snag these if your measuring spoons are a tangled mess in a drawer. They nest together neatly and the color coding means I stop accidentally using a tablespoon when I need a teaspoon.
Joseph Joseph Nest 9-Piece Food Preparation Set
Crumb Catchers and Cleaning Supplies for Toaster Maintenance
Nobody tells you that a dirty toaster is why your bread tastes weird. I pulled out my old crumb tray after two years and it looked like a crime scene. Never again.
Use the small brush to get into toaster slots where crumbs hide. I pulled out enough debris to build a small sandcastle. Do this monthly or suffer the consequences.
OXO GG DEEP CLEAN BRUSH SET - ORANGE
Spray this on your toaster's exterior if fingerprints drive you crazy. One wipe and it looks brand new. My stainless steel toaster was covered in smudges until I found this.
Weiman 22 oz. Stainless Steel Cleaner and Polish Spray
Perfect for sweeping crumbs off the counter after you empty the toaster tray. Small enough to store in a drawer, actually picks up crumbs instead of pushing them around.
Full Circle Tiny Team Mini Brush and Dustpan Set Gray
Grab a pack for wiping down toaster oven interiors. They clean baked-on cheese without scratching the surface. Learned the hard way that steel wool ruins non-stick coatings.
Scotch-Brite, Cleaning Sponges, Blue
Ditch harsh chemical sprays around your food appliances. This smells like actual lavender, cleans grease off toaster ovens, and I don't worry about chemical residue near my breakfast.
Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day Multi-Surface Everyday Cleaner
Plates and Serveware That Make Breakfast Feel Intentional
Eating toast off a paper towel while standing over the sink was my whole personality for years. Getting actual plates changed how I felt about mornings more than I expected.
Swap your chipped college plates for these. They're lightweight, nearly indestructible, and they make even basic toast and eggs look like you have your life together.
Corelle Winter Frost White 10.25" Glass Dinner Plate
Use these smaller plates for toast and it tricks your brain into thinking you made a proper breakfast. Sounds silly but presentation matters even when nobody's watching.
Sweese Porcelain Dessert Plates
For anyone who wants their kitchen to feel warm and inviting without spending a fortune. My morning toast on these plates genuinely makes me smile. That's worth the $30.
The Pioneer Woman Vintage Floral 12-Piece Dinnerware Set
Try clear glass plates if you want something that goes with everything. I rotate between different tablecloths and these always look right. Low maintenance and dishwasher safe.
Libbey Tempo Glass Dinnerware Set
Get the whole set if you're starting from scratch. Plates, bowls, mugs. I moved into a new place last year and this one purchase covered every meal situation I had.
Better Homes & Gardens Farma 16 Piece Dinnerware Set
Coffee and Tea to Pair with Your Perfect Toast
Once my toast game improved, my coffee tasted worse by comparison. So I upgraded that too. This is how one toaster purchase spiraled into a whole kitchen overhaul.
Brew this alongside your morning toast and the smell alone will wake up everyone in the house. Smooth, not bitter, and way cheaper than buying lattes every day. My wallet noticed immediately.
Lavazza, Dolcevita Classico Ground Coffee
For the person who needs coffee that tastes like it means business. Bold enough to stand up to a heavy breakfast. I pair it with buttered sourdough and it hits every time.
STARBUCKS French Roast Dark Roast Ground Coffee Bag
Keep a box around for mornings when coffee feels like too much. Strong enough to actually taste like something, pairs perfectly with toast and jam. My British coworker approved.
Twinings English Breakfast 80 Tea Bags
Try this if you want espresso-strength coffee without buying an espresso machine. Just use a regular coffee maker and add less water. Changed my mornings for under $5 a can.
Café Bustelo ® Coffee Recipes
Snag this for chilly mornings when you want something cozy. The vanilla and spice with a piece of cinnamon raisin toast is a combination I stumbled into by accident and now repeat weekly.
Bigelow Vanilla Chai Black Tea Bags 20-Count Box
Breakfast Proteins to Round Out Your Toast Routine
Toast alone wasn't keeping me full past 10 AM. Adding protein turned breakfast from a snack into an actual meal that carried me through the morning without reaching for vending machine chips.
Toss these in the microwave while your bread toasts. Ready in 60 seconds, lower fat than regular sausage, and my kids eat them without knowing they're turkey. Stealth health win.
Jimmy Dean Fully Cooked Turkey Sausage Links
Fry one egg, put it on toast, add hot sauce. That's the breakfast that got me to stop skipping mornings entirely. These eggs have noticeably more orange yolks than generic brands.
Eggland's Best Extra Large White Eggs, 18 Count
For anyone who wants bacon without the weird ingredient list. Tastes like actual bacon, not chemicals shaped like bacon. Crisp a few strips while your toast is going.
Applegate Uncured Sunday Bacon
Grab these for mornings when you don't have time to cook but still need protein. I keep them in the fridge and eat one alongside toast when I'm running out the door.
Sargento® Balanced Breaks® Cheese & Crackers
Pair a cup of this with toast instead of eating toast alone. The protein keeps you full and it's not cloyingly sweet like most flavored yogurts. Vanilla flavor is the winner.
Chobani Wild Blueberry Less Sugar Greek Yogurt
Storage Solutions to Keep Bread Fresh Longer
Nothing is more annoying than buying good bread and finding it moldy two days later. I was basically donating half my bread to the trash can until I sorted out storage.
Keep your bread in this instead of on top of the fridge where it dries out. Fits standard loaves, keeps them fresh noticeably longer, and costs less than one wasted loaf of good bread.
(2 pack) Buddeez Sandwich Size Bread Buddy Dispenser
Use these for homemade bread or rolls. The airtight seal actually works. My banana bread lasted five days instead of the usual two before going stale. Worth every penny.
Rubbermaid Brilliance Plastic Food Storage Container, 2.3 L (9.6 Cup), 1 Pack
Wrap your artisan bread in foil before storing it. Sounds old school but my grandmother was right about this one. Keeps the crust from getting chewy and weird.
Does It Matter Which Side of Aluminum Foil You Use? We
Freeze half your loaf the day you buy it. Pull out slices as needed and toast them straight from frozen. My toaster has a frozen setting and the bread comes out like it was just bought.
Great Value Double Zipper Half Gallon Freezer Bag
Snag this if you want something that looks nicer on the counter than a plastic bag. Adjustable vent keeps bread at the right humidity. Sounds fancy but it genuinely works.
Progressive Prep Works Bread Pro Keeper Expandable 12
Countertop Organization for a Less Chaotic Kitchen
My toaster used to sit on top of a pile of mail next to a tangle of cords. Clearing the counter around it made breakfast feel less like a survival situation and more like a routine I enjoy.
Use this inside a cabinet to stack plates and bowls so your counter stays clear for appliances. I freed up enough space to actually use my toaster without moving three things first.
SimpleHouseware Kitchen Cabinet & Counter Organizer
Put this above your toaster to store bread, spreads, and your coffee mug. Everything within arm's reach, nothing cluttering the counter. Installed it in 15 minutes with basic tools.
WALI Wall Mounted Media Floating Shelf System
Drop this in your utensil drawer so you can actually find a butter knife in the morning. My old drawer was chaos. Now I grab what I need without rummaging around half-awake.
madesmart Classic Large Silverware Tray with Soft Grip
For anyone who has a cabinet full of lids that avalanche out every time you open the door. This keeps them vertical and organized. My blood pressure dropped after installing it.
YouCopia StoraLid® Food Container Lid Organizer
Stick these inside cabinet doors to hang measuring cups and small tools. No drilling, no damage, and suddenly I have drawer space I didn't know existed. Renter-friendly too.
Command Large Utility Hook, Damage Free Hanging