Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried 12 Olive Oils and These Beat the Pricey Specialty Brands
32
items Sick of spending $18 on a tiny bottle of olive oil that tastes the same as the last disappointment? I went through a dozen bottles, drizzled them on bread, cooked with them, made dressings, and ranked them like my life depended on it. This is for any...
Sections
8
Everyday Cooking Olive Oils That Actually Taste Good
Finishing Oils Worth Drizzling on Everything
Organic Olive Oils That Don't Taste Like Cardboard
Olive Oils for Homemade Salad Dressings
High-Heat Cooking Oils for Searing and Roasting
Infused Olive Oils for Lazy Flavor Shortcuts
Everyday Cooking Olive Oils That Actually Taste Good
I used to just grab whatever was on sale and wonder why my food tasted flat. These changed how my weeknight dinners turned out, and none of them cost more than a decent lunch.
Swap this in for whatever generic bottle is sitting in your cabinet right now. I started using it for sauteing vegetables and my partner asked if I took a cooking class. Mild enough that it won't overpower chicken or fish. Grab a big bottle because y...
Pompeian Olive Oil: Blind Tasted & Reviewed By Experts
Keep this one next to the stove. It handles heat better than most EVOOs I tried, and it has this peppery finish that makes even scrambled eggs taste like you tried. Perfect for anyone cooking on autopilot after a long day.
Bertolli, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 16.9 fl oz, Rich Taste
Before you roll your eyes at the store brand, try it blind against a $15 bottle. I did exactly that at a dinner party and nobody picked the expensive one. For anyone on a budget who still wants real olive oil flavor, this is the move.
Great Value: 100% Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 25.5 fl oz
Use this when you're making anything Italian and want it to taste like it came from a real kitchen, not a jar. I drizzled it over pasta with garlic and red pepper flakes and my roommate literally stood up to get seconds. Stock up because it goes on s...
Filippo Berio Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Finishing Oils Worth Drizzling on Everything
This is where olive oil stops being a cooking ingredient and starts being the whole point of the dish. I never understood finishing oils until I tried these on fresh bread with salt.
Drizzle this on warm sourdough with flaky salt and tell me you don't feel like you're on vacation. Bright, grassy, a little fruity. For anyone who thinks olive oil is boring, this bottle will change your mind in one bite.
Extra Virgin Olive Oil Destination Series Everyday
Try this over a caprese salad or fresh mozzarella. It has a stronger, almost spicy kick that stands up to bold flavors. I poured it over roasted tomatoes last week and genuinely considered licking the plate. Not subtle, which is exactly the point.
Pompeian Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 68 fl oz
Bring this out when company comes over. It tastes like it should cost twice what it does. I put it next to bread at a dinner and watched three people fight over the last piece. Smooth with a buttery finish that works on literally any appetizer.
Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 34 fl oz
Snag this if you want something lighter for salads but still want olive oil flavor. The avocado oil blend gives it this silky texture that coats greens without making them soggy. My go-to for anyone who says they hate salad dressing.
Chosen Foods Extra Virgin Olive Oil/Avocado Oil
Organic Olive Oils That Don't Taste Like Cardboard
Half the organic oils I tried tasted like I was drinking lawn water. These are the ones that actually justified the organic label with real flavor.
Grab this if you care about organic but refuse to sacrifice taste for a label. Slightly fruity, smooth, zero bitterness. I switched from a $20 organic bottle to this and honestly couldn't tell the difference except in my bank account.
Pompeian Organic Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 16 fl oz
Use this for cold dishes where you can really taste the oil. It has this clean, almost nutty flavor that works so well in hummus and grain bowls. For anyone who's been burned by bland organic options, this one actually delivers.
Bionaturae Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 25.4 fl oz (750 ml)
Pour this into a dipping bowl with herbs and balsamic and watch people hover around it all night. It's got a delicate, almost floral quality that doesn't scream in your face. Wish I'd found it before wasting money on three other organic bottles.
La Tourangelle Bold Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Organic 25.4 fl oz
Keep this as your daily driver organic option. Nothing flashy, just consistently good olive oil that works in everything from marinades to baking. Perfect for anyone who wants organic without overthinking every grocery trip.
365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Olive Oils for Homemade Salad Dressings
Store-bought dressing was my crutch until I realized oil plus acid plus seasoning takes 30 seconds. These oils make vinaigrettes that taste like you actually know what you're doing.
Use this when you want the dressing flavor to come from herbs and citrus, not the oil itself. It steps back and lets everything else shine. Perfect for anyone making Asian-inspired or citrus dressings where strong olive flavor would clash.
Bertolli Olive Oil, Extra Light Taste, 25.4 fl oz
Toss this with red wine vinegar, Dijon, and a pinch of sugar. That's it. My salads went from sad desk lunch to something I actually look forward to. For anyone still buying bottled Italian dressing, please try this instead.
Star Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 3 Liter Jug
Pair this with lemon juice and garlic for a Greek-style dressing that coats greens perfectly. Not too thick, not too thin. I make a big jar on Sunday and it lasts all week. Saves money and tastes ten times better than anything in a squeeze bottle.
Pompeian Smooth Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 68 fl oz
Whisk this into balsamic with a little honey and you've got the dressing that made my coworkers start asking for the recipe. Slightly peppery, which gives dressings a nice bite. For anyone trying to eat more salads without hating every bite.
Woolworths Extra Virgin Olive Oil 500mL
High-Heat Cooking Oils for Searing and Roasting
Not every olive oil can handle a hot pan without smoking up your kitchen and setting off the alarm. I learned that the hard way. These ones hold up.
Throw this in a screaming hot skillet and it won't punish you with smoke. I seared salmon at high heat and got a perfect crust without my fire alarm going off for once. Built for anyone who cooks aggressively and needs oil that keeps up.
Pompeian Smooth Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 32 fl oz
Use this for roasting vegetables at 425 degrees. Broccoli, sweet potatoes, Brussels sprouts, all came out crispy and golden without any burnt oil taste. For anyone who keeps ending up with soggy roasted veggies, the oil might be your problem.
Bertolli Olive Oil, Extra Light Taste, 25.4 fl oz
Keep this one specifically for high-heat cooking. It's refined so it handles temperature without breaking down, but still tastes like actual olive oil, not vegetable oil pretending. Grabbed it on a whim and now it's permanently in my rotation.
Chosen Foods Extra Virgin Olive Oil/Avocado Oil
Swap this in for canola or vegetable oil next time you're pan-frying. Lighter than extra virgin but still brings real flavor. I used it to make crispy fried eggs and the edges got that lacy crunch that makes mornings worth waking up for.
Filippo Berio Extra Virgin Olive Oil 500ml
Infused Olive Oils for Lazy Flavor Shortcuts
When I'm too tired to mince garlic or chop herbs, these do the heavy lifting. One pour and dinner tastes like I spent an hour on it.
Drizzle this on pasta when you're too exhausted to peel a single clove. Real garlic flavor without any prep. I tossed it with spaghetti, parmesan, and black pepper at 11pm and it tasted like I planned it. For every tired cook out there.
Pompeian Smooth Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 16 fl oz
Try this on pizza straight out of the oven. The roasted garlic flavor is mellow, not sharp, so it adds depth without overwhelming the cheese. Brought it to a pizza night and someone literally asked where I was hiding it.
Colavita Roasted Garlic Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 32 Fluid Ounce
Pour this over grilled fish or shrimp and skip the lemon-squeezing step entirely. Bright and citrusy without tasting artificial. For anyone who wants weeknight seafood to taste like a restaurant but can't be bothered with extra steps.
Mantova Grand'Aroma Lemon Flavored Extra Virgin Olive
Toss this with fresh tomatoes and mozzarella when you don't have fresh basil on hand. It tastes surprisingly close to the real thing. I keep it in the pantry for emergency caprese situations, which happen more often than I'd like to admit.
Mantova Grand' Aroma Basil Flavored Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Olive Oils for Baking That Won't Wreck Your Cake
People looked at me funny when I said I bake with olive oil. Then they tasted the cake. Butter has its place, but these oils make baked goods ridiculously moist.
Swap this for vegetable oil in any baking recipe and nobody will know the difference, except the texture will be better. I made brownies with it and they came out fudgy in a way that box mix never achieves. For anyone trying to cut out seed oils in b...
Bertolli Olive Oil, Extra Light Taste, 25.4 fl oz
Use this in banana bread and watch it come out so moist you'll think you did something wrong. Neutral enough that you won't taste olive in your muffins. Grabbed it after my banana bread kept drying out and haven't looked back since.
Pompeian Light Taste Olive Oil for Baking - 16 fl oz
Try this in a citrus olive oil cake and prepare to feel like a pastry chef. It has just enough fruitiness to complement lemon or orange without competing. For anyone intimidated by olive oil cakes, this bottle makes it foolproof.
California Olive Ranch Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Keep this around for cookies and quick breads when you want a clean, neutral oil that won't alter the flavor. I tested it against canola in chocolate chip cookies and the olive oil batch had better texture every single time. Wish I'd made the switch ...
Star Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 3 Liter Jug
Gift-Worthy Olive Oil Sets That Don't Look Cheap
Every holiday I used to panic about what to bring the host who has everything. A nice olive oil set solves that problem and people actually use it, unlike another candle.
Bring this to a housewarming and watch the host's face light up. Three different flavors so they can actually experiment. Way more thoughtful than wine and costs about the same. For anyone who needs a last-minute gift that doesn't look last-minute.
The Health Benefits and Quality Indicators of Extra Virgin
Grab this for the person who loves cooking but already owns every gadget. The tin packaging looks expensive and the oil inside is genuinely good. I gave one to my mother-in-law and she called me to say she used it on everything for a week straight.
(Price/Case)Colavita Extra Virgin Olive Oil Tin 3 Liter
Toss this into a gift basket with pasta and good cheese. The spray format is surprisingly handy and people who've never used one always get excited about it. Perfect for anyone assembling a homemade food gift without spending a fortune.
Pack of 6, Mantova Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray, 8.5 oz
Pair this with a loaf of crusty bread and fancy salt for a host gift that takes five minutes to assemble but looks like you put real thought into it. The bottle design is pretty enough to leave on a counter. Saved me during three different holiday di...
La Tourangelle Bold Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Organic 25.4 fl oz