Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried 12 Self Tanners and These Actually Fade Without Turning Orange
45
items Spent two years looking like a streaky sweet potato every time I tried to get a glow without UV damage. Patchy knees, orange palms, weird leopard spots on my ankles. If you've ever scrubbed yourself raw in the shower trying to fix a bad self tan, thi...
Sections
9
Self Tanners That Actually Look Like Real Skin
Prep Products That Prevent Patchiness
Application Tools That Actually Make a Difference
Self Tanners for Your Face That Won't Break You Out
Bronzers to Fake It While Your Tan Develops
Tan Extending Products That Buy You Extra Days
Self Tanners That Actually Look Like Real Skin
Every bottle I bought promised ‘natural looking color’ and then turned me into a traffic cone. These are the ones where people genuinely asked if I went on vacation instead of asking what happened to my skin.
Start with this if you're terrified of commitment. It builds so gradually that you can stop the second you hit your sweet spot. My coworker didn't even notice until day four, which is exactly the point.
Jergens Natural Glow Firming Daily Moisturizer
Grab this for a weekend where you want to look sun-kissed by Monday. Goes on clear so you won't stain your white sheets. Faded off my shins evenly for the first time in my self tanning life.
Purity Gel
Use this the night before a beach day. Dries in minutes, doesn't transfer to your dress, and the shimmer is subtle enough that you won't look like a disco ball. For anyone who hates sticky formulas.
Bondi Sands Self Tanning Liquid Gold Dry to Oil Spray
Toss your old drugstore tanner and try this instead. The mousse texture makes it almost impossible to streak if you use a mitt. Faded off my arms like a natural tan would after about five days.
L'Oreal Paris Sublime Bronze Water Mousse
Keep this in your bathroom for lazy maintenance. Mix a few drops into your moisturizer and you get a low-effort glow that never crosses into orange territory. Wish someone had told me about this approach years ago.
TAN-LUXE The Water Mini - Hydrating Self-Tan Water, 100ml
Prep Products That Prevent Patchiness
Learned the hard way that self tanner is only as good as the skin underneath it. Skipping prep is why your knees and elbows look like they belong to a different person.
Scrub down with this the night before you tan. Seriously, the night before, not the morning of. Gives your skin time to calm down so the tanner grabs evenly instead of clinging to dry patches.
Tree Hut Coconut Lime Shea Butter Sugar Body Scrub, 18 oz
Switch to this in the shower for the week leading up to your tan. The salicylic acid dissolves dead skin without being harsh. My legs went from scaly to smooth and the tanner went on like butter.
CeraVe SA Body Wash For Rough & Bumpy Skin 10 oz
Pair this with a silicone scrubber for spots that always go wrong. Ankles, wrists, knuckle creases. Gentle enough to use twice a week without irritating sensitive skin.
Dove, Exfoliating Body Scrub, 15 oz, Macadamia Rice Milk
Slather this on elbows, knees, and knuckles right before applying tanner. Creates a barrier so those dry areas don't absorb too much color. This one trick fixed my perpetually dark kneecap problem.
Eucerin Advanced Repair Body Lotion 16.9 fl oz Pack of 3
Use this on your whole body the day before tanning. Hydrated skin takes color more evenly, period. Lightweight enough that it won't leave a film that blocks the tanner from developing.
Hydro Boost Body Lotion Gel Cream With Hyaluronic Acid
Application Tools That Actually Make a Difference
Spent my first year using bare hands and wondering why my palms looked like I'd been picking pumpkins. The right tools cut my application time in half and eliminated most of my mistakes.
Grab one of these before your first application. Night and day difference compared to bare hands. The velvet side blends everything seamlessly and your palms stay completely clean.
EcoTools Good Tan Full-Body Tanning Mitt
Use a damp one of these around your hairline, ears, and jawline. Blends out the edges so you don't get that obvious line where tan meets no-tan. Tiny step that makes a huge difference.
Real Techniques Expert Air Cushion Makeup Sponge
Keep a spare just for your hands and feet. Dab lightly over knuckles and between toes where color loves to pool. Costs almost nothing and saves you from the dead giveaway spots.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Blending Sponge
Toss this in the shower when it's time to start fading out your tan. Way more effective than a regular washcloth. Gets the old color off evenly so you're not left with weird patches.
Kitsch Eco Friendly Exfoliating Body Glove
Swap between the gentle and rough sides depending on the area. Rough for shins and arms, gentle for chest and stomach. Keeps everything fading at the same rate instead of in random blotches.
Cleanlogic Detoxify Dual-Texture Body Buffer
Self Tanners for Your Face That Won't Break You Out
Put body tanner on my face exactly once. Woke up with three new cystic bumps and a shade that didn't match my neck. Face formulas exist for a reason and these ones respect your pores.
Perfect for someone who wants the absolute lowest effort face tan possible. Wear it like your normal moisturizer. Takes about three days to notice and nobody will clock it as self tanner.
Jergens, Face Moisturizer, SPF 20, Natural Glow
Mix two drops into your night cream and wake up slightly bronzed. You control the intensity completely. Started with one drop because I was paranoid and worked up from there.
L'Oreal Paris Sublime Bronze Self-Tanning Facial Drops
Spritz this over your makeup or bare skin for a quick refresh. Doesn't disrupt what's underneath and dries in seconds. For anyone who needs their face to match their body tan mid-week.
St. Tropez Face Self Tan Purity Bronzing Water Mist, 2.7 Fl oz
Tear one in half and swipe it across your face when you're in a rush. Even application without needing a mirror or mitt. Threw these in my gym bag for touch-ups after the original tan starts fading.
Tan Towel Half Body Classic Self Tanner Towelette, 5 Ct
Snag this to keep your lips looking alive when the rest of your face has color. Pale lips against tan skin looks off. This adds just enough warmth without being obviously lipstick.
Meet The £6 Lip Product Margot Robbie Used In ...
Bronzers to Fake It While Your Tan Develops
Most self tanners need 6 to 8 hours to develop. These keep you from looking ghostly during the wait so you can actually leave your house without feeling weird.
Wear this while your tan develops underneath. Smells like vacation, blends with zero effort, and photographs like actual sun on your cheekbones. For anyone who can't pull off matte bronzer without looking muddy.
Physicians Formula, Murumuru Butter Bronzer
Try the lighter shade even if you think you need medium. Builds up without going overboard. Saved me on the day between applying tanner and it fully developing when I had dinner plans.
Maybelline City Bronzer Contour Powder Makeup
Use a fluffy brush and dust this on your forehead, nose, and chin. The places the sun would actually hit. Looks convincing even on very fair skin where most bronzers just look like dirt.
NYX Professional Makeup Matte Buttermelt Bronzer
Dab this on with your fingers for a dewy bronze that blends into skin instead of sitting on top. Creamy texture works better than powder when you want that just-got-back-from-the-beach look.
elf Putty Blush Tan Lines
Swirl a kabuki brush over this and hit your collarbones, shoulders, and shins. The subtle shimmer catches light in photos and bridges the gap until your self tanner kicks in fully.
Milani Baked Bronzer, Glow
Tan Extending Products That Buy You Extra Days
Nothing worse than putting in all that work and watching your glow disappear in three days. These stretched my results from four days to over a week without reapplying.
Slather this on right after every shower while your skin is still damp. Locks in moisture so your tan doesn't flake off in chunks. Smells incredible and doesn't feel greasy under clothes.
Hempz
Keep this on your nightstand and apply before bed. Your tan fades fastest on dry skin, and this keeps everything hydrated through the night. Thick formula but absorbs faster than you'd expect.
Palmer's Cocoa Butter Formula Daily Skin Therapy Body
Use this as your everyday body lotion between tanning sessions. Fragrance free so it won't react weirdly with your tanner. My tan lasted two full extra days when I was consistent with this.
Aveeno, Daily Moisturizing Body Lotion, 18 fl oz
Swap to this when your tan starts fading on day four or five. Builds back just enough color to extend the life without having to do a full reapplication. Low maintenance rescue move.
Banana Boat, Self-Tanning Lotion, Deep Dark, 6 fl oz, 2 Pack
Grab this for your legs specifically. They always fade first because of shaving and friction from jeans. This one has a tiny hint of shimmer that makes fading tan look more intentional.
Vaseline, Cocoa Radiant Body Lotion, 20.3 Fl oz, for Dry Skin
Tan Removal for When Things Go Wrong
Made a catastrophic streaky mistake at 11pm before a wedding once. Panic-Googled removal methods at midnight. These products are my emergency kit now and they've bailed me out more than once.
Use this in the shower with a rough washcloth on the worst streak areas. It's aggressive, which is exactly what you want when you have orange stripes down your forearm at 7am.
St. Ives Fresh Skin Exfoliating Face Scrub
The salicylic acid in this breaks down self tanner faster than regular body wash. Lather it on, let it sit for a minute, then scrub. Got a botched ankle situation sorted in two showers.
Neutrogena Acne Body Wash - 8.5 fl oz
Soak the patchy areas in this for 20 minutes before showering. The oil loosens the tanner's grip on your skin so it comes off more evenly when you scrub. Old trick that actually works.
Baby Oil 125ml - johnson&johnson
Pair this with an exfoliating glove for gentle but effective removal on sensitive areas like your chest and inner arms. Less abrasive than a scrub but still gets the job done overnight.
Dove Beauty Bar White, 4.75oz, 10 Pack
Hear me out. Dampen it slightly and gently swipe over stained palms, nail beds, or between fingers. Works in seconds. Just don't press hard or use it on your face. Palms only, trust me.
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Extra Durable All Purpose Pads, 7ct
Body Shimmer and Glow Products to Layer On Top
A good self tan is the base layer. These go on top for events, date nights, or anytime you want your legs to look like they cost money. The difference between nice tan and wow tan.
Rub this into your legs before going out. The shimmer is subtle gold, not glitter, and the scent alone gets compliments. For anyone who wants their tan to look expensive without trying hard.
Sol de Janeiro Brazilian Bum Bum Cream, 8.1 oz
Try this for a daytime glow that doesn't scream shimmer. Smooths over any minor imperfections in your tan and makes skin look polished. Works under a sundress without transferring.
Jergens Natural Glow Daily Moisturizer Medium To Tan
Mix a pump into your body lotion for collarbones and shoulders. Catches light perfectly in photos. Wore this to an outdoor wedding and got asked if I just came back from Italy.
NYX Professional Makeup Born to Glow Liquid Illuminator
Layer this under your shimmer product for extra hydration and staying power. Smells like dessert and makes your skin feel like velvet. The shimmer products last longer on moisturized skin.
Soap and Glory, Body Butter, 10.1 oz
Dust this on your shoulders and the tops of your cheekbones with a fan brush. Cheap, blendable, and shows up beautifully on tan skin. Nobody needs to know it cost less than a coffee.
wet n wild, Highlighting Powder, Precious Petals, 0.19 fl oz
Clothes and Accessories That Look Better With a Tan
Half the reason I self tan is because certain colors in my closet only work when I have some color. These are the pieces I reach for the second my tan develops.
White shorts and a tan is the combo that makes you look like you live somewhere warm year round. These are cheap enough that if tanner transfers slightly, you won't cry about it.
Hanes Women`s Jersey Pocket Short, S, Navy
Grab a few in white and light blue. Both colors pop against bronzed skin and these fit well without costing much. Perfect for showing off your shoulders and collarbone work.
Time and Tru Women's Ribbed Tank Top, Sizes XS-XXXL
Throw an oversized linen shirt over a tank or swimsuit. The natural fabric photographs beautifully against tan skin. Works for beach days and casual dinners equally well.
Coorders Mens Linen Shirt, Men's Regular-Fit Short Sleeve
Open shoes show off a good foot and ankle tan. Skip closed-toe shoes when your tan is fresh so you can actually enjoy the results. These are simple enough to go with everything.
No Boundaries Women's Strappy Flat Sandals
Keep your hair up for the first few hours after applying tanner to your face and neck. Nothing ruins a fresh application like hair sticking to wet product. Toss a few in your bathroom drawer.
Scunci No Damage Elastic Hair Bands, Brown, 1 Ea