Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Fragrance Oils I Mix and Match Because Single-Scent Candles Bored Me to Death
36
items Pouring candles with just one fragrance felt like cooking with only salt — technically fine but deeply uninspiring. After burning through dozens of flat, one-note candles I made myself, I started blending fragrance oils like a mad scientist and never...
Sections
12
Floral Fragrance Oils That Actually Smell Like Flowers
Warm and Spicy Oils for Fall and Winter Candles
Fresh and Clean Scents for Year-Round Burning
Woodsy and Earthy Oils for Grounding Blends
Citrus Fragrance Oils That Wake Up a Room
Sweet Gourmand Oils for Dessert-Scented Candles
Floral Fragrance Oils That Actually Smell Like Flowers
Most floral oils smell like your grandma's bathroom air freshener, and I say that with love for grandma. These actually capture real petals without that synthetic punch to the nose.
Grab this set if you've been disappointed by floral oils that smell like plastic roses — the gardenia and jasmine in here blend beautifully with almost anything woody. Took me three failed batches to find florals worth using.
Floral Set of 6 Fragrance Oils - Premium Grade Scented Oil
Use this when you want a rose that doesn't scream ‘hotel lobby soap.’ I mix two drops with a sandalwood base and people genuinely stop and ask what candle I'm burning. Perfect for anyone who thinks they hate rose scents.
Rose Fragrance Oil - Premium Grade Scented Oil - 100ml
Pair this with vanilla or coconut for a warm floral that fills a room without giving anyone a headache. My sister, who gets migraines from strong scents, actually requests this blend whenever she visits.
P&J Trading Fresh Cotton Fragrance Oil
Warm and Spicy Oils for Fall and Winter Candles
September hits and suddenly every candle I own needs to smell like a bakery crossed with a fireplace. These are the spicy oils I reach for when the temperature drops.
Swap out whatever cinnamon oil you're currently using — this one doesn't have that fake Red Hots candy smell. I blend it with orange peel oil and it's the closest thing to walking into a holiday market.
Customer reviews for P&J Trading Fragrance Oil
Try this before you write off pumpkin spice as basic — mixed with a little clove, it's warm without being a PSL parody. Sold four candles to coworkers last October using this exact blend.
Mainstays Universal Fragrance Oil, Pumpkin Spice, 5 fl oz
Keep this one on hand for holiday gifts — I mixed it with vanilla last December and my neighbor asked if I was actually baking. For anyone tired of generic ‘holiday’ scents that all smell identical.
Gingerbread Fragrance Oil - Premium Grade Scented Oil
Fresh and Clean Scents for Year-Round Burning
Not every candle needs to smell like dessert. Sometimes you just want your apartment to stop smelling like last night's fish tacos, and these handle that beautifully.
Use this if your goal is ‘my house smells like clean laundry’ without the effort of actually doing laundry. I pour these for my bathroom and they outsell every other scent at my craft fairs.
P&J Trading Clean & Fresh Fragrance Oil
Toss a few drops of this into a coconut wax blend and your living room suddenly feels like a beach house you definitely can't afford. Great for anyone making spring or summer candles.
Good Essential Oils, Fragrance Oil Set
Snag this if you love that petrichor smell but can't exactly bottle a thunderstorm. Blends surprisingly well with eucalyptus — I stumbled on that combo by accident and it's now my bestseller.
Customer reviews for P&J Trading Fragrance Oil
Woodsy and Earthy Oils for Grounding Blends
I went through a phase where every candle I made smelled like cake. These woody oils pulled me back to something more grounded and honestly more interesting.
Pair this with literally any floral and you've got a candle that smells expensive. My first batch with this outsold everything else at a local market — wish I'd found it six months earlier.
P&J Trading Nature Set of 6 Premium Grade Fragrance Oils
Get this for that cozy cabin vibe without actually having to leave your apartment. I layer it with a touch of vanilla and it's the candle equivalent of a flannel blanket.
cedarwood essential oil organic aromatherapy 100% pure
Switch to this if your woody candles have been smelling flat — teakwood has a richness that sandalwood alone can't hit. Perfect for anyone making candles marketed toward guys who claim they don't care about candles but absolutely do.
Gentlemen's Set of 6 Premium Grade Fragrance Oils
Citrus Fragrance Oils That Wake Up a Room
When my candles started all smelling heavy and musky, citrus oils saved me. A few drops of these brighten any blend like adding lemon to water.
Grab this if your kitchen candles have been falling flat — lemon cuts through cooking smells better than anything else I've tried. I mix it with basil oil for a combo that makes people think I have my life together.
P&J Trading Lemongrass Fragrance Oil
Try blending this with cinnamon or clove for a citrus-spice combo that works October through March. One drop too many and it goes from ‘warm evening’ to ‘orange juice factory,’ so measure carefully.
Mainstays Sweet Orange Essential Oil, 15 mL, 1 Pack
Use this for summer candles or anytime you need something that doesn't smell like everyone else's vanilla-everything lineup. Mixed with mint, it's basically a spa day in candle form — took me embarrassingly long to figure that out.
P&J Trading Fresh Cut Wood Fragrance Oil
Sweet Gourmand Oils for Dessert-Scented Candles
These are the oils responsible for every visitor asking if I just baked something. Spoiler: I did not. The candle did all the work.
Keep this stocked at all times — it's the base of probably 70% of my blends and I've gone through five bottles. Warm, not plasticky, and plays well with basically every other oil on this list.
P&J Trading Warm Vanilla Sugar Fragrance Oil
Pair this with sea salt or coffee oils and you've got a candle that smells like a fancy dessert shop. Made one for my mom's birthday and she burned it so fast she asked for three more.
Better Homes & Gardens Vanilla Caramel Spice Fragrance
Ditch basic sugar cookie oils for this — it's deeper, warmer, and doesn't smell like a Bath & Body Works from 2009. Blends perfectly with cinnamon for a snickerdoodle candle that actually works.
Brown Sugar Fragrance Oil - Premium Grade Scented Oil
Herbal and Green Oils for Spa-Like Blends
After months of only making sweet candles, I craved something clean and herbal. These oils turned my bathroom into a place where I actually wanted to spend time relaxing.
Throw this into a soy wax blend for a shower-adjacent candle that clears your sinuses and your mood. Anyone who takes long baths and wants the spa vibe without the spa price — this is your oil.
P&J Trading Christmas Wreath Fragrance Oil
Use this as a calming base but please don't stop there — lavender plus lemon is a combo that took my candles from ‘meh’ to ‘wait, you made this?’ Took me a year to try that mix.
Mainstays Lavender Essential Oil 15 ml Therapeutic Grade
Snag this for holiday blends or summer candles — peppermint is weirdly versatile once you stop thinking of it as just a Christmas scent. Mixed with eucalyptus, it's the candle I burn when I'm getting over a cold.
P&J Fragrance Oil | Peppermint Oil 100ml
Candle Wax That Holds Fragrance Without Going Weird
Spent my first year using whatever wax was cheapest and wondering why my candles smelled like nothing after burning for ten minutes. Wax matters more than I wanted to admit.
Switch to this if your soy candles have been throwing weak scent — the hot throw on this wax is noticeably better than the cheap stuff I started with. Clean burn, smooth tops, fewer headaches all around.
10 lb Bag of Natural Millennium Soy Wax for Candle Making
Grab this kit if you're just starting out and don't want to buy wax, wicks, and centering tools separately. Saved me from three separate orders and the wax holds fragrance oil better than I expected for a starter set.
Hearts & Crafts DIY Candle Making Kit
Try a para-soy blend if pure soy hasn't been giving you the scent throw you want — this one holds heavier fragrances like teakwood and sandalwood without sweating. Wish someone had told me about blended waxes sooner.
Virginia Candle Supply
Wicks That Don't Drown or Tunnel
Nothing kills a good fragrance blend faster than a wick that tunnels down the center and wastes half your wax. I ruined so many candles before I figured out wick sizing.
Keep a bulk pack of these around so you can test different sizes without running out mid-project. Figured out my ideal wick size by burning test candles with three different widths — these made that process cheap enough to not stress about.
EricX Light 100 Piece Candle Wick 8" Pre-Waxed Cotton
Use these for soy wax specifically — they burn clean and don't leave that black soot ring on your jars. For anyone whose white candles keep turning gray around the edges, switching wicks fixed that for me overnight.
100 Pcs Natural Smokeless Cotton Candle Wicks for DIY
Swap in a wood wick when you want that crackling fireplace sound — it completely changes the vibe. Fair warning: they're pickier about wick size than cotton, so test before you pour a whole batch. Learned that the expensive way.
EricX Light Organic Hemp Candle Wicks 100 Piece 8
Containers and Jars That Look Like You Bought Them Somewhere Fancy
Poured my first candles into old mason jars and they looked exactly like what they were — a first attempt. Good jars make even a simple vanilla candle look like a thirty-dollar purchase.
Get these in bulk if you're making gifts or selling — the matte finish looks way more expensive than what you're paying. Handed one to a friend and she thought I bought it from a boutique, which was exactly the reaction I needed.
12 Pack, 8 OZ Clear Candle Jars For Making
Grab these for sample sizes or testing new blends without committing a ton of wax. Perfect for anyone who wants to try twelve scent combos without pouring twelve full-size candles — saved me so much wasted material.
Hearts & Crafts Tin Candle Jars for Making Candles
Toss your wax in this instead of ruining another kitchen pot — the pour spout alone prevents those messy drips down the side of every jar. My countertops looked like a crime scene before I started using a proper pouring vessel.
Candle Making Kit, Candle Pouring Pot DIY Candle Craft
Mixing and Measuring Tools for Consistent Blends
Winging it with fragrance ratios gave me candles that ranged from ‘can barely smell it’ to ‘evacuate the building.’ Measuring tools turned my hobby into something repeatable.
Use a kitchen scale instead of eyeballing oil drops — the difference between a balanced blend and an overwhelming one is literally a gram or two. Bought this after my third candle came out smelling like pure cinnamon aggression.
Etekcity 22lb USB Rechargeable Waterproof Scale
Keep a few of these dedicated to candle making so you're not washing fragrance oil out of your cooking cups. Small pour spouts make mixing oils way cleaner, and they're cheap enough to grab a whole set without thinking twice.
Glass Measuring Cup, Two-Pack (8OZ
Snag a metal set that won't absorb fragrance oil the way plastic ones do — I learned this after my measuring spoons permanently smelled like patchouli and contaminated every blend for weeks.
Norpro Stainless Steel Measuring Spoons
Labels and Packaging for Gifting or Selling
Made beautiful candles and then stuck a piece of masking tape on them with the scent name in Sharpie. Presentation matters, and decent labels took my candles from craft project to actual product.
Pair these with a simple font printout and your candles instantly look handmade-chic instead of handmade-questionable. Printed the scent name and a tiny ingredient list — suddenly people started asking if I had an Etsy shop.
Avery, Kraft Brown Round Labels, 2" Diameter, 180 Labels
Get this once you're making enough candles that handwriting labels stops being charming and starts being a wrist injury. Paid for itself after my first craft fair where I needed forty labeled jars in one night.
Customer reviews for MUNBYN Shipping Label Printer 4x6
Wrap this around the jar lid with a kraft tag for a finishing touch that takes ten seconds but makes people not want to throw away the packaging. For anyone selling at markets — this tiny detail got me more compliments than the actual candle scents, ...
Black Twine String, Cotton Bakers Twine 656 Feet