Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
How I Started Pouring My Own Soy Candles Without Any Experience
29
items Buying candles at $30 a pop felt ridiculous when I realized the supplies cost about $3 per jar. If you've been curious about making your own but didn't know where to start or what actually works versus what's a waste of money — this is the exact line...
Sections
10
Soy Wax Flakes for Melting and Pouring
Mason Jars That Actually Work as Candle Vessels
Fragrance Oils That Smell Like Actual Candles Not Craft Store Potpourri
Candle Wicks That Stay Centered and Actually Light
Pouring Pots and Melting Equipment
Dye Blocks and Color Options
Soy Wax Flakes for Melting and Pouring
First three batches I tried paraffin and the soot was unreal — black rings on my ceiling. Switching to soy wax changed everything, cleaner burn, better scent throw, and way easier cleanup.
Grab this bag if you want wax that melts evenly on a regular stove — I get about 20 mason jar candles from one bag and the math comes out to like $1.50 each. Stock up before holiday season when these sell out fast.
10 lb of Freedom Soy Wax Beads for Candle Making
Try this starter kit if you're the person who wants everything in one box without hunting down wicks separately. Came with enough wax for my first dozen candles and I still had wick stickers left over.
Hearts & Crafts DIY Candle Making Kit
Switch to this if your candles keep getting sinkholes — the 464 blend handles temperature changes way better than what I was using before. Perfect for anyone pouring in a drafty kitchen like mine.
Natural Soy 464 Wax: 5 pound bag by Golden Foods
Mason Jars That Actually Work as Candle Vessels
Not every jar handles heat well. I cracked two vintage jars before figuring out which ones are actually safe to pour hot wax into without disaster.
Use these 8-ouncers for gift candles — they're the perfect size for a 30-hour burn and they look way more expensive than they are. Brought a set to a housewarming and the host thought I bought them from a boutique.
Ball, Mason Jar, Quilted Crystal, Regular Mouth
Snag the wide mouth version if you hate fishing out old wick stubs — the opening makes cleanup dead simple. These are my go-to for the living room candles I keep for myself.
Ball, Glass Mason Jars, Wide Mouth, 16 oz, Pack of 12
Keep a dozen of these tiny jars around for sample candles and party favors. Poured lavender ones for my daughter's baby shower and people kept asking where I ordered them from.
(4 pack) Ball Regular Mouth 4oz Quilted Pint Mason Jars
Fragrance Oils That Smell Like Actual Candles Not Craft Store Potpourri
Wasted probably $40 on cheap fragrance oils that smelled amazing in the bottle and then disappeared completely once the candle was lit. These are the ones that actually fill a room.
Try this sampler pack before committing to big bottles — the vanilla and fresh cotton ones are absurdly good. Figured out my favorite scents without blowing $60 on full sizes I might hate.
P&J, Spice Set of 6, 10ml, Premium Grade Fragrance Oils
Pour this into your wax if you want your house to smell like a bakery without actually baking anything. My neighbor knocked on my door once asking if I had cookies in the oven — nope, just a candle.
Warm Vanilla Sugar Fragrance Oil, 4 Fl Oz
Swap this in when you want something calming for the bedroom — real lavender, not that fake purple smell from air fresheners. Works especially well if you're sensitive to synthetic fragrances and get headaches from strong scents.
Virginia Candle Supply
Candle Wicks That Stay Centered and Actually Light
Nothing more frustrating than a wick that leans sideways and tunnels the wax into a crater. Spent three batches figuring out the right size before landing on these.
Grab the hundred pack because you'll go through them faster than you think — pre-tabbed and pre-waxed so there's zero prep work. Wish someone had told me these existed before I spent an hour hand-dipping raw wicks.
EricX Light 100pc Natural Candle Wick Low Smoke
Try wooden wicks if you want that crackling campfire sound — my kids literally sit and listen to these burn. Fair warning though, trim them shorter than you think or the flame gets wild.
MadMedic, Candle Wicks, 5.12 inches, Wood with Metal
Toss a sticker on the bottom of each wick tab to keep it dead center while pouring — before I found these I was using hot glue and burning my fingers every single time. Total no-brainer purchase.
Candle Making Sticker, Easy To Use 200Pcs Wick
Pouring Pots and Melting Equipment
Ruined a good saucepan my first week because I poured wax directly in it like a fool. A dedicated pouring pot saves your cookware and your sanity.
Use a dedicated pouring pot so your spouse doesn't kill you for ruining the pasta pot — the spout on this one gives you a clean pour without wax dribbling down the side. Learned this lesson the expensive way.
Candle Making Pouring Pot, Heavy Duty Stainless Steel
Keep one of these on the counter as a dedicated wax melter if you're making candles regularly — set it to low, walk away, come back to perfectly melted wax. Way safer than hovering over the stove with a thermometer.
Presto® Kitchen Kettle™ deep fryer/multi-cooker - Product Info
Snag a cheap digital thermometer because pouring temperature actually matters — too hot and your fragrance burns off, too cool and the wax sets lumpy. Took me four ugly batches to figure that out.
Taylor Digital Meat Thermometer, Folding Probe
Dye Blocks and Color Options
Plain white candles are fine but once I started adding color the whole hobby got way more fun. A little goes a long way — I overdid it once and stained a wick completely purple.
Pair one tiny shaving from these blocks with your melted wax and you get rich color without any weird clumps. Started with the sage green and now every room in my house has a different shade going.
Hearts & Crafts Soy Wax Candle Dye Flakes
Try a drop of this for warm peachy tones if you're making fall candles — way cheaper than buying specialty candle dye and the color payoff is honestly better than I expected.
Rit DyeMore Dye for Synthetics, Apricot Orange, 7 fl. oz.
Ditch fancy dye if you're just experimenting — peel a crayon, chop it up, melt it in. Not perfect for selling but totally fine for messing around with your kids on a Saturday afternoon.
Crayola, Crayons, 24 Count, Classic Colors for Kids
Labels and Packaging for Gifting
Started giving these away at Christmas and people genuinely asked if I was starting a business. Turns out a decent label makes a mason jar candle look professional in about two minutes.
Use these with a free Avery template online and suddenly your candles look like they came from a farmers market booth. Printed mine on a regular inkjet and the quality shocked me.
Avery, Shape Labels, Round, 2 inch Diameter, White
Grab a gold Sharpie for hand-lettering jar lids if you want that handmade-on-purpose look — takes thirty seconds and people think you hired a calligrapher. Great for anyone who doesn't own a printer.
Customer reviews for Sharpie Metallic Permanent Markers
Wrap a loop of twine around the jar neck with a sprig of dried rosemary tucked in — instant gift presentation that costs basically nothing. My sister-in-law copied this move for her entire friend group last December.
1mm 328 Feet Natural Jute Twine, for Crafts Gift
Cleanup Supplies You Will Definitely Need
Nobody warns you about the wax splatters. First time I made candles my kitchen counter looked like a crime scene and I had no idea how to get dried soy wax off granite.
Keep a bottle under the sink because dried wax on countertops is inevitable — a few drops of this and it wipes right off instead of scraping with a butter knife like I did for months.
Goo Gone Pro-Power Goo & Adhesive Remover, 8 oz
Toss one of these in your pouring pot with hot soapy water and the leftover wax slides right out. Regular sponges just smear it around — learned that the annoying way.
Scotch-Brite, Cleaning Sponges, Blue
Books and Guides for Getting Better at Candle Making
YouTube taught me the basics but a good book gave me the ratios and troubleshooting charts I kept searching for. Stopped guessing and started getting consistent results.
Grab this if you want actual science behind why your candles tunnel or frost — not just pretty photos. Read it cover to cover on a rainy weekend and my next batch was the best I'd ever made.
The Candlemaker's Companion
Try this one for creative ideas once you've got the basics down — the layered color techniques alone were worth the price. Perfect for anyone who's bored of making the same plain candle over and over.
Make your own candles! I used to love things like this! #
Use this specifically for soy wax because it covers all the quirks that generic candle books skip — like why soy wax gets that frosted look and how to prevent it. Saved me from throwing out an entire batch.
LammLoe Soy Candle Making Kit, 25 lbs Natural
Storage and Organization for Supplies
Wax flakes everywhere, fragrance bottles rolling around in drawers, wicks tangled into knots — organizing my supplies was the difference between enjoying this hobby and dreading the setup.
Toss all your wax flakes and supplies into one of these clear bins so you can actually see what you have — before this I was buying duplicate fragrance oils because I forgot what was buried in my closet.
(4 pack) Sterilite 66 Quart Large Latching Storage Bin
Keep your fragrance oil bottles upright in one of these so they stop leaking sideways in your cabinet. Fits perfectly on a shelf and holds about fifteen bottles without them clinking around.
mDesign Plastic Kitchen Pantry Storage Organizer Bin
Portion out your wax flakes into these bags by batch size so you're not scooping and measuring every time — I prep five bags on Sunday and candle making during the week takes half the time.
Hefty Slider 2.5 Gallon Jumbo Storage Bags, 10 Count