Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Lactation Cookie Mixes I Bake Weekly That Boosted My Supply in 4 Days
40
items Pumping for twenty minutes and getting barely an ounce was breaking me — I almost quit breastfeeding entirely before a friend handed me a bag of lactation cookie mix and told me to just try it for a week. Four days later my freezer stash actually sta...
Sections
8
Lactation Cookie Mixes That Actually Taste Good
Brewer's Yeast and Flaxseed for Homemade Batches
Chocolate Chips and Mix-Ins Worth Adding
Fenugreek and Herbal Lactation Supplements
Baking Tools That Make Midnight Batches Easier
Lactation-Boosting Snacks for Days I Skip Baking
Lactation Cookie Mixes That Actually Taste Good
Half the mixes out there taste like cardboard with flaxseed — I tried six brands before landing on these. Now I genuinely look forward to baking them at 11pm while the baby sleeps.
Grab this one first — I was skeptical but noticed a difference by day three. Perfect for the mom who hates baking because you literally just add butter and eggs.
Mommy Knows Best Cinnamon Raisin Lactation Cookie
Keep a bag in your diaper bag for desperate snacking. Before these I was skipping meals and wondering why my supply tanked — turns out feeding yourself matters.
Munchkin Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Lactation Cookie Bites
Try these if you want cookies that taste like actual cookies and not a health food experiment. My husband kept stealing them so I had to hide the batch.
Lactation Cookie Mix - Oatmeal Chocolate Chip - 24oz
Switch to these when you're sick of chocolate chip — the oatmeal raisin flavor surprised me. Great for tossing in your pump bag for those 3am sessions.
Munchkin Milkmakers Lactation Cookie Bites, Oatmeal Raisin
Use this when you want the chocolate chip version specifically — richer flavor than most competitors. Baked a double batch Sunday night and it lasted me exactly four days.
Mommy Knows Best Lactation Cookies Mix
Brewer's Yeast and Flaxseed for Homemade Batches
Once I got confident, I started making my own mix from scratch. These bulk ingredients saved me a fortune and let me control exactly what goes in.
Toss a tablespoon into any cookie dough — this was the missing ingredient when my homemade batches weren't working as well as store-bought mixes.
Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Large Flake Nutritional Yeast
Swap this in for part of the flour in any recipe. Before I added flaxseed my homemade lactation cookies were basically just regular cookies with wishful thinking.
Bob's Red Mill Flaxseed Meal, 16 oz Bag
Use these as your base — the thick flakes hold up better than quick oats and give you that chewy texture. Works for moms doing gluten-free too.
Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Old Fashioned Rolled Oats
Grab this if Bob's is out of stock — the grind is fine enough to disappear into dough. For anyone who gags at visible flaxseed chunks, this one hides perfectly.
Spectrum Essentials Organic Ground Premium Flaxseed
Try mixing a scoop into your cookie dough or even smoothies. Fair warning — it tastes bitter alone, but in chocolate chip cookies you genuinely cannot tell it's there.
Customer reviews for Solgar Brewer's Yeast Powder 14 oz
Chocolate Chips and Mix-Ins Worth Adding
Plain lactation cookies get boring by week two. These mix-ins keep me actually wanting to eat them instead of forcing them down like medicine.
Use the good chocolate — you're already baking at midnight, you deserve it. These melt perfectly and made my cookies taste like bakery-level stuff instead of sad health food.
Ghirardelli, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Chips
Switch to dark chocolate when you want something richer. Paired with the brewer's yeast, the bitterness of dark chocolate actually balances everything out beautifully.
Nestlé Toll House, Dark Chocolate Baking Chips
Toss a handful into oatmeal cookie batches for a tart contrast. My sister-in-law who hates chocolate loved the cranberry version and she was nursing twins.
(8 pack) Great Value Sweetened Dried Cranberries, 6 oz
Throw these in for crunch and extra healthy fats. Before adding nuts my cookies were flat and boring — now they have actual texture and keep me full longer between feeds.
Fisher Walnut Halves & Pieces, 16 oz Bag
Grab these if your baby reacts to dairy — they're allergy-friendly and still taste like real chocolate. Saved me when we discovered my son had a milk sensitivity at eight weeks.
Enjoy Life Semi-Sweet Mini Chips, Dairy Free Chocolate
Fenugreek and Herbal Lactation Supplements
Cookies alone weren't enough during my four-month supply dip. Stacking these supplements with my baking routine is what finally got me ahead of demand.
Try two capsules with meals — within 48 hours I smelled like maple syrup, which sounds weird but it means it's working. For moms who've tried everything else first.
Nature's Way Fenugreek Seed Capsules
Brew a cup while you bake your cookies — the combo hit differently than either one alone. Tastes like licorice, which you'll either love or tolerate for the results.
Traditional Medicinals - Organic Mother's Milk Herbal Tea
Swap to these if fenugreek upsets your stomach — the blend is gentler. Wish I'd found these before spending three miserable days on a different brand that gave me cramps.
Pink Stork Lactation Supplement: Breastfeeding Support
Grab the berry flavor and mix it into water between pumping sessions. Way easier than remembering pills when you're running on four hours of sleep.
UpSpring Breastfeeding Drink Mix with Fenugreek
Use this one specifically if you're an undersupplier — the combo of goat's rue and milk thistle targets production differently than fenugreek alone. Took about five days to notice.
Legendairy Milk Liquid Gold Lactation Supplement
Baking Tools That Make Midnight Batches Easier
Baking with a newborn sleeping on your chest requires specific equipment. These tools let me mix, scoop, and clean up one-handed most of the time.
Get one if you're baking weekly — my wrists were dying from hand-mixing dough while holding a baby. This freed up both arms and I could prep a double batch in ten minutes.
KitchenAid Classic Series 4.5-Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer
Ditch your old warped pan — cookies bake evenly on this and slide right off. Spent three weeks scraping stuck cookies before someone told me my sheet pan was the problem.
Wilton Premium Steel Non-Stick Medium Cookie Sheet, Gray
Use this for uniform cookies that bake evenly — before the scoop I had some burnt and some raw in the same batch. Also satisfying to use at 1am when your brain is mush.
OXO Good Grips 1055893 Medium Cookie Scoop
Grab the pre-cut sheets instead of the roll — fighting with a roll of parchment while sleep-deprived is a battle nobody needs. These lay flat and nothing sticks.
Reynolds Kitchens Stay Flat Parchment Paper Roll
Keep one bowl for dry ingredients and one for wet — cuts cleanup in half. For anyone whose sink is already full of pump parts and bottles, fewer dishes is survival.
Pyrex® 8-piece Mixing Bowl Set with Assorted Lids
Lactation-Boosting Snacks for Days I Skip Baking
Some weeks the oven doesn't get turned on and that's fine. These grab-and-go options kept my supply steady when baking just wasn't happening.
Stash two in your nightstand for those middle-of-the-night hunger attacks. Before these I was eating dry cereal at 3am and wondering why I felt terrible during morning feeds.
Boobie Bar Superfood Breastfeeding Bar
Toss one in your pump bag — twelve grams of protein means it actually keeps you full. Way better than the granola bars I was pretending counted as a meal.
Customer reviews for Munchkin® Milkmakers® Lactation
Snag these for a lighter option when you're snacked out on heavy cookies. Not technically marketed for lactation but the oats and flax do the same job in a pinch.
Earth's Best Organic Sesame Street Strawberry Sunny
Try these when you want something that doesn't taste like a supplement — they taste like actual baked goods. Brought a box to my breastfeeding support group and three moms asked for the name.
Happy Baby, Stage 2 Organic Baby Food, Apples Blueberries & Oats
Keep a pack in your car for emergencies — not a lactation product specifically, but the whole grains kept me from skipping breakfast entirely during those brutal first weeks.
belVita Blueberry Morning Breakfast Biscuits, Pack of 5
Hydration Helpers Because Water Alone Gets Old
Nobody warned me that dehydration tanks your supply faster than anything. Drinking plain water all day was miserable, so these made staying hydrated something I actually did.
Drink one during every pump session — the electrolytes made a noticeable difference versus plain water. A NICU nurse recommended this brand specifically and she was right.
BODYARMOR Lyte Peach Mango Electrolyte Sports Drink
Pour a packet into your water bottle first thing in the morning. Before using these I was chronically dehydrated and didn't even realize it until my output jumped after one day.
Liquid I.V.® Lemon Lime Hydration Multiplier® Powdered
Get a giant tumbler with a handle you can grab one-handed while nursing. My old water bottle required two hands to open and I just stopped drinking water — this fixed that immediately.
Stanley Iceflow 30 oz Insulated Tumblers
Drop a tab in your water when you don't want the sweetness of sports drinks. Low calorie, fizzy, and way more interesting than the plain water I was forcing down.
Nuun Sport Electrolytes Hydration Drink Mix Tablets
Swap to this when you want something without artificial dyes — cleaner ingredient list than regular Gatorade. Stock up because you'll go through these faster than you expect while nursing.
Gatorade Fit Zero Citrus Berry Sports Drink, 16.9 fl oz Bottle
Storage Solutions for Freezer Cookie Stash
Baking once and freezing portions saved my sanity. When a growth spurt hit and my supply needed a boost fast, I could just thaw cookies instead of scrambling to bake.
Use these to stack frozen cookie dough balls — they seal tight and don't crack in the freezer. Learned the hard way after a cheap container shattered and I lost an entire batch.
Rubbermaid Brilliance Plastic Food Storage Container, 2.3 L (9.6 Cup), 1 Pack
Grab the freezer-specific ones, not the regular storage bags — regular ones let freezer burn in within a week. Label them with the date so you rotate through oldest first.
Great Value Double Zipper Half Gallon Freezer Bag
Keep pre-mixed dry ingredients in these so you can skip measuring on rough nights. Fill three jars on Sunday and you've got cookie mix ready to go all month.
Ball Wide Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids
Use this if you're batch-freezing more than two weeks of cookies at a time. Before vacuum sealing, my frozen cookies tasted stale after ten days — now they last over a month.
FoodSaver Handheld+ 2-in-1 Vacuum Sealing System
Toss one in your kitchen drawer for labeling bags with dates and flavors. Sounds obvious but at 2am all frozen cookie dough looks identical and you will grab the wrong batch.
Sharpie Permanent Markers, Fine Point, Black, 12 Count