Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Reward Jar Toys I Use When My Daughter Needs Daily Motivation
49
items Getting a five-year-old to brush teeth, pick up toys, and finish dinner without a meltdown felt impossible. Sticker charts lasted two days before she stopped caring. Then I started filling a jar with small toys she could pick from after a successful ...
Sections
7
Small Figurines She Actually Plays With After
Craft Supplies That Double as Rewards
Fidget and Sensory Toys for the Jar
Hair Accessories She Gets Excited About
Tiny Books and Activity Pads Worth Adding
Snack-Size Treats for the Jar
Small Figurines She Actually Plays With After
Half the dollar store figurines I used to buy ended up forgotten under the couch by bedtime. These are the ones she carries around for days and actually incorporates into her pretend play.
Grab a few of these for the jar. My daughter lined them up on her windowsill like a tiny army and plays with them every morning before school. Perfect size for little hands and reward jars alike.
Barbie Mini BarbieLand Pop Reveal Doll 1.5-inch
Try these if your kid is into Disney at all. She gets SO excited unwrapping the mystery packaging. The surprise factor doubles the reward feeling, and they're small enough to fit in a mason jar.
Disney Doorables Series 10 Collectible Figures, 2.5 inches
Toss a couple of these in your jar for variety. My daughter started collecting them and now she actually asks what tasks she can do to earn another one. Never thought I'd see that level of enthusiasm about making her bed.
Kids Accessories Playset with Blind Bag Pets
Use these if your kid loves tiny grocery store pretend play. She sets up a whole miniature shop on the kitchen table. Fair warning, you WILL step on one barefoot at 6 AM eventually.
Shopkins Real Littles Snack Time Food Variety Set Toy
Keep one of these in the jar for a bigger reward day. When she finally had a full week of green lights at school, she picked this and slept with it for a month straight. Worth every penny for that proud look on her face.
Schleich Bayala - 4" Mandala Unicorn Foal Figurine
Snag a pack and scatter them through the jar. There are like 20 tiny animals in one bag so it stretches your budget forever. She sorts them by habitat, which accidentally turned into a science lesson.
Safari Ltd. Good Luck Minis Desert Fun Pack
Pair these with any dollhouse she already has. My daughter gasped when she pulled one out of the jar. Actual gasp. The tiny sleeping bags and marshmallow accessories are ridiculously cute even to adult eyes.
Calico Critters Baby Camping Series Blind Bags
Craft Supplies That Double as Rewards
She started asking for craft stuff instead of candy, which felt like a parenting win I did not expect. These are small enough for the jar and keep her busy for an hour minimum.
Swap these in when you need jar variety. She sniffs every single one before coloring and it keeps her at the table for a solid 45 minutes. The grape one smells surprisingly accurate.
Crayola Silly Scents Twistables Crayons
Toss one in the jar for a rainy day reward. She made a beaded lizard and clipped it to her backpack. Her friends asked where she got it and she said she EARNED it, which honestly made my whole week.
Made By Me Create Your Own Bead Pets by Horizon
Peel off individual sticker sheets and roll them up for the jar. She sticks them on everything. My laptop, the dog, her little brother. Chaotic but she's motivated, so I call it a win.
Melissa & Doug Sticker Collection Book: Princesses
Try this for a special Friday reward. She spent an entire afternoon making lip balm and then insisted on giving one to her teacher. The teacher actually wore it, which was incredibly sweet.
Cra-Z-Art Shimmer 'n Sparkle Glitter & Gem Lip Gloss
Use these if your kid has the patience for it. Mine surprised me. She sat for an hour making a tiny heart and then ironed it with my help. Now she has a whole collection on her dresser.
(3 pack) Perler Fused Mini Bead Tray 8000pc Cool
Keep this for when she wants to make friendship bracelets. She spelled out her best friend's name wrong the first time and just said it was a nickname. Problem-solving skills, honestly.
Fashion Angels Tell Your Story 800+ Alphabet Bead Set
Bring this out as a big reward. She planted the seeds herself and checked on them every single morning. Watching something grow that she earned gave her this sense of responsibility I wasn't expecting.
Creativity for Kids Mini Garden - Unicorn Easter Basket Filler
Fidget and Sensory Toys for the Jar
My daughter's brain runs at 900 miles an hour. These give her hands something to do during car rides and homework time, and she actually works toward earning them.
Clip one to the outside of the jar as a teaser. She spotted it immediately and asked what she needed to do that day. Tiny, cheap, and somehow endlessly entertaining during grocery store trips.
Kawaii Pop It Keychain, Mini Stress Relief Fidget Toy
Snag these when they're in stock because they sell out fast. She squeezed hers so much the first night that I thought she'd pop it. The mystery element makes picking from the jar feel like Christmas morning.
Squishmallow Squishville Mystery Mini Plush Assortment
Get a few if your kid likes the squishy popping sensation. She brings hers to the dinner table and honestly it keeps her seated longer than anything else I've tried. Weird but effective.
Orb Odditeez Beadiballz Ultra Glitter Clear
Drop one of these in the jar and watch your kid become hypnotized. Mine stared at it for ten minutes straight, which is ten minutes of silence I desperately needed after a long Wednesday.
10 Pack Liquid Motion Bubbler Liquid Timers for Kids
Use these for the older reward jar kids. She stretches it, bounces it, and hides tiny figurines inside it. One tin lasts weeks before it mysteriously disappears into the couch cushions.
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Mini Tin Skate Away
Toss individual tubes into the jar. She shakes them, rolls them, holds them up to the light. Her little brother tried to drink from one, so maybe wait until your youngest is past that stage.
Learning Resources Sensory Trio Fidget Tubes
Throw a couple in because they're dirt cheap and she loves sending them down the stairs. Sure, they tangle eventually, but for a dollar each you just replace and move on. She's earned about seven so far.
JA-RU Big Magic Rainbow Spring Pack
Hair Accessories She Gets Excited About
One morning she refused to let me brush her hair and I bribed her with a sparkly clip from the jar. Now hair accessories are her favorite reward category and mornings are 80% less dramatic.
Roll a few into tiny bundles for the jar. She picks her color and wears it all day like a trophy. Sounds small but when your kid screams during ponytails, a hair tie she CHOSE changes everything.
Customer reviews for Goody Ouchless 4mm Elastic Hair Ties
Grab the variety pack and separate them into singles for the jar. She clips them in her hair, on her shirt, on her stuffed animals. Monday mornings got so much easier once hair clips became currency.
Scunci No-Slip Grip Oval Snap Hair Clips, Multicolor, 3 Count
Keep these for when she needs a bigger reward. She wore three flower clips to school at once and told everyone her mom let her pick them herself. Teacher sent me a photo and I'm framing it honestly.
Conair 2pc Flower Claw Clips Gift Set, Black & Brown Mini
Fold one up and stuff it in the jar for variety. She put it on and immediately started narrating her day like a YouTube vlogger. Unexpected side effect but at least she brushed her teeth without a fight.
Adorable Toddler Bow Headband Baby Care Accessory
Try these if your daughter is into anything sparkly. She dangles them from her braids and shakes her head around to make them swing. Gets her to sit still for braiding, which used to be a 20-minute negotiation.
Gimme, Claw Clips, Mini, Assorted Colors, 8 Count for Fine
Stick the mini version in the jar. She wanted her OWN brush so badly that she did her chores unprompted for three days. Now she brushes her own hair every morning. I nearly cried the first time.
Wet Brush® Mini Detangler - Purple - On-the-Go Detangling
Separate the pack into individual scrunchies and scatter them through the jar. She wears them on her wrist like bracelets and trades them with friends at school. Accidentally created a whole economy.
Pastel Rainbow Velvet, Cream Velour
Tiny Books and Activity Pads Worth Adding
Screen time was becoming her default reward expectation, so I snuck small books into the jar. Now she reads in bed instead of asking for my phone, and bedtime takes half as long.
Roll one up and tie it with a ribbon for the jar. She spent an entire car ride quietly circling hidden objects instead of kicking her brother's seat. That alone is worth ten jars.
Highlight Hidden Pictures
Use these when you need a reward that won't destroy your walls. She colored the entire pad in two days and asked what she could do to earn another one. Self-motivated child? In THIS house?
Crayola Color Wonder Mess-Free Colouring Pad
Pull individual books from the set for the jar. She reads them to her stuffed animals at bedtime. Caught her sounding out words by herself last week and my heart basically exploded.
Little Leveled Readers: Level a Box Set: Just the Right
Toss one in for restaurant emergencies. She paints with the water pen, it dries, she paints again. No mess, no cleanup, and she earned it so she treats it like gold.
Melissa & Doug On the Go Water Wow! Reusable
Save this for a mega reward week. She carries it around asking me every question in the book. I don't know why flamingos are pink, kid, but I love that you're curious enough to ask.
National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of Why
Grab the Disney version if your kid is into princesses. The invisible ink marker blew her mind. She thought it was actual magic and honestly I wasn't about to correct her.
Bendon Luca 24-Page Imagine Ink Coloring Book with 1
Keep one in rotation for when she's bored of figurines. She painted every page in a single afternoon and then asked to earn another one. Repetitive? Sure. But she emptied the dishwasher voluntarily so who am I to judge.
Magic Pen Painting W Sticker Puzzles / Lee Publications
Snack-Size Treats for the Jar
Not every reward needs to be a toy. Sometimes she just wants something sweet, and honestly after a day where she cleaned her room without being asked three times, she's earned it.
Wrap individual pops in tissue paper so they look like little presents in the jar. She unwraps them so carefully you'd think it was a diamond ring. Organic so I feel slightly less guilty about the sugar.
YumEarth, Organic Fruit Pops Bulk Candy, 5 Lbs
Toss single pouches in between the toys. She gets excited when she pulls a snack instead of a toy, which surprised me. Sometimes a kid just wants gummy bunnies and honestly same.
Annie's Organic Bunny Fruit Flavoured Snacks Berry Patch
Grab the individual pouches and scatter them through the jar. She calls these her special candy even though they're just fruit snacks. I'm not correcting her. Let me have this.
Welch's® Fruit Snacks
Wrap a few rolls together for the jar. She sorts them by color before eating, which buys me an extra five minutes of peace. Also they don't melt in the jar during summer, which I learned matters.
Smarties Original Candy Rolls 5, Ib
Try these if you want a chocolate option that won't give you parent guilt. She eats them one by one and describes each flavor like a tiny food critic. Very entertaining dinner theater.
UNREAL, Dark Chocolate Crispy Quinoa Gems Candy, 6 Oz
Keep these in the jar for after-school rewards. She eats one pack and feels like she got a real treat. Vegetables are hidden inside apparently, which I discovered on the label and will never tell her.
MadeGood Chocolate Chip Granola Minis, 5 Count Box
Use these as filler between the exciting stuff. She actually likes raisins, which makes her the only child I know with this opinion. Cheap, healthy, and she earned them fair and square.
Sun-Maid, California Sun-Dried Raisins
Stationery and School Supplies She Wants to Earn
Started adding pencils and erasers to the jar when I ran out of toy ideas. Turns out she gets MORE excited about a sparkly pencil than a figurine sometimes. Kids are weird and wonderful.
Separate the pack and drop individual highlighters in the jar. She highlighted her entire coloring book and called it art. Her teacher asked why her homework had neon yellow streaks. Worth it.
Yoobi Mini Highlighters 10-Pack – Assorted Bright Colors
Pull singles from the pack for easy jar fillers. She loves that she can erase mistakes, which accidentally taught her that messing up isn't permanent. Parenting win I did not plan.
Review – Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils
Snag a few of these because they smell like strawberries and she hoards them in her pencil case. Hasn't actually erased anything with one yet. They're more like tiny scented trophies at this point.
Raymond Geddes Totally Adorkable Scented Kneaded
Roll it up and stuff it in a bigger jar. She started writing stories in hers about a cat detective. Four chapters in and honestly the plot is better than some shows I've watched.
Mead Primary Composition Book Ruled Grades K-2 100
Keep the bright colors for the jar and use the boring ones yourself. She writes her name in a different color every day on her lunchbox. The lunch lady now recognizes her handwriting, apparently.
Customer reviews for Paper Mate Flair Felt Tip Pens
Stick a small pad in the jar. She writes notes and hides them around the house. Found one in my shoe that said I love you mom. Keeping that one forever, wrinkles and all.
Post-it Super Sticky Notes, 3" x 3" , Blue, 5 Pads/Pack
Peel off individual sheets for the jar. She decorates her water bottle, her notebooks, her brother. The brother is less enthusiastic but he's learning to negotiate sticker removal, which is a life skill.
Yoobi