While this is a little bit more pricier than the other selections on the list if you wanted to treat yourself a little bit this is a great choice! I used this mascara for years and it has good wear and is not irritating.
Intense Pitch Black BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara Mini - Benefit Cosmetics | Ulta Beauty
You can't go wrong with a Maybelline mascara. This was my go to when I would run out of my usual!
Very Black Lash Sensational Mascara - Maybelline | Ulta Beauty
Nyx has the best budget eyeliner hands down! I have many of these in all different colors.