Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Blending Brushes

Purple Star emoji 30 items
I have oily lids and every shadow used to crease within an hour. After testing way too many brushes and formulas, these are the ones that actually stay put on my greasy eyelids.
Sections
6
 
 
 
 
 
 

New Section

Blending on oily lids is tricky because product moves around. These brushes give me control without pushing everything into my crease line.

 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
soft enough for sheer washes but firm enough to actually blend. my daily driver.
SEPHORA COLLECTION PRO Crease Brush #27
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
the classic for a reason 🙌 picks up powder shadows perfectly
MAC Cosmetics 217 Synthetic Blending Brush
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
I bought this on a whim and now I own three. the shape is just right for my eye shape.
Sigma Beauty E25 Blending Brush - Sephora Philippines
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
budget friendly and honestly performs way above its price
Real Techniques 3-Piece Eye Shade & Blend Set
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
tiny but mighty. great for lower lash line blending too 👀
NARS #25 Smudge Brush

Flat Shader Brushes 🖌️

Packing on shadow is where oil-free formulas shine. These flat brushes press color onto the lid without streaking or patchiness.

 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
dense and flat. packs on color in one swipe which means less fallout.
SEPHORA COLLECTION PRO Shadow Brush #18
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
this one changed how I apply shimmer shadows. so smooth.
Sigma Beauty E55 Eye Shading Brush
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
been using this for years and it still looks brand new
MAC Cosmetics 239 Synthetic Eye Shader Brush
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
a little pricier but the bristles never shed. worth every penny 💰
Essential Face Makeup Brush Trio
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
pairs perfectly with their primer. the flat edge is surprisingly precise
Too Faced Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eyeshadow Primer

Oil-Free Primers

No brush works well on oily lids without a good base. I learned this the hard way after years of creasing by noon.

 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
the OG. I've repurchased this maybe eight times now
Urban Decay Mini Original Eyeshadow Primer Potion
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
slightly tackier formula which helps powder shadows grip better 🤝
Too Faced Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eyeshadow Primer
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
if you have REALLY oily lids, start here. this stuff does not budge.
NARS Pro-Prime™ Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
honestly shocked at how well this works for the price
Eyeshadow Primers & Eye Primers
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
lightweight and dries down fast. no sticky feeling at all
Sephora Smashbox Photo Finish Under Eye Primer

Powder Shadows That Stay

Oil-free shadows work best when they're truly matte or pressed pigments. These formulas don't slide around on me.

 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
every shade in here performs on oily lids. warm tones are beautiful.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Soft Glam Eyeshadow Palette
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
my go-to crease shade. finely milled and blends like butter 🧈
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
a dusty rose that looks good on literally everyone
Nepal Single Eyeshadow
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
splurged on this and zero regrets. the pigment is insane.
NIB Viseart Eyeshadow Palette Neutral Matte VPE14 $80
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
pretty everyday shades. they set nicely and don't migrate
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Luxury Eyeshadow Palette

Detail & Liner Brushes

I like doing tight lines and precise work around my eyes. These small brushes make it way easier, especially with powder liner.

 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
perfect angle for a sharp wing. just wet it and use shadow as liner.
Chrome E05 EyeLiner Brush
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
so thin it feels like drawing with a pen ✏️
M∙A∙C 210S Precise Eye Liner Brush
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
great for filling in brows too. very versatile little brush
SEPHORA COLLECTION PRO Eyeliner Brush #22
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
the finest tip I've found. takes practice but the results are worth it.
Ultra Fine Eyeliner brush | Bobbi Brown ≡ SEPHORA
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
cheap and does the job. I keep one in my travel bag
SEPHORA COLLECTION PRO Eyeliner Brush #22

Setting & Finishing

This last step locks everything in. I used to skip setting my eye looks and wondered why they disappeared by lunch. Not anymore.

 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
I spray this over closed eyes after finishing my look. total lock-in. 🔒
All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
lighter mist than most sprays. doesn't disturb the shadow underneath.
Mist & Fix | Make Up For Ever ≡ SEPHORA
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
tiny bit under the eyes prevents fallout from ruining concealer
Translucent Loose Setting Powder - Laura Mercier
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
honestly works almost as well as the pricier ones
Dewy Setting Sprays
 
Jemima Chatham profile picture
I press this lightly over my lid primer before shadow. keeps oils at bay all day.
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Finish Setting Powder