Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Best Thrift & Consignment Shops in Western NY
12
items This curated guide highlights the best thrift stores and consignment shops across Western New York. From boutique resale and designer consignment to vintage finds and community-driven secondhand shops, this list is built for intentional shoppers, cre...
Map
Sections
2
Thrift & Consignment Shops (Curated + Everyday Finds)
Vintage & One-of-a-Kind Finds
Thrift & Consignment Shops (Curated + Everyday Finds)
A curated mix of thrift and consignment shops across Western New York. These stores offer quality secondhand clothing, accessories, and home finds without the overwhelm. Perfect for shoppers who value style, sustainability, and smart spending.
the vibes and carefully curated selection i why this one makes the list
Keepsake Consignment - Buffalo, NY
HHC is a locally-owned business with multiple locations across Western New York. Whether you're redecorating, downsizing, moving, or looking for that perfect addition to your home, HHC is your destination
HHC-Hertel Home Consignment
Currently with 3 stores in operation in the Buffalo area. They’ve been keeping clothes out of the landfill for 15 years and counting! Visit any location any day of the week! Open 11-6pm Monday-Saturday, 12-5 on Sundays
Second Chic - Contemporary Consignment Shop
providing fashionable ladies and men with high quality pre-loved clothing and accessories. Social Media @scoopshop648
Scoop Shop - Buffalo, NY
Has the largest selection of true vintage clothes. This place is a hidden gem
Ritzy Rags Consignment | Cheektowaga NY
. Shoes and purses and accessories galore. Great selections and great prices
Walk In Closet - East Aurora, NY
A friend suggested this shop so I haven't personally checked it out yet. It's on my list!
Under One Roof / New 2 You
whimsical place to find unique clothing and accessories to fit your lifestyle; from yoga class, the office, or a night on the town.
Turnstyle Designs | Women's Clothing Shop in Elmwood Village
Vintage & One-of-a-Kind Finds
These Western NY shops specialize in vintage and one-of-a-kind pieces you won’t find twice. From retro fashion to unique home accents, this list is for creatives, stylists, and anyone who loves pieces with a story. From mid-century chairs to antique ...
Vintage Grace is an Antiques, Consignments and Home Decor shop that opened December of 2013 in Historic Lancaster, N.Y. With two floors open for consignment, and about 60 showcases available to rent out, Vintage Grace is always acquiring new items!
Vintage Grace Antiques
5 stars on yelp with tons of good midcentury modern finds👀
Funky Town Vintage Antiques - Williamsville, NY
carries a large variety of Antiques, Vintage, Collectables, as well a everyday household items.
Attic To Basement Repeats - Tonawanda, NY
home decor, vintage, and antique finds at this upscale home decor shop
The Lions Den Home Consignment - Williamsville, NY
