Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Budget Beauty Picks I Actually Repurchase
56
items I've gone through so many drugstore products chasing that 'high-end feel' without the price tag — these are the ones that actually stuck. From foundation and mascara to lipsticks and highlighters, everything here earned a permanent spot in my routine...
Map
Sections
5
Eyes & Brows
Face & Base
Makeup Tools
Lip Favorites
Body Makeup
Eyes & Brows
I've tried quite a few brow pencils over the years, but this is the one I always end up repurchasing. The tip is really fine, so I can fill in small gaps with light strokes instead of making my brows look too bold. I like that it's easy to control an...
NYX Micro Brow Pencil, Precise - Ash Brown
Keeps eyeshadow crease free for up to 24 hours. Lightweight, doesn't feel sticky under makeup.
MAC Prep + Prime 24-Hour Extend Eye Base
The curved brush actually lifts and separates my lashes instead of just coating them. Held up all day without flaking on me.
M·A·CStack Elevated Mascara
Kept hearing about this one for years before actually trying it and finally understand what the hype was about.
Too Faced Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara
This has survived humidity, tears, and a full workday without smudging once. Genuinely one of those products worth the hype.
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Kept hearing this was the drugstore dupe for high end mascaras and it really does hold up. Lashes look full without feeling stiff or spidery.
Lash Sensational® Washable Mascara for Length
Keeps eyeshadow from creasing or fading even during a long night out. Small step that makes a big difference.
Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Primer 10g
this one survived a full workout and a good cry at the same event, no joke.
Double Wear Infinite Waterproof Eyeliner
Face & Base
I've been using this when my skin feels a little dry and I want my makeup to sit better. It feels rich and moisturizing without making my skin feel heavy and gives it that soft healthy glow before foundation. I especially like using it when I want my...
0.5 oz Vitamin Enriched Face Base+ Moisturizer & Primer with Vitamin C + Hyaluronic Acid - BOBBI BROWN | Ulta Beauty
I’ve been reaching for this a lot now that the weather is getting colder. My skin tends to feel drier in autumn and winter and this gives it that extra hydration it needs. It feels rich and comforting without being too heavy and leaves my skin lookin...
1.7 oz The Dewy Skin Cream Line-Plumping Moisturizer - TATCHA | Ulta Beauty
I’ve been reaching for this when I want my makeup to look fresh for longer. The mist feels light on the skin and doesn’t leave my face feeling sticky or overly wet. I like using it as the last step when I want everything to look more blended and natu...
You Mist Makeup-Extending Setting Spray FENTY BEAUTY by Rihanna
Okay this one surprised me tbh. I have combination skin and expected it to feel heavy but it's actually so lightweight — blurs pores without looking cakey. Wore it a full day at home and only had to blot my T-zone once. Not full coverage so if you ha...
Skin Tint Blurring Elixir Foundation - KYLIE COSMETICS
This has been the fastest way to get that glass skin look without a ten step routine. Swipe on cheekbones and it looks like a highlighter but way more natural.
Faceglass™ Hydrating Skin Gloss
Buildable blush that blurs into skin nicely. Holds color true for hours without fading.
Skinfinish Colourstruck Blush
Keeps this on my vanity and mist my face before, during, and after makeup honestly. Genuinely helps everything blend together and look less cakey by the end of the day.
Fix+ | Makeup Setting Spray
Went back to this after trying so many newer foundations, and honestly, nothing else controlled my oily skin quite like this does. Still my go-to when I need something to actually last.
Studio Fix Fluid SPF 15 24HR Matte Foundation + Oil Control
A budget primer that actually blurs pores and keeps foundation from slipping. Solid base for any long makeup day.
e.l.f. Liquid Poreless Putty Primer
Affordable full coverage foundation that holds up well. Great drugstore pick for costume looks.
Milani Conceal + Perfect 2-in-1 Foundation + Concealer, Creamy Nude
This is one of those foundations that just looks like skin but better. Worth the splurge if you want your face to look flawless in every Halloween photo.
Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Pro Filt'r Foundation
A few spritzes of this and your makeup just stays put all night. Great budget alternative if you don't want to spend on the higher end sprays.
Marshmellow Matte Setting Spray | NYX Professional Makeup
A tiny drop goes such a long way and the finish looks so natural. One of those products that's genuinely worth the hype.
Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Liquid Blush Bliss
Kept seeing this all over social media and finally caved. The glow really does look natural instead of overly shimmery.
e.l.f. Halo Glow Highlight Wand, Champagne
Soft focus setting powder that blurs pores. Budget pick that holds makeup all night.
e.l.f. High Definition Loose Powder - Sheer Paraben-Free, Vegan, Oil Control, Makeup Setting
This is the setting powder everyone talks about and it actually earns the hype. Keeps oil away without making your face look powdery.
Mini Translucent Loose Setting Powder - Laura Mercier
Spent so long testing different combinations before finally writing this one down since I wanted a guide that actually holds up through a whole night out. Sharing everything that made the final cut here.
Halloween Makeup Essentials: Everything You Need for a Flawless Spooky Look
Such a pretty natural flush that blends in with just a couple dots and your fingers. Affordable enough that you don't feel bad building a whole collection of shades.
HEGLAM Color Bloom Liquid Blush
Medium coverage foundation with a natural skin like finish. High end but blends beautifully.
Too Faced Born This Way Natural Finish Foundation
Tinted moisturizer with SPF 30. Lightweight, buildable coverage with dewy finish.
White Tea Tinted Moisturizer Broad Spectrum SPF 30
It has a Semi-matte finish which wears well throughout the day and for a drugstore price point it holds up impressively well....
Bare Focus Tinted Hydrator Medium Tan
I saved up for this one after hearing so much hype, and honestly it lived up to it It is a splurge compared to drugstore options but the wear-time genuinely justifies it for special occasions or long days.
Teint Idole Ultra 24H Long Wear Matte Foundation
Makeup Tools
Super-soft, latex-free sponges for smooth makeup application.
Perfect for liquid, cream & powder products.
Makeup Sponge Set Latex-Free HD Blender 6pc
I Wasn't expecting a set this affordable to actually apply makeup well but the brushes blend product out so smoothly. Ended up replacing half my old brushes with these.
Mlemle Professional 26 Pcs Makeup Brush Set
Such a random but necessary product — I go through these so fast for skincare and makeup removal, glad I always have a backup pack 🤍
Equate Beauty Cotton Rounds, 100 Count
Soft and latex-free blending sponge. It works excellent with cream and liquid products.
Soft Touch Makeup Blending Sponge - Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez
Works well on multiple pencil sizes for eyes, lips and brows....
3-in-1 Pencil Sharpener - SEPHORA COLLECTION
I love a good makeup tool set because it makes getting ready so much easier. This little trio has both brushes and a sponge so you have the basics covered without needing a whole collection. I’d definitely keep this one around for everyday makeup and...
Cheeky Trio Makeup Brush & Sponge Set
Lip Favorites
This has become one of those products I use without even thinking about it. It's comfortable to wear adds a beautiful glossy finish and makes my lips look fuller without feeling thick or tacky. I keep it in my bag because it works for pretty much any...
KIKO Milano 3D Hydra Lip Gloss - Hydrating
I reach for this whenever I want a quick fresh look without using a bunch of products. I use it on both my lips and cheeks and it blends in really easily with just my fingers. The cooling jelly texture feels so refreshing and once it sets it gives a ...
Milk Makeup Cooling Water Jelly Tint - Lip & Cheek Stain
This has become my little nighttime lip ritual. I put a layer on before bed and wake up with my lips feeling much softer and hydrated. Perfect for those days when my lips need some extra care.
Original The Kissu Hydrating & Plumping Lip Mask - TATCHA | Ulta Beauty
I have this and one dot gives the most natural flush. Blends so easily and lasts all day without budging.
Adore Soft Pinch Liquid Blush - Rare Beauty
I have this in Gentle Currant and it's such an easy multi use product. Dabs on cheeks and lips in seconds and gives such a soft natural flush. Fragrance free too which my sensitive skin really appreciates.
Gentle Currant Daily Calm Lip + Cheek Color - Clinique
Not sticky at all which is honestly rare for a gloss this shiny. Smells so good too, an unexpected bonus every time I put it on.
Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Gloss Bomb Lip Gloss
Heard about Pillow Talk for years before finally trying it and now I get why it's so hyped. The liner keeps the lipstick from feathering and the shade suits so many different skin tones.
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Mini Lipstick & Lip Liner Set
Matte finish that doesn't dry out your lips which is honestly rare. Great affordable option for long wear costume looks.
NYX Lip Lingerie XXL Matte Liquid Lipstick Warm Up
Gives such a glossy shine without feeling sticky on the lips. Perfect finishing touch for a glam Halloween look.
e.l.f. Glow Reviver Lip Oil, Money Mauve
Black Honey is basically a cult classic at this point and it gives such a your lips but better tint that somehow works on literally everyone. Pink Honey and Nude Honey are softer versions of the same idea if you want something a bit lighter.
Almost Lipstick en Black Honey, Pink Honey et Nude Honey
One stick that works on cheeks lips and even a little on the eyes, so easy to just swipe and blend with your fingers on a rushed morning. Gives such a natural flush without needing five different products.
GMaxit Multi-Use Makeup Blush Stick (Shy Pink)
Exfoliates, hydrates, tints.
Le Chouchou Exfoliating + Softening Peptide Lip Balm – Eadem
I was fully expecting a gimmick when I bought this, but the pink it settles into is genuinely the most flattering shade I've found — and I keep catching a whiff of vanilla throughout the day, which is an unexpected bonus.
Flower Lip Balm – Winky Lux
This shade is such a good everyday nude-but-not-boring color — and it genuinely stays on all day without needing touch-ups 💄
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Un-nude Liquid Lipstick, Seductress
I always come back to this lipstick whenever I've tried other brands — the creamy texture just feels so much more comfortable, especially in colder months when my lips get dry.
Revlon Super Lustrous Creme Lipstick, Creamy Formula, 463 Sassy Mauve, 0.15 oz
Hydrating formula, buildable color, deep burgundy-plum shade for fall.
wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstick Black Orchid
Body Makeup
I've been using this balm stick for a while and I always reach for it when my skin feels dry or looks tired. I usually swipe it on my cheeks under my eyes my neck and even my lips whenever I want a little extra hydration. It gives my skin a healthy g...
PDRN Pink Collagen Balm Stick w/ Caffeine & Retinol
I wasn't expecting body makeup to look this natural but this one really impressed me. It blends in easily and gives my skin a smooth even finish while still looking like real skin. I love that it's waterproof because I don't have to keep checking if ...
Westmore Beauty Body Coverage Perfector 2N
Honestly wasn't expecting much since it's so affordable but it held up all day even through summer heat. Works on cheeks brow bone and shoulders. Wish the packaging was a bit sturdier since mine got a little melted in my bag once but the product itse...
Status Stick Face-And-Body Highlighter
swipe it on your cheekbones for makeup, then your collarbones for that 'I have a glow' event look.
High Road Highlight Status Stick Face-And-Body Highlighter