Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
discover Discover

Brow Pencils That Make Great Stocking Stuffers 🎄
Purple Star emoji 30 items
By
Judith Chetwood profile picture
Judith Chetwood
I'm that person who tries every brow pencil that exists. These are the ones I'd actually gift to someone I care about. All under stocking-stuffer price range!
Sections
6
 
Micro Brow Favorites ✏️
 
Best for Sparse Brows
 
Smoothest Formulas 🧈
 
Bold Brow Options
 
Blonde & Light Brow Shades 🌾
 
Travel-Size & Mini Sets 🎅

Micro Brow Favorites ✏️

These ultra-fine tips are what finally taught me how to do hair-like strokes. If you're gifting to a beginner, start here.

 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
the tip is SO fine. I can mimic real brow hairs with this one.
Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
been using this for years. never lets me down 🤎
Brow Wiz® Ultra-Slim Precision Eyebrow Defining Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
budget friendly and honestly performs like the expensive ones
Micro Brow Eyebrow Pencil | NYX Professional Makeup
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
smooth formula, doesn't tug on skin at all. my sister stole mine immediately lol
Brow Harmony Precision Eyebrow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
splurge pick but the precision is worth every penny
DIOR Diorshow Brow Styler Eyebrow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Best for Sparse Brows

My brows are naturally thin and patchy. These are the ones that actually fill without looking drawn on.

 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
the angled tip makes it so easy. perfect for people who are nervous about brow makeup 🙌
Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
fills gaps without looking heavy
Too Faced Super Fine Brow Detailer ≡ Sephora KSA
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
this one lasts ALL day. wore it through a 12 hour wedding and it stayed put
IT Cosmetics Brow Power Universal Brow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
tiny tip, big results. just get this one. trust me.
Brow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
gives the most natural finish I've found so far
Patrick Ta Major Brow Defining Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Smoothest Formulas 🧈

Some brow pencils feel like dragging a crayon across your face. These glide on like butter and I will never go back.

 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
literally glides on. zero tugging, zero skipping
Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
creamy but sets in place. doesn't smudge when I touch my face 50 times a day
Brow Shaping Gel | Nars ≡ SEPHORA
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
fancy pick for someone you really love lol 🎁
Crayon Définition Sourcils — Powder Eyebrow Pencil - Gucci
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
smooth application and the spoolie on the other end is actually good
Brow Define Pencil Precision Eyebrow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
the wax-pencil hybrid texture is really satisfying to apply
Fenty Beauty Brow MVP Ultra Fine Brow Pencil & Styler
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Bold Brow Options

For the friend who likes their brows BOLD. These pack more pigment and really define the shape.

 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
triangular tip lets you do thick strokes AND fine lines with the same pencil
Brow Definer Triangular Brow Pencil - Anastasia Beverly Hills
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
ink side plus pencil side. two tools in one, great stocking stuffer 🧦
Brow Blade Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil & Ink Stain
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
classic for a reason. buildable pigment that doesn't get cakey
MAC Cosmetics Eyebrow
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
waterproof and it actually means it. survived a pool day
Aqua Resist Brow Definer | Make Up For Ever ≡ SEPHORA
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
deep pigment right away, no need to layer
Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Blonde & Light Brow Shades 🌾

Finding a brow pencil that doesn't turn orange on light brows is a nightmare. These actually match.

 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
true cool blonde. no warmth, no orange, finally
Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil 0.08g
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
taupe is the shade that works for like 90% of light-haired people
Brow Wiz® Ultra-Slim Precision Eyebrow Defining Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
soft and natural. my blonde friends always ask what I used on them
Brow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
newest find. really impressed with the shade range 💛
Brow Harmony Precision Eyebrow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
doesn't pull warm on fair skin which is all I ask for honestly
Too Faced Super Fine Brow Detailer ≡ Sephora KSA
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Travel-Size & Mini Sets 🎅

Actual stocking-sized picks. These minis are perfect when you want to gift something small but still really good.

 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
has everything in one tiny package. perfect intro to brow stuff
Benefit Brow Pencils & Kits | Makeup
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
same great pencil, half the size, half the price
Mini Brow Wiz® Ultra-Slim Precision Brow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
I throw these in every gift bag. people always love them
Mini Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
mini but still lasts me about 6 weeks of daily use
Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat Set
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Judith Chetwood profile picture
universal shade option is great when you're not sure what color to pick 🤷‍♀️
IT Cosmetics Brow Power Universal Brow Pencil
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder