Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Mascara Must Haves!!

Purple Star emoji 85 items
Want a mascara that won't be clumpy, flakey, or irritate your eyes? Try these beauties!
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Honestly, I cannot put people on to this mascara enough, it is my favorite in a very long time. It adds volume, it adds length, it curls, it doesn't flake or clump. A unique spoolie with two different sided brush applies your mascara perfectly, allow...
BADgal BOUNCE Volumizing & Lifting Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
No other brand does mascara like Benefit. BadGal Bang offers a range of colors and a waterproof version. You can rest assured your eyelashes will be bold, long, and lush!
BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Such a beautiful mascara! Not only is it a black woman owned business, they make amazing makeup! Their mascara adds such length, you dont even need to bother with falsies.
Lash-Amplifying Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Adds beautiful volume and length, no flakes and no problems, a staple!
Lash Brag® Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of my first makeup purchases and I have repurchased over and over since. Such a beautiful mascara, really beautiful length.
Lash Sculpt Lengthening & Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
A bit pricey but in this case, you get what you pay for. A very beautiful mascara that lifts the lashes it looks like you've had an eye lift without the work.
Vertigo Lift Extreme Length Mascara - Armani beauty Canada​
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This is a really nice mascara, it's everything a mascara should be. I wore this in Bali and it never ran or flaked. Very elegant.
Fan Fest Fanning Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
A Legend. A classic. Every makeup artist has used this at one point. Very beautiful and wears gorgeously!
Eyes To Kill Classico Mascara - Eye Makeup - Armani-beauty.ca
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of the bests on the market! I wore this to my best friend's wedding and she wanted to wear it too when she was getting ready. You can buy the dupe from elf, which is also nice, but you CANT beat the og.
Roller Lash Curling Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Very flashy, very lengthy, a beautiful choice for people with short lashes. Will make anyone's eyes pop!
Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! Lengthening Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
An extreme version of her sister, very lengthening, very bold, a classic in everyone's makeup bag!
They're Real! Magnet Extreme Lengthening Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
There are a couple different versions of this one and ill add them next because they're good too, but the original is so so good. One of 3 tubing mascaras that I love. So good.
Blinc Original TUBING™ Mascara | Vegan & Cruelty-Free
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This is another version of the original. It's the same only adds more length and a little more volume than the og.
Blinc Lash Extension Lengthening and Defining Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This is a must have makeup for complementing smokey eye makeup.
Smokey Eye Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of the best mascaras from the drug store, I constantly repurchase this and keep one in my purse at all times, so good!
Telescopic Original Mascara Blackest Black
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Literally like a raincoat for your lashes, they're always covered and look so nice. I love this one so much.
No Smudge Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Literally went viral for a reason, I think this is the best mascara at the drug store, hands down.
Lash Sensational® Sky High Washable Mascara Makeup
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Achieves a beautiful eye opening effect, perfect for hooded eyes. Makes your eyes look like a doe.
Eye Opening Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Such a beautiful formula, I absolutely love this one. I always find myself reaching for this one every now and then.
BUXOM® Lash Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Comes in different shades and a really nice formula. Pricey but worth it, I adore this mascara.
Lash Clash Mascara - Mascara - Yves Saint Laurent Beauty CA
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Also comes in brown. I don't know why people aren't talking about this mascara enough or how it hasn't gone viral.
Eye Want You Mascara in Clean Black by Westman Atelier
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Also comes in waterproof. One of my go tos for a night out, looks beautiful paired with falsies.
Perversion Mascara for Bold, Voluminous Lashes - Urban Decay CA
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Caliray is such an underrated brand. Who doesn't care about our oceans? This mascara is perfect for a day on the beach!
Come Hell or High Water Volumizing Tubing Mascara - caliray
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
The way I squealed the first time I applied this mascara. The curl it gives is so so beautiful, I dont think it can be duped!
Exagger-Eyes Volume Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Me and my girlfriends used to carry these in our book bags in high school. We loved it back then and still repurchase to this day!
Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
It's so easy to build on your lashes, making them look like your wearing fake ones.
Full Fat Lashes - Buildable Volumising Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Such an iconic mascara, the fairest of them all!
Legendary Lashes Volume 2 - Black - Volumnising Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Run, do not walk, to your local Sephora and purchase this mascara, you're whole makeup routine will be changed for the better. Not only is this brand indigenous owned, their makeup is unbelievable! One of my favorite brands ever.
Uprise Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Everybody and their mother and possible grandmother has heard and probably owned a clinique high impact mascara lol it's unique, it's clinique, enough said!
High Impact™ Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This is a super long wearing, gorgeous mascara and a decent price too. Very good quality at clinique.
Lash Power™ Mascara Long-Wearing Formula
placeholder
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I was very hesitant at first because well, it's chubby (like me), and i didn't think it would be easy application. Boy i was wrong. It's super easy and really makes your lashes volumized.
Chubby Lash™ Thickening + Volumizing Mascara
placeholder
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
The curve on this mascara applicator is *muah* chefs kiss. The curl and volume this mascara brings is legendary.
High Impact Zero Gravity™ Tubing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
She's viral. She's a classic. She is a bloody legend. Who doesn't love a tartlette?
tartelette™ tubing mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
She's an Icon next to her little sister, make sure to add her to your collection.
tartelette™ XL tubing mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
So. Much. Volume. She's amazing.
maneater™ voluptuous mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This mascara, specifically the waterproof one, got me through university. I love her.
lights, camera, lashes™ 4-in-1 24-hour mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Such a beautiful curling mascara, comes in different colors and waterproof.
Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Refillable Mascara: Volume & Curl
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of my favorites, gives your lashes a big boost.
Diorshow Pump 'N' Volume Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
A really good mascara primer. I dont usually use one but when I reach for one, it's this one.
Diorshow Maximizer 4D: Lash Primer-Serum and Lash Care
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of the best mascaras on the market. Extreme volume.
Diorshow Overvolume Mascara: No-Transfer Volume ...
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of the best drug store mascaras. I have 4 in my drawer they're that good.
Snapscara washable mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Rihanna knows best, shes the queen, and her mascara is bomb.
Hella Thicc Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Skincare and makeup. Nourishes your lashes while looking beautiful.
LASHROCKET MASCARA with Lash Enhancing Peptides - Freck Beauty
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Givenchy really out did themselves with this beautiful mascara. Such volume and length.
L'interdit Mascara Couture Volume
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Disturbia. I was disturbed at how amazing this mascara was.
Volume Disturbia - 24h wear volume & curve mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Glossier really jumped in the game with this tubing mascara. Comes in brown also and gives Tarte a run for their money.
Lash Slick
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
A really good lash primer. Lengthening and thickening.
GrandePRIMER Pre-Mascara Lengthener & Thickener
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This adds insane volume, trust me, paired with their primer, looks like you're wearing falsies.
Volumizing & Lengthening GrandeMASCARA
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of the blackest mascaras I've ever used. Good quality spoolie.
Mascara Le Magnétisme, black in 01 Eve black
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
You cant go wrong with a Gucci. Seriously.
Gucci L'Obscur Lengthening Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
A dupe for the benefit. Hardly legal to be that good.
Lash 'N Roll® Curling & Lifting Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
My favorite from elf, so good.
Lash XTNDR Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Such an iconic mascara, a must try!
Big Mood Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This mascara is so unique, I would buy it over and over again it's that good.
Mile High Club™ Length and Define Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Such an amazing formula. One of Pacificas best products.
Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mineral Mascara - Pacifica
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of Sheglams best sellers and always a favorite of mine. Comes in waterproof, black, brown, blue, burgundy.
All-In-One Volume & Length Mascara-Waterproof Brugundy
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This formula is fantastic, they really knew what to do.
Long-Lasting, Lengthening, Lifting Mascaras - ICONIC London
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Brown or black. Very nurturing and looks so beautiful all day long.
Saie Mascara 101 with Beeswax
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This mascara will give you confidence for days.
Lash Confidence Volume + Length + Curl Clean Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I freaking love clarins. They've been around for so long and really know what we need.
Wonder Perfect Mascara 4D
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Literally looks like you're wearing falsies.
Wonder Volume Mascara XXL | Long Lasting Thick Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I would love to try this mascara again for the first time. You really do say wow!
HUDA BEAUTY 1 Coat WOW! Extra Volumizing and Lifting Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I was not expecting this mascara to be that good. Trust me.
MAXIMIST® Phyto-Fiber Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I literally had someone tell me they never tried this mascara because they believed Lise Watier to be an old woman brand, a grandma brand. Girl, you were missing out. This is one of the nicest formulas on the damn market.
Eye Opening Vegan
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Sheglam has been killing it lately. This is a ten in one formula, absolutely amazing product.
All-In-One 24k Multi-Effect Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I cannot stress this enough. Try this mascara. Just try it and tell me what you think.
Watch Me! Volumizing and Lengthening Mascara with Pe
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Feels like I'm committing a crime it's that good. The aliens sent us this.
DARK STAR Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I didn't know Juice made a mascara, but let me tell you I was not disappointed.
Organic Ultra-Natural Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Words cannot express how much i love this mascara. Such a babe.
Lash Idôle Clump-free Volumizing Mascara - Lancôme Canada
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of my favorite mascara spoolies I've ever used. So big but not messy. Perfect.
Hypnôse Volumizing Mascara - Up to 8X Lash Volume - Lancôme - Lancome.ca
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Half Caked have come so far the past couple of years, they deserve all the success they have.
Eye Defy Zero Gravity Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
This is so unique. Literally two mascaras in one. One side is length. Other is volume. Use one side alone or mix them together for an amazing look.
Lash Besties 2-In-1 Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Literally removes your mascara off your lashes in half a minute. Such a cool product.
Clean Queen Mascara Remover | Cleanser Goes Directly on Lashes
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
They dont make this anymore and I have 3 in my drawer. I believe this was Becky Gs makeup brand, but I loved so many of their products.
Tresluce Beauty JET BLACK Mascara Ilusion Volumizing & Lengthening ...
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Toyfactory is so unique, all their products smash.
Hylash™ Hyaluronic Serum Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Extremely volumizing. One of the first Sheglam products I bought.
Max Impact Extreme Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I've gone through multiple tubes of this mascara. I love Rimmel so much.
Wonder'luxe Volume Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Marcelle is not a very popular brand but they have really really good mascaras. Any of them will make you happy.
Mascaras - Marcelle
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
I dont know why more people are not talking about Laura Geller. Way overlooked, very good products.
Kajal Longwear Mascara | Long-Lasting, Conditioning and Volumizing Formula
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
The first mascara I ever owned.
Mega Volume Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
Wet N Wild are so amazing, they've been making beautiful products for so long.
wet n wild Enhance & Define Megawear Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
A great every day mascara.
Big Time Eyes Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
A beautiful formula that won't budge all day long.
Flutter Wink Volumizing Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
It's such a unique product. It's almost like the spoolie is non existent but it works so well.
Lift & Elevate Lengthening Mascara
 
Karen Saunders profile picture
One of my all time favorites!
Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara - Too Faced