Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Nailed Turkey Pot Pie With Thanksgiving Leftovers Under Puff Pastry
33
items Staring at a fridge packed with leftover turkey, random veggies, and a container of gravy nobody wants to reheat again? Same. Every year I used to toss half of it by Sunday. This is the exact setup that turned my Thanksgiving leftovers into the best ...
Sections
11
Puff Pastry That Actually Puffs Golden on Top
Broth and Gravy Base That Ties Everything Together
Frozen Veggies That Save You From Chopping Anything
Seasonings That Make Leftover Turkey Taste Fresh Again
Baking Dishes That Go From Oven to Table
Thickeners So Your Filling Isn't Soup
Puff Pastry That Actually Puffs Golden on Top
I went through three brands that came out soggy or flat before landing on these. The right pastry is the difference between a pot pie that looks homemade and one that looks like a sad science experiment.
Grab a box and keep it in the freezer year-round. This is the one that actually puffs into flaky layers without collapsing into the filling. If you've ever pulled a flat, greasy sheet off the top of a pot pie, swap to this immediately.
Pepperidge Farm Puff Pastry Frozen Pastry Dough Sheets
Try this if you want a slightly thicker, butterier top crust. My sister-in-law is the one who told me about it, and she was right. Thaws fast, rolls out without cracking, and browns beautifully at 400 degrees.
Jus-Rol Puff Pastry Pre-Rolled Dough, 13.2 oz, Vegan
Use this when you're out of puff pastry and need a backup that still works. It's not traditional, but it seals over a baking dish surprisingly well. Perfect for the person who forgot to defrost anything and dinner is in two hours.
Pillsbury Dough Sheet, Original Crescent
Broth and Gravy Base That Ties Everything Together
Leftover gravy alone sometimes isn't enough to fill a whole pie. I learned that the hard way when my first attempt came out dry in the middle. A little extra liquid base fixes everything.
Pour about a cup into your filling if your leftover gravy is thick or you didn't save enough. Keeps everything saucy without watering down the flavor. Stock up now because you'll use the rest for soup later that week.
Swanson Chicken Broth, 32 oz Carton
Keep a packet in the pantry for when your homemade gravy ran out on Thursday. Whisking this together takes three minutes and nobody at the table will know the difference. Seriously, nobody.
McCormick Turkey Gravy Seasoning Mix, 0.87 oz Packet
Swap this in if you want a deeper, earthier flavor in your filling. A friend who doesn't even like mushrooms used this and said her pot pie tasted like it came from a restaurant. It's subtle but it works.
Pacific Foods Organic Mushroom Broth, 32 oz Carton
Frozen Veggies That Save You From Chopping Anything
After cooking a full Thanksgiving meal, the last thing I want to do is stand at a cutting board dicing carrots. Frozen mixed veggies go straight into the pot and nobody can tell.
Toss a whole bag into your pot pie filling without thawing. Carrots, corn, peas, green beans, all the classics. For anyone who already spent six hours cooking on Thursday and refuses to chop one more vegetable.
Birds Eye Steamfresh Mixed Vegetables
Throw in a handful if your mixed veggies don't have enough peas. My kids pick out the peas specifically, so I always add extra. They're tiny, sweet, and disappear into the gravy perfectly.
Great Value No Salt Added Green Peas, 15 oz
Try these if you want veggies that hold their shape better after baking. They come out with a little more bite instead of mushy. Took me two pot pies to figure out that not all frozen veggie bags bake the same.
Pictsweet Farms Frozen Vegetables and Fruit Mixes
Seasonings That Make Leftover Turkey Taste Fresh Again
Reheated turkey can taste flat and sad. A few specific seasonings brought mine back to life and made the whole filling smell like I was cooking from scratch.
Sprinkle about a teaspoon into your filling while it simmers. This is what makes leftover turkey stop tasting like leftovers. Wish someone had told me this five Thanksgivings ago instead of letting me serve bland pot pie.
McCormick Kosher Poultry Seasoning, 0.65 oz Bottle
Use a pinch alongside your other seasonings for that warm, herby smell that fills the kitchen. For anyone who wants their pot pie to smell like it's been simmering all day even though you threw it together in 30 minutes.
Simply Organic Whole Thyme Leaf, Certified Organic
Grab this instead of regular table salt. A good pinch at the end of cooking brings every flavor forward. I under-salted my first two pot pies and couldn't figure out why they tasted so flat. This was the fix.
Morton Kosher Salt Flakes 3 lb.
Baking Dishes That Go From Oven to Table
My first pot pie went into a random casserole dish and looked terrible. The right dish makes it look intentional, and it holds heat so the filling stays hot while everyone gets seconds.
Use this for a family-sized pot pie that feeds six easily. Goes straight from oven to table without looking like you're serving out of lab equipment. Plus it's clear so you can see if the filling is bubbling before you pull it out.
Pyrex Deep 9" x 13" Bakeware Dish with Sage Lid
Try this for a round pot pie that looks more classic. Fits perfectly under a single sheet of puff pastry with no trimming. For the person who wants their pot pie to actually look like a pie.
Anchor Hocking, Oven Basics Casserole Bowl, 2 qt
Keep these around for making individual pot pies or giving one to a neighbor. They're disposable so cleanup is nothing. I made three small ones last year and froze one for the following week.
Great Value Aluminum Pans with Board Lids, 8 in x 8
Thickeners So Your Filling Isn't Soup
The first time I made this, I poured everything in without thickening and the pastry just floated on turkey soup. A little flour or roux fixes that in two minutes.
Whisk two tablespoons into melted butter before adding your broth. That's it. That's the roux. If your filling is runny, this is the reason, and it takes literally 90 seconds to fix.
Gold Medal All Purpose Flour, Baking Flour, 5 lb Bag
Swap this in if you want a gluten-free option or a slightly glossier gravy. Mix a tablespoon with cold water first, then stir it in. Learned the hard way that dumping it straight into hot liquid creates weird clumps.
Argo 100% Pure Corn Starch, 16 Oz
Use real butter for your roux base. The flavor difference between this and margarine is night and day. My pot pie filling went from cafeteria-grade to something I'd actually be proud to serve at the table.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Salted Pure Irish Butter, 8 oz.
Cooking Utensils That Make Assembly Less Messy
Pot pie filling is hot, thick, and wants to splash everywhere. Having the right spoon and spatula saved me from burning myself and from scrubbing the stovetop for 20 minutes.
Stir your filling with this instead of a metal spoon that conducts heat straight to your hand. The slots let excess liquid drain so you can control how thick each scoop is. Feels nice to hold, too.
Kitchenaid Bamboo 2-Piece Spoon and Short Turner
Use this to spread filling evenly in the dish before laying pastry on top. It scrapes every last bit out of the pot so nothing goes to waste. For anyone who hates leaving good gravy stuck to the bottom of a pan.
Farberware Professional Silicone Kitchen Spatula Set
Lay a sheet on your baking tray under the dish to catch any filling that bubbles over. Saved me from scrubbing baked-on gravy off the oven floor twice now. Toss it when you're done, zero cleanup.
Reynolds Kitchens Stay Flat Parchment Paper Roll
Sharp Knives for Shredding Leftover Turkey Fast
Pulling apart a turkey carcass with your hands is slow and gross. A decent knife turns the whole bird into pot pie chunks in five minutes flat.
Slice through leftover turkey breast like butter. The self-sharpening sleeve means it's actually sharp when you grab it, unlike every dull knife sitting in my drawer for three years.
Farberware Edgekeeper 8-inch Chef Knife with Self
Keep this set around for cutting veggies, slicing turkey, and everything else. Color-coded handles so you remember which one you used on raw chicken last week. For anyone whose knife block is full of knives that can't cut a tomato.
Cuisinart, Kitchen Knife Set, 12-Piece
Snip through turkey joints and cartilage without wrestling the whole bird. Way faster than a knife for breaking down a carcass. I resisted buying these for years and now I can't believe I ever used a fork and my bare hands.
OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Kitchen Poultry Shears
Egg Wash Supplies for That Bakery-Level Golden Top
Skipping the egg wash was my biggest mistake the first time. The pastry came out pale and dull. One egg plus a brush changed everything.
Crack one egg, whisk it with a splash of water, brush it on the pastry before baking. That's the whole secret to a golden, shiny top. You already have eggs in the fridge, just don't forget this step like I did the first three times.
Great Value Large White Eggs, 12 Count
Brush egg wash on evenly without tearing the pastry. Silicone bristles don't shed into your food like those old-school pastry brushes. For anyone who's ever found a bristle baked into their crust and silently screamed.
Wilton Dusting Brush Set
Whisk your egg wash right in this. Pour spout means you can drizzle extra over the pastry edges without making a mess. Also perfect for measuring out broth earlier in the process, so it pulls double duty.
Pyrex, Measuring Cup, 1 Cup, Easy-Read Marks, Clear
Side Dishes That Round Out the Whole Meal
Pot pie alone is filling, but something fresh on the side makes it feel like an actual dinner instead of just reheated leftovers in a new costume.
Toss this together in two minutes while the pot pie bakes. The crunch and acidity cut through all that rich gravy. For anyone who needs something green on the plate so it doesn't look like a beige-food-only situation.
Fresh Express Thai N Cashews Chopped Salad Kit, Greens
Pop these in the oven during the last 10 minutes of baking your pot pie. They come out soft and warm without any effort. Perfect for sopping up extra gravy that pools on your plate.
Sister Schubert's Dinner Yeast Rolls 13 Oz, 10 Count
Pair a cup of this alongside your pot pie for a sweet contrast. Sounds weird, but it works the same way cranberry sauce works with turkey. My dad started doing this and now everyone at the table copies him.
Mott's Applesauce Cups, 4 Ounce, 6 Count, Apple Flavor
Storage Containers for Freezing Extra Pot Pie Filling
Making a double batch and freezing half is the smartest move. Future you will be thrilled to find pot pie filling in the freezer on a random Wednesday in January.
Fill these with extra pot pie filling, snap the lid, and freeze. They stack flat so they don't take up weird space. Thaw one out in three weeks when you're tired of cooking and just want something warm and easy.
Rubbermaid, Food Storage Containers, 5 Cup, 8 Pack
Use these for single-serving portions of filling. Grab one, thaw it, pour it in a ramekin, top with pastry, done. For the person living alone who doesn't want to commit to a full casserole dish every time.
Glad Food Storage Containers, 24 Ounce, Small, 4pk
Wrap assembled individual pot pies tightly before freezing. The heavy duty version doesn't tear or get freezer burn like the thin stuff. Learned that lesson after pulling out a frost-covered disaster in February.
Reynolds Wrap Heavy Duty Aluminum Foil Roll