Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Bridesmaid Proposal Boxes You Can Shop

Shopping Bags emoji 14 items
The best bridesmaid proposal box ideas — from personalized keepsakes to fun, celebratory gifts. This list includes unique finds your bridal party will love, including my own handmade wine charms from my Etsy shop. Perfect for making your ‘Will you be... 
This list contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through them - at no extra cost to you
Sections
5
 
 
 
 
 

The Box Itself

Start with the perfect base for your bridesmaid proposal. Whether you love sleek magnetic-close boxes, rustic wooden crates, or clear acrylic for a modern vibe, these options set the tone for your gift.

 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
These are the boxes we used for our bridesmaid and groomsmen gift boxes!
ValBox 12 White 8x8x4 Gift Boxes w/Lids
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
the stripes and bow are super cute
Blue/White Striped Large Gift Box - Sugar Paper™: Paperboard, 9.875"x9.875"x5", All Occasions, Giftbox with Lid
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
for more of a crate vibe!
Light Wood Crate Gift Basket Kit With Handles
placeholder

Personalized Touches

Add something truly special that your bridesmaids can keep forever. From custom wine charms (like my own Etsy design) to name decals or engraved keepsakes, personalization makes your proposal unforgettable

 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
I make and sell these custom wine glass charms!! Check out my shop if you are interested :)
Custom Beaded Monogram Wine Charm | Personalized Gift | Wedding Favor | Bridesmaid Gift | Hostess Gift | Drink Marker
placeholder
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
love the quilted design!
Personalized Embroidered Floral Makeup Bag: Perfect for Bridesmaids, Bridal Shower, Travel Organizer, Christmas Gift
placeholder
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
Perfect for a beach bachelorette!
Personalized Beach Bag,Custom Girls Trip Bag,Bridesmaid Beach Tote Bags,Bachelorette Gifts for Her,Summer Beach Bag,Bridesmaid Gifts Bags
placeholder

Drinkware & Drinks

Pair your proposal with a celebratory sip! Choose elegant champagne coupes, classic wine glasses, or fun tumblers—plus mini champagne bottles or sparkling cider for a toast-worthy surprise.

 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
This set was perfect since I was asking 6 bridesmaids!
LUXULISH Ribbed Coupe Glasses Set of 6 - 10Oz
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
Bought these mini bottle and made custom labels for them with information about the wedding!
La Marca Prosecco mini bottles
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
love the etched flowers
Wildflower Stemless Champagne Flute | Floral Stemless Glass | Bridal Stemless Glass | Bridal Stemless Champagne Glass | Champagne Flute

Pampering Items

Treat your bridesmaids to a little self-care. Add candles, bath salts, face masks, or dainty jewelry for a luxe touch that shows your appreciation

 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
I bought a variety of these! Honestly wish I had gotten an extra for myself
Textured Heart Dish
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
bought this for my maid of honor :)
It's a bad day to be a hot dog Embroidered Hat, Funny Reader Hat, 4th of July Embroidered Tee, To be a Hot dog Hat, Sarcastic Dad Hat
placeholder
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
perfect to split up in the boxes!
Mini Lip Glowy Balm Set

Filling & Presentation

Tie everything together with beautiful presentation. Use crinkle paper, tissue, or shredded wood fill to cushion items, and finish with ribbon, dried flowers, or custom tags

 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
We used this crinkle cut paper for our boxes in the fresh blue color! 2 lb was more than enough for 12 boxes total, we will have leftovers for a while
2 LB Beige Crinkle Cut Paper Shred Filler
 
Lauren Sewald profile picture
Used this ribbon to tie bows on the glasses I included!
Hiswan 3/4in Royal Blue Sheer Organza Ribbon 50yd