Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found the Eyebrow Pencil That Replaced My Monthly Salon Visits
28
items Spending $40 every three weeks on eyebrow shaping felt normal until I did the math and realized I was dropping over $600 a year on something I could learn to do myself. If you've got sparse brows, uneven arches, or just never learned how to fill them...
Sections
7
Eyebrow Pencils That Actually Look Like Real Hair
Brow Gels That Lock Everything in Place
Stencils and Guides for Symmetrical Brows
Concealers That Clean Up Brow Edges
Brushes That Make a Real Difference
Brow Pomades for Days You Want More Definition
Eyebrow Pencils That Actually Look Like Real Hair
Finding a pencil thin enough to mimic hair strokes was the whole battle. I went through six duds before landing on ones that don't smudge by lunch or leave thick waxy marks.
Grab this if your brows have gaps that make you self-conscious on video calls. The tip is genuinely micro-thin, so I can draw individual strokes where my left brow just decides to stop growing. A coworker asked if I got microblading.
NYX Professional Makeup Micro Eyebrow Pencil Ash
Wore this through a 10-hour wedding in August humidity and it looked the same in every photo. Perfect for anyone who touches their face constantly (guilty). Stock up because they sell out in the darker shades.
Tattoo Studio® 36 HR Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil
Switch to this if you want something stiffer than most drugstore pencils. It doesn't deposit too much product, which saved me from the blocky brow look I kept accidentally creating when I first started doing my own.
L'Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer Waterproof Eyebrow
Keep this in your bag for touch-ups. The built-in spoolie is actually decent, not one of those scratchy ones that does nothing. Great for people with medium brown brows who can never find the right shade.
Revlon ColorStay Brow Creator, 635 Medium Brown, 0.01 oz
Brow Gels That Lock Everything in Place
Pencil without gel is like doing your hair and skipping hairspray. I learned this the hard way when I rubbed my eyebrow mid-meeting and smeared half of it across my forehead.
Use this before your pencil if you want that fluffy laminated look without paying $80 at a salon. My thin brows suddenly look like they belong on someone with actual volume. Dries clear and doesn't flake.
Nyx Professional Makeup, The Brow Glue, Instant Brow Styler
Toss this in your morning routine if you only have 30 seconds. Some days I skip pencil entirely and just brush this through. Adds enough tint and hold that nobody can tell you did your brows in the car.
Maybelline, Brow Fast Sculpt Eyebrow Gel Mascara
For anyone who thinks $3 can't buy a good brow product, prepare to be wrong. This tiny tube outlasted two higher-end gels I was using. The fiber formula fills in sparse spots without looking clumpy.
e.l.f. cosmetics Wow Brow Gel
Snag this if your brows grow in different directions like mine do. One swipe tames everything and adds a slight tint. I wish someone had told me about this before I spent years looking permanently surprised.
COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Volumizing Setting Gel
Stencils and Guides for Symmetrical Brows
My biggest fear doing my own brows was ending up with two completely different shapes. One always wanted to be an arch and the other wanted to be a straight line.
Try this if you're just starting to do your own brows and feel overwhelmed. Comes with multiple shades so you can mix to match. The included brush gave me way more control than using the pencil alone.
Aesthetica Brow Contour Kit 16-Piece
Pair these with your pencil when you want both brows to actually match. Held one up, traced the shape, done. Felt silly at first but the results made me wonder why salons charge so much for the same concept.
Ardell Brow Perfection 4 Stencils #68065
Get this for under $3 and practice on a weekend when nobody's watching. Four different arch shapes so you can figure out what suits your face. Took me three tries to find my shape but now I can freehand it.
e.l.f. Cosmetics e.l.f. Eyebrow Stencil Kit
Use these if you've got a rounder face and the standard arch stencils look weird on you. More shape variety than most kits. Saved me from the skinny 2004 brow I kept accidentally giving myself.
Billion Dollar Brows Brow Buddy Kit Symmetrical Eyebrow
Concealers That Clean Up Brow Edges
Nobody told me the secret to crisp brows isn't the pencil itself. It's cleaning up the edges with concealer after. The day I figured this out, everything changed.
Dab a tiny bit under your brow arch and blend it out. Suddenly your brows look professionally shaped even if your hand was shaking. For anyone whose brows look good from far away but messy up close.
Instant Age Rewind® Eraser Multi-Use Concealer
Grab this if you want full coverage cleanup without spending more than $7. A flat brush and a thin line of this under each brow makes the whole thing look intentional. Wish I'd known this trick two years ago.
e.l.f. Cosmetics 16HR Camo Concealer, Medium Beige
Try this for a lighter touch. Sometimes you don't want full concealer, just a subtle cleanup. Works well for people with dry under-brow skin because it doesn't cling to flaky patches.
NYX Professional Makeup HD Photogenic Concealer Wand
Swap to this if you need something that won't budge during long days. One tiny dot on an angled brush gives you the sharpest tail. My brows went from looking DIY to looking like I paid someone.
ColorStay Flex Wear Full Cover™ Concealer
Brushes That Make a Real Difference
Using the built-in spoolie felt fine until I tried actual brushes. The difference was like going from finger-painting to using real art supplies. Not exaggerating.
Toss your old eyeliner brush and use the angled one from this set instead. The bristles are stiff enough to create precise lines but soft enough that you don't scratch your brow bone. Worth every dollar.
Brow Styling Set, 1 Set, Real Techniques
Keep this at your desk for midday fixes. One end blends, the other defines. For anyone tired of carrying a whole makeup bag just to maintain their brows through an 8-hour shift.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyebrow Duo Brush
Use the flat end to apply pomade and the spoolie to soften harsh lines. Finally stopped looking like I stamped my brows on. If you're transitioning from pencil-only to adding pomade, start here.
NYX Professional Makeup Pro Dual Brow Brush
Snag this specifically for concealer cleanup around your brows. Flat, firm, and under $2. I bought three because I kept losing them in my makeup drawer. Works better than brushes five times the price.
Wet n Wild small concealer brush
Brow Pomades for Days You Want More Definition
Some mornings call for bolder brows. Date night, photos, or just feeling like your pencil alone isn't cutting it. Pomade scared me at first but these were forgiving enough to learn with.
Try this on nights out when you want your brows to be the main character. Creamy enough to blend mistakes but pigmented enough that one layer does the job. My going-out brows look salon-level now.
NYX Professional Makeup Tame & Frame Brow Pomade
Get this if pomade intimidates you. It's more forgiving than most and you can build it up slowly. Started using this on weekends to practice and within a month I was confident enough for workdays.
e.l.f. Lock on Liner and Brow Cream, Light Brown, 0.19 oz
Pair this with an angled brush and light pressure. Goes on smooth without dragging. For anyone who tried pomade once, looked like Groucho Marx, and swore it off forever. Give it another shot with this one.
Maybelline Tattoo Studio Brow Pomade, Ash Brown
Wear this when you need 12-plus hours of hold and zero smudging. Survived a rainy outdoor concert without budging. If you've got oily skin around your brows, this formula won't slide off by afternoon.
Milani Stay Put Brow Color, Soft Brown, 0.09 oz
Brow Growth and Care for Sparse Spots
Half the battle was filling in brows that barely existed in certain spots. Started treating them like skincare, not just makeup, and the regrowth after a few months honestly surprised me.
Use this nightly if you over-plucked in high school and your brows never fully came back. Took about six weeks before I noticed baby hairs filling in the tails. Pricey but cheaper than a year of salon visits.
Customer reviews for Grande Cosmetics GrandeBrow
Grab this as a budget-friendly option to test whether serums even work for you before committing to expensive ones. Noticed slightly fuller brows after two months. For anyone skeptical but curious.
Physicians Formula Eye Booster™ Lash 2-in-1 Boosting
Dab this on your brows with a spoolie before bed. Old school remedy but my grandma swore by it and honestly the sparse patch near my left arch started filling in. Under $10 and lasts forever.
Sky Organics Organic Castor Oil
Take this daily alongside your topical routine. Won't work overnight but after three months my brows and nails both got noticeably stronger. For anyone who wants to attack sparse brows from the inside out.
Nature's Bounty Biotin Supplement, 10000mcg, 120 Softgels