Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried 30+ Hair Ties to Find Ones That Don't Crease or Pull
35
items Spending ten minutes smoothing out a dent in your hair after pulling out a ponytail is so defeating. If you have fine hair that breaks easily or thick hair that laughs at flimsy elastics, I tested way too many options over the past year so you can sk...
Sections
7
Spiral Hair Ties That Leave Zero Dents
Silk and Satin Hair Ties for Breakage-Prone Hair
Ribbon and Flat Hair Ties for Fine Hair
Thick Hair Solutions That Actually Hold All Day
Claw Clips and Alternatives When You Need Zero Tension
Workout Hair Ties That Survive Sweat and Movement
Spiral Hair Ties That Leave Zero Dents
I used to take my hair down before a meeting and spend five minutes trying to fluff out the crease. These spiral styles grip without leaving evidence you ever wore a ponytail.
Switch to these if you pull your hair down midday and need it to look untouched. I wore one through an eight-hour shift and my blowout still looked fresh when I took it out.
Invisibobble Original Black & Clear Traceless Hair Ring 8
Grab a pack if your hair is on the thinner side. They hold without that death grip feeling, and my fine strands stopped snapping after I ditched regular elastics for these.
Kitsch Spiral Hair Ties for Women
Try these if you want spiral ties but don't want to spend a fortune. They come in neutral colors that disappear in dark hair, and they held up through three months of daily use before stretching out.
Goody Planet Goody® Black Ponytail Holder Coils, 5 CT
Keep a few of these in your gym bag. They survived sweaty workouts without sliding, and when I pulled my hair down after, zero crease. My friend with super thick curls swears by them too.
Scunci Spiral Ponytailer, Assorted Colors, 6 Ct (2 pack)
Snag this if you lose hair ties like I do. You get enough to stash everywhere, your car, your desk, your bathroom. They bounce back to shape after stretching, which cheaper spirals never did for me.
(4 pack) Scunci Ponytail Fabric Hair Spirals
Silk and Satin Hair Ties for Breakage-Prone Hair
My colorist told me to stop using cotton elastics because they were literally sanding my highlights off. These silk and satin options changed everything.
Use these if you color-treat your hair and notice breakage around your ponytail line. They're pricey for scrunchies but my stylist stopped asking what was damaging my ends, so that says everything.
Slip Small Slipsilk™ Scrunchies - 6 pack
Wear one to bed if you wake up with tangled bird's nest hair. I started sleeping in these and my morning detangling went from ten minutes to about two. Worth it for that alone.
Kitsch Satin Sleep Scrunchies 5PC Set Black Soft & Gentle
Toss these in your work bag for a polished look that won't rip out baby hairs. They come in solid neutral shades so they actually match business casual outfits instead of looking like a 90s throwback.
Scunci Mini Matte Satin Scrunchies, Multicolor, 8 Count
Pair these with a silk pillowcase if you're serious about reducing friction damage. My bleached ends were snapping constantly until I switched, and three months later the breakage basically stopped.
Customer reviews for Blissy Silk Scrunchie Pack - Regular
Grab these if you want satin softness without the bulk of a full scrunchie. They sit flat in thick hair and don't leave marks. Perfect for anyone who wants a sleek low pony without the crease aftermath.
Conair Satin Pillowcase - Sleep & Protect, 1 Count
Ribbon and Flat Hair Ties for Fine Hair
Regular elastics would yank out clumps of my fine hair every single time. Flat ties distribute pressure differently, and my shower drain finally stopped looking like a crime scene.
Try these if thin elastics cut into your hair and leave a sharp crease. The flat ribbon shape spreads the tension out so nothing gets kinked. I wore one all day at a wedding and my curls survived.
Shop Hair Twist Ties and Hair Accessories Online
Keep these around if you have fine hair that breaks when you look at it wrong. They slide out without dragging strands with them. My daughter has wispy toddler hair and even she doesn't cry when I take these out.
Customer reviews for Goody Ouchless Ribbon Elastics
Swap your regular elastics for these before you lose any more hair. They hold a low bun surprisingly well for how gentle they feel, and they come in packs big enough that losing a few doesn't sting.
(2 pack) Scunci No Damage Elastic Ponytail Hair Ties
Snag these if you've tried everything and still get creases. They're the one tie my hairstylist actually uses in the salon. Not cheap, but they last over a year without losing stretch.
Customer reviews for L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders
Use these for half-up styles when you need something that won't slide out but also won't leave a ridge. They grip just enough without that tight headache feeling by 3 PM.
Conair Hair Ties in Hair Accessories
Thick Hair Solutions That Actually Hold All Day
My roommate has hair thick enough to snap most elastics within a week. We tested these specifically for high-density hair that needs serious hold without the scalp pain.
Grab these if regular hair ties do two loops and then give up on your hair. They're built thicker so they actually wrap enough times to stay put. My roommate goes running in these and nothing budges.
Goody Ouchless Extra Thick Elastics, Brown, 4mm
Try these for thick ponytails that need to survive a full workday. They don't dig into your scalp like metal-clasp ties, and after six months of daily use they still snap back to their original size.
Scunci No-Damage Nylon Hair Elastics for Extra Thick
Switch to these if you're tired of doubling up two elastics just to hold your hair. One tie does the job. They come in dark colors that blend into brunette and black hair without standing out.
Gimme, Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands
Toss a handful in your glove box for emergency hair situations. They grip thick hair without that tight pulling sensation at your temples, and the assorted colors mean you can match whatever you're wearing.
Conair Hair Ties in Hair Accessories
Keep these if you want ties that genuinely last. Most elastics stretch out after a month with thick hair, but these held their tension for almost four months before I needed to replace them. That's a record in my house.
Goody Ouchless Forever Polyband Hair Ties
Claw Clips and Alternatives When You Need Zero Tension
Some days my scalp is so sore from ponytails that I can't wear any elastic at all. These tension-free options saved me on headache days and lazy weekends.
Use this on days when your scalp is screaming from too many tight ponytails. It holds a twist-up with zero pressure, and the matte finish looks polished enough for video calls.
5 Ways to Style Claw Clips
Grab a multipack so you always have one within reach. They hold medium to thick hair in a loose twist without any pulling. I keep one on my desk and one in my bathroom, problem solved.
Goody Classics Hair Claw Clip, Mini Bow Tie, 18
Try these if regular claw clips slowly slide down the back of your head all morning. The grip teeth actually hold, and they don't leave those weird crimps that some clips do.
Scunci No Slip Grip No Slip Jaw Clips, 5 Ct (3 pack) (Bundle)
Snag these for working out when you want your hair up but can't deal with elastic tension. The covered teeth won't snag or pull, and they're small enough to fit in a jacket pocket.
Conair Scunci Large Chunky Jaw Clip - Pack of 2
Wear this if you have heavy hair that destroys flimsy clips by lunchtime. The spring tension is genuinely strong. I've had mine for seven months and the hinge hasn't loosened at all.
Revlon Strong Hold Hair Claw Clip, Color May Vary
Workout Hair Ties That Survive Sweat and Movement
Nothing worse than re-doing your ponytail four times during a run because your tie keeps slipping. I tested these through spin classes, lifting sessions, and humid summer jogs.
Wear this to the gym if tight ponytails give you headaches halfway through your workout. It flexes with movement instead of squeezing tighter, and it stayed put through a full hour of cardio.
Customer reviews for Goody Ouchless Poly Band Elastic
Toss a few in your gym bag because you will lose some in the locker room. They dry fast after sweaty workouts and don't get that gross stretched-out soggy feeling cheap elastics develop.
Scunci No Damage Mixed Satin Elastics, 32 count
Pair one of these with a low ponytail if flyaways drive you crazy during workouts. It keeps everything swept back without adding tension to your hairline. Washes easily and dries in about an hour.
Nike Women's Swoosh Sport Headbands – 6 Pack
Use this for outdoor runs when wind and sweat team up to destroy your hair. It stays in place without squeezing your temples, and the moisture-wicking fabric means it doesn't get heavy and saggy.
Under Armour Women's Play Up Headband
Grab these specifically for high ponytails during workouts. They have a coating that grips hair so they won't slide down during burpees or jumping. My ponytail actually stayed where I put it for once.
Goody
Kids Hair Ties That Won't Cause Tears at School Drop-Off
My five-year-old screams bloody murder when I take out a regular elastic. Finding gentle ties that still hold fine kid hair through recess and PE took way more research than it should have.
Keep these for school mornings when you have exactly three minutes to do hair. They hold small pigtails without yanking, and removal doesn't end in tears. We go through a pack a month because she loses them at recess.
Goody Kids Ouchless Hair Elastics for Fine Hair
Try these for kids with fine wispy hair that slips out of everything. They grip gently but actually stay put through a full school day. My daughter came home with her braids still intact, which felt like a miracle.
Scunci Girl No Damage Assorted Color Polyband Ponytail
Swap regular elastics for these if your kid dreads getting their hair taken down at bath time. The spiral shape slides out without catching, and the fun colors make my daughter actually excited to pick her hair ties each morning.
Customer reviews for Kitsch Spiral Hair Ties
Snag a big bag of these for intricate styles like French braids that need multiple small ties. They're thin enough to hide in sections but gentle enough that removing them doesn't pull out half your kid's hair.
Conair Scunci Mixed Textures Elastics (Pack of 2)
Use these for picture day or special occasions when you want a cute style that won't leave creases. They come in pastels and prints that kids actually like, and they're gentle enough for even the most tender-headed child.
Customer reviews for Goody Ouchless Ribbon Elastics