Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Christmas Breakfast Casserole I Assemble the Night Before and Bake Christmas Morning
35
items Christmas morning is already chaotic enough without trying to cook a full breakfast from scratch while kids are losing their minds over presents. I spent years scrambling eggs in a bathrobe, missing the good moments. Now I prep everything Christmas E...
Sections
7
Casserole Dishes That Go from Fridge to Oven Without Cracking
Eggs and Dairy That Hold Up Overnight in the Fridge
Breakfast Meats That Layer Well and Reheat Without Getting Tough
Bread and Starch Layers That Soak Without Turning to Mush
Vegetables and Add-Ins That Don't Make the Casserole Watery
Spices and Seasonings So It Doesn't Taste Like Plain Scrambled Eggs
Casserole Dishes That Go from Fridge to Oven Without Cracking
Learned this the hard way when a cold glass dish met a hot oven and shattered everywhere on Christmas morning 2021. These handle the temperature swing without drama.
Grab this one specifically for overnight casseroles. It handled going straight from my 38-degree fridge to a 375-degree oven without a single crack. Sturdy enough that my husband can wash it without me hovering.
Pyrex Deep 9" x 13" Bakeware Dish with Sage Lid
Use this for smaller batches when it's just our family of four. Fits perfectly on the middle rack and the handles are wide enough to grip with oven mitts. Bought mine three Christmases ago, still going strong.
Anchor Hocking Glass Baking Dish, 13" x 9", 3 Quart, Clear
Keep this one around for when you want something pretty enough to set on the table. My mother-in-law noticed it before she noticed the food. Goes from fridge to oven to table without needing a transfer dish.
Corningware French White 2.5 Quart Oval Baking Dish
Toss this in your cart if you hate scrubbing baked-on egg. The nonstick coating means breakfast slides right out. Perfect for the person who refuses to soak dishes on Christmas Day.
GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Steel Baking Pan, 9" x 13"
Picked this up on a whim and it became my go-to. The deeper sides keep everything from bubbling over onto the oven floor. If you've ever cleaned burnt cheese off an oven rack at 7 AM, you understand.
Rachael Ray Ceramics 1.5 Quart Oval Baker, Gray
Eggs and Dairy That Hold Up Overnight in the Fridge
Not every egg and milk combo survives sitting overnight without getting weirdly rubbery. Took me a few failed batches to figure out what actually works.
Crack a dozen of these the night before and whisk them into your custard base. They hold up beautifully after 8 hours in the fridge. The 18-count means you have extras for eggnog or cookie baking without a second trip out.
Great Value Large White Eggs 18 Count
Switch to whole milk for your egg mixture if you've been using 2%. The fat content keeps the casserole creamy instead of dry and spongy. Noticed the difference the first time I tried it and never went back.
Organic Valley Organic Whole Vitamin D Milk
Pour a splash of this into your egg mixture for richness that regular milk can't touch. About a quarter cup does the trick. For anyone who wants that diner-style fluffiness without actually going to a diner on Christmas.
Great Value Heavy Whipping Cream, 16 oz Carton
Cube this and scatter it through the casserole layers before refrigerating. By morning it softens into these little pockets of melty goodness. My kids fight over the bites that have cream cheese in them.
Philadelphia Cream Cheese, 2 Blocks, for Recipes
Pile this on top right before the casserole goes in the oven, not the night before. Learned that pre-topped cheese gets gummy overnight. Sharp cheddar browns better than mild and actually tastes like something.
Great Value Extra Sharp Cheddar Shredded Cheese 16 oz
Breakfast Meats That Layer Well and Reheat Without Getting Tough
Rubbery sausage in a casserole is a crime. These cook up the night before and still taste right after baking the next morning.
Brown this the night before, drain it well, and crumble it into your layers. It reabsorbs moisture from the egg custard overnight so it comes out tender, not dried out. Way better than those pre-cooked crumbles.
Jimmy Dean Fresh Premium Pork Regular Sausage Roll
Bake the whole package on a sheet pan Christmas Eve while you're prepping everything else. Chop it up and scatter through the casserole layers. Oven-baked bacon stays crispier than stovetop after the overnight soak.
Smithfield, Original Bacon Bits, 2.8 oz (79g)
Slice these into coins and layer them in for a fun twist the kids actually request now. They hold their texture overnight better than any other sausage I've tried. Pop a few extras on a plate for snacking while you cook.
Hillshire Farm Lit'l Smokies Smoked Sausage Links, 14 oz
Swap this in if someone at your table is watching what they eat but still wants to participate. Tastes surprisingly close to pork sausage once it's baked into all that cheese and egg. Nobody at my table clocked the difference.
All Natural Turkey Sausage | JENNIE-O® Product
Grab the thick cut if you want bacon pieces that don't disappear into the casserole. They keep their chew even after the overnight rest and second bake. Worth the extra dollar for pieces you can actually find in each bite.
Hormel Black Label Oven Ready Original Thick Cut Bacon
Bread and Starch Layers That Soak Without Turning to Mush
The bread layer is where most overnight casseroles fail. Too soft and you get baby food. Too crusty and the egg can't penetrate. These nail the middle ground.
Cube this into one-inch pieces and spread them in the dish first. The density soaks up the egg mixture without dissolving into nothing. Regular sandwich bread turns to paste overnight, but this holds its shape.
Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Hearty White Bread
Tear these into chunks for a sweeter version that tastes almost like French toast casserole. The slight sweetness pairs perfectly with salty sausage. My sister made this version once and now everyone requests it.
King's Hawaiian Original Hawaiian Sweet Rolls 12 Count
Try using stuffing cubes instead of bread for a savory version with built-in seasoning. Saves you from adding herbs separately. Soaks up the custard just right and gets crispy on top where it peeks out.
Pepperidge Farm Herb Seasoned Cubed Stuffing
Split and cube these for a casserole with more texture and those signature nooks and crannies. They hold pockets of egg custard that burst with flavor in every bite. Discovered this trick from a coworker and it changed everything.
Thomas' Original English Muffins, 6 count, 13 oz
Slice this thick, cube it, and let it go slightly stale on the counter before assembling. Day-old French bread absorbs the egg mixture perfectly without getting soggy. Cheapest option here and honestly one of the best.
Freshness Guaranteed French Bakery Bread Loaf
Vegetables and Add-Ins That Don't Make the Casserole Watery
Fresh veggies release moisture overnight and ruin the texture. Spent one Christmas eating egg soup before I figured out which ones to pre-cook and which to skip entirely.
Steam these first and squeeze out every drop of water with a towel before adding. Raw broccoli in an overnight casserole turns everything into a swamp. Pre-steamed and drained, they hold up perfectly.
Birds Eye Steamfresh Broccoli Florets, Frozen, 10.8 oz Bag
Drain this can thoroughly and fold it into the egg mixture for a Southwestern kick. Adds flavor without the wateriness of fresh tomatoes. One can is plenty for a 9x13 dish.
ROTEL Original Diced Tomatoes and Green Chilies, 10 oz
Thaw this, then wring it out in a clean kitchen towel until bone dry. Seriously, squeeze harder than you think you need to. Adds color and nutrients without anyone under age 10 noticing it's there.
Great Value Chopped Spinach, 10 oz (Frozen)
Use jarred instead of fresh because they're already cooked down and won't release a puddle of liquid overnight. Scatter them between the bread and meat layers. Earthy flavor that makes the whole thing taste more complex.
Great Value Sliced Mushrooms, 4.5 oz
Stir one can into the egg mixture for gentle heat that warms you up on a cold morning. Not spicy enough to scare the kids, but enough that adults notice. Pairs ridiculously well with the sharp cheddar on top.
Great Value Canned Medium Diced Green Chiles, 4 oz
Spices and Seasonings So It Doesn't Taste Like Plain Scrambled Eggs
Unseasoned breakfast casserole is just a hot block of nothing. A few shakes of the right stuff the night before lets flavors develop while you sleep.
Whisk half a teaspoon into your egg mixture. You won't taste mustard, but you'll taste something better than you expected. It does this subtle tangy thing that makes people ask what your secret ingredient is.
McCormick Kosher Ground Mustard, 1.75 oz Bottle
Add a full teaspoon to the egg custard and let it bloom overnight. Fresh garlic can get sharp and bitter in a baked casserole, but the powder mellows out beautifully. Non-negotiable in my recipe.
McCormick Kosher Garlic Powder, 3.12 oz Bottle
Dust this across the cheese layer right before baking for color and a hint of smokiness. Makes the top look like it came from a restaurant instead of your messy kitchen. A little goes a long way.
McCormick Kosher Smoked Paprika, 1.75 oz Bottle
Grate just a tiny pinch into the egg mixture. Sounds weird in a savory dish but trust me on this. It rounds out the flavor the same way it does in a bechamel. My grandmother's trick that I almost didn't try.
Simply Organic, Ground Nutmeg, 2.3 oz Shelf-Stable
Season your egg mixture more aggressively than feels right because the bread absorbs a lot of salt overnight. Under-seasoned casserole is the number one mistake I see people make. Taste the raw custard. It should seem slightly too salty.
Morton Kosher Salt Flakes 1 lb
Covers and Tools for Overnight Assembly and Christmas Morning Baking
You need airtight coverage so the fridge doesn't dry out the top layer, and you need the right tools so nothing goes wrong at 6 AM when you're half asleep.
Press this tightly over the dish before refrigerating. Keeps the top layer from drying out and forming that weird skin overnight. Pull it off for the last 15 minutes of baking so the cheese can brown properly.
REYNOLDS WRAP, Aluminum Foil, Heavy Duty
Whisk your eggs and dairy with this instead of a fork. Gets the mixture smooth and lump-free in about 30 seconds. For anyone who's ever bitten into a casserole and found a chunk of unmixed egg white.
Good Grips 11-Inch Balloon Whisk
Keep a dedicated pair near the oven Christmas morning because you will be pulling a heavy, hot dish out while distracted by children. These grip well even when your hands are shaking from excitement or caffeine.
KitchenAid Ribbed Soft Silicone Oven Mitt 2-Pack Set
Use this to cut and serve squares without scratching your baking dish. Metal spatulas will gouge glass and ceramic. The flat edge gets under each piece cleanly so servings don't fall apart on the way to the plate.
OXO International OXO Good Grips Nylon Square Turner
Stick this in your oven because most ovens lie about their temperature by 25 degrees or more. Found out my oven ran cold, which explained years of undercooked centers. Five dollars saved me from serving raw egg on Christmas.
Taylor Programmable Digital Probe Kitchen Meat Cooking