Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Self Care Gifts I Put Together for Friends Who Live in Eyeliner
30
items Your friend who never leaves the house without a wing deserves more than another gift card. This is the lineup I actually gifted last year to the eyeliner-obsessed people in my life, from the pencils they'll steal from you to the pampering extras tha...
Sections
5
Eyeliners They Will Actually Use Every Day
Eye Makeup Removers That Won't Punish Their Skin
Under-Eye Care for Heavy Liner Wearers
Pampering Extras That Complete the Gift
Tools That Make Eyeliner Application Way Easier
Eyeliners They Will Actually Use Every Day
I used to guess wrong on eyeliner gifts constantly. These six are the ones that got genuine screaming-in-the-group-chat reactions when people unwrapped them.
Give this to anyone who complains their wing melts off by lunch. My sister wore it through a full beach day and her cat eye survived the ocean. Seriously.
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
Grab the shade Demolition for your brown-eyeliner friend. It glides on so smoothly they'll think you spent way more than you did. Great stocking stuffer too.
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Pair this with a cute makeup bag for an instant gift. The felt tip is firm enough for beginners, so it's perfect for your friend who always asks you to do her wings.
Perfect Strokes Matte Liquid Liner
Snag this for the person who rotates between smudgy and sharp looks. Two finishes in one product means they won't need to carry a whole bag around.
Major Headlines Double-Take Crème & Powder Blush Duo
Try the shade Earth for someone who wants liner without looking like they tried too hard. It barely budges once it sets, which I learned after rubbing my eye for ten minutes.
Aqua Resist Color Pencil 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner
Switch this in for anyone tired of felt tips drying out. The formula stayed creamy in my drawer for months, which is rare for a liner at this price point.
Good Apple Lightweight Full-Coverage Concealer
Eye Makeup Removers That Won't Punish Their Skin
Nothing ruins a self care moment like scrubbing waterproof liner off with a dry cotton pad. These take everything off without making their under-eyes look like a crime scene.
Keep this in the gift bag if you're giving them waterproof liner. Two shakes, one swipe, done. My mom has repurchased this probably eight times and refuses to try anything else.
Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover
Use this for the friend with sensitive eyes who flinches at everything. No oil means no blurry vision after, which matters if they do their skincare right before bed.
NARS Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover
Toss this in for the person who wears a full face daily. It melts off everything, liner included, and leaves skin feeling like it just had a spa treatment. Not greasy at all.
Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm
Grab the travel size to tuck into a gift set. It's the one French women apparently swear by, and honestly it took off my stubborn pencil liner faster than actual makeup remover wipes.
Sensibio H2O Micellar Water
Slip this in as a post-removal step. After all that liner removal their under-eye area needs something soothing, and this one absorbs in seconds without pilling.
Summer Fridays Jet Lag Deep Hydration Serum
Spritz after removing liner for a little reset moment. Perfect for the friend who gets redness easily. It calms everything down and smells like absolutely nothing, which is actually the point.
SOS Save.Our.Skin Daily Rescue Facial Spray
Under-Eye Care for Heavy Liner Wearers
Wearing eyeliner daily takes a toll on that delicate skin. I started gifting these after noticing my own under-eyes looked tired despite sleeping eight hours.
Dab this around the eyes at night after a long liner day. My friend with dry skin said her concealer stopped creasing for the first time in years after she started using it.
The Dewy Skin Cream Plumping & Hydrating Moisturizer
Get this for someone whose under-eyes look dull from daily makeup. The vitamin C brightened my dark circles in about three weeks, which I genuinely did not expect.
Drunk Elephant – C-Tango™ Vitamin C Eye Cream
Toss this into a gift bag as the surprise extra. It's small enough to not look like you're hinting they need help, but effective enough that they'll quietly reorder it themselves.
Retinol Eye Stick - Peace Out
Perfect for your night owl friend who takes off liner at midnight. Slather it on before bed and wake up looking weirdly refreshed. The avocado scent is subtle, not salad-like.
Avocado Melt Retinol Eye Sleeping Mask sample set
Wrap this up for anyone who layers concealer under their liner. It color-corrects slightly so they need less product overall. Saved me five minutes every morning once I started using it.
Banana Bright+ Vitamin C Eye Crème for Dark Circles
Bring this to the friend who says skincare is too complicated. One jar, one ingredient story, zero confusion. It's been around forever because it just works without any fuss.
Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado - Kiehl's Since 1851
Pampering Extras That Complete the Gift
A self care gift that's only makeup feels incomplete. These are the little luxuries I add to make the whole package feel like a spa night they didn't have to plan.
Throw this in because everyone's lips are wrecked by winter. They'll put it on before bed and wake up wondering why they waited so long. Berry flavor is the crowd favorite for a reason.
Lip Sleeping Mask - LANEIGE
Snag the mini size as a gift topper. The caramel pistachio scent gets compliments everywhere, and it turns basic body lotion into something that actually feels indulgent.
Brazilian Bum Bum® Cream | Sol De Janeiro ≡ SEPHORA
Pair with the eye cream for a sleep-focused gift angle. Silk pillowcases keep liner from transferring if they accidentally nap with makeup on. Don't judge, we've all done it.
Just Married Pillowcase Set
Tuck this into the bag for a hair bonus. After a long day of looking polished from the eyes up, their hair deserves some attention too. A few drops fix frizz and dryness fast.
Moroccanoil Treatment Hair Oil
Light this during their at-home spa night. The lavender isn't that fake grandma lavender. It's warm and smoky and makes removing makeup at 9pm feel like an actual ritual.
VOLUSPA French Cade & Lavender Glass Jar Candle
Use this in the shower before a night out when they're doing a full eye look. Smooth skin plus sharp eyeliner equals feeling like a completely different person. Trust the combo.
Herbivore Botanicals Coco Rose - Coconut Oil Body Polish
Tools That Make Eyeliner Application Way Easier
Half the battle with eyeliner is having the right tools. I wasted years using my fingers and random cotton swabs before these changed everything about my routine.
Get this for the friend who tapes her eyeliner wings with scotch tape. It's a reusable silicone guide that gives clean lines without ripping off half her foundation afterward.
Liner Designer Pro - Eyeliner Tool for Cat Eyes
Pair with any liner gift because curled lashes make eyeliner look ten times more intentional. This one fits most eye shapes without pinching, which my hooded-eye friends specifically confirmed.
Classic Lash Curler | TWEEZERMAN ≡ SEPHORA
Swap this in as a brow bonus because defined brows frame whatever liner look they're going for. It's cheap enough to include without blowing your budget on one gift.
Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof
Dab this under the wing to clean up mistakes. Way easier than starting over, and the coverage is dense enough to erase smudges in one pass. Wish someone had told me this years ago.
Hourglass Brightening Vanish™ Airbrush Concealer
Toss this in for groomed brows that won't compete with a dramatic eye. Clear keeps it subtle, and the tiny brush actually reaches those sparse spots without getting goopy.
Strong Hold Clear Brow Gel - Anastasia Beverly Hills
Spritz over finished eye looks to lock everything in place. My liner survived a wedding reception, two crying sessions, and humid dancing. That's the only review that matters.
Charlotte Tilbury Transfer-Proof Setting Spray