Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
discover Discover

Colorful Toasters Under $25 🍞
Purple Star emoji 25 items
By
Mamie Cushing profile picture
Mamie Cushing
My white kitchen was so boring I wanted to scream. Started hunting for affordable toasters that actually look fun on the counter. Here's everything I found without breaking the bank.
Sections
5
 
Red & Pink Picks ❤️
 
Blue & Green 🌊
 
Yellow & Orange
 
Multi-Color & Fun Prints 🎨
 
Best for Dorms & Small Spaces

Red & Pink Picks ❤️

I'm a sucker for a red kitchen appliance. These ones actually pop on a white countertop and they all toast evenly which is a bonus.

 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
this little guy fits thick bagels perfectly. love the retro look.
Dash Clear View Toaster Red
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
super compact, heats up fast, and the red is actually vibrant not dull 🔴
Holstein Housewares 2-Slice Toaster with Defrost and Reheat Function, Red
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
bought this for my daughter's apartment. she texts me about it weekly lol
Dash Clear View Toaster Black
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
the vintage vibe is so fun. makes my kitchen feel like a diner.
Nostalgia Classic Retro 4- Slice Toaster, Red
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
honestly the cheapest one and it works great. no complaints after 4 months
proctor silex toaster slice
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Blue & Green 🌊

If warm tones aren't your thing, these cooler shades are surprisingly hard to find under $25. I tracked them down so you don't have to.

 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
the aqua color is SO much prettier in person than online
Dash ClearView Long Slot Toaster
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
mint green on a wooden counter? trust me. just do it.
Holstein Housewares 2 Slice Toaster
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
lightweight but sturdy. perfect for a small kitchen or dorm room 💙
Rise By DASH Plastic Blue 2 slot Toaster 7.4 in. HX 7.2 in. WX 11.1 in. D
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
got compliments from three different guests the first week
Nostalgia Classic Retro 2-Slice Toaster, Aqua
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
basic but reliable. the teal is more muted which I actually prefer
Proctor Silex : Toasters
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Yellow & Orange

These feel like sunshine on the counter. My morning mood genuinely improved when I swapped out my boring gray toaster for a yellow one.

 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
bright yellow, toasts perfectly, and fits in a tiny corner. what more do you need?
Yellow 2-Slice Retro Toaster | Top Picks & Reviews
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
the orange is warm, not neon. pairs well with wood tones 🍊
Rise by Dash 2-Slice Toaster: Defrost, Reheat + Auto Shut off
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
my kids actually fight over who gets to make toast now
Holstein Housewares, 2-Slice Wide Slot Toaster, Defrost Reheat, Yellow
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
retro dial, crumb tray pulls out easy. solid little machine.
Yellow Toaster | 4-Slice Retro Stainless Steel Options
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
no frills but it works every single time
Yellow 2-Slice Retro Toaster | Top Picks & Reviews
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Multi-Color & Fun Prints 🎨

For when a single color isn't enough. These ones have patterns or unique finishes that feel more personality-forward.

 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
the pattern options rotate but they're always cute. check what's in stock
Dash Clear View Toaster Black
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
gave this as a housewarming gift. they loved it more than the wine 😂
Rise by Dash 2-Slice Toaster: Defrost, Reheat + Auto Shut off
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
floral print on a toaster sounds weird but it works somehow
Holstein Housewares 2-Slice Toaster
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
technically a toaster oven but it's tiny, colorful, and under budget
Dash Mini Toaster Oven | Air Fry & More
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
cream counts as colorful in my book. warm and cozy looking.
2 Slice Retro Toaster | Vintage & Stylish Options
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder

Best for Dorms & Small Spaces

I lived in a 200 sq ft studio for two years. These compact colorful toasters saved counter space and made the place feel less depressing.

 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
barely bigger than my hand. comes in like 8 colors too
Dash Mini Toaster & Oven: Compact Cooking Solutions
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
slides right under low cabinets. my roommate and I shared one all year 🏠
Dash Mini Toaster & Oven: Compact Cooking Solutions
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
the cord wraps underneath which is such a small thing but it matters
Holstein 2-Slice Toaster, 7 Browning Settings
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
cheapest option here. if you just need toast and nothing fancy, this is it.
Proctor Silex : Toasters
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder
 
Mamie Cushing profile picture
small, cute, and the browning dial actually works well. no burnt bread surprises
Nostalgia Toaster Oven - Retro Colors & Sizes Available
placeholderplaceholderplaceholder