Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Christmas Cookie Exchange and Baking Night
15
items Baking night is my favorite kind of holiday party. Flour on the counter, something warm in the oven, friends swapping cookies and stories. These are the pretty, practical pieces that make a cookie exchange feel easy and festive, from baking to boxing...
Sections
4
Baking Basics That Feel Festive
Pretty Serving for the Swap
Boxes, Bags, and Take Home Joy
Warm Sips While You Bake
Baking Basics That Feel Festive
Good tools make baking night calm instead of chaotic.
A heavy stoneware bowl stays put while you stir, and it looks beautiful on the counter between batches. I reach for bowls that can go from mixing to serving without a swap.
Beautiful by Drew Barrymore 3-Piece Stoneware Nesting Mixing Bowl Set, Cornflower Blue
Two sturdy sheets mean one batch cools while the next one bakes. That rhythm is the whole secret to a relaxed cookie night. No waiting, no rushing.
Mainstays 2-Piece Aluminum Baking Sheet Set, 7 in x 10 in
Nothing sticks, nothing burns on the bottom, and cleanup is almost nothing. I will never go back to scraping cookies off a bare pan.
GRIDMANN Silicone Baking Mat - Set of 2 Non-Stick Half Sheet (16-1/2" x 11-5/8") Food Safe Tray Pan Liners
Wooden spoons feel right in the hand and do not scratch your bowls. A small set covers stirring, scraping, and the all important taste test.
Mainstays 5-Piece Bamboo Cooking Utensil Set
Pretty Serving for the Swap
Cookies deserve a table that shows them off.
Pile cookies on a gold tray and they instantly look bakery worthy. The tray does the decorating for you. I use mine for every gathering, all year.
Better Homes & Gardens Gold Cast Metal Decorative Tray, 17 in x 8 in
Gold flatware with warm drinks and sweet plates makes a simple kitchen party feel like an occasion. It catches the light and photographs beautifully.
Better Homes & Gardens River Stainless Steel Flatware Set, Gold, 20-Piece
Real napkins say this was planned with care, even if you decided yesterday. Cream goes with every holiday color and washes up easily after.
ANA Cream Cloth Napkins Set of 12 18x18 inch Cotton Dinner - Washable Soft Premium Hotel Quality Reusable Perfect Table Linen for Family Dinners, Weddings & Everyday Use
Height on the table makes room for more cookies and makes the spread look abundant. A tiered stand is the cookie exchange centerpiece, no flowers needed.
Creative Home 2-Tier Tempered Glass Dessert Stand, Cupcake Display and Serving Tray for Tea Parties
Boxes, Bags, and Take Home Joy
Half the fun is what guests carry out the door.
A little window box turns a handful of cookies into a gift. Guests feel so cared for carrying these home. I keep a stack ready every December.
6.25" x 6.25" x 3" Kraft Treat Boxes with Windows, 3 Count, by Way To Celebrate
For the extra cookies that never fit in the box. Clear bags, a simple tie, and suddenly leftovers look intentional and sweet.
Way To Celebrate Clear Treat Bags with Twist Ties, 5 in x 3 in x 11 in, 20 Pieces
One spool of pretty ribbon finishes every box the same warm way. It takes ten seconds and it is the detail people remember.
XHJRI Red and Gold Wired Christmas Ribbon 2.5 Inch, 6 Rolls 36 Yards, Ribbon Set for Tree Decorations, Wreath Bows, Topper Bow Making
A handwritten tag with the cookie name helps everyone remember favorites later. It also solves the nut allergy guessing game kindly and clearly.
Hello Hobby Kraft color Paper Gift Tags, 3" x 1.75 x 0.0625 (12 Count)
Warm Sips While You Bake
Something hot in a mug makes the kitchen the best room in the house.
This tea tastes like the holidays while it steeps. I keep a pot going all baking night. No caffeine, so nobody is wired at midnight.
Harney & Sons Hot Cinnamon Sunset Tea, 20 Pyramid Teabags (Sachets), Caffeinated, Spiced Cinnamon Clove Orange Flavored Black Tea, No Sugar Added, Tin
Cocoa for the bakers, cocoa for the helpers. Made with warm milk it turns a work night into a party. Keep marshmallows nearby if you are wise.
Starbucks Hot Cocoa Classic 8ct
A beautiful mug makes the baker pause and actually enjoy the night she hosted. That pause matters. Hosting should feel good for the host too.
Gold Snowflakes 14 oz Gold Handle Coffee Mug