Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Best Pizza Spots in Western New York
13
items I love pizza. I mean, who doesn’t? It’s the warm blanket that gives us the gentle hug we need when we’re feeling down, it’s the high five of foods when we’re want to celebrate. Pizza is life, and these are my favorite local pizza spots in Buffalo ...
Map
This is an obvious choice for this list as they are a top OG pizzeria and basically pizza royalty in the area. Their recent (in the last few years) addition of a sit down portion of their restaurant makes them am even better destination for anyone l...
Home | Imperial Pizza Buffalo
This place is my local favorite, since it’s less than ten minutes from my house. Great food, incredibly cool staff and management, and just an all around fantastic pizzeria vibe. It’s located in the south towns as well, so you never know when you m...
Hamburg Pizza | Hamburg Subs | Edie's Pizza, Hamburg, NY
Looking for something new and exciting for dinner? Macy’s Place has some of the wildest and most innovative pizza concoctions you’ll ever see. Along with their lengthy and ever evolving list of unique pie combos, they also serve up some wonderfully...
Buffalo Pizzeria | Macy's Place Pizzeria
This may seem like blasphemy to local pizza lovers, but I don’t discriminate, I love all pizza equally. This place has the absolute best New York style pies in all of WNY. Stop in for a slice at lunch time, or bring home an extra large for the whol...
Ferro's Famous NY Pizza - West Seneca, NY - 3521 Seneca St - Hours, Menu, Order
This spot is kinda unique for the area as well, it’s almost a style that combines the best of Buffalo and Detroit type pizza into one delicious conglomerate. Their menu is limited to basically only pizza, but that’s ok because they make an incredibl...
Home | One Pie Pizza Co.
I mean…Bocce is Buffalo pizza, right? Perhaps one of the longest running OG pizzerias in the area, they have multiple locations serving up some of the best pizza you can find.
Bocce Club Pizza | Buffalo, Clarence & East Amherst, NY | Pizza Shop
I don’t want to call this place a “hole in the wall”, because that’s far too negative sounding for such a stellar pizza establishment. But let’s call it a “hidden gem”, because honestly, if you’re not looking for it, you’re probably not going to fin...
Carbone's Pizza & Subs - View Menu & Order Online - 568 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14204 - Slice
This one is a little fancier than some of the others, but it absolutely deserves a spot on this list. As with all wood fired pizzas, I would recommend eating in instead of getting takeout, but either way you’ll be getting a delicious pizza out of th...
Authentic Craftsman Wood Fired Pizza in Buffalo NY | Rocco's Wood Fired Pizza
This is legitimately the oldest pizzeria in the area. Serving some of the highest quality food since 1927, Santora’s is definitely top tier pizza and wings. They have a good sized dining area if you want to eat in, or take it home with you and hope...
Santora's Pizzeria -Buffalo, NY
Another high quality pizza joint. Franco’s is known for not skimping on the ingredients, so you’re getting a saucy, cheesy, wonderfully doughy pie every time.
Pizza Delivery, Takeout & Catering | Serving Buffalo & All Of WNY
Papa’s is spreading like Starbucks across WNY. A couple years ago they opened one location in Lancaster (which I would occasionally drive half an hour to), then next thing you know they have five locations across all of the area. The pizza is great...
Home | Papa's Pizza Oven
This place is quickly gaining national attention for serving some of the best pies ever, anywhere. Not sure what we did to deserve Jay’s, but if you ever get the chance to check them out, please do so or forever feel the burn of that regret.
Jay's Artisan Pizza
Mattina’s is another great pizza shop with a couple locations, both in the northtowns. They have a unique but delicious take on the classic Buffalo pie, bringing together heavenly deliciousness with top quality ingredients and an obvious love for th...
Mattina's Pizzeria - Our Family to Yours | Williamsville and Tonawanda, NY