Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Fun Sandwich Cutters That Finally Got My Picky Toddler to Eat Lunch
49
items My three-year-old would peel apart her sandwich, lick the peanut butter, and toss the bread on the floor. Every single day. Once I started pressing her PBJ into dinosaurs and stars, she actually ate the whole thing. This list is for parents of tiny f...
Sections
7
Sandwich Cutter and Stamp Sets
Cookie Cutters That Double as Sandwich Shapers
Bento Lunchbox Accessories
Fun Food Picks and Decorating Tools
Spreaders and Prep Tools for Quick Assembly
Lunch Bags and Carriers That Protect Shaped Food
Sandwich Cutter and Stamp Sets
Before these showed up, lunchtime was a standoff. Now she runs to the table because she wants to see what shape her sandwich is today.
Grab this set if your kid is in a full dino phase. My daughter screamed ‘T-REX’ and ate her entire sandwich for the first time in weeks. The crust removal is automatic, which saved me an extra step.
How fantastic is this lunch made with the NEW Lunch
Use this one when you need a quick win. Press it into bread, PBJ comes out as a perfect star. My son called it a sheriff badge and ate two sandwiches back to back.
Wilton, Cookie Cutters, Set of 5, Square nesting
Perfect for the kid who wants bite-sized pieces but refuses to let you cut their food with a knife. Pop it down, press, and you get a grid of tiny squares. My nephew went from throwing lunch to clearing his plate.
FunBites Food Cutter for Kids, Green Squares
Switch to these when dinosaurs get old. Pandas, frogs, elephants. My daughter picks which animal she wants that morning and it turns lunch into a little event she actually looks forward to.
CutezCute Animal Friends Food Deco Cutter Kit
This one seals the edges so the filling stays inside. No more jelly leaking onto her shirt right before we leave for preschool. Wish someone had told me about the sealing feature two years ago.
Sandwich Cutter and Sealer Set
Try this if your kid treats crust like poison. Cuts and seals in one press. The sealed pocket means she can hold it in the car without dropping turkey everywhere.
Sandwich Sealer and Decruster for Home Use
Keep these in your drawer for variety. Four different shapes so you can rotate through the week. Monday is heart day, Friday is star day. The routine actually reduced our mealtime arguments.
Tescoma DELÍCIA Traditional Cookie Cutters, Set of 13
Cookie Cutters That Double as Sandwich Shapers
I raided my baking drawer one desperate Tuesday and realized cookie cutters work perfectly on bread. Some of these haven't seen cookie dough since.
Snag this if you want options for months. One hundred and one shapes means you literally never repeat. My kid thinks I'm some kind of lunch wizard. Reality: I just grab a random cutter each morning.
Wilton 101-Piece Cookie Cutter Set
Use the giraffe on wheat bread and watch a picky eater suddenly become interested. Stainless steel cuts cleaner than plastic, so you get sharper edges. My daughter noticed the difference immediately.
Ateco 9-Piece Stainless Steel Number Cutter Set
For the dino-obsessed kid who already has the sandwich cutters and wants MORE dinosaurs. These are slightly bigger, so they work on larger slices. Stegosaurus PBJs are apparently very delicious.
Customer reviews for Wilton Animal Cookie Cutter Set
Spell out your kid's name in sandwich letters. My daughter ate J-U-N-E one letter at a time and asked me to do it again the next day. Also low-key sneaks in letter recognition practice.
R&M International Mini Alphabet Cookie Cutter Set In Can
Bring these out during summer or when your kid is going through a Finding Nemo obsession. The starfish shape holds PBJ surprisingly well. The seahorse is trickier but my daughter loves it.
Naler 12-Pieces Sea Creature Cookie Cutter Set Ocean
Pair the bunny shape with some cream cheese and strawberry jam on white bread. My kid thought it was a special holiday treat. It was a random Wednesday. She ate every bite.
Wilton Easter Cookie Cutters Set, 18-Count Tub
Toss a rocket ship sandwich into the lunchbox and wait for the reaction. My son's teacher told me he showed the whole table before eating it. Worth it for that story alone.
Customer reviews for Ann Clark Fall Leaves Cookie Cutter
Bento Lunchbox Accessories
Shaped sandwiches look sad rattling around in a plastic bag. These boxes keep everything in place so the dinosaur still looks like a dinosaur when she opens it at school.
Get this if your kid's lunch arrives looking like it went through a washing machine. Five compartments keep the sandwich shape intact and the fruit separate from the crackers. Color options are great too.
Bentgo Kids Leak-Proof Lunch Box
Try the adult-sized version if your older kid packs bigger sandwiches. The leak-proof seal saved me from cleaning yogurt out of a backpack for the third time this month.
Bentgo Fresh, Leak-Proof
Perfect for parents who want compartments without spending a fortune. Clips lock tight, nothing shifts around. My daughter's star sandwich survived a bumpy bus ride fully intact.
Sistema Bento Boxes for Lunch and Food Storage
Swap to this if you want a single-lid design. Pop it open, everything is right there. The tray is illustrated with food group guides, which helped me stop forgetting to pack a vegetable.
Yumbox Original Leakproof Bento Lunch Box for Kids
Keep this one at home for after-school snacks. Lay out the sandwich shapes with some fruit and cheese in the other sections. Presentation matters when you're negotiating with a four-year-old.
Fit & Fresh Kids 14 Piece Leak-Proof Lunch Container Set
Use stainless steel if you're tired of plastic staining orange from marinara. This one survives the dishwasher beautifully and my kid hasn't managed to break it yet, which is saying something.
Lunchbots, Toddler Lunch Box, Stainless Steel, 4 Sections
Toss the sandwich scraps and crusts into one side, some dip in the other. My daughter now dips her dino sandwich edges in ranch. Weird, but she eats them, so I'm calling it a win.
Bentgo Kids Snack
Fun Food Picks and Decorating Tools
Shaped sandwiches were step one. Then my daughter wanted faces on them. These little tools turned me into a lunch artist in about thirty seconds flat.
Stick a panda pick into a strawberry and suddenly fruit is exciting. My daughter ate blueberries off a frog pick for a week straight. These tiny things have ridiculous power over small children.
CuteZCute Bento Food Pick, 8-Piece Animal Forks
Use the little face cutters on cheese slices and stick them onto sandwiches. My son got a smiley face ham sandwich and said it was the best day of his life. Low bar, but I'll take it.
Torune Food Picks Bento Lunch Accessories Picks Set
Draw directly on bread, cheese, or fruit leather. Wrote ‘HI’ on my daughter's sandwich and she carried it around for ten minutes before eating it. Totally food safe, no weird taste.
Wilton Fine Tip FoodWriter Edible Color Markers
Pair these with shaped sandwiches so dipping sauce doesn't soak through everything. Ranch in one, ketchup in another. No more soggy bread disasters by lunchtime.
Mini Sauce Containers
Stick googly-eye picks into a dinosaur sandwich and watch your kid lose their mind laughing. My daughter's reaction alone was worth the five dollars. She named the sandwich Gerald.
Cutezcute Bento Eyes Design Food Pick (Set of 10)
Drop these silicone cups into the lunchbox to separate snacks. They come in bright colors and my kid sorts her food into them by color. Accidentally created a sorting game.
Torune Food Picks Bento Lunch Accessories Picks Set
Grab this for making tiny decorative shapes out of cheese and deli meat. Layer a cheese star on top of a bread star and suddenly you have a gourmet toddler lunch. Takes about ten seconds.
Bento Sandwich Cutters for Home Use
Spreaders and Prep Tools for Quick Assembly
Making fancy sandwiches sounds time-consuming until you get the right tools. These shaved my morning sandwich prep down to maybe two minutes.
Spread peanut butter edge to edge in one swipe. Before this I was using a butter knife and leaving thick globs in the middle and bare spots on the corners. My sandwiches actually look even now.
OXO Good Grips Silicone Everyday Spatula - Non-Stick
Try this if you need something smaller for kid-sized bread. The ergonomic handle means my daughter can spread her own jelly, which she insists on doing. Messy but she's learning.
Norpro Grip-EZ Mini Stainless Steel Grater
Use this for cream cheese or Nutella on firmer bread. Glides without tearing. I used to destroy every piece of toast trying to spread cold cream cheese and this fixed it completely.
Customer reviews for Rada Cutlery Super Spreader
Keep this nearby for trimming sandwich edges when a cutter doesn't go all the way through. Serrated edge handles soft bread without squishing it flat, which was my constant problem.
Kitchenaid Classic Serrated Utility Knife with Blade Cover
Scrape every last bit of jelly from the jar. Sounds small but when you're making sandwiches five days a week, those last scrapes add up. Paid for itself in saved jam.
OXO Good Grips Silicone Spatula - White
Roll the bread slightly flat before cutting shapes. Sounds weird but it makes the cutter press through cleaner and the sandwich holds its shape better. Learned this trick from a mom group.
I Tested 12 Rolling Pins to Find the Best Ones for Pie Crust
Portion out the peanut butter so every sandwich gets the same amount. My older kid accused me of giving his sister more. Now I measure. Peace has been restored in this household.
Prep Solutions High Heat Silicone Measuring Cup Set
Lunch Bags and Carriers That Protect Shaped Food
A beautiful dinosaur sandwich means nothing if it gets crushed under a water bottle on the walk to school. These keep everything safe and cold.
Stick the whole bag in the freezer overnight and it keeps food cold for hours without an ice pack. No more warm yogurt smell when she opens her lunchbox. That smell haunted me.
Freezable Lunch Bag
Sized perfectly to fit a Bentgo box without extra room for things to slide around. Zip it up and the sandwich stays exactly where you put it. Finally.
Customer reviews for Bentgo Kids Insulated Lunch Tote
Get this if your kid is rough on bags. Made from recycled materials and somehow survives being dragged across the playground daily. Still looks decent after four months of abuse.
Igloo Repreve Active Classic Lunch Bag with Pack In
Use the top section for the sandwich and bottom for a drink or cold snacks. Keeps everything separated so the shaped sandwich doesn't get flattened by an apple sitting on top of it.
Thermos Dual Compartment Large Dome Adult Lunch Kit
Comes with a built-in ice pack in the lid. One less thing to remember in the morning. Before this I forgot the ice pack at least twice a week and got warm sandwich guilt all day.
Customer reviews for Arctic Zone Lunch Box Combo
Perfect for parents packing their own lunch alongside the kid's. Big enough for two containers. Started making myself shaped sandwiches too. No regrets. My coworkers are jealous.
Fit & Fresh Charlotte Insulated Lunch Bag
Snag one of the fun prints so your kid actually wants to carry it. My daughter picked the rainbow pattern and now she grabs her lunch herself every morning. Small victories matter.
Wildkin Kids Insulated Lunch Box for Boy and Girls
Bread and Ingredients Worth Shaping
Not all bread cuts cleanly. Learned that the hard way when a sourdough dinosaur crumbled into sad little pieces. These ingredients actually cooperate with cutters.
Soft enough to cut clean shapes without tearing. This is the bread that finally gave me a perfect star every time. Whole wheat was crumbling, white was too thin. This one is the sweet spot.
Sara Lee Butter Bread, 20 oz
Keep a box in the freezer for emergency days when you overslept and there's zero time for sandwich art. Thaws by lunch. Not as fun as a dinosaur but still gets eaten.
Smucker's Uncrustables Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly
Spreads smooth without catching on soft bread. Chunky was ripping holes in every slice and ruining the shape before I even got the cutter out. Creamy all the way for shaped sandwiches.
Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread
Pair with peanut butter on Sara Lee and you get a clean cut every time. This jam isn't too runny so it doesn't leak out the edges when you press the cutter down. Learned that lesson with grape.
Smucker's Strawberry Preserves, 18 oz Jar
Try this for a special Friday sandwich. Cuts beautifully because it's thick. My daughter calls Nutella dinosaurs ‘chocolate dinos’ and honestly that's the highlight of her week.
The One Nutella Alternative We Didn't Want To Stop Eating
Layer these inside or cut separate cheese shapes to stack on top. The uniform thickness means every cutter goes through perfectly. Also works for making little cheese decorations.
White American Slices | KRAFT SINGLES | United States
Swap to this if your kid's school is nut-free. Cuts and spreads exactly like peanut butter. My daughter didn't even notice the switch, which is the highest compliment a toddler can give.
SunButter Original Sunflower Seed Butter 16 oz Jar