Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Baked Dinner Rolls From Scratch That Puff Up Golden Every Time
36
items You keep buying those sad, rubbery dinner rolls from the bakery section because your homemade ones come out dense or flat. I was right there with you. Took me about two years of brick-like rolls before I nailed the exact tools, ingredients, and trick...
Sections
6
Flour and Dry Ingredients That Actually Make a Difference
Butter and Fats for Those Flaky Layers
Mixing and Kneading Tools That Save Your Arms
Baking Pans and Sheets for Even Golden Tops
Proofing and Rising Supplies for Maximum Puff
Finishing Touches That Make People Ask for the Recipe
Flour and Dry Ingredients That Actually Make a Difference
I used to grab whatever all-purpose flour was cheapest and couldn't figure out why my rolls were tough. Turns out the protein content and quality of your dry goods changes everything about the crumb.
Switch to this if your rolls keep turning out dense and chewy. The protein level sits right in the sweet spot, and I noticed the difference on my very first batch. Consistent results every single time.
King Arthur Baking Company, All-Purpose Flour, 5 lb Bag
Grab this if you've been using whatever random yeast packet was in the back of your fridge. Proofs fast and reliably. My dough started doubling in half the time once I stopped using expired yeast.
Fleischmann's Active Dry Yeast, 0g Sodium,3 Count, 1/4oz.
Use a tablespoon of this to feed the yeast and you'll see it foam up in minutes. Dissolves clean without any weird aftertaste. For anyone who's ever stared at a bowl of yeast wondering why nothing is happening.
C&H Pure Cane Granulated Sugar, 4 lb Bag
Toss this in after your flour. Regular table salt made my dough taste metallic. This dissolves evenly and gives rolls that bakery flavor without overdoing it. A small swap that I wish someone told me about sooner.
Morton All-Natural Fine Sea Salt, 17.6 Oz
Keep this on hand for recipes that need a little extra lift alongside yeast. Added half a teaspoon to my rolls on a whim and they came out pillowy instead of flat. Works for biscuits too when you're in a pinch.
Arm & Hammer Baking Soda, Pure 16 Ounces (Pack of 6)
Snag this for softer, richer rolls without adding liquid milk. Two tablespoons in the dough and the crumb turns almost brioche-like. Perfect for anyone whose rolls always come out too lean and bland.
Bobs Red Mill Milk Powder, Nonfat Dry, 22 Oz
Butter and Fats for Those Flaky Layers
Rolls without good fat are just bread shaped like a ball. I spent a long time wondering why mine never had that pull-apart quality until I got serious about the butter and oil I was using.
Use this for brushing the tops right out of the oven. The difference between this and regular butter is embarrassing. Golden, rich, and your guests will ask what bakery you ordered from. Worth every penny.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Pure Irish Unsalted Butter, 8 Oz
Keep this for the dough itself. Unsalted lets you control the flavor, and it melts into the flour perfectly at room temp. I ruined a batch with salted butter once and the rolls tasted like pretzels.
Land O Lakes® Unsalted Butter Sticks, Sweet Cream
Try a tablespoon in your dough if you want rolls that stay soft the next day. Butter alone makes them go stale fast. This is the secret my grandmother finally admitted to after 30 years of lying about her recipe.
Crisco All-Vegetable Shortening 48 oz for Baking and Frying
Drizzle a little on your hands when shaping rolls instead of using more flour. Keeps the dough from sticking without drying it out. For anyone who ends up with flour-caked hands and misshapen lumps every time.
Pompeian Smooth Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 16 fl oz
Swap this in when you're making rolls for a holiday and want to go all out. Higher butterfat means richer flavor and a deeper golden color. Brought these to Thanksgiving and my sister-in-law demanded the recipe.
Organic Valley Salted Organic Butter, 8 oz Box, 2 Sticks
Spray your bowl before the first rise. I used to oil it with a paper towel and the dough would still stick to the sides. One quick spray and the dough slides right out. Saves you from punching down a stuck mess.
PAM Original Non-Stick Cooking Spray, Canola Oil Blend
Mixing and Kneading Tools That Save Your Arms
Hand-kneading for 15 minutes sounds romantic until you're doing it after a full workday. These tools cut my prep time in half and my dough actually comes together smooth now instead of lumpy.
Get this if you're serious about baking rolls more than once a year. The dough hook does in 7 minutes what took me 20 by hand. My wrists stopped aching and my rolls got way more consistent.
KitchenAid Classic Series 4.5-Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer
Pair this with your stand mixer if the original hook lets dough climb up the shaft. This one grabs and pulls the dough properly. Noticed my gluten development improved immediately, rolls went from dense to airy.
KitchenAid Dough Hooks for Stand Mixers
Use this to proof your yeast. You can see the foam through the glass so you know it's alive before committing your flour. Saved me from dumping ingredients into dead yeast more times than I want to admit.
Pyrex Prepware 2-Cup Glass Measuring Cup (Pack of 8)
Whisk your dry ingredients together before adding wet. Sounds basic but I used to just dump everything in and wonder why some rolls were salty and others were bland. Takes ten seconds and fixes uneven mixing.
OXO International OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Whisk
Grab these for anyone working in a small kitchen. Different sizes for proofing, mixing, and resting dough. They stack inside each other so they don't eat up your entire cabinet. Practical and actually well made.
Customer reviews for Joseph Joseph Nest 9-Piece Food
Try this for the initial mixing stage before switching to the dough hook. Scrapes the sides of the bowl while it mixes so you don't have to stop and push flour down every 30 seconds. Annoying problem, simple fix.
KitchenAid Flex Edge Beater for KitchenAid Tilt Head
Baking Pans and Sheets for Even Golden Tops
My first dozen batches had rolls that were brown on the bottom and pale on top because I was using cheap, warped pans. The right pan makes the difference between golden perfection and a tray of disappointments.
Swap out your old dark cookie sheet for this. Even heat distribution means no more burnt bottoms. My rolls finally came out the same color all the way around. Feels sturdy, doesn't warp, cleans up easy.
USA Pan Bakeware Half Baking Sheet with Baking
Pack your rolls into this for that classic pull-apart cluster shape. They rise into each other and create those soft sides everyone fights over. Way better presentation than spacing them out on a flat sheet.
WILTON INDUSTRIES Round Cake Pan, Non-Stick
Use this if you want individual perfectly shaped rolls. Each cup holds one ball of dough and they puff up into uniform little domes. Great for portion control and they look like you bought them from a bakery.
Wilton Perfect Results Muffin Pan, 12 cavity
Line your pan with these and skip the greasing step entirely. Rolls slide right off, no stuck bottoms, no scrubbing. For anyone who's ever flipped a pan upside down and watched half the rolls stay behind.
Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment Paper Roll
Try baking rolls in this for a rustic look. Glass holds heat well so the bottoms crisp up without burning. I bring this straight to the table and people start tearing rolls out before I set it down.
Pyrex Easy Grab 3-quart Glass Baking Dish
Keep this as your backup sheet pan for double batches. Light-colored aluminum won't over-brown your rolls like dark nonstick does. Learned that lesson after serving charcoal-bottomed rolls at a dinner party.
Nordic Ware, Half Sheet, 18"x13" Aluminum
Proofing and Rising Supplies for Maximum Puff
Cold kitchens kill yeast. I spent an entire winter wondering why my rolls wouldn't rise until I figured out that temperature and humidity control aren't optional, they're the whole point.
Check your water temp before adding yeast. Too hot and you kill it, too cold and nothing happens. I eyeballed it for years and my results were totally random. This takes three seconds and removes all guesswork.
Taylor Stainless Steel Digital Foldable Probe Meat
Lay this over your bowl during the rise. Traps moisture better than plastic wrap and actually sticks to the rim. My dough used to dry out on top and form a crust. Haven't had that problem since switching.
Glad, Press'n Seal Plastic Food Wrap, 100 sq ft, Clear
Drape a damp one over your shaped rolls during the second rise. Keeps them from drying out without pressing down on them. Also handy for wiping floury counters. You'll use these constantly, stock up now.
Customer reviews for Utopia Kitchen White Flour Sack
Proof your dough in this overnight in the fridge for a cold rise. The seal keeps it airtight and the clear sides let you check progress without opening it. Cold-risen rolls have way more flavor, trust me on this.
Rubbermaid Brilliance 2-Pack | Food storage containers for
Set this and walk away during rises. I used to forget about my dough for three hours and it would over-proof into a sticky blob. Fifteen minutes of rising can make the difference between fluffy and flat.
Taylor Mechanical Plastic Kitchen Timer 5870
Use this as your proofing bowl. Big enough for the dough to double without overflowing. Mark the starting level with a rubber band so you can actually see when it's doubled. Changed my whole process.
Pyrex 4-quart Mixing Bowl with Red Lid
Finishing Touches That Make People Ask for the Recipe
The rolls themselves matter, but what you do in the last five minutes before and after baking is what separates forgettable bread from rolls that disappear in 60 seconds flat at the dinner table.
Brush melted butter onto hot rolls using one of these instead of a pastry brush. Absorbs just the right amount and spreads it evenly. My pastry brush always left bristles behind. This is faster and cleaner.
Viva Multi-Surface Cloth Paper Towels, 6 Triple Rolls
Sprinkle a pinch into your melted butter before brushing it on. Not enough to make garlic bread, just enough to make people say ‘what IS that.’ Subtle and addictive. For anyone whose rolls taste good but feel like they're missing something.
McCormick Kosher Garlic Powder, 3.12 oz Bottle
Crack a few twists over the tops right after buttering. The crunch against soft bread is incredible. Do this if you've ever eaten a roll and thought it tasted flat even though you added salt to the dough.
Morton Sea Salt Grinder Refill, Extra Coarse
Try brushing this on top instead of butter for a slightly sweet, nutty finish. Works especially well on Hawaiian-style rolls. My dairy-free friend nearly cried when she finally got a warm, glossy roll at my table.
Nature's Way USDA Organic Extra Virgin Coconut Oil
Drizzle a thin layer over hot rolls for a sweet and salty combo. The heat melts it right into the crust. Brought honey-topped rolls to a potluck once and the pan came back completely empty in under ten minutes.
Wholesome! - Organic Raw Honey - 16 oz.
Chop this fine and press it into the tops before baking for herb rolls that look and smell incredible. Perfect if you're tired of plain rolls but don't want to learn a whole new recipe. One small addition, huge impact.
Simply Organic, Herb, Whole Rosemary Leaf, 1.23 oz