Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found the Compost Sifting Setup That Gives Me Fine Soil Every Time
44
items Chunky compost that clogs your garden beds and looks terrible around transplants is so frustrating after months of waiting. If you have been hand-picking sticks and eggshell fragments out of your finished pile, this is the gear that finally gave me d...
Sections
11
Compost Screens and Sifters That Actually Work
Wheelbarrows for Hauling Finished Compost
Pitchforks and Shovels for Loading the Sifter
Compost Tumblers for Faster Finished Compost
Compost Thermometers to Know When It Is Ready
Garden Gloves That Survive Compost Work
Compost Screens and Sifters That Actually Work
Spent two years using a janky homemade screen that sagged in the middle. These are the sifters that held up under shovelfuls of heavy compost without bowing or breaking.
Grab this if you are sifting wheelbarrow-sized batches. Before I had it, I was hunched over a tiny screen for an hour. Now I knock out a full bin in fifteen minutes flat.
Wheelbarrow Sifter
Use the interchangeable mesh sizes when you need super fine soil for seed starting versus coarser stuff for raised beds. My neighbor borrowed it once and ordered her own within a week.
UPGRATOR 4-Piece Garden Soil Sifter Set with Plastic
Keep this one around for smaller batches on the patio. The quarter-inch mesh catches every twig and shell fragment. Perfect for apartment balcony gardeners working with a tumbler.
VIVOSUN Stainless Steel Garden Sieve for Soil Sifting
Toss your compost right in and shake. The galvanized frame survived three New England winters in my shed without rusting. Stock up on a second one if you share a community garden plot.
Soil Sifter | Walmart Canada
Wheelbarrows for Hauling Finished Compost
Tried carrying buckets across my yard for a whole summer. My back told me to stop being cheap and get a proper wheelbarrow.
Switch to this from a traditional wheelbarrow if your yard has bumps and roots everywhere. Four wheels instead of one means you stop tipping loads of compost onto your shoes.
Gorilla Carts, Poly Garden Dump Cart, 600 lb. Capacity
Pair this with your sifter right underneath so the fine compost drops straight in. Held up to daily use all last spring without a single wobble.
True Temper 6' Cubic Steel Wheelbarrow w
Get the dual wheel version if you are hauling on soft garden soil. Single wheels sink and get stuck. Learned that one the hard way during a rainy April.
Marathon Yard Rover Poly Tray Wheelbarrow
Bring this out when you are moving wet, heavy compost. Poly tub does not rust and rinses clean with a hose. For anyone tired of scraping caked-on dirt out of a metal basin.
Customer reviews for AMES COMPANIES Heavy Duty Poly
Pitchforks and Shovels for Loading the Sifter
A regular shovel just pushes compost around. The right fork lets you scoop, toss, and break apart clumps before they even hit the screen.
Use this to load your sifter instead of a flat shovel. The tines break apart clumps on the way up, which means less shaking and faster sifting. My arms thanked me immediately.
Razor-Back 2827400 4-Tine Forged Spading Fork
Grab the D-handle version if your wrist aches after an hour of turning compost. The ergonomic grip actually makes a difference when you are doing repetitive motions all morning.
Fiskars 333400-1001 47" Ergo D-handle Steel Garden Fork
Keep a round point shovel nearby for scraping the bottom of the bin where everything is dense and wet. This one is heavier gauge steel than the flimsy hardware store versions.
Bully Tools 262758 9 x 11 in. 14 Gauge Round Point Shovel
Swap to the square point when you are scooping sifted compost into bags or pots. Flat edge means you pick up everything instead of leaving half of it behind on the ground.
48.75 in. Fiberglass Handle Square Point Shovel
Compost Tumblers for Faster Finished Compost
Waiting fourteen months for a static pile to break down nearly made me quit composting. A tumbler cut my wait time to about six weeks.
Try the dual chamber so you always have one side cooking while you add fresh scraps to the other. Before this, I kept mixing new stuff into almost-done compost and resetting the clock.
FCMP Outdoor Tumbling Composter with Two Chambers for Efficient Batch Composting IM 4000
Snag this if you produce a lot of kitchen scraps. The large capacity means you are not cramming everything into a tiny barrel. Fits a week of food waste from a family of four easily.
Miracle-Gro Large Dual Chamber Compost Tumbler 27.7
Get the smaller version if you have a tight backyard. Sits right next to my back door and I toss scraps in every night after dinner. Finished compost in about eight weeks flat.
VIVOSUN Outdoor Tumbling Composter, 43 Gallon, Black
Use the sliding doors on this one to check if your batch is done without flipping the whole thing. Saved me from dumping half-finished compost onto my tomatoes last July.
SQUEEZE master Large Dual Chamber Compost Bin
Compost Thermometers to Know When It Is Ready
Guessing whether compost is finished led me to spread half-decomposed food scraps on my garden beds. A thermometer tells you exactly when the pile has cooled and cured.
Stick this in the center of your pile and check it weekly. When it stops heating up after a turn, your compost is done. No more guessing and accidentally planting in raw kitchen waste.
Reotemp 20 Inch Fahrenheit Backyard Compost
Grab the shorter version for tumbler composting where you cannot jam a 20-inch probe inside. Reads accurately in about sixty seconds and the dial is easy to see without reading glasses.
Compost Soil Thermometer by Greenco
Keep one of these in your garden shed so you always know where it is. Lost my first thermometer in the pile itself, which is embarrassing but apparently common.
Taylor Precision Products Outdoor Thermometers
Try this budget-friendly option if you are just starting out and not sure composting is for you yet. Accurate enough to tell you hot versus cured, which is really all you need.
Luster Leaf Rapitest Dial Compost Thermometer
Garden Gloves That Survive Compost Work
Went through four pairs of cheap gloves in one season because compost eats through thin fabric. These actually lasted.
Wear these for sifting sessions when you need to feel what you are grabbing. Thin enough for dexterity but tough enough that sharp sticks do not poke through. For anyone who hates bulky gloves.
Pine Tree Tools Bamboo Gardening Gloves
Pair these with wet compost work. The leather holds up to moisture way better than cotton. Dried them on my porch railing overnight and they were ready to go again by morning.
Wells Lamont Men's HydraHyde Leather Work Gloves
Use these if you also do mechanic or woodworking projects. One glove for everything means you actually know where they are when you need them.
Winter Insulated Work Gloves
Toss a pair every few weeks without guilt because the whole pack costs less than one fancy pair. Perfect for the person who loses gloves in the yard constantly. That person is me.
G & F Products Work Gloves Textured Latex Coated Grip
Raised Bed Soil Amendments to Mix With Sifted Compost
Pure compost is too rich on its own for most plants. Mixing it with the right amendments gave me beds that drained properly and did not burn my seedlings.
Throw a few handfuls into your sifted compost before filling raised beds. Keeps the soil loose so roots can breathe. My basil went from yellow and droopy to bushy and green in two weeks.
ESPOMA COMPANY Perlite Soil Mix, Organic, 8-Qts. PR8
Use vermiculite if your beds dry out fast in summer heat. Holds onto moisture so you are not watering twice a day. Saved my lettuce crop during a brutal August heatwave last year.
Hoffman 16004 Horticultural Vermiculite
Blend this 50/50 with your sifted compost for container gardening. The mix drains perfectly and has enough nutrients to get seedlings through their first month without extra fertilizer.
FoxFarm Ocean Forest Potting Soil - Pack of 2
Toss some in if your compost runs acidic from too many coffee grounds and citrus peels. Tested my soil pH after adding lime and it came right back into the sweet spot for tomatoes.
Espoma, Garden Lime, 5 lb, Covers 135 sq ft
Compost Bins for the Curing Stage
Sifted compost still needs a week or two to cure before you use it. Dumping it straight on plants burned my pepper seedlings one spring and I never made that mistake again.
Wrap this around your curing pile to keep it contained. Expands when you have a big batch and shrinks down for storage. Way cheaper than building a wooden bin from scratch.
Geobin Compost Bin
Get the solid-sided version if critters keep digging through your curing compost. Raccoons destroyed my open pile twice before I wised up and got something with a lid.
VIVOSUN Compost Bin 80Gallon (300L)
Snag this compact bin if your HOA gives you grief about visible compost piles. Looks tidy enough that my neighbors stopped complaining, and it holds more than it looks like.
Redmon 65 Gallon Black Plastic Compost Bin with Air Vents
Use the bottom hatch to pull cured compost from the bottom while fresh stuff sits on top. Gravity does the work. Wish someone had told me about this design three years ago.
Algreen Products Soil Saver Classic Compost bin
Moisture Meters and Soil Testing Tools
Overwatered my compost pile for months because I thought wetter meant faster. Turns out there is a sweet spot, and these tools keep you in it.
Stick this in your pile to check if it is damp like a wrung-out sponge. Too wet and it goes anaerobic and stinks. Too dry and nothing breaks down. This takes the guesswork out completely.
XLUX Long Probe Plant Soil Moisture Meter
Test your finished compost before spreading it on beds. Found out my pile was way too acidic one year and would have killed my spinach if I had not checked first.
Luster Leaf 1601 - Test Kit, Soil, Rapitest
Grab the combo meter that does pH, moisture, and light all in one probe. Less stuff rattling around in your garden tote. For the person who wants one tool instead of three.
Sonkir Soil pH Meter, 3-in-1 Moisture Light pH Tester
Try the mail-in version if you want lab-grade accuracy on your finished compost. Results come back in about a week and tell you exactly what nutrients are present and what is missing.
My Soil, Soil Test Kit, Complete & Accurate Nutrient and pH
Protective Gear for Dusty Sifting Days
Dry compost sifting kicked up enough dust to make me cough for hours. Started wearing proper protection and felt ridiculous for not doing it sooner.
Wear one of these on dry sifting days. Compost dust contains mold spores that mess with your lungs. Felt silly wearing it until my allergist told me I was breathing in aspergillus. Not silly anymore.
3M N95 Aura Particulate Respirator 9205+, 10 Pack
Keep a pair hanging on your sifter so you never forget them. Got a piece of something in my eye once during a windy sift and spent the rest of the afternoon at urgent care.
DEWALT, Safety Goggles, DPG82-11, Clear Anti-Fog Lens
Wrap this around your neck during summer sifting sessions. Stays cool for hours and you can re-wet it with the garden hose. For anyone who sweats through their shirt by 9 AM.
Chill-Its® - Ergodyne Work Gear - Cooling Bandana - 6615
Toss this on before heading out to the compost area. Wide brim keeps sun off your neck and face. Folds flat in your back pocket when you go inside. Way better than baseball caps for yard work.
Customer reviews for Luxtrada Columbia Unisex Bora
Storage and Bagging for Sifted Compost
Piled my beautiful sifted compost on a tarp once and rain washed half of it into the grass overnight. Now I bag and store it properly.
Use these heavy-duty bags when you have a massive sifting session and need to store the overflow. Holds way more than regular trash bags and will not rip when you drag them across the yard.
Bagster® - Dumpster in a Bag
Grab the contractor grade bags for smaller batches. Regular kitchen bags split open every single time. These hold wet, heavy compost without tearing at the seams.
Husky, Contractor Bags, 42 Gallon, Heavy Duty 2 Mil Black
Snap the lid on and stack these in your garage until planting day. Keeps the compost at the right moisture level and nothing gets in or out. Reusable season after season.
Rubbermaid Roughneck 18-Gallon Box, Dark Indigo Metallic
Get a few of these cheap totes if you are storing compost for multiple beds. Label them with masking tape so you know which batch is which. Organization is not glamorous but it saves so much time.
27 Gallon Tough Storage Tote with Lid