Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Nailed Baked Mac and Cheese That Outshines the Turkey
35
items Every Thanksgiving my mac and cheese was either soupy, bland, or had a sad soggy top while the turkey got all the compliments. After years of tinkering with different cheeses, breadcrumb ratios, and baking times, I finally locked in the exact product...
Sections
7
Pasta That Holds Up Under All That Cheese
Cheeses That Make People Stop Talking Mid-Bite
Building the Cheese Sauce Without Lumps or Panic
The Breadcrumb Crust That Steals the Show
Bakeware That Gives You Even Heat and a Crispy Edge
Seasonings and Add-Ins That Take It From Good to Legendary
Pasta That Holds Up Under All That Cheese
Thin noodles get lost in heavy cheese sauce and turn to mush after baking. I ruined two Thanksgivings before I figured out the right shape and brand actually matters more than cooking time.
Stick with this if you want elbows that hold their shape after 30 minutes in the oven. I tried store brand once and ended up with cheese soup instead of baked mac.
Barilla, Elbows Pasta, Kosher Certified, Non-GMO, 16 oz
Swap these in when you want every spiral to trap cheese inside. My brother-in-law literally picked one up and said it looked like a cheese delivery system.
(12 pack) Barilla Gluten Free Spaghetti Pasta, 12 oz
Try rigatoni if you're feeding a crowd that wants big, satisfying bites. The ridges hold sauce like nothing else and they don't go soft even reheated the next day.
De Cecco Rigatoni no.24 Pasta, 16 oz
Grab this for a budget-friendly option that still has enough texture to stand up to a thick bechamel. Spent years overpaying for pasta before landing here.
Mueller's Kosher Low-Sodium Penne Rigate Pasta
Keep a few boxes on hand because these disappear fast around November. Larger elbows mean more cheese per bite, which is really the whole point.
Great Value Elbows Pasta, 32 oz, Enriched Macaroni, Kosher
Cheeses That Make People Stop Talking Mid-Bite
Using only one type of cheese is the number one mistake I see. The magic is in layering three or four varieties so you get sharp flavor, creamy melt, and that stringy pull everyone photographs.
Shred this yourself instead of buying pre-shredded. The anti-caking powder on bagged cheese messes with the melt and I learned that the hard way three holidays ago.
Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Block 2 lb aged 15
Use a small chunk of this melted into your sauce for that silky smooth base. Purists will judge you until they taste it, then they quietly ask how you got the texture so creamy.
Velveeta, Cheese Product, 32 oz Block
Toss a few slices into the sauce for a nutty depth that cheddar alone can't hit. This is the secret layer that makes people say it tastes like a restaurant.
Sargento® Sliced Baby Swiss Natural Cheese, 11 slices
Stir half a block into the hot sauce right before combining with pasta. Sounds weird but it adds a richness that made my cousin put her fork down and just stare at me.
Philadelphia Cream Cheese, 2 Blocks, for Recipes
Tear small pieces and tuck them between pasta layers before baking. When you scoop a serving and get that fresh mozz stretch, the table loses it every single time.
BelGioioso Fresh Mozzarella Cheese Ball
Building the Cheese Sauce Without Lumps or Panic
My cheese sauce used to break or clump every single time until I got the right butter and flour dialed in. Now it comes together in about eight minutes and I don't even stress anymore.
Start your roux with this and the flavor difference is noticeable from the first whiff. Regular butter works fine but this adds a richness that people can't quite place.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Pure Irish Unsalted Butter, 8 Oz
Use exactly two tablespoons per two tablespoons of butter for a smooth roux. Too much flour and you get wallpaper paste, too little and your sauce runs everywhere.
Gold Medal All Purpose Flour, Baking Flour, 5 lb Bag
Warm this before adding it to the roux. Cold milk into hot butter is how you get lumps, and that's a mistake I made for literally five years before someone told me.
Horizon Organic 2% Reduced Fat Milk, 1 Gallon
Sprinkle half a teaspoon into the sauce while it thickens. You won't taste mustard but you'll notice the cheese flavor somehow gets sharper and more complex.
McCormick Kosher Ground Mustard, 1.75 oz Bottle
Add just a tiny pinch, seriously tiny, right after the cheese melts. My grandmother did this and I thought she was strange until I tasted it side by side without.
McCormick Kosher Ground Nutmeg, 1.1 oz Bottle
The Breadcrumb Crust That Steals the Show
A great crust should shatter when you tap it with a spoon and taste buttery and toasty. For years mine was either burnt or barely there, and it turned out the fix was stupidly simple.
Mix these with melted butter and spread them thick on top before baking. The Italian seasoning baked into the crumbs means you don't have to measure out six different herbs.
Progresso Italian Style Bread Crumbs Canister (15 oz)
Blend half panko with half regular breadcrumbs for a crust that's crunchy but not uniform. Pure panko alone can feel too airy and doesn't form that satisfying golden sheet.
4C Japanese Style Panko Bread Crumbs, Plain, 8 Oz
Toss a few tablespoons into your breadcrumb mixture before spreading. The parmesan crisps up into little salty pockets that make the top layer dangerously snackable before dinner even starts.
Kraft Natural Grated Parmesan Cheese Shaker, 8 oz Bottle
Melt three tablespoons and fold into your crumb mix until everything looks like wet sand. Dry breadcrumbs on top is the fastest way to get a dusty, disappointing crust.
Land O'Lakes Salted Butter, 4 Sticks, 1 lb Pack
Dust this over the crumb layer right before the pan goes in. It adds a subtle smokiness and turns the top a deep golden color that makes the dish look like a magazine cover.
McCormick Kosher Smoked Paprika, 1.75 oz Bottle
Bakeware That Gives You Even Heat and a Crispy Edge
I used to bake mac and cheese in whatever random dish was clean. Turns out the pan shape and material completely change whether you get crispy edges or a soggy center.
Use this for big batches when you're feeding eight or more. Glass holds heat evenly so you don't end up with burnt corners and a cold middle like I did with flimsy metal pans.
Pyrex Deep (9x13") Glass Baking Dish with Lid
Bake a smaller batch in this and every single edge piece turns into a crispy cheese cracker. Fair warning, whoever sits closest to the skillet will eat directly from it.
Lodge - 10.25 in. Cast Iron Skillet in Black with Pour Spout
Slide this under your baking dish to catch any cheese that bubbles over. Learned this after scraping burnt gruyere off the bottom of my oven at 11pm on Thanksgiving.
USA Pan Bakeware Half Baking Sheet with Baking
Cover the dish for the first 20 minutes so the inside gets hot and bubbly, then remove so the top crisps. Skipping this step is why so many people get a crunchy top over lukewarm pasta.
Reynolds Wrap Heavy Duty Aluminum Foil, 18 Inch Width
Grab the dish confidently with these because that cast iron or glass at 400 degrees is no joke. Burned myself with a damp towel once and now I refuse to use anything else.
Best Brands Cuisinart Silicone Oven Mitt, Gray
Seasonings and Add-Ins That Take It From Good to Legendary
Plain mac and cheese is fine but one or two unexpected ingredients turn it into the thing people talk about in the group chat the next morning. These are the additions I rotate depending on the crowd.
Stir a few shakes into the cheese sauce before combining. Not enough to make it spicy, just enough to add a warmth that makes people take a second scoop without knowing why.
Frank's RedHot, Hot Sauce, 23 fl oz, Cayenne Pepper
Fold these into the pasta layer right before adding the crumb top. Crispy bacon bits scattered through cheesy pasta is the kind of move that gets you permanently assigned to mac duty.
Hormel, Real Bacon Bits, 3 oz Plastic Jar, Salad Topping
Mix a handful into the breadcrumb crust for extra crunch and a savory sweetness. Yes, these are for green bean casserole, but they work even better here and nobody is gatekeeping fried onions.
French's Kosher Original Crispy Fried Onions, 6.0 oz Can
Season every layer, the pasta water, the sauce, and the crumb top. Under-salted mac and cheese is the silent killer of holiday dinners and most people don't salt enough.
Morton Kosher Salt Flakes 1 lb
Crack fresh pepper over the top right when it comes out of the oven. Pre-ground pepper tastes flat compared to this and the built-in grinder means one less thing to wash.
McCormick Kosher Black Peppercorn Grinder, 2.5 oz Bottle
Serving and Storing So Leftovers Hit Just as Hard
Thanksgiving mac and cheese reheated wrong turns into a dry brick. Getting the right containers and tools means day-two mac tastes almost as good as the first scoop out of the oven.
Portion leftovers into these while the mac is still slightly warm so steam keeps it moist. Tried regular zip bags once and peeled dried cheese off plastic for ten minutes.
Rubbermaid Brilliance 2-Pack | Food storage containers for
Use this to cut clean squares right in the baking dish. A regular spatula tears up the crust and you end up with a messy pile instead of a beautiful plated portion.
OXO Good Grips Nylon Square Turner
Lay this directly on the surface of leftover mac before lidding the container. Keeps air off the cheese so it doesn't develop that weird dry skin overnight.
Glad Press'n Seal Plastic Food Wrap, 70 Square Feet
Pop this over your plate when reheating so the steam recirculates and the pasta doesn't dry out. Sprinkle a few drops of milk on top before microwaving for extra insurance.
Nordic Ware 10" Microwave Splatter Cover, Clear Plastic,
Warm a splash of milk in this and drizzle it over leftover mac before reheating. Brings back the creamy sauce consistency and took me way too many sad dry lunches to figure out.
Pyrex, Measuring Cup, 2-Cup, Glass with Red Graphics