Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Replaced In-Turkey Stuffing and My Casserole Version Has the Crispiest Top
42
items If you've been shoving bread cubes inside a turkey for years and wondering why your stuffing is always soggy and flavorless, welcome to the club I just left. This is everything I use to make casserole-dish stuffing with a crunchy golden top that peop...
Sections
6
Bread and Cubes for the Stuffing Base
Broths and Liquids That Keep It Moist Inside
Herbs and Seasonings for Real Flavor
Mix-Ins That Make People Ask for the Recipe
Bakeware for the Crispiest Possible Top
Finishing Touches for a Golden Crunchy Crust
Bread and Cubes for the Stuffing Base
I used to tear up whatever stale bread was lying around and the texture was always off. These give you that perfect chewy-inside, crispy-outside foundation without any guesswork.
Grab this if you want a shortcut that still tastes homemade. I used to cube my own bread for hours, and honestly this gets me 90% there in zero time. Stock up early because shelves go bare by mid-November.
Pepperidge Farm Herb Seasoned Classic Stuffing
Switch to this if regular bread stuffing bores you. The slight sweetness plays so well with sage and butter. Perfect for anyone who grew up on Southern-style dressing and wants that cornbread crumble on top.
Pepperidge Farm's Sausage Cornbread Stuffing
Toss this in your cart if you hate measuring out dried herbs. The sage flavor is already baked in and it saves me a solid 15 minutes of seasoning and tasting. My sister-in-law asked for the recipe and was shocked it started with a bag.
Brownberry Premium Sage & Onion Cubed Bread Stuffing
Use this for a lighter, crispier texture. Regular stuffing can get dense and brick-like, but these smaller cubes toast up beautifully on top. Great for anyone making a thinner casserole layer.
Mrs. Cubbison's Herb Seasoned Turkey Stuffing, 10 oz Box
Keep a couple bags of these on hand as your blank canvas. No seasoning means you control everything. I add my own herb butter and it beats any pre-seasoned version when I have the time.
Great Value Plain Bread Crumbs, 15 oz
Look, I know purists will judge me, but mix half a box of this into homemade cubes and the flavor depth jumps. It's my secret layer in the middle. Nobody has ever guessed.
Stove Top Turkey Stuffing Mix 6 oz Box with Herbs
Try this if Pepperidge Farm is sold out, which happens every single year in my town. Slightly larger cubes that hold up well under broth without turning to mush. Solid backup that deserves starting lineup status.
Arnold Premium Herb Seasoned Cubed Bread Stuffing, 12 oz
Broths and Liquids That Keep It Moist Inside
The whole point of casserole stuffing is crispy on top, moist underneath. I ruined three batches before I figured out the right liquid ratio and which broths actually add flavor instead of just wetness.
Pour this over your bread cubes slowly, not all at once. I learned the hard way that dumping it in makes soup, not stuffing. A carton and a half is my sweet spot for a 9x13 dish.
Swanson Chicken Broth, 32 oz Carton
Swap this in for chicken broth on Thanksgiving specifically. The turkey flavor ties everything together on the plate. For anyone who wants their stuffing to taste like it actually met the bird.
Kitchen Basics Gluten Free Original Turkey Stock, 32 oz
Use this when you want a richer, more savory base. Regular broth can taste thin and watery. This one coats the bread cubes properly and the gelatin helps everything hold together when you slice portions.
Pacific Foods Organic Free Range Chicken Broth
Grab the unsalted version if you're already using seasoned bread cubes. I over-salted my stuffing two Thanksgivings in a row before realizing the broth was doubling up on sodium. Lesson learned.
Great Value Reduced Sodium Unsalted Chicken Broth 32
Snag a bottle and splash about a quarter cup into your broth mixture. It adds this subtle acidity that cuts through all the butter and keeps the stuffing from tasting flat. My mom started doing this and never went back.
White Cooking Wine
Melt a full stick into your broth before pouring. Sounds excessive, it's not. This is what makes the bottom layer rich and the top layer golden. For anyone who's tired of dry, cardboard-tasting stuffing.
Great Value Sweet Cream Salted Butter, 4 Sticks
Try adding just three tablespoons to your liquid mix. Not enough to make it creamy, just enough to give the inside this silky quality. A friend taught me this trick and my stuffing went from good to people-requesting-it-in-July good.
Great Value Heavy Whipping Cream, 16 oz Carton
Herbs and Seasonings for Real Flavor
Dried sage from 2019 sitting in the back of your spice cabinet is not going to cut it. Fresh herbs and the right seasoning blends took my stuffing from bland side dish to the thing people actually come back for seconds on.
Keep this as your backbone spice. Fresh sage is great but burns easily on the crispy top layer. Rubbed sage distributes evenly through the whole casserole. Two teaspoons is my starting point for a full dish.
McCormick Gourmet Organic Rubbed Sage, 0.75 oz Bottle
Pair this with your sage, about a teaspoon. Thyme rounds out that sharp herby flavor so it doesn't taste like you dumped a garden into bread. For anyone whose stuffing always tastes one-note.
McCormick Kosher Ground Thyme, 1.37 oz Bottle
Toss in half a teaspoon if you want to skip measuring individual herbs. This blend was literally designed for this exact purpose. Saved me when I was cooking Thanksgiving at my in-laws' house and they had zero spices.
McCormick Kosher Poultry Seasoning, 0.65 oz Bottle
Use more than you think you need. Stuffing absorbs pepper like crazy and what tastes peppery raw will taste perfectly balanced after baking. I do about 20 cranks from the grinder per batch.
McCormick Pure Ground Black Pepper, 6.0 oz Can
Crush these between your fingers before sprinkling in. Whole rosemary leaves in stuffing are annoying to bite into. A little goes a long way, maybe half a teaspoon, but it adds this piney warmth that makes people ask what your secret is.
Spice Islands Crushed Rosemary, Kosher, 1.25 oz
Ditch the table salt for this. The larger flakes dissolve more evenly and you're less likely to over-salt. I sprinkle some on the top right before baking so the crust has little pops of salt when you bite in.
MORTON SALT EXPIRATION GUIDE
Sneak in a teaspoon. Traditional stuffing recipes skip garlic entirely and I genuinely don't understand why. It doesn't make it taste garlicky, it just fills in a savory gap you didn't know was there.
McCormick spices impossible to open. Apparently, it's the glue
Mix-Ins That Make People Ask for the Recipe
Plain bread stuffing is fine. But celery, sausage, dried cranberries - that's what turns a side into the star. Every Thanksgiving I add one new mix-in and watch who notices first.
Brown this in a skillet, break it into small crumbles, fold it into your bread cubes. The fat from the sausage keeps the inside moist while adding savory richness. My brother won't eat stuffing without it now.
Jimmy Dean Fresh Premium Pork Regular Sausage Roll
Throw a handful in for little bursts of tart sweetness. They rehydrate slightly during baking and get plump and jammy. Perfect for anyone who thinks traditional stuffing needs a flavor surprise.
Ocean Spray Craisins® Original Dried Cranberries
Chop these roughly and scatter them through the mix. They toast up during baking and add crunch that contrasts with the soft bread. Started doing this three years ago and it's now non-negotiable at my table.
Fisher, Pecan Halves, 16 oz Bag, Naturally Gluten Free
Use these if you cry like a baby cutting onions. No shame. Saute them with butter until golden before mixing in. Caramelized onions in stuffing is one of those why-didn't-I-always-do-this moments.
Great Value Chopped Onions, 10 oz (Frozen)
Dice two stalks small and saute with your onions. Celery adds a vegetal crunch that keeps the stuffing from being all-carb-all-the-time. For the person who wants a little freshness in every bite.
Fresh Whole Celery, 1ea Premium Quality
Slice and brown these hard in butter until they're dark and concentrated. Soggy pale mushrooms will ruin your stuffing texture. Done right, they add this deep umami flavor that makes the whole dish taste more complex.
Giorgio Sliced Mushrooms, 6oz Jar
Peel and dice one small apple into tiny cubes. It sounds weird until you try it. The tartness cuts through all the butter and sausage and keeps each bite interesting. Stole this idea from a restaurant and never looked back.
Freshness Guaranteed Granny Smith Apples, 3 lb Bag
Bakeware for the Crispiest Possible Top
Your casserole dish matters more than you think. I spent years baking stuffing in a deep dish and wondering why only the corners got crispy. Wider, shallower, heavier. That's the formula.
Use this as your everyday workhorse. Glass conducts heat evenly so you don't get burnt edges and a raw center. I've had mine for six years and it's survived every holiday and one accidental drop onto a towel.
Pyrex Deep 9" x 13" Bakeware Dish with Sage Lid
Try spreading your stuffing on a sheet pan for maximum crispy surface area. Sounds unconventional but the thin layer means almost every bite has crunch. For anyone who fights over the corner pieces.
USA Pan Bakeware Half Baking Sheet with Baking
Bake your stuffing directly in cast iron for edges that get dark and caramelized. The heat retention is unreal. Pull it out of the oven and it keeps crisping for another five minutes on the counter.
Lodge 12" Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet
Grab this if you're making a double batch. The wide flat bottom gives you tons of surface area and the low sides let hot air circulate over the top. Feeds a crowd and everything gets evenly golden.
Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster
Cover your stuffing for the first 30 minutes, then remove the foil for the last 15. This is the actual secret to moist inside, crispy outside. I resisted this technique for years and I was wrong.
Reynolds Wrap Heavy Duty Aluminum Foil Roll
Line your dish with this before adding stuffing. Cleanup goes from 20 minutes of soaking and scrubbing to literally lifting everything out. Wish someone had told me this a decade ago.
Wax Paper vs. Parchment Paper for Cooking and Baking
Keep this one for smaller batches or for transporting stuffing to someone else's house. The lid snaps on tight so nothing sloshes in the car. Brought this to a potluck and it arrived looking like I just pulled it from the oven.
Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Baking Dish with Red Lid, 3-Quart
Finishing Touches for a Golden Crunchy Crust
The top layer is what separates casserole stuffing from the soggy mess inside a turkey. These last-minute additions are what give you that shatteringly crisp, buttery, golden surface people photograph before eating.
Melt this and brush it over the top before the last 15 minutes of baking. Regular butter works fine but Kerrygold browns deeper and tastes nuttier. Your crispy top goes from good to genuinely impressive.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Salted Pure Irish Butter, 8 oz
Drizzle a thin stream over the top along with butter for extra crunch. The olive oil helps the surface get almost cracker-like. For anyone who wants that shattering texture when you break through with a spoon.
Pompeian Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 68 fl oz
Sprinkle a light layer over the top before the final bake. These toast up fast and add an extra tier of crunch on top of the already-crispy stuffing cubes. It's like stuffing with a breadcrumb gratin hat.
4C Plain Bread Crumbs, 15 oz Canister
Dust this over the top in the last 10 minutes. It melts into a thin savory crust that's salty and crispy. Not traditional at all, but nobody has ever complained. They just eat faster.
Kraft Grated Parmesan Cheese 125g
Give your dish a quick spray before adding stuffing. The edges where bread meets dish become the crispiest, most fought-over bites. Skip this step and you'll be chiseling stuffing off glass for an hour.
Pam, Non-Stick Cooking Spray, 8 oz, Canola Oil Blend
Sprinkle these on right after pulling the dish out. They don't change the flavor much but they make your stuffing look like it belongs in a food magazine. Presentation matters when 14 relatives are judging your cooking.
Great Value Parsley Flakes, 0.4 oz
Pinch these over the top the second it comes out of the oven. The big flaky crystals sit on the crust and give you these little salty pops with every bite. Started doing this last year and it's the detail that made everyone lose their minds.
What's So Special About Sea Salt? The Maldon Difference